Benevolence of 'General Dyer'? How sedition became a membership perk in Gujarat

By Prof. Hemantkumar Shah*

Reports indicate that on December 18, 2025, the Surat District and Sessions Court approved the Gujarat government’s decision to withdraw the sedition case against BJP MLA Hardik Patel. This follows a similar move in March, where the Ahmedabad Sessions Court sanctioned the withdrawal of another case against him. In both instances, Hardik and four of his associates were granted a clean slate.

These cases date back to 2015, when Hardik Patel led the Patidar reservation movement—not as a seasoned politician, but as a citizen activist. The Surat case specifically involved allegations that he incited Patel youths to attack the police rather than commit suicide. It was a charge that carried a potential sentence ranging from three years to life imprisonment. Now, that legal threat has simply vanished.

A Political Masterstroke or Legal Mockery?

Why did the Gujarat government suddenly lose its appetite for prosecution? In Gujarat, the "government" is widely understood to be synonymous with Narendra Modi and Amit Shah; folk wisdom suggests not a leaf stirs in the state administration without their nod.

The reason for this sudden leniency is transparent: Hardik Patel is now in the BJP. In 2019, he joined the Congress and rose to the rank of Working President. Yet, he eventually defected to the very party whose leader, Amit Shah, he had once famously branded "General Dyer." One can only assume that the looming fear of a prison sentence prompted a political bargain: "Join the BJP, and the cases disappear."

The Erosion of Equality

This isn't just about Hardik Patel; it is a fundamental question of the rule of law and our judicial integrity. If Hardik Patel never committed sedition, why was he charged in the first place? If he did, why was the case withdrawn before the court could reach a verdict? The answer is simple: between 2015 and 2022, he was an opponent, so the cases remained. Today, he is a member of the fold, so the cases are gone.

This is a textbook example of discriminatory governance. When a government operates on the principle that "one of our own can do no wrong," it violates the very essence of democracy and the Fundamental Rights to equality enshrined in Articles 14 and 15 of the Indian Constitution. But such principles are currently being "sent to the oil mills" (ignored). In a regime where one man acts as the ultimate arbiter, "General Dyer" decides who deserves the rain of mercy and who deserves the heat of the law.

A Tale of Two Leaders

Contrast this with the case of Jignesh Mevani.

In 2022, a BJP worker in Kokrajhar, Assam, filed a case against Mevani. The Assam Police rushed to Palanpur, Gujarat, and whisked him away overnight, forcing him to endure the grueling legal cycles of a distant state. Did that BJP worker act alone, or was the "General Dyer" spirit at work there too?

Unlike Hardik, Jignesh chose not to trade his principles for a BJP membership to escape his legal woes. For Jignesh, individual liberty and dissent are paramount; for Hardik, the "benevolence" of the powerful is his shield.

The Question of Legacy

Hardik Patel is my friend; Jignesh Mevani was my student. Both are now MLAs—one from the BJP, one from the Congress. Ask yourselves: Which one should I be proud of?

More importantly, set aside my personal pride and ask: Should we not be deeply concerned about the blatant destruction of our democratic fabric?

---

*Senior academic based in Ahmedabad

Comments

From algorithms to exploitation: New report exposes plight of India's gig workers

By Jag Jivan The recent report, "State of Finance in India Report 2024-25," released by a coalition including the Centre for Financial Accountability, Focus on the Global South, and other organizations, paints a stark picture of India's burgeoning digital economy, particularly highlighting the exploitation faced by gig workers on platform-based services.

Countrywide protest by gig workers puts spotlight on algorithmic exploitation

By A Representative A nationwide protest led largely by women gig and platform workers was held across several states on February 3, with the Gig & Platform Service Workers Union (GIPSWU) claiming the mobilisation as a success and a strong assertion of workers’ rights against what it described as widespread exploitation by digital platform companies. Demonstrations took place in Delhi, Rajasthan, Karnataka, Maharashtra and other states, covering major cities including New Delhi, Jaipur, Bengaluru and Mumbai, along with multiple districts across the country.

Over 40% of gig workers earn below ₹15,000 a month: Economic Survey

By A Representative The Finance Minister, Nirmala Sitharaman, while reviewing the Economic Survey in Parliament on Tuesday, highlighted the rapid growth of gig and platform workers in India. According to the Survey, the number of gig workers has increased from 7.7 million to around 12 million, marking a growth of about 55 percent. Their share in the overall workforce is projected to rise from 2 percent to 6.7 percent, with gig workers expected to contribute approximately ₹2.35 lakh crore to the GDP by 2030. The Survey also noted that over 40 percent of gig workers earn less than ₹15,000 per month.

Budget 2026 focuses on pharma and medical tourism, overlooks public health needs: JSAI

By A Representative Jan Swasthya Abhiyan India (JSAI) has criticised the Union Budget 2026, stating that it overlooks core public health needs while prioritising the pharmaceutical industry, private healthcare, medical tourism, public-private partnerships, and exports related to AYUSH systems. In a press note issued from New Delhi, the public health network said that primary healthcare services and public health infrastructure continue to remain underfunded despite repeated policy assurances.

Swami Vivekananda's views on caste and sexuality were 'painfully' regressive

By Bhaskar Sur* Swami Vivekananda now belongs more to the modern Hindu mythology than reality. It makes a daunting job to discover the real human being who knew unemployment, humiliation of losing a teaching job for 'incompetence', longed in vain for the bliss of a happy conjugal life only to suffer the consequent frustration.

When compassion turns lethal: Euthanasia and the fear of becoming a burden

By Deepika A 55-year-old acquaintance passed away recently after a long battle with cancer. Why so many people are dying relatively young is a question being raised in several forums, and that debate is best reserved for another day. This individual was kept on a ventilator for nearly five months, after which the doctors and the family finally decided to let go. The cost of keeping a person on life support for such extended periods is enormous. Yet families continue to spend vast sums even when the chances of survival are minimal. Life, we are told, is precious, and nature itself strives to protect and sustain it.

Death behind locked doors in East Kolkata: A fire that exposed systemic neglect

By Atanu Roy* It was Sunday at midnight. Around 30 migrant workers were in deep sleep after a hard day’s work. A devastating fire engulfed the godown where they were sleeping. There was no escape route for the workers, as the door was locked and no firefighting system was installed. Rules of the land were violated as usual. The fire continued for days, despite the sincere efforts of fire brigade personnel. The bodies were charred in the intense heat and were beyond identification, not fit for immediate forensic examination. As a result, nobody knows the exact death toll; estimates are hovering around 21 as of now.

When resistance became administrative: How I learned to stop romanticising the labour movement

By Rohit Chauhan* On my first day at a labour rights NGO, I was given a monthly sales target: sixty memberships. Not sixty workers to organise, not sixty conversations about exploitation, not sixty political discussions. Sixty conversions. I remember staring at the whiteboard, wondering whether I had mistakenly walked into a multi-level marketing office instead of a trade union. The language was corporate, the urgency managerial, and the tone unmistakably transactional. It was my formal introduction to a strange truth I would slowly learn: in contemporary India, even rebellion runs on performance metrics.

Report exposes human rights gaps in India's $36 billion garment export industry

By Jag Jivan A new report sheds light on the urgent human rights challenges within India’s vast textile and garment industry, as global regulations increasingly demand corporate accountability in supply chains. Titled “Beneath the Seams,” the study reveals that despite the sector employing over 45 million people, systemic issues of poverty wages, unfair purchasing practices, and the exclusion of workers from decision-making persist, leaving millions vulnerable.

Search This Blog