Skip to main content

Poverty isn't just a seven letter word; what about nutrition, sanitation, infant mortality?

Counterview Desk
In an interview to Counterview, well-known economist Prof Amitabh Kundu* seeks to look at the reasons behind the controversy surrounding the working papers of the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) which report low or no poverty for India in the years of the pandemic or before that.
He says, “Unfortunately, no attempt is made to determine any poverty basket and check if the poverty line is adequate to buy that. Meeting the basic human needs, thus, is not the basic concern in the current poverty debate as it is argued that such needs cannot be decided in any robust manner.”

Text:

Q: How do you look at the low figures of poverty in India in the context of deprivation figures for Indian population in different spheres?
A: India witnessed lakhs of migrants walking thousands of kilometres with children in their hands from India’s urban centre to their homes in rural areas during the first year of the pandemic. Nor is it a secret that thousands died on the streets and around the hospitals due to lack of beds and oxygen. Yet there have been claims, particularly by international organisations, that the level of poverty in India has considerably gone down, or it is almost negligible. Clearly, there is an anomaly.
The problems faced by common people, particularly those at the bottom rung of the society, are those of management and governance and cannot be attributed to poverty, it is being argued. But what about the National Family Health Survey recording the infant mortality rate (IMR) to have gone down only marginally from 40.7 to 35.2 per thousand between the two rounds covering 2015-16 and 2019-21? Or, the percentage of anaemic children aged 6 to 59 months, pregnant and non-pregnant women and adult males have gone up significantly during the period?
These indicators, we are told, are no proxies for poverty. Their linkages with nutritional indicators are considered tenuous, as these can be explained in terms of intra-household distribution, poor dietary habits, improper water/sanitation facilities etc. Not without reason, there is uproar about the working papers of the World Bank and IMF that report low or no poverty for India in the years of the pandemic or before that.
The real question is what does the poverty index measure or attempt to capture? The construction of the index involves complex calculations to identify a poverty basket of consumption, working out price indices for updation of poverty line, and then applying these to the income or consumption of households for determining the poverty status. Unfortunately, no attempt is made now to determine any poverty basket and check if the povery line is adequate to buy that. Meeting the basic human needs, thus, is not the basic concern in the current poverty debate as it is argued that such needs cannot be decided in any robust manner.
Q: How has the delinking of poverty from nutrition has taken place in Indian poverty literature?
A: A nine member Working Group set up by the Planning Commission proposed the poverty line at Rs 20 per capita per month in early 1960s, loosely ensuring adequacy of minimum requirements. VM Dandekar and Nilakantha Rath (1970) went into details of minimum calorie needs, based on the average consumption pattern. During 1980s and 1990s, it was realised that this linkage is getting blurred due to changes in the consumption pattern, changing micro environment for living, withdrawal of the state in provision of basic necessities etc.
PV Sukhatme argued that the emphasis on calorie and nutrition is misplaced as the absorption of nutrients in the body depends on physical health, particularly presence or absence of gastrointestinal diseases. Water and sanitation facilities were noted as important in determining the poverty line in the absence of which, out of pocket expenditure of the household on these and health would shoot up.
Indeed, engagement of the state in providing the basic necessities free or at subsidised rates would lower the household expenditure required to cross over the poverty line. BS Minhas’ exhaustive work too suggested that calorie/nutrient requirements are largely socially and culturally determined and even the biological needs vary from person to person within a household.
It was accepted that the state through poverty intervention cannot and should not try to guarantee adequate nutrition or health to people. The Tendulkar Committee formally announced delinking of nutritional norms from poverty in 2009. Subsequently, efforts to bring dietary factors into poverty domain by the Rangarajan Committee received lukewarm response from the policy makers.
As a young Assistant Professor at the Jawaharlal Nehru University (JNU), I have observed the transition taking place. I recall Dr DT Lakdawala beseeching Dr B. S. Minhas at a seminar “not to remove the pegs on with the whole poverty debate hangs.” He thought that poverty has a special punch and force in policy discourse at national and global level, because people consider it to be linked with human deprivation, suffering, and absence of basic necessities. If it is reduced to a number which is temporally and cross sectionally comparable but lacks in content of suffering, it will cease to be an instrument in the hands of researchers and civil society to pressurise the government for appropriate welfare policies.
Q: How has the Working Paper, prepared by the IMF computed poverty figures for the recent years when there has been no Consumption Expenditure Survey whose results have been accepted by the government?
A: The results of the NSS consumption expenditure for 2017-18 have been rejected by the government as being not comparable with those of previous rounds. The computation of poverty has thus become extremely challenging in the absence of the data on consumption expenditure, as is the case in India today, as also in several developing countries. With a view to providing inputs into policy making, researchers have evolved ingenious methods of estimating the data, using the past datasets and those where the samples are not representative of the households in the country.
One must compliment Surjit Bhalla, Karan Bhasin and Arvind Virmani who have taken up this challenge in their IMF Working Paper of developing a method of interpolation and extrapolation of the consumption expenditure of the NSS survey of 2011-12 and build a series up to 2019-20. They come out with definite numbers. It would only be fair to consider these seriously to examine the extent to which these maintain temporal and cross section comparability and, more importantly, what exactly do they capture or can convey to policy makers.
They use the growth rate of the private final consumption expenditure (PFCE), but bring in the distributional changes by allowing the households consumption to grow as per the growth in nominal per capita income in each state.
Computation of poverty has become extremely challenging in the absence of data on consumption expenditure
Rural urban price differences are also introduced through separate poverty lines for rural and urban households. The method is reasonable -- except that it assumes the distributions to remain unchanged, both within the rural and urban segments in each state over the period 2014-20.
Objections have been raised regarding updating household expenditure by the growth in PFCE, as it is estimated as a residual in national income accounts and therefore includes many other components such as expenditure of unincorporated enterprises. Also, with regard to the extent to which government hospitals and non-profit organisations transfer benefits to households, there will be double counting.
It may, on the other hand, be noted that the expenditure data collected from households do not include rental payments. However, considering the pluses and minuses, updating consumption expenditure by PFCE enhances the estimated value. One wonders if there could be other multipliers for updating the figures, free from these problems .
Q: What could have been done to bring in distributional changes realistically in rural and urban areas within the states in the IMF Working Paper?
A: The first suggestion would be to multiply the figure of consumption expenditure of each household by the growth rate of income in the economic activity with which the household is associated, since the authors consider using income growth as a possible basis for projection. Secondly, the growth rates of different commodities in the PFCE are significantly different and hence adjustments can be done commodity wise, to bring focus on items of consumption by the poor, across the states.
Q: What do you think of bringing in the subsidised and free food grains given to poor households, in the poverty calculations in the IMF paper?
A: The most significant contribution of the study is its bringing in differential engagement of the state in provisioning of the essentials to the poor into poverty calculations. The public distribution system (PDS) off take of the poor has doubled after implementation of the National Food Security Act after 2014. The provisioning of extra food grains per person per month free of cost since March 2020 has also been built into the real expenditure of the poor.
This, however, opens up the possibility of bringing in the changes in the level of state engagement in provisioning of essentials, including free gas cylinders etc. within the framework of calculations. However, this must be supplemented by an assessment of the disengagement of the state in crucial social sectors such as education and health. Incremental expenditure of the poor on health and education in recent years, as estimated through NSS data, would have to be considered by revising up the poverty line.
Q: What is your opinion regarding the methodology and poverty calculations in the Working Paper of the World Bank?
A: The paper by Sutirtha Sinha Roy and Roy van der Weide for the World Bank, released recently. explores the possibility of using Centre for Monitoring Indian Economy (CMIE) data in poverty calculations after correcting for the unrepresentative character of the panel data, by modifying the weightages of households for aggregation. Indeed, the asset position and level of basic amenities are generally higher in the CMIE sample than in more robust national sources, basically due the former’s sampling procedure.
These adjustments carried out to remove the non-convergence of the CMIE data with others at macro level have resulted in a poverty figure of 12 per cent. This, many people find more acceptable not because of the methodology but the magnitude. One does not know whether the poverty estimate would be a bit higher had the adjustments been carried out for a few other parameters and also at the state level.
Q: Any concluding observation?
A: The efforts of all the scholars in building up appropriate data sets, given that the decade 2011-21 has been disastrous for macro data, may be commendable. But let it be clear, there is no royal road to statistics. Let these exercises be not similar to the search of the proverbial smart man for his wallet under a lamppost. Being asked, he answered that he dropped it somewhere near the dark gutter but insisted on not searching there since there was no light.
---
*Senior Fellow with the Sustainable Cities and Transport program at WRI India; former professor, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi

Comments

TRENDING

Economist-editor's allegations on Narmada defamatory, baseless: Medha Patkar

Counterview Desk  In a reply directly addressed to well-known economist, journalist and columnist Swaminathan S Anklesaria Aiyar’s two articles in the Times of India (republished here and here ), calling them defamatory and wondering whether they were borne out of “ignorance or a conspiracy through political alliance”, Narmada Bachao Andolan leader Medha Pakar has said that the Narmada Sardar Saravar Project and the people's movement by adivasis, farmers, labourers, fish workers, potters and all the generations’ old communities from the river valley have suddenly come to be focused on, since the Gujarat elections are in the doorstep. She believes that while the “defamatory accusations with baseless conceptions such as ‘urban naxals’ are to be laughed at as the electoral strategic moves, one gets shocked to read the articles by a known old columnist like Swaminathan Ankalesaria Aiyar, published in a reputed daily like the Times of India." According to her, Aiyar’s two articl

Hindutva groups threat to peace, freedom: US diaspora groups tell FBI, other govt depts

By Our Representative  The Islamophobic and neo-Nazi ideology of Hindutva is a clear and present danger to peace and freedoms in the United States, a coalition of civil rights organizations told key officials of the U.S. Attorney General’s Office, the US Department of Justice (DOJ), and the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) at a recent event in Edison, New Jersey. At the event titled United Against Hate, activists from American Muslims for Democracy (AMD), Hindus for Human Rights (HfHR) and Indian American Muslim Council (IAMC) made detailed presentations on this ideology of Hindu supremacism that is committing mass persecution of India’s Muslims and Christians and is rearing its ugly head in New Jersey as well as across the US. Attending the event were David S Leonardis, Special Investigator from the New Jersey Department of Law & Public Safety; Michael E Campion, Chief of the Civil Rights Division for the US Attorney General's Office; and Jonathan R Norbut of the U.S. Dep

Facing tough times, Rajasthan's Raika herders hold first-ever camel cheese festival

By Rosamma Thomas*  During the pandemic, the annual Pushkar camel fair in Rajasthan did not occur for fear of contagion; in 2022, it was called off again as lumpy skin disease affected cattle. At Sadri in Pali district, however, festivity continues – a two-day Camel Cheese Festival was held on November 23 and 24, 2022. Visitors spent time with the camel herds and their Raika, drank camel-milk tea with the herders and then returned to lunch at the Kumbhalgarh Camel Dairy, from where the Kumbhalgarh Fort is visible, to taste camel cheese. The Raika herders have been facing a tough time – camels are no longer used as much for transport or agriculture in Rajasthan. The animals have limited utility, but their milk is prized. Camel Charisma, the dairy at Kumbhalgarh, sends camel milk across the country to people who use it in therapy – for autistic children, improved blood sugar levels, or even to treat cancer. It is believed that the health benefits of the camel milk is because the animals

Buddhist shrines were 'massively destroyed' by Brahmanical rulers: Historian DN Jha

Nalanda mahavihara By Our Representative Prominent historian DN Jha, an expert in India's ancient and medieval past, in his new book , "Against the Grain: Notes on Identity, Intolerance and History", in a sharp critique of "Hindutva ideologues", who look at the ancient period of Indian history as "a golden age marked by social harmony, devoid of any religious violence", has said, "Demolition and desecration of rival religious establishments, and the appropriation of their idols, was not uncommon in India before the advent of Islam".

As polls approach, electorate 'failing to realise': Gujarat model is in a shambles

By DN Rath*  Gujarat assembly elections, scheduled to be held on 1 and 5 December 2022, is viewed by many as dress rehearsal for the 2024 Lok Sabha elections. When the suffering people have been pointing towards redressal of some local issues like absence of cleanliness, sewage problem, shortage of water supply, troubles created by stray cattle, insufficiency of streetlights, etc., it is evident that they are not fully aware that assembly elections are being fought on ideological standpoints and policy decisions. Nor is there the realisation that the state is in a shambles and the much-trumpeted ‘Gujarat model’ of development has proved to be a hoax. Like other states, the people of Gujarat are also back-broken by steep rise in prices to the tune of 400% in last 20 years. It is not that the government cannot control the spurt in prices if it so wants. Apart from the fact that price rise is an inevitability in a capitalist economy, artificial shortage triggered by massive hoarding, b

Shedding Hindu-Hindi-Hindustan? New Modi-Shah love for Tamil Nadu 'ignores' Periyar

By Sandeep Pandey*   The Rashtriya Swayamsewak Sangh (RSS) or the Bhartiya Janata Party (BJP) have long argued for ‘Hindu-Hindi-Hindustan’, which into recent years has translated into a crisper English expression: ‘One Nation-One Religion-One Language’. Given this backdrop, it is curious that the BJP government has organised the Kashi Tamil Sangamam in Varanasi, the Prime Minister’s constituency. Why did the BJP and RSS feel the need for such an event? All Narendra Modi events are highly publicised and have multiple political objectives. It is never an innocuous religious/cultural event as it may appear from the face of it. Afterall, RSS calls itself a cultural organisation, but has never ceased to surprise us with its political designs. Tamil Nadu has a long history of opposing imposition of Hindi by Union governments. Periyar EV Ramasamy had opposed the idea of compulsory teaching in Hindi as far back as in 1937. The 1960s witnessed violent protests against Hindi in which a number

GM mustard not swadeshi, it's a patent of MNC Bayer, GoI 'misleading' SC: Modi told

Counterview Desk  In a representation to Prime Minister Narendra Modi, as many as 42 farmers’ organisations though their representatives , backed by senior scientists and experts, have said that the Government of India (GoI) should stop misleading the Supreme Court “with untrue and incorrect” statements on GM mustard. Insisting that India does not need unsafe GM mustard, in their representation, they urged the Supreme Court to order immediate uprooting of GM mustard crop in various locations. The representation comes even as a penal of experts, coming down heavily on the GoI for refusing to see how in less than a week’s time the pollen from GM mustard will “start contaminating” non-GM mustard fields with transgenes, including male sterility and herbicide tolerant traits. Alleging that the GoI is actively misleading the Supreme Court with untrue and incorrect statements on GM mustard, Kavitha Kuruganti of the Coalition for a GM-Free India said, “We can list at least five areas where Gov

Demand to withdraw 'anti-environment, anti-adivasi' forest conservation rules 2022

By Gopinath Majhi*  The Campaign for Survival and Dignity (CSD), Odisha, a coalition of adivasis and forest dwellers’ organisations, has sent a memorandum to the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC) raising serious concerns over Forest (Conservation) Rules, 2022, notified by the Centre on June 29.  Contending that recent amendments and a host of executive orders/guidelines issued by the ministry undermine and dilute the FRA and threaten the rights of adivasis and forest dwellers, CSD demands that the 2022 FC Rules should be rescinded forthwith. Demanding withdrawal of such anti-people and anti-environment rules CSD Odisha organised a protest Dharana in front of State Assembly today on 25th November 2022 and submitted memorandums to the Hon’ble Governor of Odisha, Chief Secretary and Commissioner-cum-Secretary, ST & SC Development Department for conveying our concerns against the FC Rules 2022 to the Central Government for its withdrawal. The memorandums w

BJP poll gimmick? Bilkis Bano rape case 'pardon' vs Rajiv assassins' release

By Sandeep Pandey*  Supreme Court has released six convicts in the Rajiv Gandhi assassination case. This was bound to happen as earlier AG Perarivalan was released in the same case, setting a precedent. Even though four of them are Sri Lankans but a popular Tamil sentiment favoured the release of these convicts which is why Tamil political parties supported this and resolutions were passed by different governments in Tamil Nadu to his effect.  Rajiv Gandhi paid the price of sending Indian Peace Keeping Force to Sri Lanka where it got entangled with Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam and eventually the whole operation ended up is a fiasco.  However, most importantly Sonia and Priyanka Gandhi and probably Rahul too do not have any objections to the release of these convicts. In fact, Sonia Gandhi played an important role in getting the death sentence of the only lady among the convicts Nalini commuted to life term through the Tamil Nadu Governor. Priyanka visited Nalini in Vellore Jail and

Never-ending saga of sin tax: What if murder is taxed at Rs 1 crore, rape at Rs 5 crore?

By Moses Raj GS, Sangeetha Thomas*  What should have ended by June 30, 2022 as a 5 year experiment has resurfaced. The government has extended the levy of GST compensation cess by another 4 years till March 31, 2026. This cess, dubbed as the sin tax imposed on sin(ful) goods, is double the highest slab on indirect taxes. But only a few pay for it and the majority benefit, unendingly. The year 2017 is a landmark year for indirect taxes. With the grand idea of ‘One Nation, One Tax’ as a fiscal slogan subsuming all State based taxes such as octroi /entry tax, Value Added Tax (VAT), sales tax, taxes on lottery, betting and gambling, luxury tax, purchase tax, entertainment tax, property tax, professional tax and central sales tax into a single framework of Goods and Services Tax (GST) changed the contours of revenue collection. Complicating it further, India, with each State having its own size and revenue problems, has the most complex and highly centralised indirect tax structure in the w