Skip to main content

Ideological dissonance? A critical analysis of Left’s engagement with Indian traditions

By Harasankar Adhikari 
India has long been recognized as a land of religious diversity. People from multiple religious backgrounds have coexisted for centuries, making “unity in diversity” a foundational idea of the Indian identity. Among these communities, followers of Sanatan Dharma, or Hindus, constitute the majority.
Historically, India witnessed several invasions, some of which led to religious conversions and cultural shifts. These developments have shaped modern India's socio-political structure, particularly after it emerged as a democratic republic. The multiparty system reflects diverse ideological perspectives, including those from the political Left.
The Indian Left, traditionally aligned with Marxist or socialist ideologies, has often viewed religion—particularly organized or dominant religious expressions—as a factor influencing social hierarchy and inequality. This perspective can be seen as divergent from figures like Swami Vivekananda, who emphasized religion as central to India’s civilizational identity. Over time, reform movements within Sanatan Dharma have attempted to address internal challenges and democratize spiritual practices.
The Indian Constitution adopted the word “secular” in its Preamble in 1976 through the 42nd Amendment. Secularism in India is often interpreted as equal respect for all religions, though its practical application continues to be a subject of debate. Some argue that secularism has been politicized, while others see it as essential for maintaining harmony in a pluralistic society.
Critics of the Indian Left allege that its approach to secularism is sometimes perceived as selective. While the Left has supported the rights of religious minorities, opponents claim it has failed to equally address concerns related to the Hindu community, especially in cases of religious violence. This perceived asymmetry has led to accusations that the Left is indifferent or even antagonistic toward Hindu sentiments, though supporters of the Left argue that its stance is rooted in a commitment to minority rights and social justice.
Historical events have also shaped these perceptions. For instance, during the long rule of the Left Front in West Bengal, led by leaders like Jyoti Basu, certain symbolic acts—such as not formally hosting the national flag—sparked controversy, though not all such actions were necessarily illegal or unconstitutional. Critics interpret such incidents as signs of inadequate patriotic commitment, while defenders attribute them to ideological differences or symbolic protest.
Similarly, reactions to incidents of religious violence—whether in Kashmir, Bangladesh, or within India—often become a lens through which political allegiances are judged. The Left has been accused of underplaying acts of religious extremism, particularly those involving Islamist groups, while being vocal on issues like Palestine or international conflicts involving Muslim populations. Supporters argue that such global solidarity is consistent with Leftist principles of anti-imperialism and human rights.
The slogan “Kashmir Maange Azadi” (Kashmir wants freedom), reportedly raised during student protests associated with Left-affiliated groups, has been cited by critics as an example of anti-national sentiment. However, such slogans are also defended as part of free speech in a democratic society, though they remain contentious in public discourse.
The question arises whether ideologies like Marxism, which originated in different historical and cultural contexts, are fully compatible with India’s unique civilizational fabric. Leaders like Subhas Chandra Bose had warned that such ideologies must be adapted carefully to the Indian context.
Ultimately, India’s democracy allows for ideological pluralism. Constructive criticism of any political group, including the Left, is necessary. At the same time, broad labels such as “anti-national” or “anti-patriotic” should be used cautiously, supported by evidence, and situated within the framework of democratic debate and legal norms.

Comments

TRENDING

Gujarat minority rights group seeks suspension of Botad police officials for brutal assault on minor

By A Representative   A human rights group, the Minority Coordination Committee (MCC) Gujarat,  has written to the Director General of Police (DGP), Gandhinagar, demanding the immediate suspension and criminal action against police personnel of Botad police station for allegedly brutally assaulting a minor boy from the Muslim community.

On Teachers’ Day, remembering Mother Teresa as the teacher of compassion

By Fr. Cedric Prakash SJ   It is Teachers’ Day once again! Significantly, the day also marks the Feast of St. Teresa of Calcutta (still lovingly called Mother Teresa). In 2012, the United Nations, as a fitting tribute to her, declared this day the International Day of Charity. A day pregnant with meaning—one that we must celebrate as meaningfully as possible.

Targeted eviction of Bengali-speaking Muslims across Assam districts alleged

By A Representative   A delegation led by prominent academic and civil rights leader Sandeep Pandey  visited three districts in Assam—Goalpara, Dhubri, and Lakhimpur—between 2 and 4 September 2025 to meet families affected by recent demolitions and evictions. The delegation reported widespread displacement of Bengali-speaking Muslim communities, many of whom possess valid citizenship documents including Aadhaar, voter ID, ration cards, PAN cards, and NRC certification. 

A comrade in culture and controversy: Yao Wenyuan’s revolutionary legacy

By Harsh Thakor*  This year marks two important anniversaries in Chinese revolutionary history—the 20th death anniversary of Yao Wenyuan, and the 50th anniversary of his seminal essay "On the Social Basis of the Lin Biao Anti-Party Clique". These milestones invite reflection on the man whose pen ignited the first sparks of the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution and whose sharp ideological interventions left an indelible imprint on the political and cultural landscape of socialist China.

Gandhiji quoted as saying his anti-untouchability view has little space for inter-dining with "lower" castes

By A Representative A senior activist close to Narmada Bachao Andolan (NBA) leader Medha Patkar has defended top Booker prize winning novelist Arundhati Roy’s controversial utterance on Gandhiji that “his doctrine of nonviolence was based on an acceptance of the most brutal social hierarchy the world has ever known, the caste system.” Surprised at the police seeking video footage and transcript of Roy’s Mahatma Ayyankali memorial lecture at the Kerala University on July 17, Nandini K Oza in a recent blog quotes from available sources to “prove” that Gandhiji indeed believed in “removal of untouchability within the caste system.”

'Govts must walk the talk on gender equality, right to health, human rights to deliver SDGs by 2030'

By A Representative  With just 64 months left to deliver on the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), global health and rights advocates have called upon governments to honour their commitments on gender equality and the human right to health. Speaking ahead of the 80th United Nations General Assembly (UNGA), experts warned that rising anti-rights and anti-gender pushes are threatening hard-won progress on SDG-3 (health and wellbeing) and SDG-5 (gender equality).

Is U.S. fast losing its financial and technological edge under Trump’s second tenure?

By Dr. Manoj Kumar Mishra*  The United States, along with its Western European allies, once promoted globalization as a democratic force that would deliver shared prosperity and balanced growth. That promise has unraveled. Globalization, instead of building an even world, has produced one defined by inequality, asymmetry of power, and new vulnerabilities. For decades, Washington successfully turned this system to its advantage. Today, however, under Trump’s second administration, America is attempting to exploit the weaknesses of others without acknowledging how exposed it has become itself.

Bhojpuri cinema’s crisis: When popularity becomes an excuse for vulgarity

By Vidya Bhushan Rawat*  Bhojpuri cinema is expanding rapidly. Songs from new films are eagerly awaited, and the industry is hailed for its booming business. Yet, big money and mass popularity do not automatically translate into quality cinema or meaningful content. The market has compelled us to celebrate numbers, even when what is being produced is deeply troubling.

What mainstream economists won’t tell you about Chinese modernisation

By Shiran Illanperuma  China’s modernisation has been one of the most remarkable processes of the 21st century and one that has sparked endless academic debate. Meng Jie (孟捷), a distinguished professor from the School of Marxism at Fudan University in Shanghai, has spent the better part of his career unpacking this process to better understand what has taken place.