Skip to main content

Was Dalit scholar Rohith Vemula a Christian? If true, Hindus are "under siege": BJP's Subramaniam Swamy

By Our Representative
Senior BJP leader Subramaniam Swamy, lately gone very close to Prime Minister Narendra Modi, has said, if it is proved that Rohith Vemula -- the 27-year-old University of Hyderabad Dalit scholar who committed suicide -- was a “converted Christian and Opus Dei”, then “it is a new dimension of Hindus under siege.”
According to Wikipedia, Opus Dei is an institution of the Roman Catholic Church that teaches that everyone is called to holiness and that ordinary life is a path to sanctity. “The majority of its members are lay people, with secular priests under the governance of a prelate (bishop) elected by specific members and appointed by the Pope”, it says.
While it is not known if this is the official line of the BJP on seeking to consider Rohith a Christian, Swamy’s declaration, as a tweet, comes close on the heels of Hindutva social media fans seeking to provide concrete “proof” that the Dalit scholars was, indeed, a Christian, who “converted” to Christianity in 2005.
One of them, Suresh Kochattil, whose Facebook profile says he “works with BJP”, says, “Rohit's father Manikumar, uncle Venkateswarlu and grandmother give a statement today (January 21) at Madhapur ACP Ramana Kumar at Gurazala in Guntur district, confirming that the family is from Vaddera BC community and that they are not Scheduled Caste (SC) or Scheduled Tribe (ST). They informed the ACP that in 2005, Rohith and his mother converted to Christianity.”
The effort to declare Vermula a Christian, significantly, comes just two days after efforts to prove Rohith was not a Dalit but  an Other Backward Class (OBC) proved to be incorrect.
A top media site reports, “As a proof, a snapshot of a caste certificate was offered. The source of the certificate, printed in Telugu, remains unknown. It shows that Vemula Radhika, Rohith's mother, having signed a certificate declaring her other son, Vemula Raja, as a ‘Vaddera’, a caste which is categorised as OBC.”
Following this, the site says, “Several journalists reached out to the family and friends of Rohith to ask them what the issue was here. They were not happy to hear such questions, but answers were given.”
It adds, “First proof offered was Rohith’s own caste certificate, issued by the Government of Andhra Pradesh. NDTV’s Uma Sudhir tweeted it out first. The certificate clearly states that Rohith was a ‘Mala’, a caste categorized as SC in the state. That's the certificate below.”
However, said the site, “the questions did not stop here – what if he had faked the certificate before entering the University? Why is his brother’s certificate showing OBC?” The site’s correspondent asked the mother, who said, “When I was pregnant with the third kid my husband left us. My kids don't even recognize their dad. So my husband is a Vaddera (BC) and I'm a Mala (SC).”
The site further says, “We also reached out to one of Rohith’s close friends, Chittibabu Padavala, for an explanation, and he told us the following: ‘The idea that father's caste automatically or mandatorily passes on to the kids is the typical Hindu's ignorant idea. Law is far more enlightened’.”
Padavala adds, “Children born of couples of different castes can choose either of their parent's caste. Misusing this Hindu ignorance by Hindutva demagogues is understandable if unacceptable. But media allowing and misusing its space and time to for such clearly verifiable fact is really the issue, from the point of view of media criticism."
The site wonders, “But even if he was proven to be a Vaddera on record, how does it matter? The issues being raised are of discrimination of caste within the campus, and the political intervention in it. He identified himself as a Dalit. He was a Dalit as per records. He fought what he thought was discrimination against him based on his identity.”

Comments

NPNAIR said…
India has not learned any lessons out of these caste menace.one side people fighting against caste system,at the same time they want to retain it for govt's charity benefits!!What a contradiction.The rulers of this country ,the present and the past have no conviction about how a real secular country should be!!.It is really unfortunate !!!
Ha-ha. The father's caste is not valid? What a prejudiced article. If someone has misrepresented his caste, it can't be brushed away. First of all, the secular media seems to have deliberately forgotten that he committed suicide, hr wasn't murdered. Never seen such a partisan reportage and such a dirty level of politics
Anonymous said…
Quoting NDTV correspondent itself proves that this article is biased. NDTV as all know works as paid media. How many of us know Rajasekhar Reddy and his son Jagan are Christians? These people keep their Hindu identity unchanged for political and reservation benefits
Anonymous said…
Mr. Anonymous, do you see any problem if Mr. Rajasekhar Reddy's family are Christians? I have never heard them proclaiming as belonging to a certain religion in public. If at all, they call themselves as Christian in public. Your understanding that one that converts to Christianity gets the reservation is shows how unlearned you are. How about dumping your head in cow dung to get some enlightenment? Know that who converts to Christianity loses the reservation and other benefits whatever they had.
NPNAIR said…
If converted Christians from sc,st looses their reservation benefits why they are doing it ?.To get a higher cast ? But they are called "dalith christians" what a pity.That shows that they didn't get a higher cast by conversion.They are still Dalith in Christianity.By the by is there any cast system in Christianity? If so why they are converting Hindus promising a higher status?? Daliths are not being allowed to pray in normal Christian churches.Daliths should go to Dalith Christian churches it seems . Daliths are being cheated by the Christians !!
Anonymous said…
This is another attempt to malign the central government and Hindus by the converted christians, and as expected anything which is anti hindu they are two common things which are always present
1- Rahul Gandhi
2- NDTV (Nehru Dynasty Television).

TRENDING

Gujarat's high profile GIFT city 'fails to attract' funds, India's FinTech investment dips

By Rajiv Shah  While the Narendra Modi government may have gone out of the way to promote the Gujarat International Finance Tec-City (GIFT City), sought to be developed as India’s formidable financial technology hub off the state capital Gandhinagar, just 20 km from Ahmedabad, a recent report , prepared by Tracxn Technologies suggests that neither of the two cities figure in the list of top FinTech funding receiving centres.

A Hindu alternative to Valentine's Day? 'Shiv-Parvati was first love marriage in Universe'

By Rajiv Shah*   The other day, I was searching on Google a quote on Maha Shivratri which I wanted to send to someone, a confirmed Shiv Bhakt, quite close to me -- with an underlying message to act positively instead of being negative. On top of the search, I chanced upon an article in, imagine!, a Nashik Corporation site which offered me something very unusual. 

Why Ramdev, vaccine producing pharma companies and government are all at fault

By Colin Gonsalves*  It was perhaps Ramdev’s closeness to government which made him over-confident. According to reports he promoted a cure for Covid, thus directly contravening various provisions of The Drugs and Magic Remedies (Objectionable Advertisements) Act, 1954. Persons convicted of such offences may not get away with a mere apology and would suffer imprisonment.

Decade long Modi rule 'undermines' people's welfare and democracy

By Ram Puniyani*  Modi has many ploys up his sleeves when it comes to propaganda. On one hand he is turning many a pronouncements of Congress in the communal direction, on the other he is claiming that whatever has been achieved during last ten years of his rule is phenomenal, but it is still a ‘trailer’ and the bigger things are in the offing as he claims to be coming to power yet again in 2024. While his admirers are ga ga about his achievements, the truth lies somewhere else.

Belgian report alleges MNC Etex responsible for asbestos pollution in Madhya Pradesh town Kymore: COP's Geneva meet

By Our Representative A comprehensive Belgian report has held MNC Etex , into construction business and one of the richest, responsible for asbestos pollution in Kymore, an industrial town in in Katni district of Madhya Pradesh. The report provides evidence from the ground on how Kymore’s dust even today is “annoying… it creeps into your clothes, you have to cough it”, saying “It can be deadly.”

Malayalam movie Aadujeevitham: Unrealistic, disservice to pastoralists

By Rosamma Thomas*  The Malayalam movie 'Aadujeevitham' (Goat Life), currently screening in movie theatres in Kerala, has received positive reviews and was featured also on the website of the British Broadcasting Corporation. The story is based on a 2008 novel by Benyamin, and relates the real-life story of a job-seeker from Kerala tricked into working in slave conditions in a goat farm in Saudi Arabia.

Can universal basic income help usher in sustainable egalitarianism in India?

By Prof RR Prasad*  The ongoing debate on application of Article 39(b) in the Supreme Court on redistribution of community material resources to subserve common good and for ushering in an egalitarian society has opened new vistas wherein possible available alternative solutions could be explored.

Plagued by opportunism, adventurism, tailism, Left 'doesn't matter' in India

By Harsh Thakor*  2024 elections are starting when India appears to be on the verge of turning proto-fascist. The Hindutva saffron brigade has penetrated in every sphere of Indian life, every social order, destroying and undermining the very fabric of the Constitution.

Press freedom? 28 journalists killed since 2014, nine currently in jail

By Kirity Roy*  On the eve of the Press Freedom Day on 3rd of May, the Banglar Manabadhikar Suraksha Mancha (MASUM) shared its anxiety with the broader civil society platforms as the situation of freedom of any form of expression became grimmer in India day by day. This day was intended to raise awareness on the importance of freedom of press and to pay tribute to pressmen who lost their lives in the line of duty.

'Livelihood crisis': Hundreds of Delhi sewer contract workers suddenly retrenched

By Sanjeev Danda*  Sanitation workers in Delhi have been facing unemployment because of the inability of the government sector to properly integrate them. In a consultation meeting and dialogue with sanitation workers on 27th April 2024 at the Constitution Club of India, New Delhi, many such issues were raised by the sewer workers and waste pickers of Delhi.