No environmental release of GM mustard, 'at least till SC considers the case further'

By Rosamma Thomas*
On November 3, 2022, a Supreme Court bench comprising Justices Dinesh Maheshwari and Sudhanshu Dhulia ordered status quo on the Genetic Engineering Appraisal Committee’s (GEAC) decision of October 18, 2022 and subsequent decision of the Ministry of Environment and Forests of 25 October 2022 to allow environmental release of herbicide-tolerant (HT) genetically modified mustard DMH11 (Dhara Mustard Hybrid 11) in five states, based on an interim application filed by Ms Aruna Rodrigues in her pending writ petition.
No environmental release will be permitted, at least until the case is considered further on 10 November. Advocate Prashant Bhushan, representing Rodrigues, contended that the apex court in 2012 had constituted a technical expert committee with broad terms of reference to examine in detail the matter of genetically modified crops in India.
A press release from the petition said, “That committee called HT crops “unsustainable” and “unsuitable” for India; it noted that the herbicide sprayed on HT crops caused cancer; and said that non-GMO alternatives were available in the country; and recommended a “total ban” on all HT crops on the basis of the precautionary principle, as no long-term safety studies were done on the impact of edible GM crops in India on human health, animal health, and biodiversity.”
The government counsel had informed the court that GM mustard seeds were going to be planted in facilities of Indian Council of Agricultural Research (ICAR).
The court ordered the counsel to ensure that “no precipitative action is taken” until the application is heard and scheduled the matter for consideration on November 10.
Advocate Prashant Bhushan, representing Ms Rodrigues, reminded the court of the committee it had constituted in 2012, the Technical Expert Committee, whose terms of reference were to examine in detail the matter of genetically modified crops in India.
Here are excerpts from the TEC report:

Conclusion on HT crops: “The major concern with HT approaches is the excessive reliance on increased amounts of one or two herbicides which results in strong selective pressure for the emergence of herbicide resistant weeds and a negative impact on sustainability... they are likely to be accompanied by negative socio economic consequences as well as on the environment. There are alternatives to HT ….more appropriate in the Indian context”. p.67 of TEC Report
“The conclusion of the TEC is that HT crops would most likely exert a highly adverse impact over time on sustainable agriculture, rural livelihoods, and the environment. The TEC finds them completely unsuitable in the Indian context”. p.71 of TEC Report
“The release of GM crop into its area of origin or diversity has far greater ramifications and potential for negative impact…. The TEC therefore recommends that release of GM crops for which India is a center of origin or diversity should not be allowed”. p.72 of TEC Report
In the case of HT Crops, “The evidence of harm is significant. ‘Roundup’ is also a potent carcinogen; it causes mammary cancers in rats which are equivalent to breast cancers in humans”. p.72 of TEC Report
“The bottom line for any biotechnology regulatory policy should be the safety of the environment, the wellbeing of farming families, the ecological and economic sustainability of farming systems, the health and nutrition security of consumers, safeguarding home and external trade and biosecurity of nation... Since there is public, political, and professional concern about transgenics with reference to their short and long term impacts on human health and the environment, their testing, evaluation, and approval have to be stringent, elaborate, and science based. The general approach therefore should be that: Biotech applications, which do not involve transgenics as biopesticides, biofertilizers and bio-remediation agents, should be accorded high priority.” p.93 of TEC Report
“Having examined the issue of HT crops in the detail required to arrive at a decision, the TEC recommends a complete ban on HT crops". p.93 of TEC Report

Bhushan reminded the court of its earlier orders and the submission by the Union government that as of that time no decision had been taken to release GM mustard in the environment. At that time, the government had also said that if such a decision were to be taken, it would be placed before the court.
The court asked Additional Solicitor General Ms Aishwarya Bhati of the current status of environmental release of GM mustard. She informed the court that GM mustard seeds were going to be planted in facilities of ICAR. The court directed her to ensure “no precipitative action is taken” until the application is heard. The matter is posted for hearing on November 10, 2022.
---
*Freelance journalist

Comments

TU activist Anirudh Rajan, lawyer Ajay Kumar in custody: Wounded reputation of world's largest democracy?

By Vedika S* Over the last few days, India's National Investigation Agency (NIA), known to be tasked with suppressing revolutionary, democratic, and progressive forces, conducted a series of raids across Haryana, Punjab, Uttar Pradesh, and Delhi. Targets included human rights attorney Pankaj Tripathi, student leader Devendra Azad, and peasant union leader Sukhwinder Kaur. Lawyer and anti-displacement activist Ajay Kumar was arrested and taken to his home in Mohali, which was subsequently raided. He is now imprisoned in Lucknow as a suspect in the NIA's "Northern Regional Bureau (NRB) Revival case."

RG Kar saga: Towards liberation from the constraints of rigid political parties?

By Atanu Roy* There's a saying: "There is no such thing as a half-pregnancy." This adage seems particularly relevant when discussing the current regime of the Trinamool Congress (TMC). The party appears to be entrenched in widespread corruption that affects nearly every aspect of our lives. One must wonder, why would they exclude the health sector—a lucrative area where illicit money can flow freely, thanks to a network of corrupt leaders colluding with ambitious bureaucrats?

India's 55.6% still can't afford healthy diet, yet food wastage a serious issue

By Vikas Meshram According to this year's 'State of Food Security and Nutrition in the World' report, India has the highest number of malnourished people in the world, with a staggering 195 million affected. This report, prepared by the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) of the United Nations, was published jointly by five UN agencies, including UNICEF. The report also highlights a slight improvement in India's statistics: between 2004-06, the number of malnourished people in the country was 240 million.

A Hindu alternative to Valentine's Day? 'Shiv-Parvati was first love marriage in Universe'

By Rajiv Shah* The other day, I was searching on Google a quote on Maha Shivratri which I wanted to send to someone, a confirmed Shiv Bhakt, quite close to me -- with an underlying message to act positively instead of being negative. On top of the search, I chanced upon an article in, imagine!, a Nashik Corporation site which offered me something very unusual.

Unwavering source of ideological inspiration in politics, life: Personal tribute to Yechury

By Bhabani Shankar Nayak Sitaram Yechury was everyone's comrade. He lived his life in public like an open book of praxis. Everyone was familiar with his family background, student life, many talents, achievements, and political journey that defines his everyday life as a committed communist.

Trailblazer in literary innovation, critic of Indian mythology, including Ramayana

By Harsh Thakor* Ranganayakamma, commonly known as RN, stands out as a transformative figure in promoting Marxist thought, democratic ideals, and anti-caste principles through her remarkably clear and engaging writing style. A trailblazer in literary innovation, her works span a broad array of topics, from critiques of Indian mythology and revivalism to discussions on civil liberties, the Indian Communist Movement, and Maoism in China.

'Abduction' of labour activist Anirudh Rajan part of a 'troubling trend': CASR

By Our Representative The civil rights network Campaign Against State Repression (CASR) has issued a strong denunciation of the "abduction" of labour rights activist Anirudh Rajan, who was taken by state authorities on September 5, 2024, while traveling to meet his family. This incident is part of a troubling trend, as the National Investigation Agency (NIA) and various state forces have increasingly targeted trade union and democratic rights activists over the past year.

'Void in Leftist landscape': Loss of Sitaram Yechury who had helped form INDIA bloc

By Vikas Meshram* The passing of Sitaram Yechury has cast a profound stillness over leftist organizations across India. Renowned as a distinguished politician, columnist, economist, and social activist, Yechury was a staunch advocate for student rights and movements. His leadership skills became apparent early in his academic career, as he was elected three times as the president of Jawaharlal Nehru University (JNU). Yechury also endured imprisonment during the Emergency period, underscoring his commitment to political activism.

'300 Nazis fell by your gun': Most successful female sniper in history

By Harsh Thakor* "Miss Pavlichenko’s well known to fame, Russia’s your country, fighting is your game. The whole world will always love you for all time to come, Three hundred Nazis fell by your gun." — from Woody Guthrie's “Miss Pavlichenko"

Search This Blog