Skip to main content

Truth behind assertion: activists like Medha Patkar fooled people in opposing dams

By Bharat Dogra* 

There has been an increasing, welcome trend in many parts of world for seeking a better, unbiased and more comprehensive understanding of real-life impacts of large dams. This is to a substantial part driven by the actual experience of several leading and highly publicized dam projects which turned out to be very different from the rosy promises made earlier.
The displacement caused by many dam projects has been not only very high but in fact has even turned to be significantly higher than original estimates. There have often been several indirect displacements other than the direct displacement. The initial promises of satisfactory rehabilitation often made to dam evictees are not fulfilled. 
In the Sardar Sarovar Project on the Narmada river, the majority of displaced people were from Madhya Pradesh and the earlier promise of land-for-land made to them was not fulfilled at all. Instead only cash compensation was paid and there was so much corruption even in this that a special commission -- the Jha Commission -- had to be appointed to investigate it. 
The Morse Committee report had predicted much in advance, on the basis of its detailed study, that the promised rehabilitation is not possible, something which turned out to be entirely correct in the case of a big majority of dam evictees. 
Often some of the most fertile farmlands of concerned regions have been lost in the submergence zones of dam reservoirs, and along with them sustainable livelihoods and bountiful food producing systems have been submerged too. There are other adverse upstream impacts as well.
The destruction of forests and biodiversity has been immense. The upcoming Ken-Betwa link project involves the axing of 2.3 million trees (recent estimates are even higher), while its basic viability is not assured at all. 
In most evaluations trees lost to power lines have not been counted. In Latin America studies say Tucurui dam caused a 60% loss in fisheries while Itaipu dam resulted in 70% loss in biodiversity.
Loss of water quality including very serious deterioration with health impacts has been reported from reservoirs, particularly those affected by algae blooms, as well as bottom level water released from turbines, which may have harmful excess of minerals. 
When fresh, free flowing water is spread out in still form over dam reservoirs, there is not only quality loss but also substantial quantity lost due to higher evaporation rates.
In its downstream reach river gets depleted of water as well as sediments. Fertile silt is denied to fields and water to floodplain aquifers. In lean season this results in severe water scarcity for people and animals, higher pollution levels and sometimes even fish deaths. 
At a time of heavy rains the river may suddenly get heavy sudden release of water from dams which can cause very destructive floods. In fact some of the most destructive floods in recent times have been caused by excess release of water, which is also related to inadequacies in dam management. 
The sediment-free water has higher capacity or ‘hunger’ for causing land-erosion and the problem of land erosion is in fact increasing very fast. When the dammed river meets the sea, lack of adequate water and its lesser pressure in lean season can lead to intrusion of salt water, threatening coastal water supply and ecology, while absence of adequate sediments in it can harm marine ecology and biodiversity.
At the same time the hydro-power generation capacity of many publicized projects has been often found to be much lower than projected, not just during the low rainfall months but sometimes also during periods of heavy rainfall, either due to excessive silt brought by water or due to damage to projects themselves.
Despite all this, however, the dam construction lobby cleverly used the recent concern over fossil fuels to push for increase in dam construction. This is ill-advised, as it is well-known that vast forests have been denied their GHG absorbing role due to their submergence in dam reservoirs, while at the same time submerged vegetation rotting in these dam reservoirs releases frightening amounts of methane , a powerful GHG gas, adding up to about 1 billion tons of GHG emissions a year.
Many dams have serious safety issues, which increase greatly in times of heavy rains and earthquakes, while there is also the phenomenon of reservoir-induced seismicity, or RIS, which is itself a serious risk in some cases. 
Vast forests have been denied their GHG absorbing role due to their submergence in dam reservoirs
Tens of thousands have been killed in dam failures all over the world (there were 200 notable dam failures between 2000-2009 and 170,000 are reported to have been killed in a single such tragedy--the Banqiao dam failure in China) and no less in the more frequent, high risk flash floods caused by the sudden releases of vast quantities of water to avoid the risk of dam failure.
Movements like the Narmada Bachao Andolan (NBA -- Save the Narmada) and the Anti-Tehri Dam Struggle deserve great credit for drawing attention to these aspects, paving the way for a more comprehensive understanding of impacts of dams. 
Instead of acknowledging this contribution, narrow-minded interests never cease to spread disinformation about such movements and their activists who actually have a great record of serving people.
The latest of such efforts can be seen in the form of a recent article where the writer laments that Medha Patkar fooled thousands of people while opposing the Sardar Sarovar dam but she was wrong, adding that they should be angry.
The proof the writer offers is his study funded by the London School of Economics (LSE). In fact even the study results quoted by him show 54% of the resettled tribals saying that they would rather be back in the forest!
The bigger point ignored by this article is that a clear majority never got the promised land for land and even the cash compensation given to them involved so many irregularities that a commission had to be appointed to investigate this. 
Another issue is whether researchers funded by LSE are encouraged/authorized by the reputed institute to use incomplete, selective research to trash the most respectable social activists, that too women who are in poor health and are facing endless harassment by the authorities. 
This may be taken up further by those in the academic community concerned with ethical issues.
---
*Honorary convener, Campaign to Save Earth Now, his recent books include ‘A Day in 2071’, ‘Planet in Peril', ‘Man over Machine’ and ‘Protecting Earth for Children'

Comments

TRENDING

'Flawed' argument: Gandhi had minimal role, naval mutinies alone led to Independence

Counterview Desk Reacting to a Counterview  story , "Rewiring history? Bose, not Gandhi, was real Father of Nation: British PM Attlee 'cited'" (January 26, 2016), an avid reader has forwarded  reaction  in the form of a  link , which carries the article "Did Atlee say Gandhi had minimal role in Independence? #FactCheck", published in the site satyagrahis.in. The satyagraha.in article seeks to debunk the view, reported in the Counterview story, taken by retired army officer GD Bakshi in his book, “Bose: An Indian Samurai”, which claims that Gandhiji had a minimal role to play in India's freedom struggle, and that it was Netaji who played the crucial role. We reproduce the satyagraha.in article here. Text: Nowadays it is said by many MK Gandhi critics that Clement Atlee made a statement in which he said Gandhi has ‘minimal’ role in India's independence and gave credit to naval mutinies and with this statement, they concluded the whole freedom struggle.

BSF should take full responsibility for death of 4 kids in West Bengal: Rights defender

By Kirity Roy*  One is deeply disturbed and appalled by the callous trench-digging by BSF in Chetnagachh village under Daspara Gram Panchayat, Chopra, North Dinajpur District, West Bengal that has claimed the lives of four children. Along the entire stretch of Indo-Bangladesh border of West Bengal instead of guarding the actual border delineated by the international border pillars, BSF builds fences and digs trenches well inside the Indian territory, passing through villages and encroaching on private lands, often without due clearance or consent. 

A Hindu alternative to Valentine's Day? 'Shiv-Parvati was first love marriage in Universe'

By Rajiv Shah*   The other day, I was searching on Google a quote on Maha Shivratri which I wanted to send to someone, a confirmed Shiv Bhakt, quite close to me -- with an underlying message to act positively instead of being negative. On top of the search, I chanced upon an article in, imagine!, a Nashik Corporation site which offered me something very unusual. 

How GMOs would destroy non-GMO crops: Aruna Rodrigues' key submissions in SC

Counterview Desk The introduction of Bt and HT crops will harm the health of 1 billion Indians and their animals, believes Aruna Rodrigues, who has made some 60 submissions to the Supreme Court (SC) during the last 20 years. As lead petitioner who filed Public Interest Litigation in 2005, during a spate of intense hearings, which ended on 18 January 2024, she fought in the Apex Court to prevent the commercialization of genetically modified organisms (GMOs) in Indian agriculture. 

Social justice day amidst 'official neglect' of salt pan workers in Little Rann of Kutch

By Prerana Pamkar*  In India’s struggle for Independence, the Salt Satyagraha stands as a landmark movement and a powerful symbol of nonviolent resistance. Led by Mahatma Gandhi, countless determined citizens walked from Sabarmati Ashram to Dandi in Gujarat. However, the Gujarat which witnessed the power of the common Indian during the freedom struggle is now in the throes of another significant movement: this time it is seeking to free salt pan workers from untenable working conditions in the Little Rann of Kutch (LRK).

Corporatizing Indian agriculture 'to enhance' farmer efficiency, market competitiveness

By Shashank Shukla*  Today, amidst the ongoing farmers' protest, one of the key demands raised is for India to withdraw from the World Trade Organization (WTO). Let us delve into the feasibility of such a move and explore its historical context within India's globalization trajectory.

Jallianwala massacre: Why Indian govt hasn't ever officially sought apology from UK

By Manjari Chatterjee Miller*  The king of the Netherlands, Willem-Alexander, apologized in July 2023 for his ancestors’ role in the colonial slave trade. He is not alone in expressing remorse for past wrongs. In 2021, France returned 26 works of art seized by French colonial soldiers in Africa – the largest restitution France has ever made to a former colony. In the same year, Germany officially apologized for its 1904-08 genocide of the Herero and Nama people of Namibia and agreed to fund reconstruction and development projects in Namibia. .

Livelihood issues return to national agenda ahead of LS polls: SKM on Bharat Bandh

Counterview Desk  Top farmers' network, the Samyukta Kisan Morcha (SKM) has claimed big success of Grameen Bharat Bandh and industrial /sectoral strikes, stating, the “struggle reflected anger of farmers, workers and rural people across India”, adding, the move on February 16 succeeded in bringing back peoples’ livelihood issues in the national agenda just ahead of the general election to the Lok Sabha.

How retraints were imposed on academic freedom on the IIM-Ahmedabad campus

By Sandeep Pandey*  This is the seventh consecutive academic year when I would have gone as a visiting faculty member to the Indian Institute of Management at Ahmedabad to teach an Elective course on Transformational Social Movements to the second year of Post Graduate Programme students. But the invitation has not come so far and it looks like it is the end of my teaching stint at IIM, at least, so long as the Bhartiya Janata Party remains in power at the centre.

A 'distorted narrative' of Indian politics: Congress failing to look beyond LS polls

By Prem Singh*  About 15 days ago, I told a senior journalist friend that there are not even two   months left for the Lok Sabha elections, Rahul Gandhi is roaming around on a delectation (tafreeh). The friend probably found my comment exasperating and replied that he is not on a delectation trip. The conversation between us on this topic ended there.