Skip to main content

Indian democracy so fragile it's threatened by Arundhati's 13-yr-old dissenting note?: PUCL

Counterview Desk 

Insisting that dissent is the beating heart of a democracy, India's premier human rights organisation, People’s Union for Civil Liberties (PUCL), has demanded withdrawal of prosecution sanctioned against well known writer Arundhati Roy for offences under sections 153A, 153B and 505 of the Indian Penal Code pertaining to her speech at a convention on Kashmir, ‘Azadi: The Only Way’, organised in New Delhi in October 2010.
"A mature constitutional democracy ought not to prosecute speech, which by itself has no direct causal connection to violence or disorder. It is shameful that an FIR was even registered for speech which by all accounts did not incite or provoke any form of violence", the PUCL statement said, adding, "It does great disservice to the Modi government’s belief that India is the ‘mother of democracy’."

Text:

The PUCL condemns the decision of the Delhi Lieutenant-Governor Vinay Kumar Saxena to grant Delhi Police sanction to prosecute writer Arundhati Roy and Sheikh Showkat Hussain, (former Professor of International Law at Central University of Kashmir), in a 2010 case for offences under sections 153A, 153B and 505 of the Indian Penal Code. The complaint itself pertains to speeches by Arundhati Roy and others at a convention on Kashmir, ‘Azadi: The Only Way’, organised in New Delhi in October 2010.
It is baffling that a 2010 related case is now on the front burner, with sanction being granted by the L-G, almost thirteen years after the alleged incident. The case itself pertains to speech which allegedly fell within the IPC provisions relating to ‘promoting enmity between different groups' (Section 153-A), ‘imputations or assertions prejudicial to national integration’ (Section 153-B) as well as statement conducing to mischief (Section 505). According to the LG, though her speech fell within the understanding of sedition ( Sec 124-A), sanction to prosecute for sedition was not given as ‘the Supreme Court on May 5, 2022, in another case has directed that all pending trials, appeals and proceedings with respect to the charge framed under Section 124A (Sedition) of IPC shall be kept in abeyance and thereafter the three-Judge Bench headed by CJI had referred the matter to Constitution Bench on September 12, 2023’.
A mature constitutional democracy ought not to prosecute speech, which by itself has no direct causal connection to violence or disorder. It is shameful that an FIR was even registered for speech which by all accounts did not incite or provoke any form of violence.
It does great disservice to the Modi government’s belief that India is the ‘mother of democracy’, when the ‘mother’ prosecutes one of her most illustrious children. Arundhati Roy is one of India’s most eminent writers who has used her writing to amplify the concerns of those whose voices are ignored or muted. In her writing be it on the Indian nuclear tests, the dams on the Narmada or of the US war on Iraq she has sought to remind Indians and indeed the inhabitants of the world of the human costs of nuclear technology, development and war.
Her voice matters in contemporary India because her essays though crafted in a highly individual, poetic and literary voice, ‘rose from the heart of a crowd’. She characterised her own writing as not ‘neutral commentary’, but rather as ‘just another stream that flowed into the quick, immense rushing currents that I was writing about.’ By writing about issues which the powerful would rather forget, she forged her ‘contribution to our collective refusal to obediently fade away’.
It is shameful that FIR was registered for speech which by all accounts did not incite or provoke any form of violence
As a writer she has been unafraid to tackle difficult and controversial issues. In a constitutional democracy, such voices even if they shock or disturb the government ought to have free play, because dissent is the beating heart of a democracy.
Mahatma Gandhi spoke about the importance of dissent most powerfully during his prosecution for sedition in colonial times:
“Section 124-A under which I am happily charged is perhaps the prince among the political sections of the Indian Penal Code designed to suppress the liberty of the citizen. Affection cannot be manufactured or regulated by law. If one has no affection for a person or system, one should be free to give the fullest expression to his disaffection, so long as he does not contemplate, promote or incite violence...”
'Speech’ in Gandhi’s words, should have the ‘fullest expression’, with the only limit point being the promotion of violence. The jurisprudence of the Supreme Court also limits the understanding of sedition to speech which directly results in or incites violence. In Balwant Singh v. State of Punjab in 1995, the Supreme Court adjudicated the question as to whether shouting slogans including, “Khalistan Zindabad” in a crowd the day Indira Gandhi was assassinated amounted to sedition. The Supreme Court noted, ‘We find it difficult to hold that upon the raising of such casual slogans, a couple of times without any other act whatsoever the charge of sedition can be founded.’ The Supreme Court went on to chastise the policemen who filed the case, stating that, ‘It does not appear to us that the police should have attached much significance to the casual slogans raised by two appellants, a couple of times and read too much into them’?
Indian democracy is not so fragile as to be threatened by the expression of a dissenting opinion. The LG granting sanction to prosecute is a particularly egregious and constitutionally suspect exercise of state power as is evidenced by the fact that even thirteen years post the utterance of the words those words have not resulted in any violence.
Arundhati Roy is being prosecuted for ‘worrying the edges of the human Imagination’ for writing as if ‘the only thing worth globalizing is dissent’ and believing that dissent is ‘India’s best export’. This is a tragedy for a country which prides itself as being the ‘mother of democracy’.
The PUCL demands that the prosecution be withdrawn with immediate effect against both Arundhati Roy and Sheikh Showkat Hussain.
-- Kavita Srivastava, President, Dr. V. Suresh, General Secretary, PUCL

Comments

TRENDING

Wave of disappearances sparks human rights fears for activists in Delhi

By Harsh Thakor*  A philosophy student from Zakir Hussain College, Delhi University, and an activist associated with Nazariya magazine, Rudra, has been reported missing since the morning of July 19, 2025. This disappearance adds to a growing concern among human rights advocates regarding the escalating number of detentions and disappearances of activists in Delhi.

How community leaders overcome obstacles to protect forests and pastures in remote villages

By Bharat Dogra  Dheera Ram Kapaya grew up in such poverty that, unable to attend school himself, he would carry another boy’s heavy school bag for five kilometers just to get a scoop of daliya (porridge). When he was finally able to attend school, he had to leave after class five to join other adolescent workers. However, as soon as opportunities arose, he involved himself in community efforts—promoting forest protection, adult literacy, and other constructive initiatives. His hidden talent for writing emerged during this time, and he became known for the songs and street play scripts he created to promote forest conservation, discourage child marriages, and support other social reforms.

‘Act of war on agriculture’: Aruna Rodrigues slams GM crop expansion and regulatory apathy

By Rosamma Thomas*  Expressing appreciation to the Union Agriculture Minister for inviting suggestions from farmers and concerned citizens on the sharp decline in cotton crop productivity, Aruna Rodrigues—lead petitioner in the Supreme Court case ongoing since 2005 that seeks a moratorium on genetically modified (GM) crops—wrote to Union Minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan on July 14, 2025, stating that conflicts of interest have infiltrated India’s regulatory system like a spreading cancer, including within the Indian Council for Agricultural Research (ICAR).

The GMO illusion: Three decades of hype, harm, and false hope

By Sridhar Radhakrishnan  Three decades of hype, billions of dollars spent, and still no miracle crop. It's time to abandon the GMO biotech fairy tale and return to the soil, the seed, and the farmer. “Trust us,” they said. “GMOs will feed the world.” Picture a world where there is plenty of food, no hunger, fields grow without chemical pesticides, children are saved from malnutrition, and people live healthily.

Overriding India's constitutional sovereignty? Citizens urge PM to reject WHO IHR amendments

By A Representative   A group of concerned Indian citizens, including medical professionals and activists, has sent an urgent appeal to Prime Minister Narendra Modi, urging him to reject proposed amendments to the International Health Regulations (IHR) before the ratification deadline of July 19, 2025. 

Sandra Gonzalez Sanabria: An inspiring life from Colombia’s Amazonian valley

By Vidya Bhushan Rawat*  In the village of Héctor Ramírez, known as Agua Bonita, in La Montañita, Caquetá, Colombia, a vision of peace and renewal is unfolding. In the pre-2016 period, this would have been nearly impossible for outsiders to visit, as it was the epicenter of violent resistance against state oppression. However, after the Peace Accord was signed between the Colombian government and former revolutionaries—marking the end of a 70-year insurgency that claimed over 400,000 lives until 2025, including civilians, rebel fighters, and security personnel—things began to change. Visiting Agua Bonita during the Global Land Forum in Bogotá revealed a village of hope and resilience. Former FARC revolutionaries have settled here and transformed the village into a center of peace and aspiration.

Indigenous Karen activist calls for global solidarity amid continued struggles in Burma

By A Representative   At the International Festival for People’s Rights and Struggles (IFPRS), Naw Paw Pree, an Indigenous Karen activist from the Karen Human Rights Group (KHRG), shared her experiences of oppression, resilience, and hope. Organized with the support of the International Indigenous Peoples Movement for Self-Determination and Liberation (IPMSDL), the event brought together Indigenous and marginalized communities from across the globe, offering a rare safe space for shared learning, solidarity, and expression.

Activists allege abduction and torture by Delhi Police Special Cell in missing person probe

By A Representative   A press statement released today by the Campaign Against State Repression (CASR) alleges that several student and social activists have been abducted, illegally detained, and subjected to torture by the Delhi Police Special Cell. The CASR claims these actions are linked to an investigation into the disappearance of Vallika Varshri, an editorial team member of 'Nazariya' magazine.

India’s zero-emission, eco-friendly energy strategies have a long way to go, despite impressive progress

By N.S. Venkataraman*   The recent report released by OPEC’s World Oil Outlook 2025 has predicted that by the year 2050, crude oil would replace coal as India’s key energy source. Clearly, OPEC expects that India’s dependence on fossil fuels for energy will continue to remain high in one form or another.