Skip to main content

Historical narratives shaped by academic work overshadowed by politically charged "WhatsApp" history

By Ram Puniyani
The rise of "WhatsApp University," as it’s popularly called, has profoundly impacted public perceptions. It’s a platform where historical narratives shaped by rigorous academic work are often overshadowed by politically charged interpretations. Academic historians, who have devoted years to producing historical work grounded in rational, scientific methods, are increasingly sidelined by a dominant political agenda. A key concern is that social perceptions shaped by this medium are advancing a specific ideological goal—namely, the retrogressive agenda of Hindutva or Hindu Nationalism.
This issue was highlighted recently by historian William Dalrymple (photo), who, in a conversation with journalists, pointed to the spread of "WhatsApp history." According to Dalrymple, the failure of Indian historians to connect with a general audience has given rise to a wave of misconceived ideas—such as the belief that Aryans were the original inhabitants of India, or that ancient India had advanced scientific knowledge including aeronautics, plastic surgery, and genetic engineering. This medium also fosters popular but misleading ideas about Islam and Christianity as “foreign” religions, portrays Muslim rulers as temple destroyers, and perpetuates the myth that Gandhi was anti-Hindu or that India's independence was not due to the national movement.
This narrative has its roots in the political ideology of Hindu nationalism. During India’s freedom movement, the prevailing narrative promoted by the national movement was one of inclusiveness, recognizing India as a “nation in the making.” However, Hindu nationalists at the time asserted that Hindus constituted a nation since ancient times, while Muslim nationalists dated their “nationhood” to the eighth century with Mohammad bin Qasim’s conquest of Sindh. British colonial historiography, such as James Mill's History of India, further divided Indian history into Hindu, Muslim, and British periods, reinforcing religiously polarized narratives.
Hindu nationalist historiography began taking hold through RSS programs and publications, later finding institutional support. This process gained momentum when Lal Krishna Advani served as the Information and Broadcasting Minister in the Janata Party government, leading to a strategic infiltration of Hindu nationalist narratives into government channels. Today, this process has expanded, with RSS-aligned educational campaigns and the introduction of a series of textbooks authored by Dinanath Batra in thousands of schools in Gujarat. Additionally, with corporate control of media by groups friendly to the ruling party, the reach of these narratives has grown exponentially. BJP’s IT cell has strategically utilized WhatsApp to circulate these versions of history, as analyzed in Swati Chaturvedi’s book I Was a Troll.
Meanwhile, academic historians like Romila Thapar, Irfan Habib, and Bipan Chandra have contributed comprehensive works on ancient, medieval, and modern Indian history, many of which were included in NCERT syllabi in the 1980s. However, with the BJP’s rise to power in 1998, the “saffronization” of education began, intensifying after 2014. The objective appears to be the full-scale introduction of pseudo-historical and mythological content as part of the official history curriculum.
While scholars have historically played a part in shaping public perceptions, these perceptions are largely molded by the ruling political ideologies. Noam Chomsky’s concept of “Manufacturing Consent” illustrates how governments create public understanding that aligns with their own agendas, often at the expense of historical truth. In India, despite the remarkable work of historians, the dominant political tendencies frequently dictate what becomes "common sense" for the masses.
Although Dalrymple’s concerns about WhatsApp's spread of irrational narratives are valid, the issue runs deeper. The rise of right-wing politics has amplified these narratives, creating a version of history that departs significantly from academic scholarship. Figures like Arun Shourie, once affiliated with the BJP, have written critiques against reputed historians, further fueling an antagonistic stance toward academic history.
Ultimately, WhatsApp is just an additional tool in the broader dissemination of Hindu nationalist propaganda. To counteract this trend, more groups need to help bridge the gap between historians and the public, fostering a social common sense rooted in inclusivity, scientific reasoning, and Indian nationalism. While academic historians continue to contribute, WhatsApp’s influence is largely a byproduct of the rise of communal politics, not a reflection of historians’ shortcomings.
---
A version of this article was first published in Newsclick

Comments

TRENDING

How natural and organic farming can be a key to combating the climate crisis

By Raj Kumar Sinha*  On July 9, while addressing the “Sahkar Samvad” in Ahmedabad with women and workers associated with cooperatives from Gujarat, Madhya Pradesh, and Rajasthan, Union Home Minister Amit Shah emphasized that natural farming is essential for both our health and the health of the soil. This is a significant statement in the context of addressing the climate change crisis. Natural farming can play a crucial role in combating climate change. Also known as organic farming, it is a system of agriculture that can increase food production without harming the environment. Natural farming has the potential to reduce carbon emissions by 35% to 50%.

100 yrs of RSS as seen by global media house: Power, controversy, push for Hindu-first India

By Rajiv Shah  On a blistering summer evening in Nagpur, nearly a thousand men in brown trousers, white shirts, and black caps stood in formation as a saffron flag was raised, marking a graduation ceremony for Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) workers. This vivid scene, described in a recent FT Weekend Magazine article, “A hundred years after it was founded, India's Hindu-nationalist movement is getting closer to its goal of a Hindu-first state,” captures the enduring presence of the RSS, a century-old Hindu-nationalist organization.

Top US thinktank probe questions ECI's institutional integrity, democratic fairness

By Rajiv Shah   In a comprehensive analysis published in "Indian Politics & Policy" (Vol. 5, No. 1, Summer 2025), a research periodical of the Washington DC-based think tank Policy Studies Organization, author Milan Vaishnav, Senior Fellow and Director, South Asia Programme, Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, has raised questions over the fairness of the Election Commission of India (ECI) in conducting Lok Sabha elections. Titled “Assessing the Integrity of India’s 2024 Lok Sabha Elections,” the analysis acquires significance as it precedes recent controversies surrounding the ECI’s move to revise electoral rolls.

Another 'honor' killing in Tamil Nadu: Caste pride has murdered love, again

By Vidya Bhushan Rawat*  Once again, Tamil Nadu has witnessed a brutal so-called 'honor' killing. This time, it is Kevin Selvaganesh, a 27-year-old software engineer from the Scheduled Caste community, who has been hacked to death by the family of the girl he loved since childhood. Kevin, a brilliant student employed at Tata Consultancy Services, was in a relationship with Subashini, his schoolmate and girlfriend. The couple, both well-educated and professionally qualified, had plans to marry. Yet, that love story ended in bloodshed — sacrificed at the altar of caste pride.

Why is India’s cheetah project under fire? Study flags ecological, social, species injustices

  By Rajiv Shah  A recent peer-reviewed study has sharply criticized Project Cheetah—India’s high-profile initiative to reintroduce African cheetahs into the wild—as ethically compromised, scientifically flawed, and socially unjust. Titled “Delineating the Environmental Justice Implications of an Experimental Cheetah Introduction Project in India”, the paper is authored by Yashendu C. Joshi, Stephanie E. Klarmann, and Louise C. de Waal, and was published in  Frontiers in Conservation Science.

The myth of population decline: India’s real challenge is density, not fertility

By N.S. Venkataraman*   India’s population in 2025 stands at approximately 1.4 billion. In 1950, it was 359 million, rising sharply to 1.05 billion by 2000. The population continues to grow and is projected to reach around 1.7 billion by 2050.

Siang dam project sparks debate over security, development, and displacement in Arunachal

By Aarna Gupta*  The proposed Siang Upper Multipurpose Project (SUMP) in Arunachal Pradesh, India, has emerged as a contentious initiative shaped by strategic, environmental, and social concerns. Indian officials, including Union Minister Kiren Rijiju and Arunachal Pradesh Chief Minister Pema Khandu, have voiced strong support for the project. One of the primary motivations is China’s plan to build a 60,000 MW hydropower dam on the Yarlung Tsangpo River (the upper stretch of the Brahmaputra) in Tibet, which Indian authorities see as a threat to water and national security. In response, the 11,000 MW Siang Dam, with its 9 billion cubic meter reservoir, is viewed as a necessary countermeasure to manage water flow and reduce vulnerability.

Shanghai Textbook reassessed: Between revolutionary rhetoric and economic reality

By Harsh Thakor  "Maoist Economics and the Revolutionary Road to Communism: The Shanghai Textbook on Socialist Political Economy" (1975) presents a detailed exposition of the Chinese perspective on socialist political economy under Mao . Developed during the Cultural Revolution, it outlines a theoretical framework for the functioning of a socialist alternative to capitalism. The book was formulated under the direction of Zhang Chunqiao, who played a central role in discussions, content planning, and final reviews of the draft.

Trump’s tariff tactics are a geopolitical bully move that may backfire

By Vidya Bhushan Rawat*  U.S. President Donald Trump’s recent move to impose high tariffs on Indian goods is yet another example of his aggressive, unilateralist economic policy—an attempt to pressure and punish rather than to negotiate. This is not an isolated action. Trump has shown similar hostility toward other countries aligned with the BRICS bloc—Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa—reflecting his disdain for multipolar global cooperation and his desire to maintain American economic supremacy at all costs.