Ethics and aesthetics are the cornerstones of our identity and history. They define who we are and how we are remembered. I have often observed these values in Europe during significant events, and I wonder why we, in India, struggle to emulate such dignity and authenticity. Instead, we often find ourselves caught in the artificiality of performative gestures, waiting for the camera's gaze or the allure of live television. Our leaders, or Netas, rarely pay genuine tribute to the people; instead, they seize these moments to push their agendas.
The recent passing of Pope Francis was a poignant reminder of how events can be conducted with grace and dignity. World leaders, monarchs, presidents, and prime ministers gathered at the Vatican for his funeral. The event was meticulously planned, evoking a sense of awe and reverence. Such grandeur and order are reminiscent of royal ceremonies in London. Every society has its unique style, reflecting its traditions and history. While I respect this diversity, there are lessons our administrators and planners can take to heart.
In India, the passing of a prominent leader often devolves into chaos. For days, it becomes a political spectacle, with supporters weeping, shouting slogans, and creating unnecessary drama. This has become our norm. The recent last journey of former Prime Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh highlighted this issue. The vehicle carrying his body sped through the streets, with people dangerously running behind. Such scenes are not only disorganized but perilous. Why can't we adopt a more structured approach? Instead of encouraging people to chase vehicles, we could organize tributes at designated venues or cremation grounds, ensuring safety and dignity.
Another area where we can learn is the sense of responsibility and maturity often displayed by the Christian community and the Western world. Their leaders speak with wisdom and restraint, unlike many of our Dharmgurus, who often resort to provocative and irresponsible rhetoric. While Christianity has its flaws, it has shown a remarkable ability to learn and evolve. Pope Francis exemplified this with his courage and conviction. He stood with the people of Gaza, called for an end to war, and initiated reforms within the Church, even in the face of opposition. His leadership showcased the Church's diversity, with representation from Africa, Latin America, and Asia, breaking the stereotype of European dominance.
The funeral of Pope Francis was a masterclass in dignity. Leaders from over 130 countries attended, yet there was no VIP culture. Cameras did not focus on individuals, and no one received special treatment. The procession through Vatican City and Rome was marked by discipline and respect. The prayers and choir resonated in traditional languages, not English, preserving the authenticity of the occasion. This stands in stark contrast to the melodrama and political messaging that often mar similar events in India.
As we reflect on these differences, it is clear that we have much to learn. Moving away from VIP culture, sloganeering, and political opportunism is essential. The Vatican funeral was a testament to unity and respect, reinforcing faith in the institution of the Papacy. Pope Francis's legacy of outreach and reform should inspire us to strive for a more dignified and ethical approach in our own traditions and ceremonies.
---
*Human rights defender
Comments
Post a Comment
NOTE: Hateful, abusive comments won't be published. -- Editor