Skip to main content

Stan Swamy vs Arnab Goswami: Are activists fighting a losing battle? Whither justice?

By Fr Sunil Macwan SJ*

It is time one raised pertinent questions over the courts denying bail to Fr Stan Swamy, who was arrested under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA), and granting it to Arnab Goswami, editor-in-chief of the Republic TV, arrested under the charge of abetting suicide of Avay Naik, who ended his life in 2018. It is travesty of justice that a human rights activist is not only denied bail but is also made to wait for weeks to hear a response to his legitimate request for a straw to drink water, while Arnab Goswami walks free.
Arnab found a quick hearing from the Supreme Court, which granted him bail to uphold his personal liberty. Baffling as it is, the apparent double-standards of our legal system reveal a harsh reality, which the supporters of Stan Swamy and champions of truth and justice would need to perceive.
Arnab was released on bail in less than 10 days but Stan Swamy still remains imprisoned for over a month now, because the former is a powerful mainstream media personality who speaks for certain establishments, while the latter is a peripheral activist, who speaks for the marginalized and the voiceless. One speaks with power; the other speaks truth to power. The former is facile, while the latter is challenging.
An activist, Stan Swamy has fought for justice for well over four decades, vowing to relentlessly continue doing so in future. Therefore, those supporting him must not become disheartened by the denial of bail to him, nor by the legal relief made available to others, such as Arnab Goswami. If speaking truth to power were easy and cheap, an octogenarian with serious ailments would not be languishing in jail today. Indeed, speaking truth to power has consequences and being heard can take a long time.
Stan Swamy, an 83-year-old priest, was arrested on October 8 from his residence in Ranchi by the National Investigation Agency (NIA) in connection with the Bhima Koregaon case. The chargesheet accuses him of possessing Maoist propaganda material and receiving Rs 8 lakh from the CPI-Maoist organization. He is also accused of planning to instruct people to “disrupt the fake development propaganda disseminated by star campaigners of BJP-RSS corporate-friendly family”.
Stan categorically denies these charges and courageously claims that if NIA refuses to consider his plea, he is “ready to face the consequence”. According to the octogenarian activist, he is not alone in facing the government’s ire for fighting for justice and human rights. Several others have also been indicted, arrested and imprisoned.
One could notice three trends on speaking truth to power in support of Fr Stan Swamy – among masses, politicians, and the international community.

Spontaneous public protests

Spontaneous public support for Stan Swamy gained momentum across the country after his arrest. Concerned citizens, fellow social activists, and human rights groups came together to express solidarity with him in recognition of his decades-long service to the Adivasis and the marginalized. Notable among these were demonstrations in Jharkhand – Fr. Stan’s karmabhumi for the last three decades – in the form of justice rally and human chain on October 16 and 17. Similar solidarity events also took place in various places in Tamil Nadu, West Bengal, and Maharastra.
Social media has been abuzz with the campaign #StandWithStan, though not much about it is heard in the mainstream media either because they consider the matter sub judice or for fear backlash from the government. That said, a sustained public outrage against the arrest of Stan Swamy and other human rights activists in the Bhima Koregaon case evinces that there are people who consider him a champion of human rights and justice. They all are an asset to the nation and not a threat.

Political leaders

Political leaders and groups have also risen in support of Stan Swamy across the country. A good example of this trend is the virtual meeting organized on October 21 by various political parties and eminent personalities to condemn the arrests of the Bhima Koregaon activists and to demand immediate their release.
The participants included Jharkhand chief minister Hemant Soren (who sent across his video message to the meet), CPI-M general secretary Sitaram Yechuri, CPI leader and Rajya Sabha MP D Raja, DMK leader and Lok Sabha MP Kanimozhi, Congress leader and Lok Sabha MP Shashi Tharoor, and eminent academic Jean Dreze.
Their sentiment was eloquently expressed by Shashi Tharoor. Describing Stan Swamy as an ailing activist “who has spent four decades of his life, working with poor people and tribal people,” Tharoor said, Stan Swamy “is a good man who has worked and lived with the Adivasis” of Jharkhand. He described Stan Swamy as part of the groups that strive to meet the challenge of making progress in the future of “the most deprived and marginalized of our country.”
Indeed, in that role, Stan Swamy joins ranks with various lawmakers, writers, opinion shapers, social activists and religious and social leaders, who collaborate to realize this dream. It is crucial, therefore, to highlight the wider context in which Stan Swamy lives and serves. But will Tharoor’s observation on Stan Swamy’s invaluable service as a social activist will find a listening ear among the investigating agencies so as to examine his track record in proper light?

International community

Solidarity with Stan Swamy and other human rights activists is not limited to spontaneous protests and political support in India. International organisations have also raised concerns about his unfortunate arrest and incarceration. Among them, UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Michelle Bachelet expressed serious concern about Stan Swamy’s arrest in a statement released on October 20.
Noting that activists and human rights defenders have faced pressure from the Indian government in recent months, Bachelet cited the recent arrest of “the 83-year-old Catholic priest Stan Swamy, a long-standing activist engaged in defending the rights of marginalized groups”, and urged the government “to ensure that no one else is detained for exercising their rights to freedom of expression and peaceful assembly… and to protect India’s robust civil society.” The larger context of Bachelet’s statement focused on urging the Indian government to protect human rights defenders and NGOs in the aftermath of the Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act (FCRA) and the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA).
Intensity of protests has waned. Much of the public demonstrations have ceased. Political parties have diverted attention to other issues
Bachelet’s reading of Stan Swamy’s arrest serves as an example of the challenges faced by social activists who oppose certain government policies in the wider public interests. It also functions as a reminder to the establishments to respect the legitimate concerns felt by the international community with regard to the human rights and justice situation in India. Treating Stan Swamy’s case merely as a Maoist sympathizer’s arraignment will grossly overlook the deeper sociopolitical and economic issues addressed by his social work.
In his recorded statement just before his arrest, Stan Swamy identified his predicament with those of several others across the country. “What is happening to me is not unique. Many activists, lawyers, writers, journalists, student leaders, poets, intellectuals and others who stand for the rights of Adivasis, dalits and the marginalized and express their dissent to the ruling powers of the country are being targeted,” he said.
Those who have rallied in solidarity with Stan Swamy on the streets and social media, political circles and international organizations have spoken truth to power, albeit in different degrees and manners. And inasmuch as speaking truth to power involves standing up for justice in the face of oppression and intimidation, these movements have, in their own way, helped globalise dissent to promote justice.
Such activism can be violently suppressed in the name of law and order and national security, but cannot be completely silenced. Much less can they be completely wiped out in our 21st century. We live in a digital and cyber world, which enables us to transcend all barriers to connect with others instantly.
Yet, the fact is, the intensity of the protests has waned in recent weeks. Much of the public demonstrations have ceased. Political parties have diverted attention to other issues, and the international community seems to have lost track of the case. The denial of bail to Stan Swamy has dealt a setback to his supporters, and the granting of bail to Arnab Goswami rubs salt in the wound.
The question arises: Is there no justice in India? Are we fighting a lost cause? Is it a losing battle? No. Speaking truth to power is a potent act and the fight must continue. The struggle has to be sustained by campaigning for Stan Swamy’s release. It will be a painfully long and challenging process. Deserting it is not an option, just as speaking truth to power is not an option for civil society.
Veteran Congress leader Kapil Sibal’s recent comment on Justice Chandrachud’s statement on the Supreme Court’s responsibility of safeguarding personal liberty of citizens gives one hope that intellectual and legal struggle to free Stan Swamy will endure for as long as it takes. It is not only about his freedom; it is about the freedom to stand up for truth, justice and human rights without the fear of reprisal. After all, if Arnab Goswami can be released on bail on account of his personal liberty, why not Stan Swami? Why not all others? Time will tell.
---
*Department of English, St Xavier’s College, Ahmedabad

Comments

Anonymous said…
What is happening in the case of Fr.Stan Swamy is Gross injustice .
Anonymous said…
It's a shame to see the media and the political parties influencing and controlling the entire system and especially the judiciary in India. Hope to get bold people who can reinstall our faith in the system.
SAMIR SARDANA said…
STAN SWAMY, A PASTOR, 85 YEARS OLD,SUFFERING FROM PARKINSON, DENIED BAIL AND MEDICAL AID ,WAS KILLED BY THE NIA.dindooohindoo

HE WAS FIGHTING FOR TRIBAL RIGHTS ! THIS IS THE STATE OF DALIT AND TRIBALS IN INDIA ! IF A PASTOR CAN BE KILLED - THEN WHAT OF THE TRIBALS ?

Y MAOISM ? dindooohindoo

NIA IS A CRIMINAL ORGANISATION OF SCUM – WHO DESERVE TO BE DESTROYED ! I CALL THEM PANDOOS AND KHAKI KE KUTTE !

SOME CASES OF HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND CORRUPTION BY THE NIA

• Suicide by a 22 year old Dalit Sikh after NIA 10 hour interrogation

https://indianexpress.com/article/india/dalit-youth-suicide-kin-demand-probe-link-death-to-nia-quizzing-6515902/
• An 89 year old missionary classed and jailed as a Terrorist and denied a straw https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-54490554
• A 80 year old poet classed and jailed as a Terrorist and infected with COVID https://newsbox9.com/varavara-rao-gets-bail-in-surjagarh-iron-ore-mine-arson-case/

NIA IS ALSO AN ORGANISATION OF CHORS AND BLACKMAILERS.EXAMPLE OF CORRUPTION BY NIA SP AND 2 OTHERS

https://www.news18.com/news/india/3-nia-officers-accused-of-demanding-rs-2-crore-from-businessman-to-exempt-him-from-hafiz-saeeds-case-transferred-2276915.html https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/3-nia-officers-accused-of-seeking-bribe-in-case-against-hafiz-saeed-removed/story-VEIln0tILHengK5xu3e0LN.html https://www.news18.com/news/india/3-nia-officers-accused-of-demanding-rs-2-crore-from-businessman-to-exempt-him-from-hafiz-saeeds-case-transferred-2276915.html

NIA INDICTS ITS OWN FOR CORRUPTION

https://www.indiatoday.in/india/story/nia-asks-home-ministry-to-take-action-against-own-sp-2-officials-in-bribery-case-1599834-2019-09-16

CBI CHARGESHEETS NIA SP

https://www.deccanherald.com/national/cbi-books-ex-nia-asp-for-fraudulently-obtaining-cdr-of-mobile-phone-numbers-879174.html

NIA IS ALSO A NIKAMMA ORGANISATION .SOME CASES OF FAILED NIA INVESTIGATIONS

• Kerala Gold Smuggling case

https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/kerala/nia-failed-to-prove-terror-link-court/article32931347.ece
https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/kerala/nothing-to-substantiate-terror-funding-nia-court/article32864036.ece

COURT DIRECTIONS TO NIA TO SUBMIT EVIDENCE

https://www.newindianexpress.com/states/kerala/2020/jul/30/court-asks-nia-to-present-proof-to-link-terrorism-and-gold-smuggling-2176572.html

COURT GRANTING BAIL TO STUDENTS CHARGED BY NIA

https://scroll.in/latest/972817/kochi-nia-court-grants-bail-to-terror-accused-students-says-they-have-fundamental-right-to-protest

FAILURE OF NIA TO FILE CHARGESHEET WITHIN 180 DAYS IN PULWAMA CASE

https://www.firstpost.com/india/days-after-pulwama-terror-attack-anniversary-accused-gets-bail-after-nia-fails-to-file-chargesheet-in-time-8094521.html
SAMIR SARDANA said…
If there is NIA there will be retribution - whether from ISIS or any others !

COURT STRICTURES ON ACQUITTAL OF UAPA ACCUSED - WHICH PROVES THAT NIA IS SCUM

Jalandhar fast track court acquitted Manjit, seven others in a case registered against them under UAPA at Bhogpur police station in Jalandhar on September 28, 2009

• Court stated “From all this evidence, the prosecution has failed to prove any link of recoveries made from accused or transactions of money with any terrorist act or organisation.Simple statement of DSP Rajinder Singh Sohal that he received secret information is not sufficient to hold the accused having committed or attempted to have committed any such offence”

UAPA case was registered against Kobad Gandhy on January 1, 2010

• The court observed: “In this case, neither any recovery was affected at the instance of accused. Since the prosecution failed to prove that the accused was pertaining to a militant group or he was having any nexus with enemy countries, there is no evidence on record to show the accused was having any link with terrorist activities or militant group. … Supreme Court… has held, that mere membership of a banned organisation cannot incriminate a person..

UAPA and Arms Act on Sept 15, 2013,at Purana Shalla police station in Gurdaspur Gurpreet Singh and 11 others

• The trial court observed: “So many disclosures were recorded to show that he (Gurpreet Singh) had kept concealed and got recovered the ammunition from different parts of the country between November 7 and 9, 2014. It is highly impossible for anyone to move such distances cities in three days. It shows prosecution only wants to implicate him by hook or crook

IT IS EVIDENT THAT THE PURPOSE OF NIA AND THE INDIAN STATE IS TO TERRORISE AND TRAUMATISE THE ACCUSED AND SEND A MESSAGE TO SOCIETY AS TO THE FATE OF THOSE WHO DISSENT – AND TO SEND A SIGNAL TO THE PEOPLE THAT THE NIA AND THE INDIAN STATE CAN VIOLATE THE RIGHTS OF INDIANS AT WILL

IN ADDITION,NIA USES THESE DUBIOUS ENQUIRIES TO “DIG DIRT ON AN ACCUSED” AND THEN USE THE INFORMATION TO COERCE AND BLACKMAIL THE ACCUSED – A TRAIT OF HEATHENS AND MENIALS. dindooohindoo

TRENDING

India reaches 8th of 10 stage genocide: US Muslim advocacy group raises 'alert'

By Hena Zuberi* India has reached the 8th stage of genocide with the persecution of the Muslim community. Stating this, Professor Greg Stanton, who heads Genocide Watch, declared a Genocide Emergency Alert for India today at Justice For All online briefing.

Mayawati's 'success' depends on how BSP taps new crop of young Amdekarite leaders

By Vidya Bhushan Rawat*  Whatever be the election results in Uttar Pradesh on March 10, it is extremely important to understand: that the Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP) and its leader Mayawati have the potential to rise like a Phoenix any time.

Swami Vivekananda's views on caste and sexuality were 'painfully' regressive

By Bhaskar Sur* Swami Vivekananda now belongs more to the modern Hindu mythology than reality. It makes a daunting job to discover the real human being who knew unemployment, humiliation of losing a teaching job for 'incompetence', longed in vain for the bliss of a happy conjugal life only to suffer the consequent frustration.

Anti-poor? 'Cumbersome' to link aadhaar, voter ID for people sans internet access

By Prashant Kumar Chaudhary, Ajit Kumar Jaiswal*  At present, technology plays an increasingly crucial part in modelling human existence by offering a variety of solutions to many of the challenges individuals confront in the real world. As a result, every branch of research works to provides means to solve these difficulties precisely and efficiently. The Central government works along the same lines as well.

India's actual Covid death rate about 2500 per million, third highest in world: Study

By Rajiv Shah  There is now well-researched proof, if it can be called that, indicating that the Government of India may have fudged data to show lower Covid death rate. A new paper, published in “Science”, has said that while officially the Government of India’s Covid-related death estimates as of January 1, 2022 – 345 per million population – are one-seventh of the US death rate, the actual analysis of crude death rate in India suggests, this may be a gross underestimation. 

Democratic leaders silently greeting Modi's 'increasingly autocratic' rule: HRW

Counterview Desk The Human Rights Watch (HRW)’s new “World Report 2022: Events of 2021”, claiming to “investigate abuses, expose facts widely, and pressure those with power to respect rights and secure justice”, has identified India as one of the countries where “autocracy is ascendant and democracy on the decline” because of emergence of leaders with autocratic tendencies.

Barbaric, inhuman attack on Odisha villagers to implement JSW project: NGO networks

Counterview Desk  A “solidarity statement" issued by three top civil society networks, Friends of the Earth India (FoE India), Delhi Solidarity Group (DSG) and the National Alliance of People’s Movements (NAPM), has asked the Odisha chief minister to ensure that the “inhumane barbaric attack on the villagers of Dhinkia, Odisha” in order to implement a corporate project.

Gender insensitive? Model Gujarat's cyclone relief package ignores 40,000 fisherwomen

CSJ volunteers talking to fisherwomen By Rajiv Shah  A Centre for Social Justice (CSJ) note on the Gujarat government’s compensation package to the victims of the devastating Tauktae cyclone, which hit the coastal belt of Saurashtra's Amerli, Rajula, Una, and Gir-Somnath districts in May 2021, has said, the relief offered was so terribly inadequate that many of the fisherfolk were not able to fish for the rest of the year.

Buddhist shrines were 'massively destroyed' by Brahmanical rulers: Historian DN Jha

Nalanda mahavihara By Our Representative Prominent historian DN Jha, an expert in India's ancient and medieval past, in his new book , "Against the Grain: Notes on Identity, Intolerance and History", in a sharp critique of "Hindutva ideologues", who look at the ancient period of Indian history as "a golden age marked by social harmony, devoid of any religious violence", has said, "Demolition and desecration of rival religious establishments, and the appropriation of their idols, was not uncommon in India before the advent of Islam".

Haridwar call for genocide direct result of Modi 'tolerating' Islamophobic policies

By Our Representative  A high-level briefing organised in Washington DC, in which as many as 17 human rights and interfaith organizations -- including Amnesty International USA, Genocide Watch and Hindus for Human Rights, apart from several persons in their individual capacity -- participated, has come down heavily on what they called "Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Islamophobic policies and tolerance of open incitement by Hindu extremists for a genocide of Muslims."