Skip to main content

Varavara Rao's personal liberty: Will Justice Chadrachud's order set a precedent?

By Vidya Bhushan Rawat*
The Bombay High Court has rejected the bail of poet and author Varavara Rao, who is incarcerating in Mumbai’s Taloja Central Jail for over two years in the Bhima Koregaon 'conspiracy' case, in which a chargesheet has not yet been filed. Rao is 80 plus and cannot walk without help. He is suffering from various ailments. The court has “directed” the government to get him treated. It seems the government is willing to spend money on his treatment but is not ready to give him bail.
The Bombay High Court order came a day after Supreme Court judge, Justice Chandrachud, spoke powerfully about 'personal liberty', asking High Courts to ensure that bail is given to people. However, it seems, those who can’t hire powerful lawyers or those who don’t have the backing of the state and media would continue to suffer.
Those who saw Arnab Goswami coming out of jail can understand how much 'respect' he has for institutions. He 'threatened' and 'challenged' Maharashtra chief minister Uddhav Thackeray and Mumbai Police Commissioner Paramveer Singh. While the Supreme Court said that he will cooperate in investigation into charges of abetment to suicide, it is for anyone to assume that Arnab will now continue with his diatribes, unless a court passes clear injunctions.
Varavara Rao and his family have no news channel running for them. Unlike Arnab, he is not crying and begging that his life is under threat. Even if he and other activists behind bars are released on bail, they can’t influence anyone, unlike Arnab, who can use everything, right from his media to political connections, to threaten opponents.
Many people were upset with the Supreme Court becoming conscious of 'personal liberty' of Arnab, who never respected the same for anyone else. Hence, they questioned the verdict. While courts are known to have ruled that they are open to fair criticism, India’s attorney-general has now approved contempt proceedings against comedian Kunal Kamra.
One may not be much interested in Kamra’s comedies, which most of the time are foul-mouthed (quite like Arnab’s), it is surprising that his tweets were called as 'contempt of court'. Ironically, The attorney-General did not find any contempt of the court in Andhra Pradesh chief minister Jagan Reddy's explosive letter against one of the sitting judges of the Supreme Court..
While one awaits the detailed judgment of Justice Chandrachud, where, he said, he had given detailed reasons of granting bail to Arnab, the wait for justice for human rights defenders, political dissenters and social activists will continue to be long. One does not know when will the dark tunnel see the light of the day. Till then, one would have to believe in the system, even if it has become fragile and suffocating.
Justice Chandrachud
Be that as it may, the fact is, Justice Chandrachud’s observation on 'personal liberty', insisting that if states go against it as they should know there is a Supreme Court ready to “protect” it, comes from one of the top thinking judges of our time. He is considered very knowledgeable, one who has disagreed many a time with major judgments. 
Yet, the fact is, the special Supreme Court sitting was just a plan to give Arnab bail. This happened despite the fact that Arnab never followed any procedures, even bypassed them. He showed no faith in lower courts. He was indecent during hearings. His bail application was pending in a higher court, yet he decided to approach the High Court.
So many activists have been suffering enormously in difficult circumstances in various jails, but there is no outrage on personal liberty
But when the High Court asked him to return to the lower court for regular bail, as is the procedure, his lawyers felt, enough was enough. They should now get intervention from the Supreme Court. Hearing for his bail was urgently listed, leading senior advocate Dushyant Dave raising questions about Supreme Court registry picking up Arnab's case so fast when thousands of such cases are pending.
In fact, political leaders and activists languishing in jail after the abrogation of Article 370 is rarely heard on time. Habeas corpus petition of former chief minister Farooq Abdullah was dismissed after the government said he had been 'released', even when he was not. Similar things happened to Prof Saifuddin Soz. The court accepted the 'government' version as gospel truth.
For the last several years, so many activists have been suffering enormously in difficult circumstances in various jails, but there is no outrage on personal liberty. Like Varavara Rao, Stan Swamy is 80 plus and is suffering from various age-related ailments. Yet there is no outrage. Anand Teltumbde, Gautam Navlakha and others have been in jail for their writings. Both of them are in their sixties.
Indeed, it is good that Justice Chandrachud said that he wanted to give an order which would set a precedent. He admonished High Courts for not being active enough on the issue of personal liberty, pointing out, they have been very lax in giving bail. But it is also a fact that some of the High Courts over the last six years have delivered better judgments in terms of people's rights, which is not the case with the apex court.
A case in point is what happened to Dr Kafeel Khan, who was arrested under the National Security Act (NSA) for no fault of his and was released by the High Court. The Uttar Pradesh government shamelessly slapped other cases on him and rearrested him. It was only after the Allahabad High Court intervened that he got bail.
Meanwhile, there is reason to wonder if courts will undo the systematic wrong under which those who can't afford a Harish Salve or a Kapil Sibal are able to get justice. It is possible to appoint a judicial commission under retired judges of Supreme Court to come up with clear guidelines related to political prisoners, human rights defenders and activists working for people's rights. After all, they are punished for being the voice of the people.
Talking of 'personal liberty' in isolation, in relation to just one case, would be hypocrisy. It is important that the whole issue is dealt in a decisive way by the Supreme Court, which should give categorical guidelines to the state not to arrest people for a mere tweet or a Facebook post. During the arguments, Justice Chandrachud said if you don’t like Republic TV, don’t watch it. While these are just observations, things are not so simple.
---
*Human rights defender

Comments

TRENDING

India's GDP down by 50%, not 23%, job loss 200 million not 122 million: Top economist

By Our Representative  One of India’s topmost economists has estimated that India’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP) decline was around 50%, and not 23%, as claimed by the Government of India’s top data body, National Statistical Organization (NSO). Prof Arun Kumar, who is Malcolm S Adiseshiah chair professor, Institute of Social Sciences, New Delhi, said this was delivering a web policy speech, organised by the Impact and Policy Research Institute (IMPRI), New Delhi.

Youngest of 16 activists jailed for sedition, Mahesh Raut 'fought' mining on tribal land

By Surabhi Agarwal, Sandeep Pandey* A compassionate human being, always popular among his friends and colleagues because of his friendly nature and human sensitivity, 33-year-old Mahesh Raut, champion of the democratic rights of the marginalised Adivasi people of Gadchiroli, Maharashtra, has been in prison for over two years now.

#StandWithStan: It's about Constitution, democracy and freedom of expression

By Fr Cedric Prakash SJ*  It is more than three weeks now: On the night of October 8, 2020, the 83-year-old Jesuit Fr Stan Swamy was taken into custody by the National Intelligence Agency (NIA) from his residence in Ranchi to an undisclosed destination. According to his colleagues, the NIA did not serve a warrant on Fr. Stan and that their behaviour was absolutely arrogant and rude.

Stan Swamy vs Arnab Goswami: Are activists fighting a losing battle? Whither justice?

By Fr Sunil Macwan SJ* It is time one raised pertinent questions over the courts denying bail to Fr Stan Swamy, who was arrested under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA), and granting it to Arnab Goswami, editor-in-chief of the Republic TV, arrested under the charge of abetting suicide of Avay Naik, who ended his life in 2018. It is travesty of justice that a human rights activist is not only denied bail but is also made to wait for weeks to hear a response to his legitimate request for a straw to drink water, while Arnab Goswami walks free.

Human development index: India performs worse than G-20 developing countries

By Rajiv Shah A new book, “Sustainable Development in India: A Comparison with the G-20”, authored by Dr Keshab Chandra Mandal, has regretted that though India’s GDP has doubled over the last one decade, its human development indicators are worse than not just developed countries of the Group of 20 countries but also developing countries who its members.

India performs 'poorly' in Quality of Life Index, ranks 62nd out of 64 countries

Counterview Desk “Expat Insider”, which claims to be one of the world’s most extensive surveys about living and working abroad, in a survey of 20,259 participants from around the globe, has found that of the 64 destinations around the globe, has found that while Taiwan is the best destination for persons living outside their native country, closely by Vietnam and Portugal, India ranks 59th.

Buddhist shrines massively destroyed by Brahmanical rulers in "pre-Islamic" era: Historian DN Jha's survey

Nalanda mahavihara By Our Representative Prominent historian DN Jha, an expert in India's ancient and medieval past, in his new book , "Against the Grain: Notes on Identity, Intolerance and History", in a sharp critique of "Hindutva ideologues", who look at the ancient period of Indian history as "a golden age marked by social harmony, devoid of any religious violence", has said, "Demolition and desecration of rival religious establishments, and the appropriation of their idols, was not uncommon in India before the advent of Islam".

Namaz in Mathura temple: Haridwar, Ayodhya monks seek Faisal Khan's release

By Our Representative As many as 23 members of the Hindu Voices for Peace (HVP), including the founder president of the well-known Haridwar-based Matri Sadan Ashram, Swami Shivananda Saraswati, and a one of its top monks, Brahmachari Aatmabodhanand, have expressed their “dismay” over the arrest of Khudai Khidmatdar chief Faisal Khan and three others on charges of “promoting enmity between religions” and “defiling a place of worship” after they offered namaz in Mathura’s Nand Baba temple premises on October 29.

Government of India 'refuses' to admit: 52% of bird species show declining trend

Finn's Weaver  By Our Representative The Government of India has been pushing out “misleading” data on the country’s drastic wildlife decline, says a well-researched report, pointing towards how top ministers are hiding data on biodiversity losses, even as obfuscating its own data. It quotes “State of India’s Birds Report 2020” to note that of the 261 out of 867 bird species for which long-term trends could be determined, 52% have declined since the year 2000, with 22% declining strongly.

Dalit, Adivasi protest in Jharkhand against 'illegal' transfer of land for development

By Rishit Neogi Displacement and eviction are not new terms. It is surprising that they are still continuing and have become a tool in the hands of state backed corporates to forcibly occupy lands in the name of development.