Skip to main content

Varavara Rao's personal liberty: Will Justice Chadrachud's order set a precedent?

By Vidya Bhushan Rawat*
The Bombay High Court has rejected the bail of poet and author Varavara Rao, who is incarcerating in Mumbai’s Taloja Central Jail for over two years in the Bhima Koregaon 'conspiracy' case, in which a chargesheet has not yet been filed. Rao is 80 plus and cannot walk without help. He is suffering from various ailments. The court has “directed” the government to get him treated. It seems the government is willing to spend money on his treatment but is not ready to give him bail.
The Bombay High Court order came a day after Supreme Court judge, Justice Chandrachud, spoke powerfully about 'personal liberty', asking High Courts to ensure that bail is given to people. However, it seems, those who can’t hire powerful lawyers or those who don’t have the backing of the state and media would continue to suffer.
Those who saw Arnab Goswami coming out of jail can understand how much 'respect' he has for institutions. He 'threatened' and 'challenged' Maharashtra chief minister Uddhav Thackeray and Mumbai Police Commissioner Paramveer Singh. While the Supreme Court said that he will cooperate in investigation into charges of abetment to suicide, it is for anyone to assume that Arnab will now continue with his diatribes, unless a court passes clear injunctions.
Varavara Rao and his family have no news channel running for them. Unlike Arnab, he is not crying and begging that his life is under threat. Even if he and other activists behind bars are released on bail, they can’t influence anyone, unlike Arnab, who can use everything, right from his media to political connections, to threaten opponents.
Many people were upset with the Supreme Court becoming conscious of 'personal liberty' of Arnab, who never respected the same for anyone else. Hence, they questioned the verdict. While courts are known to have ruled that they are open to fair criticism, India’s attorney-general has now approved contempt proceedings against comedian Kunal Kamra.
One may not be much interested in Kamra’s comedies, which most of the time are foul-mouthed (quite like Arnab’s), it is surprising that his tweets were called as 'contempt of court'. Ironically, The attorney-General did not find any contempt of the court in Andhra Pradesh chief minister Jagan Reddy's explosive letter against one of the sitting judges of the Supreme Court..
While one awaits the detailed judgment of Justice Chandrachud, where, he said, he had given detailed reasons of granting bail to Arnab, the wait for justice for human rights defenders, political dissenters and social activists will continue to be long. One does not know when will the dark tunnel see the light of the day. Till then, one would have to believe in the system, even if it has become fragile and suffocating.
Justice Chandrachud
Be that as it may, the fact is, Justice Chandrachud’s observation on 'personal liberty', insisting that if states go against it as they should know there is a Supreme Court ready to “protect” it, comes from one of the top thinking judges of our time. He is considered very knowledgeable, one who has disagreed many a time with major judgments. 
Yet, the fact is, the special Supreme Court sitting was just a plan to give Arnab bail. This happened despite the fact that Arnab never followed any procedures, even bypassed them. He showed no faith in lower courts. He was indecent during hearings. His bail application was pending in a higher court, yet he decided to approach the High Court.
So many activists have been suffering enormously in difficult circumstances in various jails, but there is no outrage on personal liberty
But when the High Court asked him to return to the lower court for regular bail, as is the procedure, his lawyers felt, enough was enough. They should now get intervention from the Supreme Court. Hearing for his bail was urgently listed, leading senior advocate Dushyant Dave raising questions about Supreme Court registry picking up Arnab's case so fast when thousands of such cases are pending.
In fact, political leaders and activists languishing in jail after the abrogation of Article 370 is rarely heard on time. Habeas corpus petition of former chief minister Farooq Abdullah was dismissed after the government said he had been 'released', even when he was not. Similar things happened to Prof Saifuddin Soz. The court accepted the 'government' version as gospel truth.
For the last several years, so many activists have been suffering enormously in difficult circumstances in various jails, but there is no outrage on personal liberty. Like Varavara Rao, Stan Swamy is 80 plus and is suffering from various age-related ailments. Yet there is no outrage. Anand Teltumbde, Gautam Navlakha and others have been in jail for their writings. Both of them are in their sixties.
Indeed, it is good that Justice Chandrachud said that he wanted to give an order which would set a precedent. He admonished High Courts for not being active enough on the issue of personal liberty, pointing out, they have been very lax in giving bail. But it is also a fact that some of the High Courts over the last six years have delivered better judgments in terms of people's rights, which is not the case with the apex court.
A case in point is what happened to Dr Kafeel Khan, who was arrested under the National Security Act (NSA) for no fault of his and was released by the High Court. The Uttar Pradesh government shamelessly slapped other cases on him and rearrested him. It was only after the Allahabad High Court intervened that he got bail.
Meanwhile, there is reason to wonder if courts will undo the systematic wrong under which those who can't afford a Harish Salve or a Kapil Sibal are able to get justice. It is possible to appoint a judicial commission under retired judges of Supreme Court to come up with clear guidelines related to political prisoners, human rights defenders and activists working for people's rights. After all, they are punished for being the voice of the people.
Talking of 'personal liberty' in isolation, in relation to just one case, would be hypocrisy. It is important that the whole issue is dealt in a decisive way by the Supreme Court, which should give categorical guidelines to the state not to arrest people for a mere tweet or a Facebook post. During the arguments, Justice Chandrachud said if you don’t like Republic TV, don’t watch it. While these are just observations, things are not so simple.
---
*Human rights defender

Comments

TRENDING

Buddhist shrines were 'massively destroyed' by Brahmanical rulers: Historian DN Jha

Nalanda mahavihara By Our Representative Prominent historian DN Jha, an expert in India's ancient and medieval past, in his new book , "Against the Grain: Notes on Identity, Intolerance and History", in a sharp critique of "Hindutva ideologues", who look at the ancient period of Indian history as "a golden age marked by social harmony, devoid of any religious violence", has said, "Demolition and desecration of rival religious establishments, and the appropriation of their idols, was not uncommon in India before the advent of Islam".

Gyanvapi case: Use of 'illegal' lawfare to keep the communal pot simmering

By Venkatesh Narayanan, Bobby Ramakant, Manoj Sarang* With a steady drumbeat of bad news for the lives of ordinary citizens --  inflation at a multi-year high , rupee at an all-time low , negative job creation and when all forward indicators as seen by industry leaders point to recessionary clouds on the horizon , what’s a serially-incompetent government to do?  Dust out their time-tested-citizen-distraction playbook. The Gyanvapi-Masjid case is all of this -- as a weapon of mass distraction. This zeitgeist of our times is best captured by a recent opinion piece : "The idea is to keep the pot on a perpetual boil, simmering at the top, whirling feverishly beneath. A restless society forever living precariously on the precipice arouses distrst, uneasiness, fear and discomfort, That is a toxic panoply for manufacturing rage, which can then be effortlessly mobilized at short notice. BJP is creating an eco-system of real-time instant delivery of hate-mongers. That is how we are sudde

Upholding labour rights, Nehruvian scientific temper, Rajni Patel opposed Emergency

By Harsh Thakor*  Rajni Patel, who died 40 years ago, whatever his flaws, had one great quality: his human touch to offer selfless service and ability to galvanise or influence human beings from all walks of life. Few people would ever go out of the way to help someone or serve as selflessly without aim of personal gain. Rajni championed Nehruvian secular ideas and scientific temper. As a master in public relations he revealed utmost humility. As a barrister, he never appeared against the trade unions or workers. A Fabien Socialist he opposed liberal capitalism and radical socialism. Unlike most lawyers, he did not succumb to the lure of amassing wealth. Rajni was born in Sirsa, in Gujarat, on the very day Gandhi set foot on Indian soil, on 9th January, 1915. He gained his baptism through one of Gandhi's speeches calling for the boycott of foreign goods, which was the virtual turning point of his life. Rajni toed Gandhi to organise boycott of foreign goods. Rajni was able to cros

Targeting mosques, churches: 'Roadmap' for 2025, RSS' centenary year?

416 years old Our Lady of Health Church, Sancoale, Goa  By Fr Cedric Prakash SJ*  Fascists use manipulative strategies aimed at whipping up sympathy and support from the majority community, to which they normally ‘belong’. They do so in a variety of insidious and subtle ways. In the past few months, they have gone overboard in their efforts to denigrate and demonize minorities in India, particularly Muslims and Christians. They have spewed hate and divisiveness through their venomous speeches; incited people to violence and have effectively used officialdom to further their vested interests. The results are there for all to see: greater polarisation of the majority community in a country which prided itself for its pluralism and diversity. Their meticulously planned agenda is in order to gain absolute power of the country in the 2024 national elections. More so it is also a roadmap towards 2025 when the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) will complete one hundred years of its existence.

Vadodara violence: Fine Arts Faculty alumni raise fingers at Varsity's political appointee

Hasmukh Vaghela with PM Counterview Desk  In a statement, alumni of the Faculty of Fine Arts (FoFA), Maharaja Sayajirao University (MSU), Baroda, Gujarat, referring to the “violence” by right-wing groups for displaying “objectionable” paintings that “hurt religious sentiments” at the one of India’s top fine arts institute May 5, have taken strong exception to “the assault and rustication” of one of the students, and lack of action taken against those who “violated” the institution and committed the act. Floated as an online petition seeking wider support, the FoFA alumni, in their statement, addressed to the vice chancellor, MSU, said, there should be “thorough” investigation in the whole incident and “immediate action” should be taken against syndicate member Hasmukh Vaghela, MSU, who sparked the assault, and “other co-conspirators” for breaching “university code of conduct and unlawful activities committed in broad daylight”. While the alumni statement doesn't say so, Vaghela

Examples of support to Hindu temples, scriptures, saints by 'Muslim' rulers galore

Siya Ram coin issued by Akbar By Bharat Dogra* At a time when the country as well as the world are passing through very difficult times leading to more urgent need for strengthening national unity for meeting several big challenges ahead, unfortunately disputes relating to religious places have been allowed to raise their ugly head once again. It is well-realized by now by many people that it is not historical facts but narrow considerations of political gain and spreading of fanatic ideas of intolerance which are behind such mischief, but due to the increasing threat of mob violence and patronage available at higher levels to groups spreading intolerance many people are reluctant to openly and fearlessly express their views. Hence there is urgent need for broad-based peace committees with wider social support to spread the message of communal harmony and to appeal against the dangers of spreading false messages regarding places of worship which can ultimate

This varsity succumbed to extra-academic mobocracy, 'ignored' Hindutva archives

By Shamsul Islam* Open letter to Sharda University vice-chancellor Sub: Discarding a Question on Linkages of Hindutva with Nazism/Fascism is blatant Academic Dishonesty! Dear Professor Sibaram Khara Saheb, Namaskaar! According to your esteemed University’s portal: “The name of University, 'Sharda' is synonymous to 'Goddess of knowledge and learning-Saraswati'. She is identified with 'veena', an Indian musical instrument and the ‘lotus’, where she resides. The lotus in our logo symbolizes the seat of learning that the University is created for.  "Variety of colours signify the variety of disciplines the university offers and the overlap between petals creating new colours demonstrate the ethos of collaboration between students and teachers of different programme, nationality, creed and colour working towards creating new knowledge…the University's cherished mission to provide education beyond boundaries and to facilitate the students and faculty to achie

Swami Vivekananda's views on caste and sexuality were 'painfully' regressive

By Bhaskar Sur* Swami Vivekananda now belongs more to the modern Hindu mythology than reality. It makes a daunting job to discover the real human being who knew unemployment, humiliation of losing a teaching job for 'incompetence', longed in vain for the bliss of a happy conjugal life only to suffer the consequent frustration.

Whither climate goal? Increasing reliance on coal 'likely to worsen' India's power crisis

By Shankar Sharma*  Recent news articles, How to shock-proof India’s power sector and Power minister points finger at states for worsening electricity crisis , have highlighted a few current problems for the ongoing power sector issues as in April 2022. However, there is a lot more to it than a few temporary solutions as indicated in the articles. It should also be emphasised that it is techno-economically impossible to completely shock-proof a highly complex and geographically wide-spread vast power network, such as the one in India, which is only getting more and more complex with the passage of each year due to some irrational policies/ practices in the sector. A business-as-usual (BAU) scenario, wherein more and more of conventional technology power plants, including coal power plants, will be added in the near future, will also necessitate the increased complexity in the integrated national grid, and as a result the instances of power shortage/ disruptions can only escalate for

A former Modi ally, Prashant Kishor wanted to enter Congress 'on contract, as trader'

By Anand Sahay*  The Congress Party and the election campaigns specialist Prashant Kishor, whose company has done strategic communications for a host of political parties across ideology, should both count themselves lucky that they could not reach an agreement for Kishor to join the party. News reports suggest that the Congress rejected Kishor’s terms. This is not wholly unexpected. People join a party because they are attracted to it, and wish to serve it in any capacity that the party may see fit. But that isn’t Kishor at all. He gave the impression of entering into a contract, as a trader might. If news reports are to be believed, he sought freedom to report directly to party chief Sonia Gandhi, and sought untrammeled control over party communications. When such ideas did not find favour, the consultant withdrew. It is clear he has no particular love for the Congress, and its ideas, ideology and politics. In contrast, look at the key personae in G-23. They