Skip to main content

Religious 'motivations', cops' negligence, doctors' lapses behind Tabrez's death

Counterview Desk
Ravi Kiran Jain, national president, and Dr V Suresh, national general secretary, People’s Union for Civil Liberties (PUCL), have said, there is clear evidence to suggest, Jharkhand’s Tabrez Ansari “lynching murder case” is sought to be watered down by state authorities, including police officials and doctors, insisting, the government should “restore the murder charge under Section (u/s) 302 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC)”, even as taking steps against the prosecuting police officials and doctors for “criminal negligence.”
Tied to a pole and forced to chant “Jai Shri Ram” and “Jai Hanuman” and barbarically assaulted, the police not only failed to rescue him from the mob, which beat him continuously for over six hours, it arrested Tabrez and took him to Saraikela police station, where he was kept for days without any medical assistance, said PUCL in a statement
Calling the incident “cold blooded killing by right-wing Hindutva fanatics”, PUCL added, “The religious motivations behind this crime are laid bare in the gruesome videos that were taken by the assailants which have been widely circulated on social media.”

Text: 

PUCL strongly condemns the actions of the Jharkhand police in dropping murder charges u/s 302 IPC from the charge sheet of the case related to the brutal lynching murder of Tabrez Ansari and replacing it with a much more diluted charge u/s 304 IPC, (culpable homicide not amounting to murder).
PUCL also strongly deprecates the justification offered by the SP of the Saraikela – Kharsawan District, Jharkhand, that they decided to drop murder charges because Tabrez did not die on the spot, which according to him indicated that the intention of the mob was not to kill Tabrez, and because the post mortem (PM) report stated that Tabrez died four days after the incident due to ‘cardiac arrest and head injury’, as not just a motivated interpretation meant to screen cold blooded killing by right-wing Hindutva fanatics, but also an attempt to tamper with the criminal case with the intention to let the accused escape conviction for what is a cold blooded lynching murder, fully videotaped by the assailants.
What makes the police action suspect and suspicious is the fact that Jharkhand will soon have state elections and it is not in the interest of the ruling BJP government if the criminal prosecution of Tabrez Ansari’s killers is pursued as a murder case.
To recall facts, on June 17, 2019, in Dhatkidih village, Kharsawan block, Saraikela Kharsawan district, Jharkhand, Tabrez Ansari and two 14-year-old boys – Mohammad Irfan and Numer Ali – were returning from Jamshedpur when they were surrounded by a mob in Dhaktidih village and beaten up brutally. While Irfan and Numer escaped, Tabrez was caught by residents of the village, tied to a pole, forced to chant “Jai Shri Ram” and “Jai Hanuman” and barbarically assaulted. The police were informed but failed to come to rescue him from the mob, who beat him continuously for over six hours.
Despite the brutality and injuries inflicted on him, the police that arrived on the spot, arrested Tabrez and took him to Saraikela police station where he was kept for days without any medical assistance. He finally died on June 22, due to the injuries inflicted on him. The religious motivations behind this crime are laid bare in the gruesome videos that were taken by the assailants which have been widely circulated on social media.
The family members of Tabrez who visited him while he was in the Saraikela police station found him severely injured and bleeding, but when they requested the police officials to take him to the hospital they were refused. The threats of violence were made by the officials and refusal to provide timely medical assistance indicated both their complicity in the murder and their intention to screen the real offenders to escape criminal liability for their murderous action. Tragically, Tabrez was finally taken to the Saraikela Sadar Hospital only after his condition worsened on 22 June, 5 days after the assault.
The young, 22-year-old Tabrez Ansari’s family lived in Kadamdiha village of Kharsawan block. Both his parents had passed away and he lived with his paternal uncles and their families. Tabrez worked as a welder in Pune, and would visit his home once in a while. He got married a month and a half before the incident on 17th June, 2019, and was scheduled to return to Pune the day after the incident took place, with his newly wedded wife.
There has clearly been gross and willful culpable inaction on the part of the police officials of PS Seraikela that led to the death of Tabrez. Worse, there has been an attempt by the police to change the narrative by attributing the cause of death to heart attack or consumption of poison thereby diluting the case.
The post-mortem report filed with the preliminary charge sheet clearly shows that there was hemorrhage in his brain and internal bleeding. It states that the cause of injury that caused his death was a ‘hard blunt object with force’.
However, on September 12, NDTV reported, that a medico-legal document signed by five heads of department of a medical college in Jamshedpur stated that Tabrez died of cardiac arrest caused by the combined effect of the severe trauma that he received.
The news report stated that the document signed by five doctors said, "The fracture of bone is grievous injury caused by hard and blunt object. The combined effect of fracture of bone, pale organs and heart chambers full of blood resulting into cardiac arrest".
Despite this, the Jharkhand Police have removed murder charges against 11 people who attacked Tabrez simply because the post-mortem report said he died of a cardiac arrest. But the police did not give any reference to the reason - injuries from the beating - that led to the cardiac arrest.
The accused have now been charged under Section 304 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) for culpable homicide, rather than murder under Section 302 of the IPC. The punishment for culpable homicide is between 10 years to life, while that of murder is life imprisonment or death.
This goes against the opinion of an enquiry by senior officials of the Jharkhand government that Tabrez died due to the negligence of police officials and lapses on the part of doctors. Police officials arrived too late and the doctor who treated Tabrez Ansari, 24, "did not take the matter seriously", concluded the inquiry panel.
With regard to the medical opinion, several serious infirmities need to be pointed out.
First, there was only one post mortem. The second report, signed by 5 so called 'experts', only issued the statement based on previous papers. They have not conducted an independent post mortem! And, therefore, it is not credible. The first report did not mention a] the amount of blood in the cranium, and b] it does not mention cardiac arrest.
The first PM [the only PM] certificate that is in circulation does not contain the signature and the designation of the doctor who conducted PM. Even today in many taluk and district hospitals, PM is done by doctors who have no specialised qualification in forensic medicine. However, in sensitive cases, like custodial deaths etc., the body is always moved to a medical college where a qualified forensic department is always available.
It is a Medical Council of India (MCI) norm and no medical college can exist without a Forensic Department with a Professor and couple of assistant professors, tutors etc. Tabrez Ansari’s case can qualify to be a custodial death or at least a sensational case and it is not clear why his PM was not conducted by a qualified forensic professional in a medical college is an important question.
The certificate from the MGM Medical College is even more curious. If one looks at those five doctors who have signed, it is obvious that none of them is a qualified forensic specialist. The head of the departments (HODs) of ortho, surgery, pathology, medicine and ear nose and throat (ENT) signed the certificate; these subjects have nothing to do with Forensic Science. What is both intriguing and suspicious is about why the HOD or other faculty members of the Forensic Medicine Department of the MGM Medical College were not consulted or involved with this team.
It is important to point out that the MGM Medical College has a full-fledged Forensic Medicine Department with a Professor level – HOD, Dr Lalan Choudhury, assisted by two assistant professors and two tutors. It is therefore hard to avoid the impression that the HOD and other faculty members of the Forensic Medicine department were deliberately side-lined by the police.
Second opinions, especially in such a vital case as this, is usually obtained from persons more qualified or more experienced than the person who issued the first certificate. That this simple principle is flouted in this case is a serious issue on the part of the Investigating Officer and higher police officials who form part of the `Chain of Command’, including the Superintendent of Police, Saraikela Kharsawan district.

Analysis of the medical details

An amount of 02 to 03 ml of subarachnoid blood is mentioned in the second report. It is not clear where they got this amount. It is not mentioned in the first report. Such a small amount is impossible to measure in the normal circumstances. In any case, forensic specialists confirm the amount of blood does not matter. If the brain is injured and caused bleeding that is enough to indicate the severity of damage. The size and dimension of the fronto-parietal fracture is not mentioned at all.
The first report mentions "Discharge present in B/L nostrils”. The discharge can only be bloody because watery discharge or mucous will not be present so many hours after that and they will not be important to be noted as a finding. It must have been clotted blood in the nostrils. Bilateral nasal bleeding is not necessarily one of the indication of serious brain injury. The first thing that any experienced doctor checks is to check if the patients is bleeding from ENT areas in case of injuries. If so, that is an indication of the need to have a CT scan of the head.
It should also be mentioned that the "Medical Certificate of Cause of Death" (Form 4 and 4A) which doctors fill up after death is uniform across the country. It clearly forbids mentioning of heart failure as the immediate cause of death. What is important is to note as to what circumstances and causes led to the heart failure.
The human skull bone is quite strong. To quote an article: “Human bone is incredibly sturdy; it is stronger than steel and concrete of the same mass". Quoting from a study, it has been pointed out that roughly 235 kg (520 pounds) or 2300 Newtons of force is required to crush the human skull, “almost twice as much force as human hands can possibly muster". 
Tabrez was healthy and normal, he was beaten so severely that he cracked his skull and bled inside his brain. He was beaten to death
The point is the skull bone is very strong and requires great force to break it. In the Tabrez Ansari lynching case, it is only because such great force was applied by the mob assaulting and beating him with iron rods and sticks, it is difficult to conclude that the mob did not intend for the man to be killed.
This intention by the mob is also corroborated by Ansari’s uncle Mohammad Masroor Alam, who rushed to the spot on hearing about the assault, recorded this statement: He heard a member of the mob shout, “Itnamaaroki mar jaye (beat him so much that he dies).”
It is quite possible for a person with brain injury to be walking and talking subsequent to serious brain injury and die later. This is called "Lucid interval" or ' Talk and die patients" So death after more than 4 days of head injury is not unusual.
Tabrez Ansari had been beaten by a mob for several hours. It is a callous neglect not to have examined him meticulously. Head injury patients can be confused and drowsy and one should not expect them to complain of headache in all cases. Or he would have complained and the doctors did not care to record it. A whole body CT scan is certainly mandatory in such patients not to miss any brain, thoracic, abdominal and pelvic injuries.
The most likely scenario is that the brain gradually swells due to repeated injuries and causes what is called Diffuse Cerebral Odema or Diffuse Axonal Injury. The brain cannot swell because it is within the rigid skull and hence pushes itself down ["Herniation"] and thus the vital centres like the Cardiac and Respiratory Centres are irreversibly damaged and the heart and lungs stop function. In other words, the so-called Cardiac Arrest is the consequence of brain injury and irreversible damage of Cardio-Respiratory Centres in the brain.
It will be useful to point out to the opinion of retired professor and HOD of vascular surgery, Madras Medical College, Dr Amalorpavanathan, who concludes that "It is very clear that this young person who was otherwise healthy and normal was beaten so severely that he cracked his skull and bled inside his brain and resulted in his death. In short, he was beaten to death."

PUCL demands that:

  1. The Jharkhand police restore and add again Sec 302 IPC Charge to the charge sheet.
  2. The police officials and concerned doctor(s) be immediately placed under suspension and prosecuted for tampering with evidence and attempt to cover up the crime by mis-using their position as public officials to help guilty accused to escape criminal liability for their actions of murder, hate crime and other offences. 
  3. Under the circumstances where senior officials in charge of ensuring fair, independent and unbiased investigation have been found to have compromised their authority and position, it is of great importance to instill confidence in the minds of victim’s families that the trial be transferred out of the district and to be under the direct supervision of a senior police official. 
  4. The victim’s families should be allowed to have a say in the selection and appointment of public prosecutor with adequate seniority, standing and experience in handling criminal trials to handle the case of the prosecution in the trial court.

Comments

TRENDING

'Blatant violation' of law by Central government in making NREGA payments

By Our Representative  In September third week, NREGA workers across the country were mobilised for two day so raise their issues and submit a memorandum to the Prime Minister. Organised the NREGA Sangharsh Morcha (NSM), a collective of groups that work with NREGA labourers across the country, workers from 13 states -- Andhra Pradesh, Bihar, Chhattisgarh, Gujarat, Haryana, Jharkhand, Karnataka, Madhya Pradesh, Odisha, Rajasthan, Telangana, Uttar Pradesh and West Bengal -- carried out Kaam Do Abhiyaan, staging demonstrations and rallies against what they called blatant violation of law by the Central government in making NREGA payments. While NREGA has had very positive impacts, it has lately become fruitless, exploiting labour, even though workers who have put in honest hard work have to wait for their wages endlessly, it was suggested.  In such a situation, there is a need to firm up NREGA implementation and end systematic corruption to ensure that workers get their basic NREGA entit

Fascism on prowl? Religious meet 'deeply pained' at silence of Church, bishops, priests

Counterview Desk  The ‘Forum of Religious for Justice and Peace’which held its 17th National Convention at the Montfort Social Institute, Hyderabad, Telangana from 22 to 24 September 2022 on the theme “Deepening our Identity as Religious: Responding to the Signs of the Times”, has expressed concern “at the deteriorating situation of our nation on every front”, especially stating, “Fascism seems to have come to stay” in India. At the same time, the convention, which took place with the participation of 60 persons from 16 states representing 20 religious congregations, in its unanimously-adopted statement added, “We have reached abysmal depths on every parameter: be it social, economic and political”, underlining, “The poor in India become poorer every day; the rich and powerful continue to profiteer at their expense and amass scandalous amounts of wealth.” Text: We, members (63 women and men Religious, from 16 states representing 20 Congregations) of the Forum of Religious for Justice

Muslim intellectuals met Bhagwat, extra-constitutional authority 'like Sanjay Gandhi'

By Shamsul Islam*  In a significant development a delegation of five Muslim intellectuals namely former chief election commissioner SY Quraishi; former senior bureaucrat Najeeb Jung; former AMU vice-chancellor and Lt Gen (retd) Zameer U Shah; politician-cum-journalist Shahid Siddiqui (presently with RLD); and businessman Saeed Shervani [Samajvadi Party] met RSS Supremo Mohan Bhagwat at RSS Delhi headquarters. The meeting was kept secret for reasons known to the participants and was held in August. According to the Muslim intellectuals the meeting held in “a very cordial” atmosphere continued for 75 minutes whereas time allotted was 30 minutes! In a post-meeting justification of the parleys Quraishi stated that their main concern was “the insecurity being increasingly felt by the Muslim community in the wake of recurring incidents of lynching of innocents, calls by Hindutva hotheads for genocide and the marginalisation of the community in almost every sphere”. This delegation consistin

Whither Govt of India strategy to reduce import dependence on crude oil, natural gas?

By NS Venkataraman*  India presently imports around 80% of it’s crude oil requirement and around 50% of its natural gas requirements . As the domestic production of crude oil and natural gas are virtually stagnant and the domestic demand is increasing at around 7% per annum, India’s steadily increasing dependence on import of the vital energy source is a matter of high energy security concern. This is particularly so, since the price of crude oil and natural gas are considerably fluctuating / increasing in the global market due to geo political factors, which are beyond the control of India. India has promised to achieve zero emission by the year 2070, which mean that the level of emission has to start declining at slow and steady rate from now onwards. It is now well recognized that global emission is caused largely due to use of coal as fuel and natural gas as fuel and feedstock. While burning of coal as fuel cause emission of global warming carbon dioxide gas and sulphur

Rajasthan cops 'halt' Gujarat Dalit women's rally: homage to untouchability victim boy

By Our Representative  In a surprise move, the Rajasthan police stopped a Dalit women's rally from Gujarat on the borders after it crossed Gujarat alleging that it would "disturb peace" in village Surana, Jalore district, where the gruesome incident of death of a Dalit boy took place on August 13 after he was brutally beaten up by his teacher on touching the drinking water pot. Sources said, while the Gujarat government had "no objection" in allowing the rally, which originated from the Dalit Shakti Kendra (DSK), an empowerment-cut-technical institute for teens founded by human rights leader Martin Macwan, on September 24 morning, the Rajasthan police stopped it for two and a half hours before allowing it to proceed to Surana. The decision to take out a women's rally was taken at a DSK meeting on September 5 following a condolence meeting of the NGO Navsarjan Trust, also founded by Macwan, activists committed to work against caste-based discrimination, orga

Why Bose's India Gate statue suggests RSS, BJP need violence-loving ‘Hindu’ Netaji

By Prem Singh*  In a TV channel debate, a BJP spokesperson and anchor shared and served a lie that Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose's daughter in her letter to the Prime Minister has alleged that the Congress kept devaluing Netaji to further Gandhi's non-violence; because Netaji had taken the path of liberating the country through violence mode by forming the Azad Hind Fauj (INA). They also praised the Bombay Royal Naval Mutiny of 1946 to confirm that the country got its independence through a violent route. I stated that I have read the letter of Netaji's daughter, and there is no such allegation in it. But a lie told in the intoxication of power is bound to be blatant. Netaji's daughter Anita Bose Pfaff, even in the past, has already requested some earlier prime ministers of the country to bring back the mortal remains of her father from Japan to India. In none of the letters she has spoken about devaluation of her father’s role in the freedom movement on the basis of Gandh

Buddhist shrines were 'massively destroyed' by Brahmanical rulers: Historian DN Jha

Nalanda mahavihara By Our Representative Prominent historian DN Jha, an expert in India's ancient and medieval past, in his new book , "Against the Grain: Notes on Identity, Intolerance and History", in a sharp critique of "Hindutva ideologues", who look at the ancient period of Indian history as "a golden age marked by social harmony, devoid of any religious violence", has said, "Demolition and desecration of rival religious establishments, and the appropriation of their idols, was not uncommon in India before the advent of Islam".

Is coal import dependence of more than 50% by 2047 of any relevance to India?

By Shankar Sharma*  I have read the article " Building Resilience in India’s Power Sector " by N Vedachalam, released by the Observer Research Foundation, with a lot of interest. I expected it to provide few useful recommendations to our authorities in charting out a sustainable pathway to green energy transition much before the climate catastrophe push our communities to the precipice. But I am sorry to say that the overall discussions or the message implied in the article disappointed me. I was expecting the article, coming from an engineer with past experience in the power sector, to discuss the much needed recommendations to put the power sector on a sustainable developmental pathway. But I could notice mostly technical jargon and a lot of statistical information, which may already be available in the public domain.   The article also seems to have simply accepted what some of the official agencies seem to have indicated as inevitable for the power sector in our country;

'True decolonisation move': Demand to name new Parliament building after Ambedkar

By Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd*  In recent weeks, there has been a demand for the new Parliament building being constructed on the revamped Central Vista in New Delhi to be named after the architect of the Constitution and anti-caste leader BR Ambedkar. On September 14, the Telangana Assembly passed a resolution urging the Centre to name the new Parliament building after Ambedkar. The Bharatiya Janata Party was absent during the debate about the resolution. The next day, the Telangana Rashtra Samithi-led government declared that the new secretariat in the centre of Hyderabad would be named after Ambedkar. Chief Minister K Chandrasekhar Rao added that he would write to Prime Minister Narendra Modi requesting him to name the new Parliament building in Delhi “Ambedkar Parliament”. The demand is finding resonance among civil society groups too and has led to social media discussions as well as public mobilisation.  But two questions arise: Should a Parliament that makes laws for a nation over a

Government 'fails to take up' Indian migrants' unpaid wages issue with other countries

By Rafeek Ravuther, Chandan Kumar, Dharmendra Kumar*  The migrant workers were one of the most vulnerable sections during the pandemic. India experiences large-scale movement of migrants internally and internationally. After the outbreak of the pandemic, migrant workers continued to face injustice especially in getting wages in expedited manner. In the international context, India, the home of 9 million cross-border temporary labour migrants, carried out the largest repatriation exercise ‘Vande Bharat Mission’. Even though the Indian government addressed the immediate requirement of repatriation, it failed to understand and recognise their post-arrival grievances, like back wages, social protection etc. Recently many workers were deported from the middle- east region. Amidst the establishment of grievance mechanisms such as Consular Services Management System (MADAD) and helplines in Pravasi Bharatiya Sahayata Kendra (PBSK), the unresolved grievances remain high. The number of unresolv