Vyacheslav Mikhailovich Molotov died in Moscow on November 8, 1986, at the age of 96. Forty years later, his name remains tied to the construction of socialism in the USSR, the defeat of fascism, and the political conflicts over the Soviet Union's direction after Stalin's death. Born in 1890, Molotov joined the Bolshevik movement in 1906 and took part in the revolutionary struggle against tsarism that culminated in the October Revolution of 1917. He subsequently became one of the leading figures of the Communist Party and the Soviet government, devoting most of his political life to the consolidation and defence of the world's first socialist state.
As Chairman of the Council of People's Commissars from 1930 to 1941, he played a central role in shaping the socialist industrialization of the USSR and the transformation of its economic foundations. Under Communist Party leadership, the Soviet Union developed an industrial and productive capacity that proved decisive in resisting the Nazi invasion.
Appointed People's Commissar for Foreign Affairs in 1939, Molotov became one of the principal representatives of Soviet diplomacy during the Second World War. The Soviet-German Non-Aggression Pact of August 1939, concluded after the failure of negotiations for collective security with Britain and France, remains among the most fiercely debated decisions of that period.
Following Germany's invasion of the USSR in June 1941, Molotov played a central role in forging diplomatic cooperation with the Western Allies against Nazi Germany. The Soviet triumph in the antifascist victory, gained at an immense human cost, fundamentally transformed the international balance of forces and strengthened the position of socialism worldwide. Molotov subsequently represented the USSR in major international negotiations and became an instrumental figure in the diplomatic confrontation with the imperialist powers during the early Cold War.
Molotov's long political career was shaped by the complex dynamics of socialist construction, intense class struggle, imperialist encirclement and the contradictions entangling Soviet society. His historical significance lies less in an image of personal heroism than in his role in shaping the collective revolutionary effort that transformed the USSR into a major industrial power and an international centre of the communist movement. His political convictions came to the fore in the years following Stalin's death.
Molotov opposed Nikita Khrushchev's ideological and political plan, particularly the campaign of de-Stalinization initiated at the 20th Congress of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union in 1956. Following the unsuccessful attempt to remove Khrushchev in 1957, he was gradually stripped of his positions and eventually expelled from the Party in 1962. His membership was restored in 1984.
Molotov was also critical of Stalin's theses on the possibility of constructing socialism and communism in one country. He considered it an error for Stalin to declare that socialism had been built in the USSR as early as 1935; he held instead that the basis of socialism had been established and that completion of the task lay in the future. One major issue was capitalist encirclement. The second was the continued existence of classes, the working class and the peasantry, and the continuation of money. The third was the low level of material development, which precluded the operation of the principle "from each according to his ability, to each according to his work."
Molotov strongly disapproved of Stalin's position at the 18th Congress that communism could be built in one country and that the state would continue under communism. Whatever his views on these matters, his opposition to Stalin's positions did not assume a programmatic or practical form, and he continued to work under the guidance of Stalin's theoretical formulations.
Stalin began to view Molotov as overly conciliatory toward the West. In 1949, Stalin stripped Molotov of his post as Foreign Minister. At a Central Committee plenum in October 1952, Stalin launched a harsh public attack against Molotov, accusing him of cowardice, capitulation to Western powers, unauthorized concessions to British diplomats regarding bourgeois newspapers, and sharing state secrets with his imprisoned wife. Stalin removed Molotov from the inner leadership, the newly formed Bureau of the Presidium, and barred him from attending meetings or dinners at Stalin's dacha. Many historians believe Molotov was slated to be a primary target of a new purge that was halted only by Stalin's death in March 1953.
Stalin's death was followed by a reversal of the policies he had outlined, immediate in some areas such as products-exchange and gradual in many others. Malenkov and Khrushchev together spearheaded the dismantling of Stalin's policy toward the collective farms. In August-September 1953, policy statements by Malenkov and Khrushchev in effect relaxed pressure on private farming by collective farmers, increased the prices paid for compulsory deliveries to the state by the collective farms, and encouraged trade by the collective farms. Collective farms were granted greater independence in planning agricultural production.
Molotov reaffirmed Stalin's positions on the agrarian question in his memoirs; his silence on the question of elevating collective farms into state farms during those years is questionable. It is noteworthy that Molotov was not criticized by the Khrushchevites for impeding the dismantling of Stalin's policies in this regard, although he was criticized for opposing greater economic autonomy for the collective farms from the state planning authorities.
Molotov was most vocal on international issues. Though Stalin had relieved him of foreign office responsibilities in his last years, Molotov returned to his old office immediately after Stalin's death. He was steadfast in his opposition to the reestablishment of relations with Titoite Yugoslavia and to basing Soviet foreign policy on the assumption of the possibility of peaceful coexistence of socialism and imperialism, and he stood for building a unified socialist bloc of nations that stood not only for peace but also for socialism.
The schema of liquidation of socialism in the USSR, the opening up of the USSR to imperialism, was an essential ingredient, for imperialism alone could trigger an economy that was reverting to capitalism from socialism. Hence the emphasis on peaceful coexistence and rapprochement with Tito. Molotov seems to have fought against these measures tenaciously on matters of logic and principle, but he did not see a link between giving up the plan to abolish classes in the USSR, the emphasis on light industries, and the new foreign policy initiatives. At most he foresaw them all as part of a non-revolutionary policy thrust provided by petty bourgeois elements of the party.
Although Molotov was elected to the Presidium of the Central Committee at the 19th Congress, he was not included by the Plenum of the Central Committee in the smaller Politburo, which incidentally was not made public at the time. The Khrushchevites forced the Politburo to summon a session of the plenum of the Central Committee where Khrushchev had a majority. Central Committee members were summoned with the active assistance of Marshal Zhukov, indicating the backing provided by the army to Khrushchev, and there Molotov and others were denounced and divested of their positions. Molotov began to systematically counter Khrushchev after this, and their struggle came out into the open. Molotov's struggle took the form of repeated letters to the Central Committee criticizing the leadership on various issues of principle and policy. This continued until 1961, when the 22nd Congress expelled Molotov from the party.
Since then Molotov continued to write his views on various matters to the Central Committee, but by then the struggle was lost beyond hope. The foregoing discussion seems to indicate that Molotov was isolated during the last years of Stalin and owed his return to centre stage to the support of a coalition of revisionists of various hues. The balance of forces then might have obstructed his taking an active position against the de-Stalinization drive begun soon after Stalin's death. His silence on issues other than foreign policy matters ensured the consolidation of the victory.
Molotov was the most vocal and consistent critic of the policies pursued by the revisionist leadership of the CPSU, yet he continued to firmly uphold the belief that the USSR was a socialist state with a dictatorship of the proletariat led by a Communist Party. It was this belief that motivated him to appeal time and again for readmission into the party, to support the Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia and Afghanistan and the suppression of the Polish working class by General Jaruzelski, to seek positive elements in the leadership of the CPSU under Andropov, and to maintain his overall faith that "we are continuing to march ahead," even if he was troubled by the developments leading to the final liquidation of the USSR, the last vestiges of socialism and the CPSU within five years of his own death. Stalin, in his fight against the right deviation—Molotov considered Khrushchev a continuer of Bukharin—repeatedly emphasized that the policy of pandering to the petty bourgeoisie would result in the strengthening of capitalist elements and the eventual restoration of capitalism. That was the essence of his struggle against Bukharin.
Molotov believed that capitalism would not be restored despite decades of petty bourgeois policy and that the CPSU would not cease to be a communist party even after being flooded by petty bourgeois elements. In essence this was a centrist position. Centrism in this context consisted in the belief that a petty bourgeois policy only retarded the pace of socialist construction but did not open the way for capitalism. Eventually centrism merely takes correct positions with regard to past history but abandons the struggle in the present stage. Any splitting of the CPSU was tantamount to anti-socialist activity. Perhaps this explains the dichotomy between Molotov's radical critique of the policy pursued by the CPSU since 1956 and his faith in the need to preserve such a party.
Forty years after his death, Vyacheslav Molotov deserves to be commemorated as a steadfast Bolshevik who devoted his life to the October Revolution, the defence of Soviet power and the cause of socialism. His legacy belongs to the history of a revolutionary movement that challenged capitalist domination and demonstrated that the working class could take political power and begin building a new society.
V. M. Molotov will be remembered as a Stalinist who remained unwaveringly committed to Stalinism not because of any personal devotion to Stalin or for opportunistic reasons but on grounds of principle. In the last years of Stalin he was placed under suspicion and removed from the Politburo of the Party, being on the verge of being arrested and shot. Perhaps he lived on because of Stalin's death. Yet Molotov remained a staunch Stalinist to his very death. Nevertheless he made no bones about his differences with Stalin.
---
*Freelance journalist
Comments