The restrictions imposed on Sonam Wangchuk in Ladakh and the arrest of Arunachal Pradesh activist and lawyer Ebo Mili raise serious questions about how India treats dissent. The two cases concern different political and environmental issues, but both involve individuals who publicly challenged government decisions and mobilised opposition to policies affecting their communities.
The government has a responsibility to maintain public order and enforce the law. However, that responsibility must not become a justification for restricting peaceful criticism, intimidating activists or discouraging citizens from questioning official decisions. The growing number of controversies surrounding protest movements in different parts of the country deserves serious scrutiny.
Sonam Wangchuk: Restrictions On Peaceful Political Participation
On November 11, 2026, the Leh administration issued a 60-day preventive restriction order against Sonam Wangchuk under Section 163 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita. The order restricted his participation in unauthorised rallies, processions and public gatherings, citing concerns about public order and the electoral process. Wangchuk, however, alleged that police personnel forcibly took him from a protest site and prevented him from leaving his residence. The administration maintained that he had merely been advised to remain at home under the prohibitory restrictions.
Whatever terminology is used, the practical restrictions on his movement and public participation require scrutiny. Wangchuk has questioned the legal basis and scope of the order and sought clarification from the authorities.
His demands for greater political representation, constitutional safeguards and protection of Ladakh's identity are not merely personal. They are also supported by wider political and civil society organisations, including the Leh Apex Body and the Kargil Democratic Alliance.
The government may disagree with his methods or political positions, but peaceful criticism should not automatically be treated as a threat to public order. If specific unlawful conduct is alleged, it should be investigated individually and through due process.
Wangchuk's earlier detention also deserves mention. He was detained under the National Security Act on September 26, 2025, following the violent unrest in Leh on September 24, which left four people dead. The Union Government revoked his detention on March 14, 2026. The government had accused him of contributing to the unrest, an allegation that remained contested. His release, however, did not resolve the underlying political demands in Ladakh.
Ebo Mili: An Arrest Amid Opposition To The Siang Dam
A similar controversy has emerged in Arunachal Pradesh, where lawyer and environmental activist Ebo Mili has been involved in opposing the proposed Siang Upper Multipurpose Project, an approximately 11,200-megawatt hydropower and water-storage project.
Local communities, particularly residents of the Siang Valley, have expressed concerns about the possible displacement of indigenous communities, the submergence of ancestral land and the environmental consequences of the project.
The situation escalated in October 2026 as protests intensified over pre-feasibility surveys and the presence of security personnel in the region. Tensions rose further during a bandh on October 23, when violence, property damage and clashes were reported. Police subsequently registered eight criminal cases and reported 26 arrests, including five juveniles. Ebo Mili and youth leader Otul Jerang were among those arrested after surrendering to the police. Reports also stated that Mili and Jerang began refusing food while in custody, although the police disputed the description of their action as a hunger strike.
These details matter. The violence and alleged damage to public property must be investigated, and individuals accused of specific offences should be dealt with according to law. But the arrest of activists in the context of a wider protest movement also raises the question of whether the authorities are distinguishing between participation in peaceful opposition and responsibility for particular unlawful acts.
Mili has previously criticised the treatment of anti-dam protesters, describing the restrictions on expression and assembly as an assault on democratic rights. His concerns have also attracted international attention: a 2024 communication by United Nations human rights experts expressed concern about his earlier arrest and restrictions, while explicitly noting that the allegations required examination.
The controversy is therefore not limited to one recent arrest. It forms part of a longer dispute over how the authorities respond to environmental and indigenous-rights activism in Arunachal Pradesh.
The Government's Response To Dissent Deserves Scrutiny
The cases of Wangchuk and Mili should not be treated as identical, as the legal circumstances and allegations in the two cases are different. However, both raise a broader question: are government authorities responding to public grievances through meaningful consultation, or increasingly relying on restrictions, preventive detention and police action?
This question is particularly relevant under the present Bharatiya Janata Party-led political establishment. The Arunachal Pradesh government and the Union Government are politically aligned, while the Union Government exercises substantial administrative authority over Ladakh. That political context makes public accountability especially important, although it does not by itself establish that every action by a state or Union Territory authority was directed by the Centre.
There are also concerns about restrictions on public communication. A Scroll report published on October 24, 2026, documented claims by residents and activists that social media accounts associated with reporting on the Siang protests had been blocked. The report stated that some blocking orders came from the Union Information Technology Ministry. If confirmed, the involvement of central authorities makes the issue broader than the actions of the Arunachal Pradesh Police alone.
The government should explain the legal grounds for such restrictions and demonstrate that they are necessary and proportionate. Social media restrictions, arrests and prohibitory orders should not become instruments for preventing communities from discussing projects that may fundamentally alter their land, environment and livelihoods.
Ladakh's Election Delay Raises Further Questions About Accountability
The controversy in Ladakh extends beyond Wangchuk's personal restrictions. It also concerns the delayed renewal of democratic representation.
The Leh Hill Council last held elections in October 2020. Its five-year term expired in October 2025, but fresh elections were not held that year amid the political unrest and subsequent administrative developments. In 2026, the administration restructured the earlier two-council system into eight Hill Development Councils following the creation of eight districts. Elections for all eight councils, covering 100 elected constituencies, have been scheduled for December 4, 2026.
The restructuring provides an administrative explanation for the new electoral arrangements, but it does not fully answer why the Leh election could not be held earlier or why December was chosen. Political representatives and civil society organisations have raised concerns about severe winter conditions, snowfall, road closures and seasonal migration. Some have demanded postponement until April or May 2027.
The administration has defended the December schedule, pointing to heating arrangements at polling stations and the need to establish elected councils in the new districts. These arguments should be examined, but the government must also demonstrate that residents in remote settlements will have a genuine opportunity to vote.
For a Union Territory without an elected Legislative Assembly, the Hill Councils are particularly important institutions of local representation. Their electoral legitimacy should not be treated as a mere administrative formality.
Dialogue, Not Restrictions, Is Needed
The cases of Sonam Wangchuk and Ebo Mili illustrate two different regional disputes: Ladakh's demand for stronger political representation and Arunachal Pradesh's opposition to a major hydropower project. Both involve communities seeking a greater voice in decisions affecting their future.
The government is entitled to defend its policies and enforce the law. It is also entitled to investigate violence and prosecute individuals where evidence supports criminal charges. But these powers must be exercised transparently and proportionately. Peaceful opposition, criticism of public policy and demands for consultation are legitimate parts of democratic life.
The Leh administration should review the restrictions imposed on Wangchuk and lift them if their continued necessity cannot be established. The Arunachal Pradesh authorities should ensure that Mili and other arrested activists receive due process, access to legal representation and fair treatment, while clearly distinguishing individual criminal allegations from peaceful participation in the anti-dam movement.
The Union Government should also clarify its role in any restrictions imposed on social media accounts covering the Siang protests. In Ladakh, it should address the outstanding questions about the election schedule and resume meaningful discussions with local representatives.
A government confident in its policies should be prepared to defend them through evidence, public debate and consultation. It should not allow public-order measures to become a substitute for addressing the grievances that drive protests in the first place.
The right to question government decisions is not an obstacle to democracy; it is one of its essential foundations. Whether in Ladakh or Arunachal Pradesh, citizens should not have to fear restrictions or arrest simply for demanding that their voices be heard.
---
*Contact: himadripriya19@gmail.com
Comments