Whatever the nature of the criticism directed at Jawaharlal Nehru, his contribution to nation-building in post-Independence India was second to none. Along with Gandhi, Sardar Patel and Subhas Chandra Bose, Nehru was among the most prominent leaders of his time, both in terms of popular support and political understanding. He was a visionary, and Gandhi recognised this quality in him.
Nehru and Subhas Chandra Bose represented the hopes of a large section of Indians for the country's future. After Independence, it was Nehru who led India from the front and laid the foundations of what we today call modern India. Babasaheb Ambedkar, meanwhile, gave the country a Constitution that became the strongest pillar of its democratic framework, enabling it to withstand repeated challenges over the decades.
Nehru's importance can be better understood by studying the political landscape and leadership across different parts of the world during his time. He was recognised as one of the greatest anti-colonial leaders of the twentieth century. However, a comparison with other leaders who emerged as icons in their respective countries reveals an important distinction. Many of them eventually became dictators, suppressing freedom and democratic institutions. Nehru, despite his immense popularity, chose to uphold democratic principles and institutions. He was an extraordinarily popular leader during his lifetime. One may write extensively about his shortcomings today, but there is little doubt that he commanded enormous public affection and respect.
This does not mean that Nehru cannot be criticised. Like every other political leader, he had his weaknesses, and several decisions taken by his government can legitimately be questioned. They were also open to public scrutiny during his lifetime. Yet, until his death in 1964, Nehru enjoyed extraordinary love and affection among the people of India. He was widely regarded as an elder statesman, and the public regard he commanded was unprecedented.
Recognising Nehru's greatness does not mean denying the contributions of other leaders. However, blaming him for everything that went wrong, distorting his views or turning his personal life into a subject of scandal does little good for the country. Interestingly, many of Nehru's contemporaries, who were members of his Cabinet or had worked alongside him in the Congress during the freedom movement, continue to be accepted and celebrated, while Nehru himself is increasingly singled out for criticism.
A Cabinet decision is essentially a collective decision. If there were shortcomings in the formulation of the Constitution or in its implementation, responsibility cannot automatically be placed on one individual. If India's Kashmir policy was flawed, why is the role of the Home Minister of that period not examined? Why is the 1962 war with China not discussed as a failure of the entire Cabinet and the political establishment? Similarly, why is India's success in the 1971 Bangladesh Liberation War attributed exclusively to the armed forces, without adequately acknowledging the political leadership of Indira Gandhi? We cannot selectively distribute credit and blame according to our political convenience.
In a democracy, people have every right to question their leaders, and democratic engagement must continue. Criticism strengthens democracy. No leader is greater than the country, and no political personality should be beyond scrutiny. However, when criticism becomes primarily a tool for spreading hatred and deepening divisions in society, it becomes necessary to question its purpose and consequences.
Nobody denies that Nehru had differences with Subhas Chandra Bose, Gandhi, Patel or even Ambedkar. Yet, despite their disagreements, these leaders worked together at different stages of the national movement and the country's early years. Syama Prasad Mookerjee was also a member of Nehru's first Cabinet. In the interim government, leaders such as Liaquat Ali Khan and Jogendra Nath Mandal were also part of the government. These arrangements reflected the willingness of political leaders with different ideological positions to work together in the task of building a new India.
One of the major differences between India and Pakistan after Partition was the nature of their political institutions and leadership. Nehru played a significant role in shaping India's democratic trajectory. Several historians and commentators, including those from Pakistan and among its diaspora, have acknowledged that India was fortunate to have a leader who invested in democratic institutions and constitutional governance. These institutions became sufficiently robust to withstand political opposition and criticism. Pakistan, by contrast, struggled to establish a stable democratic system, and its political institutions remained vulnerable to military intervention. Land reforms also followed different trajectories in the two countries. In India, Nehru's government pursued the abolition of zamindari, although implementation varied across states.
Whatever Nehru's personal views on reservation may have been at different points, his government ensured constitutional safeguards and reservation provisions for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes in public employment. These measures formed part of the larger effort to address historical inequalities and create a more inclusive political and administrative system.
Nehru's legacy must therefore be assessed not merely through his personal writings, speeches or individual opinions but also through the decisions of the Cabinet he headed. His critics are often willing to acknowledge and celebrate the contributions of his colleagues while attributing the shortcomings of the government exclusively to him. Such an approach is neither historically consistent nor intellectually honest. The successes and failures of a government are, to a considerable extent, the outcome of collective decisions. Whether the issues concerned Kashmir, refugees, reservations or women's rights, they were addressed through the government and its Cabinet. Individual ministers deserve recognition for their contributions, but it is equally important to acknowledge the role of the Prime Minister. Would many of these initiatives have been possible without his support?
We must not denigrate our national icons. There are numerous books, archival records and historical documents dealing with the issues they addressed. Isolating one paragraph, one letter or one statement cannot adequately explain the complexities of an entire political life or historical period. India cannot progress as a nation by insulting the leaders who were part of its freedom struggle and laid the foundations of the Republic.
In a democracy, it is the government, its policies and its performance that must be evaluated. Nehru, Indira Gandhi and other leaders were elected by the people. Indira Gandhi was voted out of power in 1977 and subsequently returned to office in 1980. This is the essence of democratic accountability: the people have the ultimate authority to judge their representatives.
The challenges facing India today are vastly different from those confronting the country in the immediate aftermath of Independence. We must respond to contemporary realities rather than remain trapped in endless arguments about the past. It would be far more constructive to learn from history and apply its lessons to present circumstances. Blaming everything on previous governments to conceal the failures or shortcomings of the present will take the country nowhere. What India needs is a serious engagement with today's problems and practical solutions to address them.
There are important lessons to be drawn from Nehru's political life, particularly his commitment to democratic institutions, scientific temper, pluralism and the idea of India as a diverse nation. These lessons remain relevant and can strengthen both democracy and national unity.
A secular, liberal and democratic India is essential for a better future. Rather than allowing political disagreements over historical personalities to divide society, we should draw upon the values and institutions that helped shape the Republic. Nehru's legacy deserves critical examination, but it should not be reduced to selective criticism, historical distortion or political vilification.
---
*Human rights defender
Comments