More than 500 feminists, activists, academics, lawyers, writers, artists and concerned citizens have signed an open letter to Bilkis Bano, condemning the Supreme Court's 28 October 2026 order suspending the sentences of two men convicted in the 2002 gang-rape and murder of 14 members of her family, including her three-year-old daughter Saleha.
The letter, released under the title "How Many Times Must Justice Be Won?", expresses outrage that Bano — who "was neither asked, informed nor heard" — learned of the order through press reports.
"Every line of this letter is difficult to write without anger, but especially that the men convicted of violating you, massacring 14 members of your family in front of your eyes, including your mother, aunts, little brothers and sisters and your precious 3 year old Saleha, were heard by the highest court in the land, while you, who have lived with the consequences of their violence every day, learned of its decision from the press," the letter states.
'Not The First Time'
The signatories note that this is not the first such shock for Bano. On 15 August 2022, the same day the Prime Minister's Independence Day address spoke of women's rights, dignity and "Nari Shakti," Bano learned that the perpetrators had walked free. "No one asked how you felt about the release of these rapists and murderers. No one enquired about your safety," the letter says, recalling that the Supreme Court later quashed the Gujarat government's remission order — but only two years later.
"But today the Supreme Court itself has let you down," the letter states, asking: "What does justice mean when it can be pronounced without the woman whose life is at its centre?"
'Justice Cannot Be Repeatedly Put On Trial'
The press release accompanying the letter declares: "Justice cannot be repeatedly put on trial!" and warns that the judgment "will embolden perpetrators of hate crimes" and "have a chilling effect on victims."
The letter describes Bano's struggle as inseparable from "the wider fight against communal hatred, patriarchal violence and the erosion of constitutional protections," drawing attention to "the increasingly precarious position of Muslims in India, whose citizenship, dignity and constitutional rights are repeatedly called into question."
The signatories write: "Your struggle lays bare the brutal truth of our times of being a Muslim woman in an increasingly authoritarian, majoritarian India, where justice remains conditional, citizenship is constantly put on trial, and even the most hard-won victories can be undone."
MSD Meeting Recalls Movement's History
The solidarity push also extended to the Movement for Secular Democracy (MSD), which met in Ahmedabad to place the legal fight of Bilkis Bano in its historical context. Prakashbhai N. Shah, Convenor, laid out the historical background and the civil movements behind Bano's long legal battle, while Dwarikanath Rath, Secretary, introduced the meeting. At the end, participants came together to show solidarity with Bano by carrying various banners.
Demands
The open letter demands that Bano's voice be heard, that her safety and that of her family be ensured, and that survivors' rights remain central to judicial processes. It also flags the "chilling effect this release has on all victims of rape/gang rape across the country" and "the impunity it extends to all perpetrators of such hate crimes."
"You have said you will challenge this order. We stand with you," the signatories write. "You have the right to an ordinary morning, to laughter without vigilance, to the peace you have worked so hard to reclaim."
Signatories
Among the signatories are women's and gender rights activists and academics including Uma Chakravarti, Dr. Ruth Manorama, Sujata Surepally, Annie Raja, Nivedita Menon, Kalpana Kannabiran, Kavita Srivastava, Shabnam Hashmi, Hasina Khan, Mary E John, J Devika, and Nandini Sundar; journalists Revati Laul, Namita Bhandare, Laxmi Murthy and Geeta Seshu; filmmakers and artists Prakash Raj, Anand Patwardhan, Leena Manimekalai and Maya Rao; and groups including Saheli Women's Resource Centre, AIDWA, Forum Against Oppression of Women, National Federation of Dalit Women, ANHAD, Sangat and Feminists in Resistance.
The letter, issued in English and Hindi, concludes: "We will fight back together, for you, for your loved ones, for justice, and for a country that belongs equally to all its people. In pyaar and solidarity."
Comments