Skip to main content

Two celebrated memoirs, one common thread: Status, power and shared hope

By Bhabani Shankar Nayak* 
Two celebrated memoirs have arrived in India within the same year.
The voluminous "Just Being: A Memoir", which documents the life and times of the internationally acclaimed historian Professor Emerita Romila Thapar, was published earlier this year. A similarly voluminous autobiography, "Belonging: A Journey of Love" by Sonia Gandhi, followed on 10 November 2026.
Both authors are celebrated Indian women in their personal, professional, and public lives. In politics, both are reviled by right-wing politicians, sections of the reactionary press, and conservative Indians. Both books are not only well written but also document the life and times of their authors, reflecting personal and political choices and lived experiences with people, places, ideas, and events in India and beyond.
There is an uncanny similarity between the two: privilege, status, class, power, and elitism blossom subtly across their pages. Texts can disclose more than their authors can sanitise.
One does not hide her elite origins; the other does not forget to celebrate her not-so-humble beginnings. Both women had access to the corridors of power in their time.
One is a formidable professional historian who decolonised the writing of Indian history, offered a much-needed Indian perspective, and single-handedly countered Eurocentric historians and their views of India and Indians.
The other is an Italian girl who fell in love, left Europe to marry the son of an Indian prime minister, claimed her Indian identity with love, and reclaimed her position as a formidable politician in India despite all odds shaped by the right-wing ideology she detests.
Both authors write with elegance, restraint, and courage. Both celebrate liberty, justice, and harmony.
Professor Thapar begins her memoir with Faiz Ahmed Faiz's poem "Bol" ("Speak"). Ms Gandhi begins hers with lines from the Rig Veda celebrating unity, togetherness, and harmony.
Both writers show an unwavering commitment to constitutional democracy and reject right-wing narratives that seek to rewrite India's multicultural, integrated, spiritual, and secular social and political ethos.
Thus, though their life trajectories differ, a common thread of subtle power, status, class, and elitism defines both autobiographies. Their commitment to Indian diversity gives their books a common purpose. "Belonging" is the more enjoyable and readable of the two, though both nurture hope in times of despair.
"Just Being" documents the story of Thapar's privileged childhood in colonial India, the nightmare and trauma of Partition, and the rise of an independent India. It follows her studies and her struggles to find her way on a journey from Rangoon, Peshawar, Lahore, Lucknow, and Poona to settling in Delhi.
That journey shaped her as a person and as a professional historian who rejected dominant, monolithic, and reactionary Eurocentric history in favour of writing history from multiple sources of evidence. Her autobiographical reflections navigate carefully between her personal privileges and her egalitarian political trajectory in writing the history of her times and beyond.
"Belonging" is painfully personal and intimately political. Belonging to a time, place, people, and set of events is one of the most difficult things in life. It is harder still for a migrant, whether in search of life, livelihood, or love.
A migrant becomes a temporary guest in the home country and a permanent guest in the host country. Longing for home, people, food, and friends becomes a permanent condition in an ever-changing world of time, relationships, people, and place.
Ms Gandhi has managed to connect people, places, time, and relationships in a thread of love while building a family and a home in a host country. She is among the privileged few who have overcome the ordeals of life, stopped longing, found home in the host country, and called it their own.
Ms Gandhi found her home in the most powerful political family in India, which she celebrates as her country, where she belongs.
"Belonging" is truly a journey of love and loss. The autobiography begins with her love at first sight with Rajiv Gandhi, their shared love of food, music, weekend parties, and travel in Cambridge and London, and her approach to relationships, shaped by her upbringing as a girl from a remote part of Italy.
She depicts her patriarchal family background, which shaped her outlook on life and relationships, against the backdrop of the precarity of pre- and post-World War II Italy and the horrors of war, poverty, and unemployment in Europe. But her love story dominates the first part of the book.
Amid multiple family tragedies—from the premature death of her first son to the death of Sanjay Gandhi, the assassination of her mother-in-law, Indira Gandhi, and the trauma of Rajiv Gandhi's assassination—Sonia Gandhi survives them all, including her own health ordeals, to tell her love story. It reveals her strength as a person.
Her journey from reluctant politician to consummate leader also defines her as a formidable figure in the Congress Party. Ms Gandhi not only depicts her transformation from an Italian girl into an Indian woman but also covers the wider world of politics and her encounters with different people and places. This is her life in her own words.
Her words bring out her growing up, love, family life, sensitivities, and humane side, as when she narrates her harrowing experience in the relief camps of Gujarat during the 2002 anti-Muslim pogrom. The book also exposes her political proprietorship of the Congress Party in its discussion of Pranab Mukherjee as a politician and his ambitions.
It is clear that this book will be widely read and discussed and will have a long shelf life.
In these two autobiographies, readers can discover the authors' love for people, places, politics, and family, and their commitment to the country they love and fight for, imagining its present and future with love and hope.
Autobiographies are personal reflections on one's own life and times. They are not research probes based on narrow empiricist prisms in the name of evidence.
Thus, criticism of selective writing in these two autobiographies—which seeks to deny two formidable women writers of national importance the freedom to choose their own focus—is unfounded. It comes from readers who expected more detail.
It is a feast to read these two feisty women on their lives, struggles, times, events, perspectives, hopes, and despairs, and to renew our collective commitment to a secular, democratic, constitutional India that is being eroded by right-wing politics that fears reason, reading, and the power of women.
As people celebrate reading and discussing the autobiographies of these two formidable women, it is also worth reading the memoirs of two ordinary Indian women.
The first is "A Life Less Ordinary" by Baby Halder, which shows the exemplary determination and courage of a working-class woman's struggle for survival, as well as the lessons of her life.
The second is "The Weave of My Life: A Dalit Woman's Memoir" by Urmila Pawar, which helps readers understand the burden of caste atrocities and everyday caste violence in the lives of Dalit women in India.
"Ants Among Elephants: An Untouchable Family and the Making of Modern India" by Sujatha Gidla is another memoir that reveals the underbelly of India, where marginalisation defines everyday life.
Many other lives remain invisible because of linguistic, caste, class, and other barriers. Only by reading can we understand and experience life beyond celebrity culture and lifestyles.
Only by reading, understanding, and fighting patriarchal capitalism can we imagine and reclaim a world free from all forms of exploitation and inequality.
--
*Academic based in UK

Comments

TRENDING

Telangana CM urged to call off investment summit amid El Niño drought crisis

By A Representative   A group of 400 concerned citizens, environmentalists, scientists, academics, and people's organizations from Telangana and across India has written an open letter to Chief Minister A. Revanth Reddy, demanding the cancellation or postponement of the 'Invest Telangana Global Summit 2026', scheduled to be held from December 7 to 9 at Bharat Future City near Hyderabad, citing the severe El Niño-induced drought and water crisis in the state.

‘A simple cut could become incurable’: The looming threat of drug-resistant infections

By A Representative   As the world approaches World AMR Awareness Week (WAAW) 2026 (November 18-24), global health leaders are issuing a stark warning: the gap between political commitments and on-the-ground implementation in the fight against antimicrobial resistance (AMR) remains dangerously wide. With bacterial AMR already associated with more than 4.7 million deaths in 2021, the World Health Organization (WHO) and its Quadripartite partners are urging immediate, funded, and measurable action across human, animal, agricultural, and environmental sectors.

China’s Medog dam, India’s Siang project could multiply disaster risks, warns SANDRP

Counterview News   A new report by the advocacy group South Asia Network on Dams, Rivers and People (SANDRP) has warned that China's proposed 60,000 MW Medog hydropower project and India's proposed 11,000 MW Siang Upper Multipurpose Project (SUMP) are being planned in one of the world's most geologically unstable and disaster-prone regions, potentially exposing millions of people downstream to serious risks.