Skip to main content

Bail, betrayal and the Bilkis Bano case: A verdict that shames the judiciary

By Fr. Cedric Prakash SJ* 
Bilkis Bano has once again become a victim of a travesty of justice.
On 28 October, the Supreme Court granted bail to two convicts serving life imprisonment for the gangrape of Bilkis Bano and the murder of her family, including a two-month-old infant, during the 2002 riots. The order, uploaded on the Apex Court's website almost a fortnight later, was passed by the bench of Justices MM Sundresh and PB Varale. Bail was granted to Bipin Chandra Joshi and Pradeep Mordhiya, noting they had been incarcerated for more than 17 years. The bench observed: "Having heard the parties, suffice it to state that the appellants have been under incarceration for a period of more than 17 years, and also the fact remains that one of the appellants has a severe handicap. Certainly, there are issues to be decided in the appeal, both on fact and law."
This order has raised the hackles of right-thinking people everywhere. It is clearly a travesty of justice. The order is hollow. It puts the entire judiciary to shame. Such a heinous crime deserves the severest of punishments. If one goes by this utterly pathetic order, how does one address the likes of Umar Khalid, who has been languishing in jail for over six years without any charges framed against him? How does one address the reality of the late Fr. Stan Swamy, who was denied even a straw sipper while incarcerated? How does one explain the fact that despite being severely handicapped, Prof. G. N. Saibaba was in jail for almost ten years? The Apex Court will certainly not have answers to these questions to justify a clear travesty of justice.
Bilkis Bano has expressed shock and disbelief over the Supreme Court's order suspending the life sentence. In a soul-wrenching and powerful statement issued to the media, she said: "I was a young girl, just 19 years old, when my world, my baby daughter, my family, my home, my trust in humanity was brutally wrenched from me. For 24 long years since that day, I have stood up to fight for justice, for myself and for women everywhere, again and again and again. For 24 years, I have searched for and found reservoirs of courage I did not know I had, only because a million voices of support and solidarity came my way.
"Yet today I find myself losing the very justice I had fought so hard to win. Familiar fears are resurfacing. I am scared once again. For myself, my family, and my children. And I am scared of losing faith in justice, yet again. How could the honourable Supreme Court simply suspend the sentence of the men who did this to me? How could they not even inform me? How could they not even make sure my voice was heard in their courtroom? I have walked to courtroom after courtroom, and been grateful each time I was vindicated; each time my faith in the idea of justice was restored. I have rebuilt from the rubble of my life, with the love of family and friends. I have yearned for peace. I make this statement even when words come slowly through fresh tears of pain, shock and disbelief. I still cannot believe that once again, for the second time, an order has been passed by the Supreme Court without calling me up and without hearing me. I learnt of this through press reports...
"I do this for my three-year-old Saleha, who deserved to live, and whose memory demands justice. I do this for women everywhere. Because no woman, no survivor, no citizen should have to endure this eternal test of belonging and equality, and fight for justice for the rest of her life."
The agony of Bilkis Bano must be seen in the context of the horrendous Gujarat Carnage of 2002. Following the burning of the S-6 compartment and the tragic death of 59 persons (mainly kar sevaks) on 27 February 2002, all hell broke loose the following day in several parts of Gujarat. Sensing trouble, a group of seventeen persons fled their native village of Randhikpur in Dahod district. The group consisted of Bilkis, her three-year-old daughter Saleha, her mother and fourteen others. They took refuge in another village, Chhaparvad. On 3 March, however, they were attacked by about 20–30 people armed with sickles, swords and sticks. Bilkis, her mother and three other women were raped and brutally assaulted. Of the seventeen Muslims, eight were found dead and six were missing. Only Bilkis, a man and a three-year-old child survived the attack. Bilkis was unconscious for at least three hours; after regaining consciousness, she borrowed some clothes from an Adivasi woman and made her way to the Limkheda police station to register a complaint. The Head Constable there, according to the CBI, "suppressed material facts and wrote a distorted and truncated version of Bilkis' complaint."
Since then, Bilkis has relived the horror of that tragedy several times as she unwaveringly, but with great pain, narrates the brutality to which she was subjected. She says: "All the four men of my family were killed brutally. The women were stripped naked and raped by many men. They caught me too. My three-year-old daughter, Saleha, was in my arms. They snatched her and threw her into the air with all their might. My heart broke as her little head shattered on the rocks. Four men caught me by the arms and legs, and many others entered me one by one. When satisfying their lust, they kicked me and beat my head with a rod. Assuming that I was dead, they threw me into the bushes. Four or five hours later, I regained consciousness. I searched for some rags to cover my body, but couldn't find any. I spent a day and a half on a hilltop without food or water. I longed for death. Finally, I managed to find a tribal colony. Declaring myself a Hindu, I sought shelter there. The men who attacked us used foul language; I can't repeat it ever. In front of me, they killed my mother, sister and 12 other relatives. While raping and killing us, they were shouting sexual abuse. I could not even tell them that I was five months pregnant because their feet were on my mouth and neck. I have known the men who raped me for many years. We sold them milk. They were our customers. If they had any shame, they would not have done this to me. How can I forgive them?"
Any lesser mortal would have given up, but not Bilkis Bano. With her husband, Yakub Rasool (who was away from home when the violence broke out), who has stood by her through thick and thin, she has experienced a roller-coaster journey of suffering and temporary justice. At first, Bilkis could hardly open her mouth. With the help of some concerned citizens, she slowly regained her confidence and realised that she was the key witness in bringing the perpetrators of this heinous crime to book. She plucked up courage and began a painful struggle for truth and justice. She knew who the murderers and rapists were, and she courageously identified them. The journey was fraught with obstacles and hostilities, threats and intimidation. The Gujarat Government, with Narendra Modi at the helm, was obviously supportive of the criminals who raped her and killed her family members. The FIR was manipulated; the medical reports and post-mortem of the bodies omitted significant details; evidence was destroyed, since all the dead were buried by the police themselves; the body of her three-year-old disappeared. The prosecution sided with the accused; the lower court that heard her case upheld all the falsehoods and lies. Case closed.
Bilkis, however, never gave up; her pursuit of truth and justice was relentless. The then National Human Rights Commission (a far cry from the NHRC of today, which is absolutely spineless and openly supports the crimes of the ruling regime) received her petition, conducted its own independent inquiry and supported her case. She then appealed to the Supreme Court. In 2004, the case was reopened and referred to the CBI. Twelve of the twenty accused were arrested in 2004, and the trial began in Ahmedabad. However, after Bilkis expressed grave apprehensions that witnesses could be harmed and the evidence collected by the CBI tampered with, the Supreme Court transferred the case to Mumbai. Bilkis was the only direct eyewitness. She was constantly under threat. For her own safety, she had to move from one place to another. In 2008, the Special Court sentenced eleven accused (one died during the trial) to life imprisonment on charges of conspiring to rape a pregnant woman, murder and unlawful assembly under the Indian Penal Code. The police and doctors accused of being complicit in fudging reports were exonerated. In May 2017, on an appeal from the CBI, the Mumbai High Court upheld the sentencing and also found the doctors and police guilty. One of the judges, Justice Salvi, termed Bilkis' "courageous deposition as the turning point in the case." In 2019, the Supreme Court awarded compensation of Rs 50 lakh to Bilkis — the first such order in a case related to the 2002 riots. The bench, then Chief Justice of India Ranjan Gogoi and Justices Deepak Gupta and Sanjiv Khanna, stated: "It is very apparent that what should not have happened has happened and the state has to give compensation."
Sadly, on Independence Day 2022, the nation was in for a terrible shock when those who were imprisoned were set free by the Gujarat Government. The moment the convicts (rapists and murderers) came out of prison, they were felicitated by the Hindutva brigade with ladoos and garlands. Significantly, the moment their remission order was received, they were out of the prison gates (for human rights defenders and others illegally incarcerated, even after the release or bail order is received by the jail authorities, it takes hours and even several days for them to come out of prison). Besides, the convicts seemed to have enjoyed their so-called time in jail; they came out fatted, well-dressed and groomed. Most prisoners in India are certainly not as privileged as these henchmen of Hindutva. It was back to square one for Bilkis, her kith and kin, for the many victim survivors of the Gujarat Carnage, for human rights defenders and others who have given up so much for these victim survivors, and for the many millions of others.
The world and all citizens who care for truth and justice were outraged at the fact that the eleven criminals had their sentences remitted. For such a ghastly crime, remission is just not given. Officialdom tried to justify this act with flimsy and unacceptable reasons. Social media went viral, with people from all walks of life coming together to express condemnation. Leading newspapers (nationally and internationally) carried editorials and op-eds clearly taking a stand against this remission. Interestingly, even some of the godified electronic media, namely the RSS and the VHP, were criticised in their reporting. Powerful statements of condemnation came in from eminent citizens, intellectuals, politicians, activists and others from across the board. The voice of all was loud and clear: this act, for a heinous crime, is a blatant travesty of justice.
On 17 August 2022, Bilkis stated: "Two days ago, on August 15, 2022, the trauma of the past 20 years washed over me again. When I heard that the 11 convicted men who devastated my family and my life, and took from me my three-year-old daughter, had walked free, I was bereft of words. I am still numb. Today I can only say this — how can justice for any woman end like this? I trusted the highest courts in our land. I trusted the system, and I was learning slowly to live with my trauma. The release of these convicts has taken from me my peace and shaken my faith in justice. My sorrow and my wavering faith are not for myself alone but for every woman who is struggling for justice in courts. No one enquired about my safety and well-being before taking such a big and unjust decision. I appeal to the Gujarat Government: please undo this harm. Give me back my right to live without fear and in peace. Please ensure that my family and I are kept safe."
Fortunately, some women stalwarts and a battery of committed and brilliant lawyers (mainly women) were convinced that the cause of truth and justice had to triumph for Bilkis, for the women of India and, ultimately, for the future of the country. For more than sixteen months, Bilkis waited patiently. On 8 January 2024, Bilkis Bano stood vindicated. Her relentless quest for truth and justice met with triumph as the Supreme Court of India quashed the Gujarat Government's decision to allow the premature release of convicts in the gangrape case — a heinous, brutal crime that took place during the Gujarat Carnage of 2002.
In a landmark judgment, the bench of Justice B.V. Nagarathna and Justice Ujjal Bhuyan held that the eleven convicts (who had been given remission) had to report back to the jail authorities within two weeks and continue to remain in jail. The bench clearly stated that the Gujarat Government was not empowered to pass the remission order, since the appropriate government entitled to pass orders of remission was the government of the State where the trial had taken place; in this particular case, it was the Government of Maharashtra, not that of Gujarat, which was the competent authority even to consider remission.
The 251-page judgment is excellent; the key para states: "On competence of Gujarat government to pass remission orders, it is apparent that appropriate government had to take permission of the court before passing remission orders. This means that the place of occurrence or place of imprisonment of convicts is not relevant for remission. The definition of appropriate government is otherwise. The government intends that the State under which the convict was tried and sentenced was the appropriate government. This emphasises the place of trial rather than where the crime took place."
The judges came down heavily on the Gujarat Government, stating that it was complicit in the crime for not filing a review plea against the May 2022 judgment, acting in tandem with the convicts and usurping Maharashtra's jurisdiction to grant remission. "It was the State of Maharashtra that could have passed the remission orders; Respondent No. 3 surreptitiously filed the plea before the Supreme Court. Taking advantage of the May 13, 2022 order of this Court, other convicts also filed remission applications and the Gujarat government passed remission orders. Gujarat was complicit and acted in tandem with respondent no. 3 in this case. This Court was misled by suppressing facts. Use of power by Gujarat was only a usurpation of power by the State."
In great detail, the judgment exposed all the fraudulent tactics the convicts used, as well as how Gujarat's government acted in tandem with them in securing their unmerited and premature release from prison via reduction of sentences through a sham process of remission, albeit under erroneous directions from the Supreme Court itself. The Court also came down strongly on one of the convicts, Radhyesham, for playing a fraud upon the Court by suppressing material facts and obtaining a favourable order from the top court in May 2022, which eventually led to the release of all eleven convicts. It unequivocally stated that the May 2022 judgment was obtained by fraud and therefore not good in law. The convicts had to return to jail as per the Court order.
The 2024 Supreme Court order meant that the Gujarat Government, together with the other criminals in the Central Government, had to hang their heads in shame. They had reached such abysmal depths that they were unable to stand up for a poor rural woman who had been gang-raped and who had witnessed the rape and murder of her kith and kin. That judgment, in the Bilkis Bano case, was certainly a shot in the arm for all those who believe in truth and justice; it delivered a body blow to criminals who are part of a fascist regime. On hearing the verdict, Bilkis said: "Today is truly the New Year for me. I have wept tears of relief. I have smiled for the first time in over a year and a half. I have hugged my children. It feels like a stone the size of a mountain has been lifted from my chest, and I can breathe again. This is what justice feels like. I thank the honourable Supreme Court of India for giving me, my children and women everywhere, this vindication and hope in the promise of equal justice for all."
Sadly, however, with the recent order by the Apex Court, Bilkis' world has turned upside down once again. It is a clear travesty of justice — there is no doubt about that. Bilkis has once again become a victim. But she is a fighter. We, the people of India, will stand by her till the cause of justice is served and truth triumphs. It will be a relentless struggle till that day dawns.
---
*Human rights, justice, reconciliation and peace activist, writer and trainer

Comments

TRENDING

Telangana CM urged to call off investment summit amid El Niño drought crisis

By A Representative   A group of 400 concerned citizens, environmentalists, scientists, academics, and people's organizations from Telangana and across India has written an open letter to Chief Minister A. Revanth Reddy, demanding the cancellation or postponement of the 'Invest Telangana Global Summit 2026', scheduled to be held from December 7 to 9 at Bharat Future City near Hyderabad, citing the severe El Niño-induced drought and water crisis in the state.

‘A simple cut could become incurable’: The looming threat of drug-resistant infections

By A Representative   As the world approaches World AMR Awareness Week (WAAW) 2026 (November 18-24), global health leaders are issuing a stark warning: the gap between political commitments and on-the-ground implementation in the fight against antimicrobial resistance (AMR) remains dangerously wide. With bacterial AMR already associated with more than 4.7 million deaths in 2021, the World Health Organization (WHO) and its Quadripartite partners are urging immediate, funded, and measurable action across human, animal, agricultural, and environmental sectors.

China’s Medog dam, India’s Siang project could multiply disaster risks, warns SANDRP

Counterview News   A new report by the advocacy group South Asia Network on Dams, Rivers and People (SANDRP) has warned that China's proposed 60,000 MW Medog hydropower project and India's proposed 11,000 MW Siang Upper Multipurpose Project (SUMP) are being planned in one of the world's most geologically unstable and disaster-prone regions, potentially exposing millions of people downstream to serious risks.