Not risky? How schools closure flattened children’s future, not Covid curve

By Bhaskaran Raman*

“Flatten the curve” so that hospitals are not overwhelmed, was the clarion call in March 2020, based on which all schools in India were shut. Does school closure flatten the Covid curve? There was weak evidence in Mar 2020, and schools were shut along with everything else in an atmosphere of panic. Eighteen months later there is now plenty of evidence that school closure does indeed flatten, not the Covid curve, but children’s futures.

Tens of thousands of schools have been open in over 170 countries, many even at the peak of the Covid curve. But reports of Covid outbreaks in schools are few and far between. Let us look rationally at a few such recent reports from India as well as abroad, to gauge the level of concern warranted.

The state of Punjab opened schools from August 2. It was reported that “infection” was high among children in Punjab following school reopening. Tamil Nadu opened schools for classes 9-12 on September 1. By mid-September, a total of 117 paediatric cases were reported in that State. Toward the end of August, a report of a Covid outbreak in California, USA, made waves in the media.

Does school closure help reduce hospitalization?

To a layperson, such reports paint a picture that schools are dangerous places, hospitals may crumble if schools are opened. Is this picture accurate, or is it a gross exaggeration? It is important to note that none of the media reports say anything about the severity of the “cases”. Have there been any severe cases? Any hospitalizations?
None report on this. Taking “no news” as “good news”, perhaps we can conclude that there have been no severe cases or hospitalizations. Indeed the original CDC report of the California outbreak says “No persons infected in this outbreak were hospitalized”.
Let us pause for a moment and let that sink in.
Across the thousands of schools opened so far, very few reports of outbreaks, and even there, no reported hospitalization!
In other words, there was no curve to flatten through school closure.
Dozens of methodical studies have indeed shown that schools do not increase Covid hospitalization or even Covid spread. As early as June 2020, a comparison of Sweden (schools open) vs Finland (schools closed) showed no statistical difference in paediatric cases, and no increased risk to teachers compared to other professions. The US CDC’s own report in Jan 2021 cites a study which found “no increase in Covid-19 hospitalization rates associated with in-person education”.

Case counting serves no useful purpose

Thus even the rare reports of supposed Covid spread in schools report only “cases”. Does this serve any purpose? What exactly does an “infection” or a “case” mean in a child? It would do good to remind ourselves what the abbreviation SARS-Cov-2 stands for. The first “S” stands for “severe” and the “A” stands for “acute”. “Cases”, or PCR positive results, can happen among children too. But the risk of severe outcomes is very rare.

All schools must open now; continued closure is morally and scientifically unjustifiable

The human body has hundreds of different kinds of viruses: if we test for them, we will find them, but there is no clinical relevance since the body is able to fight off the bad ones. For most children, SARS-Cov-2 is just one other such virus with severe outcomes being very rare.

Therefore counting “cases”, especially in children, serves only the negative purpose of increasing anxiety.

The zeal for zero-risk

Paediatric “case” reporting arises from a misplaced zeal for zero-risk and zero-Covid, a scientific impossibility. A clear fact which has been lost amidst muddled thinking in the last 18 months is the age-differential risk of Covid. While Covid is deadly for old/comorbid people, it is literally a 1000 times less risk for children.
Despite this, surely every parent would say “my child should not face any risk, however small”. This is natural and emotional, but irrational on three counts.

First, zero risk is an impossibility. A recent UK study concluded that children under 10 are 20 times more likely to die of accidental injury, compared to Covid-19. Surely, we wouldn’t shut schools or kids’ play to avoid accidents.
Second, staying at home away from schools has not protected children from exposure to Covid-19. A recent sero-survey conducted by PGIMER showed that 71% of children were already exposed and had antibodies. What has protected these children from any severe outcome is their own natural immune system (for which we should be thankful), not school closure.
Third, school closure increases health risk for children: causing great psychological harm, even suicides, alongside increasing manifold other severe problems like child labour, child marriage, malnutrition, etc.

Recently it was reported that the Supreme Court had said that it would hold the State of Kerala accountable “if even one case is reported” during conduct of class-11 exams. Is this level of containment humanly possible? That too against a respiratory virus spreading through airborne aerosols? When the harshest of military enforced lockdowns have not contained the virus in much more sparsely populated countries like Australia? Instead of seeking the impossible, should we not be celebrating the fact that the virus has spared children and young people from severe outcomes?

Absurdities abound

So why did we shut schools? The saying goes: “the road to hell is paved with good intentions”. We shut schools to keep children safe. Or to keep parents safe. Or to keep grandparents safe. Or to keep society safe from the Covid curve. All well intentioned perhaps, but evidence is mounting that none of these are remotely true.
Were children not exposed to Covid-19? No, they were exposed (but safe) despite school closure. Were parents or grandparents safe due to school closure? We have the recent tall second wave to answer that.
Self-evident contradictions that any lay person can see are also mounting: how can schools be viewed as super-spreaders when everything else including malls, theaters, markets, banks, post-offices, public buses, shared auto-rickshaws, etc are open? When currently the Covid curve is on a downward trend, what is there to flatten via school closure anyway, except childrens’ futures?

Now means now

If truth and scientific evidence matter, if our children's futures matter, all schools in India must open. We must go back in time 18 months to open them. Since we don’t have a time machine, we must open all schools now. Possible third wave or fourth wave have no role in this.
Covid-19 vaccines for kids are unnecessary and have no role in this. It is appalling that several States have still not opened primary schools. Our children should be made to wait no longer.
---
*Professor in the Department of Computer Science and Engineering at IIT Bombay. Views are personal.

Comments

The curious case of multiple entries of a female voter of Maharashtra: What ECI's online voter records reveal

By Venkatesh Nayak* Cyberspace is agog with data, names and documents which question the reliability of the electoral rolls prepared by the electoral bureaucracy in Maharashtra prior to the General Elections conducted in 2024. One such example of deep dive probing has brought to the surface, the name of one female voter in the 132-Nalasopara (Gen) Vidhan Sabha Constituency in Maharashtra. Nalasopara is part of the Palghar (ST) Lok Sabha constituency. This media report claims that this individual's name figures multiple times in the voter list of the same constituency.

Spirit of leadership vs bondage: Of empowered chairman of 100-acre social forestry coop

By Gagan Sethi* This is about Khoda Sava, a young Dalit belonging to the Vankar sub-caste, who worked as a bonded labourer in a village near Vadgam in Banskantha district of North Gujarat. The year was 1982. Khoda had taken a loan of Rs 7,000 from the village sarpanch, a powerful landlord doing money-lending as his side business. Khoda, who had taken the loan for marriage, was landless. Normally, villagers would mortgage their land if they took loan from the sarpanch. But Khoda had no land. He had no option but to enter into a bondage agreement with the sarpanch in order to repay the loan. Working in bondage on the sarpanch’s field meant that he would be paid Rs 1,200 per annum, from which his loan amount with interest would be deducted. He was also obliged not to leave the sarpanch’s field and work as daily wager somewhere else. At the same time, Khoda was offered meal once a day, and his wife job as agricultural worker on a “priority basis”. That year, I was working as secretary...

1857 War of Independence... when Hindu-Muslim separatism, hatred wasn't an issue

"The Sepoy Revolt at Meerut", Illustrated London News, 1857 By Shamsul Islam* Large sections of Hindus, Muslims and Sikhs unitedly challenged the greatest imperialist power, Britain, during India’s First War of Independence which began on May 10, 1857; the day being Sunday. This extraordinary unity, naturally, unnerved the firangees and made them realize that if their rule was to continue in India, it could happen only when Hindus and Muslims, the largest two religious communities were divided on communal lines.

N-power plant at Mithi Virdi: CRZ nod is arbitrary, without jurisdiction

By Krishnakant* A case-appeal has been filed against the order of the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEF&CC) and others granting CRZ clearance for establishment of intake and outfall facility for proposed 6000 MWe Nuclear Power Plant at Mithi Virdi, District Bhavnagar, Gujarat by Nuclear Power Corporation of India Limited (NPCIL) vide order in F 11-23 /2014-IA- III dated March 3, 2015. The case-appeal in the National Green Tribunal at Western Bench at Pune is filed by Shaktisinh Gohil, Sarpanch of Jasapara; Hajabhai Dihora of Mithi Virdi; Jagrutiben Gohil of Jasapara; Krishnakant and Rohit Prajapati activist of the Paryavaran Suraksha Samiti. The National Green Tribunal (NGT) has issued a notice to the MoEF&CC, Gujarat Pollution Control Board, Gujarat Coastal Zone Management Authority, Atomic Energy Regulatory Board and Nuclear Power Corporation of India Limited (NPCIL) and case is kept for hearing on August 20, 2015. Appeal No. 23 of 2015 (WZ) is filed, a...

Ground reality: Israel would a remain Jewish state, attempt to overthrow it will be futile

By NS Venkataraman* Now that truce has been arrived at between Israel and Hamas for a period of four days and with release of a few hostages from both sides, there is hope that truce would be further extended and the intensity of war would become significantly less. This likely “truce period” gives an opportunity for the sworn supporters and bitter opponents of Hamas as well as Israel and the observers around the world to introspect on the happenings and whether this war could have been avoided. There is prolonged debate for the last several decades as to whom the present region that has been provided to Jews after the World War II belong. View of some people is that Jews have been occupants earlier and therefore, the region should belong to Jews only. However, Christians and those belonging to Islam have also lived in this regions for long period. While Christians make no claim, the dispute is between Jews and those who claim themselves to be Palestinians. In any case...

Two more "aadhaar-linked" Jharkhand deaths: 17 die of starvation since Sept 2017

Kaleshwar's sons Santosh and Mantosh Counterview Desk A fact-finding team of the Right to Feed Campaign, pointing towards the death of two more persons due to starvation in Jharkhand, has said that this has happened because of the absence of aadhaar, leading to “persistent lack of food at home and unavailability of any means of earning.” It has disputed the state government claims that these deaths are due to reasons other than starvation, adding, the authorities have “done nothing” to reduce the alarming state of food insecurity in the state.

Govt of India "tarnishing" NGO reputation, dossier leaked selectively: Amnesty

Counterview Desk Amnesty International India has said that a deliberate attempt is being made to tarnish its reputation by leaking a dossier, supposedly made by investigating agencies, to media without giving it access to any such information. The high profile NGO’s claim follows a Times Now report about proceedings launched by investigative agencies, including Enforcement Directorate (ED) against the rights body for “violations” of rules pertaining to overseas donations.

How AMU student politics prioritises Islamist ideologies rather than addressing campus-specific concerns

By Yanis Iqbal* In his recent piece titled "Unmasking the Power Struggles of Soqme Teachers Behind the AMU Students’ Agitation," Mohammad Sajjad, professor of modern and contemporary Indian history at the Aligarh Muslim University (AMU), has has approached the recent protests against fee increases at AMU with a skeptical eye. He portrays them not as a pure, student-led reaction to financial burdens, but as possibly intertwined with deeper institutional rivalries. While recognizing that the university administration faces ongoing demands from the government and the University Grants Commission (UGC) to boost self-generated revenue via fee adjustments, he highlights a key shortfall: neither the administration nor the protesters have shared clear, comparative data on fee structures or their rationale.

Proposed Modi yatra from Jharkhand an 'insult' of Adivasi hero Birsa Munda: JMM

Counterview Desk The civil rights network, Jharkhand Janadhikar Mahasabha (JMM), which claims to have 30 grassroots groups under its wings, has decided to launch Save Democracy campaign to oppose Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Vikasit Bharat Sankalp Yatra to be launched on November 15 from the village of legendary 19th century tribal independence leader Birsa Munda from Ulihatu (Khunti district).

Search This Blog