Skip to main content

US, European 'failure' in dealing with corona crisis: Whither failed state thesis?

By Bhabani Shankar Nayak*
Policy practitioners in the World Bank, OECD, and other development agencies used the term ‘fragile state’ during 1990s before using of the term ‘failed state’. The failure to provide security to the citizens, failure to provide public services including health and monopoly of state violence are three central components that define ‘failed state’. 
The incubation and spread of deadly diseases are one of the many features of failed state, as outlined by the United States Institute of Peace (USIP) in its 2004 report. The Dutch Advisory Council on International Affairs (AIV) on Issues of Public International Law has defined failed state or state failures as “the impotence of the central government.” Bourgeois intellectuals started using the term without questioning the validity of its core concepts. The Failed State Index was designed by the Funds for Peace in 2005.
There is no empirical evidence or justification behind such an index. But the think tanks and academicians started using such a sham index to rank states in terms of their abilities, and efficiency in dealing with different forms of crisis and frame policies accordingly.
The coronavirus pandemic and failures of capitalist states provide an opportunity to interrogate the ideas and objectives around the ‘failed state’ and expose its conceptual ambiguity, theoretical absurdity and empirical fallacies. The ‘failed state’ thesis and its narratives were developed in the form of blistering critique of postcolonial states in Africa, Asia and Latin America. The motivation was to undermine postcolonial states, their development promises, processes, and legitimacy in the eyes of their own citizens.
Stages of economic growth, modernisation, and development theories were offered as alternatives within Eurocentric paradigm, that ignored the historical conditions and contemporary limitations to reflect on the realities of uneven developments in world economy. The idea behind such a narrative is to hide the imperialist and colonial plunders, which led to the economic underdevelopment in postcolonial states and their failures.
Further, the neo-colonial trade policies undermined the postcolonial states ability to engage with international trade and business. The terms of trade during globalisation is not only unequal and unfair but also exploitative. 
Colonial aid for trade policies were designed in such a way that led to exploitation of natural resources of postcolonial states. These are some of the causes that led to the failure of postcolonial states in delivering public goods such as basic health, education, security, roads, transportation, and communication infrastructures.
Predatory ruling regimes, and their cronies were promoted by the western powers, which accelerated weakening and collapse of postcolonial states. States in Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, Egypt, Nigeria, Somalia and Serra Leone have collapsed due to different forms of imperialist and neo-colonial interventions. But these states were branded as failed states.
The failed state as a concept developed to organise these weak states and control their resources necessary for the survival and growth of capitalism. Failed state was a pretext of imperialist interventions to establish a political regime that works as per the orders of the capitalist states in Europe and America.
It is capitalism and its international institutional apparatus developed the failed state thesis to hide the exploitative colonial past and imperialist present. The failed state as a concept needs to be discarded as it does not serve to analyse and explain the conditions of development and underdevelopment within the historical contexts of state formations. 
The Failed State Index is historically flawed and analytically poor. It does not help us to understand the subjective and objective conditions of state failures. It cannot guide policy framework in any positive direction.
Capitalist states like UK and USA have abandoned their constitutional responsibilities to protect citizens from the Covid-19 pandemic. The pestilence led lockdown impels to rethink, reflect and reject the Eurocentric ideological narratives of ‘Westphalian nation-states’; capitalist in letter and spirit. It is also the time to rewrite the ideological narratives and dominance of the so-called success stories of western states and their universalising tendencies of capitalism as only alternatives. 
Failed state as a concept was developed to organise weak states and control their resources necessary for the survival capitalism
In reality, capitalist states have not only failed to face the pandemic, the USDA under the Trump administration is making all efforts to strip away nutrition benefits from more than a million Americans who depend completely on food stamps. UK under Boris Johnson led conservative government has failed to provide basic safety nets to frontline workers. 
The government is planning to further weaken the working class by freezing the wages, and removing triple lock system on pensions to fund the debt and cover the deficit due to coronavirus crisis. This is morally indefensible, but UK lacks moral compass.
Capitalist states in France, Italy and Spain have also failed to protect their citizens during this pandemic. These Westphalian states were formed to consolidate capitalism during mid 17th century but they failed miserably to face the challenges of public health crisis during 2020 Coronavirus pandemic.
The failure shows the limits of the capitalist states and fallacies of failed state as a narrative. Countries like China, Cuba and Vietnam were successful because of their swift, scientific and collective response to the crisis. But this is unacceptable to the advocates of failed state thesis.
However, the rise of radical right-wing political parties and their reactionary nationalist politics is giving breathing space to the failed capitalist states. The popular discontent is externalised by conspiracy theorists and their propaganda machine to undermine the success of China, Cuba and Vietnam in dealing with the coronavirus crisis.
The rising tide of xenophobia gives the capitalist states more power to hide their failures under security cover that undermines civil liberties of citizens during lockdowns. The emergency measures and suspension of normality helps the capitalist states to divert the democratic discontents and resistance movements that empowers the citizens. Deaths and destitutions are the twin net outcome of the coronavirus pandemic accelerated by capitalism.
Capitalist states have failed to respond to the global health crisis and other ancillaries of the pandemic. The people are facing alienation and discontent in life within lockdown for survival. The dreadful days of coronavirus pandemic will come to an end at one point of time and people will take off their mask of fear.
But let’s not forget to unmask the capitalist state and its healthcare systems that failed the masses. The atomised individualism promoted by capitalist system is also busted during the unavoidable lockdown induced lethal loneliness. All forms of alienations are organic to capitalism that the failed states aggravate during this pandemic.
There is an adage that one learns from everyday experiences of the present crisis; that the capitalist state and all its machineries have failed in the face of pandemic. Therefore, social and political solidarity is the only alternative against capitalism and all its alienating experiences.
Societies, states, governments, economy, culture and politics exists for the people, and because of the people. These entities and institutions are meaningless without people. So, it is imperative to reflect on the directions of our life, society and states.
There are two directions. The first one is to continue with business as usual with the capitalist system and suffer under its profit driven barbaric pandemic of inequality and exploitation. The second option is to break away from such a system and focus on people and their wellbeing. This is a historic opportunity to make a clear choice for our present and future.
The coronavirus pandemic provides an opportunity to transform the state apparatus and overthrow capitalism, that destabilises human existence and failed citizens, states and societies around the world. It important to move to an unwaveringly international, regional, national and local political and economic system that puts people and nature at the core of its agenda.
---
*Coventry University, UK

Comments

TRENDING

Contempt of court? UP CM taking 'personal vendetta' against Dr Kafeel Khan: Activists

Counterview Desk
Demanding that the Uttar Pradesh government immediately release well-known paediatrician Dr Kafeel Khan, a group of more than 100 academicians, activists, researchers, doctors and lawyers have said in an open letter that he is being “targeted at the behest of the chief minister”, wondering, “When is an act of challenging the government a threat under the National Security Act (NSA)?”

Buddhist shrines massively destroyed by Brahmanical rulers in "pre-Islamic" era: Historian DN Jha's survey

By Our Representative
Prominent historian DN Jha, an expert in India's ancient and medieval past, in his new book, "Against the Grain: Notes on Identity, Intolerance and History", in a sharp critique of "Hindutva ideologues", who look at the ancient period of Indian history as "a golden age marked by social harmony, devoid of any religious violence", has said, "Demolition and desecration of rival religious establishments, and the appropriation of their idols, was not uncommon in India before the advent of Islam".

ASI has 'no funds' to protect five centuries old Goa church, a World Heritage Site

Counterview Desk
The century-old All-India Catholic Union (AICU), the largest Laity movement in Asia, has blamed the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) for neglecting the historic Bom Jesu church by keeping its ceilings  open to the vagaries weather, with no steps  taken to protect the five century old monument from damage on account of impending rains on the lame excuse that there are "no funds". In a letter to Prime Minister Narendra Modi, AICU simultaneously asks the Government of India to devise a "comprehensive" national social security safety net, universal health Insurance and medical Infrastructure so that the “calamity” that has befalenl millions of migrant labour and jobless rural and urban poor in “the Covid pandemic-driven lockdown is “never repeated.”

Gujarat govt move for fewer Covid-19 tests 'pushing' people to edge: Activists, academics

By Our Representative
About 100 concerned citizens, including top social activists and experts, have strongly protested against the Gujarat government’s alleged move to “dictate” the medical community to “reduce” Covid-19 tests in order to suggest that the state has fewer number of cononavirus positive patients, stating, this is nothing but “criminal negligence” which would “push people towards death without their knowledge.”

Withdraw sedition charges against three young women activists: 1100 feminists

Counterview Desk
About 1,100 feminists from all over India – organisations and individuals across religion, class, caste, ethnicity, ability, sexuality and genders – have issued a solidarity statement condemning what they have called “the targeted crackdown on Muslims and women activists in Delhi”, who were at the forefront of protests against the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA), National Register of Citizens (NRC) and National Population Register (NPR).

Will Govt of India, ICMR end 'perverse' practice of extracting profits from ill-health?

By Asmita Verma, Surabhi Agarwal, Bobby Ramakant*
The Epidemics Act, 1897 gives the central and state governments authority to impose any regulations which may be necessary to contain the outbreak of a disease. Some state governments such as Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan and Chhatisgarh have already used this power to bring private healthcare facilities in their state under government control.

Tablighis or Namaste Trump? Rupani must 'clarify' on origin of Covid-19 in Gujarat

By Mujahid Nafees* In his video communication on April 24, 2020, chief minister Vijay Rupani informed us that in the month of March the Gujarat government had quarantined 6,000 people returning from abroad in order to prevent the spread of Covid-19 pandemic. He further asserted that the spread of Covid-19 was caused by the tablighis returning from Nizamuddin in Delhi. His statements were widely publicized and given front page coverage by some local dailies.

Coping with Covid-19? Options before small, marginal farmers of rainfed regions

By Biswanath Sinha, Kuntal Mukherjee*
The global crisis due to Covid-19 has hit after reaching in western Europe. India’s response to curtail the spread of the disease was quite decisive. It announced a Janata curfew on the March 22, followed by a complete national lockdown from the midnight of March 24.

Roll back full lockdown, it's being used to 'brutally' assault, beat people: PUCL to Modi

By Our Representative India’s premier human rights organization, People’s Union for Civil Liberties (PUCL), in a 3,600 word statement, has demanded that Prime Minister Narendra Modi, in consultation with chief ministers, should immediately consider rolling back of the full lockdown in the wake of the Covid-19 crisis, insisting, if it all, India should “have calibrated, limited lockdown areas.”