Skip to main content

Time to lockout the lockdown: Why social distancing is a hugely unfulfilled aspiration

By Mohan Guruswamy*
It is time now to sit back and objectively reconsider the draconian policy measures unleashed in India. The four hours to midnight order for a nationwide “curfew” to enforce social distancing had caught our public and public administration woefully unprepared. In one fell stroke we have managed to render wage less at least 100 million people.
We still don’t have any record of deaths due to lockdown stress, but we are getting a clearer picture of economic losses. The consequences of Covid2019 to the Indian economy and consequent loss of lives and longevity, seems very likely to exceed the loss due to any mass spread of the virus.
Epidemiological studies put out at several well regarded institutions such as MIT and the Global Virus Network (GVN) suggest that this particular coronavirus is endemic in populated areas falling in temperature band of 3-17C with a humidity between 51-79%. These initial findings suggesting a correlation between latitude and incidence have the powerful endorsement of Dr. Robert Gallo, the famed virologist and head of the Global Virology Network.
The essential facts about Covid2019 is that while it is virulent, its fatality is about 3% and this is principally concentrated among the elderly and already ailing. Its symptoms are mostly akin to common seasonal flus often attributed to change of season etc.
Over 80% of the infected remain asymptomatic or have mild symptoms. Covid2019 can only be confirmed by testing and the cheapest test costs about Rs.4500 each. Clearly we cannot afford to test enough, which simply means we won’t ever know how many are truly afflicted by Covid2019.
The average life expectancy of Indians is 68.7 years. The above 65 years cohort accounts for only about 6% of India, which suggests that the incidence of fatality here will be lower. Bubonic plague has a mortality of over 80%, while even diphtheria has a mortality rate of 32%.
Covid2019 is not a killer virus. In the developed countries like USA, Italy and elsewhere with substantially higher life expectancy, the 70+ years cohorts are much bigger. The mortality rate due has been the highest in Italy with about 9%. Almost 86% of the Italians who died were over 70 years. Italy has the second oldest population in the world after Japan, with over 23% over 65 years. Experts believe this was the determining factor in its high fatality rate.
The goal of social distancing is a hugely unfulfilled aspiration. The poor in India live cheek by jowl, with densities often exceeding 60,000 per sq miles. India has over 410 million workers in the unorganized sector, the vast majority of whom are daily wagers making a little more than the prescribed official wages and often much below that. 
This working age cohort is mostly made up of younger Indians. The youthful age group (14-35 years) accounts for about 34% of India’s population. This cohort is about as much as the 35-65 years cohorts. Thus, even if the pandemic is real for India, the fatality due to it will be very low. The vast majority of Indians who might get infected by Covid2019 virus won’t even know it. 
Now assume that the Covid2019 pandemic will overwhelm India, and consider India’s abysmal health care scene. We have 6 physicians, 9 hospital beds and 13 nurses per 10,000 people. Nationwide we have less than 40000 ventilators and only 70,000 intensive care beds (ICU). This calls for a policy that will help stagger the load and allow immunity to build up without overwhelming the critical care system.
Only possible method for dealing with the epidemic may be multiple intermittent social-distancing periods that ease up when cases fall
Even given this situation we don’t help ourselves when solutions present themselves. The chairman of Maruti Suzuki, which responded with alacrity to the PM’s appeal to develop low cost ventilators, was forced to publicly complain that the company now has a stock of over 1,500 ventilators but has received no instructions from the government on where they must be deployed.
Harvard’s Yonatan Grad, Professor of Immunology and Infectious Diseases, and colleagues conducted research on how to prevent overwhelming the US health care system during the pandemic. 
This indicates the only possible method for dealing with the epidemic may be multiple “intermittent” social-distancing periods that ease up when cases fall to a certain level and then are re-imposed when they rise past a key threshold. As time passes and more of the population gains immunity, they said, the restrictive episodes could be shorter, with longer intervals between them. Clearly the nationwide simultaneous social distancing imposition was not only but also ill conceived.
Dr.Johanne Giesecke, one of the world’s most senior epidemiologists, advisor to the Swedish Government, the first Chief Scientist of the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control, and an advisor to the director general of the WHO, lays out with typically Swedish bluntness what he thinks: 1.The policy on lockdown in many countries are not evidence-based; 2. The correct policy is to protect the old and the frail only; and 3. Only this will eventually lead to herd immunity as a “by-product."
Closer home, Dr Jayaprakash Muylil, Dean of the Christian Medical College and Hospital, Vellore, is also unequivocal about the efficacy of lockdown. He says that we must build herd immunity while shielding the vulnerable. He also made clear that the flattening of the incidence curve would stop once the lockdown is lifted. The lockdown cannot be a permanent solution.
"The question of containing the virus is out. What is the next course? The next strategy is to say, ok, infections will continue and we need to take care of people who fall ill and require medical help”. 
He adds: “In 2009, there was an epidemic of H1N1 influenza. What happened to it? It came in and stayed for 2-3 months and spontaneously disappeared. Nothing that we did at the point of time was of help. It went away. Why? It is because of a certain level of herd immunity that was produced by the infection. So, our only hope is that, on its own, this virus is headed line in that way - in a particular way of herd immunity”.
Apart from the coronavirus pandemic, we seem to be also afflicted by a panic and hysteria pandemic. We have begun to fear the worst is at hand. Far from it. This is not bubonic plague or small pox. This is a more inspired version of the seasonal flu’s we have been accustomed to but with a slightly higher case fatality rate. We need to have the courage to take a rational look at known facts and act accordingly. We must lockout our fears and ease off the lockdown.
---
*Well-known policy expert. Source: Author’s Facebook timeline

Comments

TRENDING

India under Modi among top 10 autocratizing nations, on verge of 'losing' democracy status

By Rajiv Shah
A new report, prepared by a top Swedish institute studying liberal democracy, has observed that there has been a sharp “dive in press freedom along with increasing repression of civil society in India associated with the current Hindu-nationalist regime of Prime Minister Narendra Modi.” The report places India among the top 10 countries that “have autocratized the most”. Other countries that have been identified for rolling towards autocracy are -- Hungary, Turkey, Poland, Serbia, Brazil, Mali, Thailand, Nicaragua and Zambia.

Savarkar 'criminally betrayed' Netaji and his INA by siding with the British rulers

By Shamsul Islam*
RSS-BJP rulers of India have been trying to show off as great fans of Netaji. But Indians must know what role ideological parents of today's RSS/BJP played against Netaji and Indian National Army (INA). The Hindu Mahasabha and RSS which always had prominent lawyers on their rolls made no attempt to defend the INA accused at Red Fort trials.

Border conflict? RBI nod India's 'brotherly' help to China internationalise its currency

By Bhabani Shankar Nayak*
In the middle of a global pandemic, China started an unprovoked border conflict with India. It unraveled trust deficit and ties between the two neighbours. As thousands of Chinese troops tried occupying Indian territory, the Narendra Modi-led BJP government directs the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) to allow the Bank of China to start regular banking services in India. The Bank of China will now operate in India like any other commercial banks.

RSS supremo Deoras 'supported' Emergency, but Indira, Sanjay Gandhi 'didn't respond'

By Shamsul Islam*
National Emergency was imposed on the country by then Prime Minister Indira Gandhi on June 25-26, 1975, and it lasted for 19 months. This period is considered as ''dark times' for Indian democratic polity. Indira Gandhi claimed that due to Jaiprakash Narayan's call to the armed forces to disobey the 'illegal' orders of Congress rulers had created a situation of anarchy and there was danger to the existence of Indian Republic so there was no alternative but to impose Emergency under article 352 of the Constitution.

Clean chit to British rulers, Muslim League? Karnataka to have Veer Savarkar flyovers

By Shamsul Islam*
The BJP government of Karnataka led by BS Yediyurappa is going to honour Hindutva icon VD Savarkar by naming two of the newly built major flyovers in Bangalore and Mangalore after him. There was a huge uproar against this decision of the RSS-BJP government as many pro-Kannada organisations with opposition parties and liberal-secular organizations questioned the logic to ignore so many freedom fighters, social reformers and others from within the state.

Hurried nod to Western Ghat projects: 16 lakh Goans' water security 'jeopardised'

Counterview Desk
Taking strong exception to "virtual clearances" to eco-sensitive projects in the Western Ghats, the National Alliance of People’s Movements (NAPM) in a statement has said urged for a review of the four-lane highway, 400 KV transmission line and double tracking of the railway line through the Bhagwan Mahavir Wildlife Sanctuary and Mollem National Park in Goa.

Disturbing signal? Reliance 'shifting focus' away from Indian petrochemical sector

By NS Venkataraman*
Reliance Industries Ltd (RIL), a large Indian company, has expanded and grown in a spectacular manner during the last few decades, like of which no industrial group in India has performed before. RIL is now involved in multi various activities relating to petroleum refineries, petrochemicals, oil and gas exploration, coal bed methane, life sciences, retail business, communication network, (Jio platform) media/entertainment etc.

Letter to friends, mentors: Coming together of class, communal, corona viruses 'scary'

By Prof (Dr) Mansee Bal Bhargava*
COVID greetings from Ahmedabad to dear mentors and friends from around the world…
I hope you are keeping well and taking care of yourself besides caring for the people around you. I’m writing to learn how is the science and the society coping with the prevention and cure of the pandemic. I’m also writing to share the state of the corona virus that is further complicated with the long-standing class and communal viruses.

Case for nationalising India's healthcare system amidst 'strong' private control

Counterview Desk
A draft discussion note, prepared by Dr Maya Valecha, a Gujarat-based gynecologist and activist, sent to the People's Union for Civil Liberties (PUCL) as also a large number of activists, academics and professionals as an email alert, is all set to create a flutter among policy experts for its strong insistence on nationalizing India’s healthcare system.