Skip to main content

New India? A case for urgent transfer of public health from state to concurrent list

By Uday Shankar, Simi Mehta, Shubham Pandey*
The success of janata (public) curfew and the discipline demonstrated by the citizens of India during the nationwide lockdown has conveyed the message of citizen-government cooperation in the effort to contain the menace of coronavirus.
Maintaining social distancing and the need to stay at home during the prevailing health crisis is expected from the people to contain the spread of the virus. The state has rolled up its sleeves to provide rapid medical support with the support of all union and state departments.
At a time when the human civilization is confronted with the most severe challenge from a single strand virus, it becomes imperative to glance at the Constitution to understand the responsibility of the government to provide health care. The Constitution of India distributes the legislative powers between the centre and the states under the Seventh Schedule.
Services related to public health, sanitation, hospitals and dispensaries are categorised under Entry 6 of List II, and is the responsibility of the states. The rationale to entrust the responsibility of public health and sanitation to the states is because the health requirements vary from one state to another. Considering the specific health care issues, the state government devise their own plans to deliver these services to the people efficiently.
However, when it comes to pandemics like SARS, MERS, HINI (swine flu) and more recently the coronavirus disease (COVID-19), the same rationale does not hold the ground and poses an obstacle in formulating and efficient response to such diseases. A characteristic of these pandemics is that it is spread globally by affecting millions of people.
Any robust response in tackling pandemics like the COVID-19 requires synergy of government machinery, wherein the role of the Union government becomes extremely important.
The Constitutional design on public health identifies the responsibility amongst two layers of the government. For instance, there is a shared responsibility on the matters of adulteration of food stuffs and other goods (Entry 18 in List III), drugs (Entry 19 in List III), medical professions (Entry 26 in List III), contagious diseases (Entry 29 in List III).
Moreover, the allocation of public goods cannot be effectively decided by the central government. It would be imprudent and impractical to provide a single government to decide on the entitlement on the goods of citizens.
But when it comes to making effective response strategy for tackling pandemics that affect the health of the population around the country, it becomes imperative for the Union to spearhead the nationwide planning in consort with the state governments.
In fact, given their inherent challenges, it becomes implicit for the states to look up to the Union government for a direct intervention to mobilise their medical resources and devise efficient strategies for routing the resources where it is most needed.
The annual comprehensive state health index, or the 'Healthy States, Progressive India- Report on the Ranks of States and Union Territories', is spearheaded by the NITI Aayog. It is tool to measure and compare the overall performance and incremental performance across States and UTs over time.
The Health Index ranks them based on the scores obtained for 23 indicators grouped into the domains of health outcomes, governance and information, and key inputs/processes. Since 2017 when it was first released, it has become an important instrument in understanding the variations and complexity of the nation’s performance in health.

Constituent Assembly debate

The need for state-of-the-art health care facilities and the readiness of the states on their toes to respond to pandemics provides compelling reasons to revisit the farsightedness displayed by the founders of the Constitution during the Constituent Assembly debates.
For instance, HV Kamath stressed the need to ‘public health and sanitation; hospitals and sanitation in List III, because the prevailing standards of health of the nation was deplorable. Hence, according it a top priority would raise India its full stature.
Speaking with his prior experience of certain provinces, he mentioned that well-intentioned health schemes launched by provincial governments often fail because of the lack of direction and co-ordination from the Centre.
Providing a picture of the depleted, inefficient and inept public health situation, Brajeshwar Prasad in the Assembly strongly advocated for placing the subject exclusively in the domain of the central government, i.e., under List 1 or in the Union List. Only this would save the nation from the scourge of disease and epidemics.
Right to Health should be declared a fundamental right on the occasion of the 75th Independence Day in 2022
Unfortunately, such far-reaching insights were disapproved by the Assembly, which ultimately entrusted the responsibility upon the states to create the robust health infrastructure, so that the country will effectively deal with pandemic in future. Sadly, the current epidemic has exposed the reality of preparedness of many states.
The Health Index 2019 ranked Kerala first in terms of overall health care performance in the country. Not without reason, though it was among the worst hit states due to the coronavirus, it ably handled the situation. However, the number of infections and deaths is steadily rising in other states, and population is witnessing increasing panic and catastrophe.
This is being exacerbated by the poor health infrastructure and amenities around the country. Thus, these formidable challenges, arising out of the threat of the novel coronavirus, call for urgent need to revitalize health care. It reminds the obligations of the elected governments at the Union and State levels towards public health care systems.
In this situation, inclusion of public health and allied services, at par with medical education and family planning, as an Entry in List III for fighting with Pandemic diseases, and making it a concurrent responsibility of both Union and the states will help in building robust pandemic disease management infrastructure in India. It would help bring medical support from advanced nations and states to those states that lack in health care and support system.
In fact, the high-level group (HLG) formed for the health sector by the 15th Finance Commission recommended the transfer of ‘health’ from the State List to the Concurrent List and that ‘Right to Health’ should be declared a fundamental right on the occasion of the 75th Independence Day in 2022.
However, given the coronavirus crisis in the country, it is pertinent for the government to have an immediate Executive Order and later enact a legislation to bring the subject of ‘dealing with pandemics like COVID-19’ into List III (Concurrent List) of the Constitution.
As is being observed, the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare (MoHFW) would play a key role in guiding the comprehensive public health system of the country. In fact, the COVID-19 has brought to the fore importance of health care reforms, which has long been pending.
Perhaps the silver lining in the coronavirus crisis has brought attention to the long pending health care reforms. The working of the Union, state and local governments in tandem with all frontline workers, ASHA, ANMs and Anganwadi Workers is showing that the Health Management Information System (HMIS) is steadily becoming sturdy in providing real-time administrative data of physical and financial progress at this critical juncture. It is India would have solid health infrastructure and pandemic preparedness after emerging victorious from the COVID-19 battle.
The COVID-19 pandemic has been referred to as the greatest emergency since India’s independence. And as Constitutional provisions for emergency delineates the take-over of the state powers by the Union government, this health emergency requires more- the Union government must lead from the front, in close coordination, sharp strategy, synergy and informed policy choices with the state governments.
Also, the pandemic necessitated a federal structure, and thus, the Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s idea of cooperative federalism stands the real test of time. A successful manoeuvring through this unprecedented challenge by harnessing artificial intelligence, blockchain and information and communication technology will go a long way in the realignment of subjects like public health and hospitals, consolidate the states’ support and strengthen planning, resources allocation and implementation.
Such efforts would be a milestone in the public health agenda for India, which includes the epidemiological transition, demographical transition, environmental changes and social determinants of health. A close and harmonious relationship between the Union and the state governments with the support of the people demonstrated in this hour of crisis would eventually have an enormous role to play in building the ‘New India’.
---
*Respectively: Associate Professor at the Rajiv Gandhi School of Intellectual Property Law, Indian Institute of Technology (IIT) Kharagpur, and Senior Visiting Fellow at Impact and Policy Research Institute (IMPRI), New Delhi; CEO and Editorial Director of IMPRI; Research Scholar, the Rajiv Gandhi School of Intellectual Property Law, Indian Institute of Technology (IIT) Kharagpur

Comments

TRENDING

North Gujarat gram panchayat bars villagers from dealing with Muslim hawkers, traders

By Our Representative  A gram panchayat in North Gujarat has barred its residents not to buy anything from Muslim traders and hawkers. An order of the Waghasan group gram panchayat of Tharad taluka of Banaskantha district dated June 30 states that the decision has been taken in the wake of beheading of a Hindu tailor after he posted a derogatory writeup on Prophet Mohammad in Udaipur. The gram panchayat resolution says, anyone seen buying or selling any commodity from a Muslim hawker or trader would be fined Rs 5,100. Bringing this to light, Mujahid Nafees, convener, Minority Coordination Committee, in a letter to Gujarat chief minister Bhupendra Patel, says, the state government should take legal action against the panchayat chief who has signed the “unjust” order. The letter says, the act of the sarpanch and other signatories is a violation of rule of law of the state and threat to peace, pointing out, the move is in violation of Article 15 of the Constitution, which says that none

Unlike Soviet Union, Russia is no friend to India: Ukrainian scholar tells 'Indian friends'

Counterview Desk In an open letter to "dear Indian friends", Anastasia Piliavsky, born in Odessa, Ukraine, studied at Boston and Oxford Universities (on a Rhodes Scholarship), and now teaches at King’s College, London, has said that she faces "deep moral dilemma", personally and professionally, over the "astonishingly unified Indian response to the war in Ukraine." Based on her interaction with a "number of thoughtful and caring Indian friends", in this letter, she says, she is "reeling at the ubiquitous silence at, justifications of or outright support for Putin’s terror, which now prevails in India, at the ubiquitous #IStandWithPutin and #istandwithrussia hashtags." She insists, India must understand, "Unlike the Soviet Union, Russia is no friend to India. Soviet leaders, beginning with (the Ukrainian) Nikita Khrushchev – who declared hindi rusi bhai bhai – built up deep political and cultural exchange with India." Text : I

PLFS data: Is rising employment good news? Deeper analysis suggests contrary results

By Ishwar Chandra Awasthi, Puneet Kumar Shrivastav*  Results of the Periodic Labour Force Survey (PLFS), 2020-21 , released by the Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation, Government of India (GoI) on June 14, 2022, show improvement in work force participation rate (WPR) and labour force participation rate (LFPR) and declining unemployment rate. Four rounds of data have been released from 2017-18 to 2020-21 based on PLFS. The general trend in the last four rounds clearly shows consistent increase in WPR and LFPR and falling unemployment rates by usual status (PS+SS). Though increase in WPR and LFPR is reported highest in 2019-20 over 2018-19, yet rising trend in these two key indicators continues throughout, and similarly fall in unemployment is registered highest in 2019-20 over 2018-19. Clearly, the recent results give some solace and relief after unprecedented Covid-19 pandemic that has entailed enormous loss of human lives and livelihoods and crippled economic activit

Technocratic globalism, tyranny? Health Ministry warned: bill to 'enslave' Indians

Sandeep Pandey, Tushar Gandhi By Rosamma Thomas*  Union of Concerned Citizens, a group comprising Magsaysay Award winner Prof Sandeep Pandey, human rights activist Tushar Gandhi, former judge of the Bombay High Court BG Kolse Patil, pediatrician Dr Jacob Puliyel and several renowned Indian citizens have written to the Union Health Minister cautioning him against tabling the draft Public Health Bill in the Monsoon Session of Parliament. “The Public Health (Prevention, Control And Management Of Epidemics, Bio-Terrorism And Disasters) Bill, 2017 and a Prospective Bill of 2022 as discussed in news articles, is straightforwardly violative of Fundamental Rights of the citizens of India and therefore, Ultra Vires of the Indian Constitution. It contravenes several International Treaties and Conventions including the Nuremberg Treaty of 1947 which was enacted to ensure that no country would repeat such inhuman medical atrocities on fellow human beings”, the 12-page letter reads. “Strangely, t

'Drop all falsed charges': 150 citizens demand early release of AltNews co-founder

Counterview Desk  About 150 concerned citizens have demanded the release of Mohammed Zubair, co-founder of the fact-checkng newsportal AltNews, arrested over a 2018 tweet which allegedly hurt religious sentiments, even as booking for criminal conspiracy and having received foreign funds in violation of the Foreign Contribution Regulation Act (FCRA). Denied bail last weekend and sent to 14-day judicial custody, the concerned citizens, in a statement, regretted that while the Delhi High Court issued notice to the Delhi police on a petition filed on behalf of Zubair challenging the legality and propriety of his police remand and the seizure of his electronic devices, the “frivolous case” continues. Excerpts: The illegal arrest of Mr. Mohammed Zubair happened on June 27, 2022, by the Delhi Police for allegedly hurting religious sentiments and promoting enmity over a tweet from 2018. The IPC Sections included 153(a) (Promoting enmity between different groups on grounds of religion, race,

Chennai residents 'suffering': Faulty design, implementation of storm water project

By NS Venkataraman*  The Greater Chennai Corporation is now implementing storm water drainage project in 559 roads, covering a distance of 1033 kilometres, which cost around Rs 4,070 crore. For this massive project, which is targeted to be completed between April and September this year, huge loan has been availed from World Bank, Asian Development Bank and others. Several technocrats have pointed out that the project has been designed with outdated technology and quality of the implementation is so poor that the residents have been put to great hardships. As part of the project, digging of the road has been done to around 5 to 6 feet deep and width of around 4 to 5 feet. The drains are being constructed using steel reinforced cement concrete with two walls on either side with provisions for manhole, chute etc. This has been done in front of several houses leaving little space between the gate of the house and that of the drainage structure. As the work has been going on for mor

Prime Minister's 'affordable' housing policy fails to help Gujarat slum dwellers: Study

By Rajiv Shah  A new study on the implementation of one of the major policy initiatives for the urban poor by the Narendra Modi government after it came to power, Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana (PMAY), has said that in Gujarat, which happens to be the Prime Minister’s home state, has quoted state officials as “confirming” that no progress towards tenure regularization, a key requirement for providing housing to the state’s slum dwellers. Stating that this particularly true of smaller town, the study, carried out by the non-profit Homes in the City (HIC), which is based in Bhuj, district headquarter of Kutch that saw a devastating earthquake in 2001, says, the failure to provide affordable housing is there despite the fact that there has been “significant demand” in all the 83 out of 153 Gujarat municipalities studied by experts involved in the study. According to the study, out f a total of 1.41 lakh demands for housing under the Beneficiary Led Construction (BLC) category, 94,232 (66.7%)

Buddhist shrines were 'massively destroyed' by Brahmanical rulers: Historian DN Jha

Nalanda mahavihara By Our Representative Prominent historian DN Jha, an expert in India's ancient and medieval past, in his new book , "Against the Grain: Notes on Identity, Intolerance and History", in a sharp critique of "Hindutva ideologues", who look at the ancient period of Indian history as "a golden age marked by social harmony, devoid of any religious violence", has said, "Demolition and desecration of rival religious establishments, and the appropriation of their idols, was not uncommon in India before the advent of Islam".

'Contractor-official nexus led to RTI activist's murder': Fact-finding team seeks probe

Courtyard inside of PWD office where Ranjeet Soni was killed Counterview Desk  A fact-finding team* visited Vidisha, Madhya Pradesh (MP) on June 19, 2022 to meet with the family of Ranjeet Soni, who was shot dead on June 2, 2022 inside the premises of the PWD office in Vidisha. The objective was to gather information about the circumstances surrounding the death of Ranjeet Soni and his work on exposing corruption through the use of the Right to Information (RTI) Act. A report prepared by the team members says that Ranjeet had been extensively using the RTI Act to access information from the government, and upon receiving documents showing misuse of public funds or corruption, he was filing complaints to various authorities including the Lokyukta, Publi Works Department (PWD) and the Chief Minister’s Office. It notes, Ranjeet used to work as a contractor and often undertook government works in collaboration with other contractors, including those being investigated for his murder. A f

Electricity Bill: Centre's reform measures contain 'carrot and stick package' for states

Counterview Desk  The Peoples’ Commission on Public Sector and Public Services (PCPSPS), claiming to be a network of eminent academics, jurists, erstwhile administrators, trade unionists and social activists, seeking consultations with stakeholders with those who are against the government’s decision to monetise, disinvest and privatise public assets/enterprises, has said that the proposed Electricity (Amendment) Bill-2022 will have far-reaching impacts on the finances of states. Insisting that the proposed Bill would lead to “assault on India’s federal structure”, in a statement, it says, it would weaken the finances of states’ power distribution companies, have adverse impact on utility employees, cripple the states' finances, impose a heavy cost burden on the smaller subsidized consumers (especially farmers), and benefit only corporate business houses. “States cannot afford to ignore the far-reaching implications of the Bill on their economy, finances, agricultural and industria