In a resurvey, Navsarjan counters Gujarat govt study claim that untouchability in state is a matter of perception

In a scathing reply to the Gujarat government-sponsored study, “Impact of Caste Discrimination and Distinctions on Equal Opportunities: A Study of Gujarat”, carried out in five of Gujarat’s villages to “prove” that there is no wide-scale practice of untouchability in the state, a “resurvey” in the same five villages has found it prevails in all its manifestations. Carried out by Navsarjan Trust, a state human rights organization, the “resurvey” says that in every walk of life – whether it is temple entry, social or cultural festivals, or access to basic necessities – untouchability is widely prevalent, something the government-supported study has sought to "undermine".

The government study was prepared by the prestigious CEPT University, Ahmedabad, under a team headed by Prof R Parthasarathy, in response to Navsarjan’s “untouchability census” in about 1,600 villages across the state, whose results were put out in 2010 in a report titled “Understanding Untouchability”. Alarmed by conclusions in “Understanding Untouchability”, the Gujarat government decided to “counter” it first by sending government officials to take “affidavits” from Dalits in a few villages to “prove” that Navsarjan report findings were “baseless”, and then sponsored a study by the CEPT University to “review” the realities of untouchability.

Interestingly, CEPT scholars preferred not to touch any of the 1,600 villages which were surveyed by Navsarjan; instead, in consultation with government officials, they just chose five villages. These were Khavda village in Kutch district, Kherva village in Surendranagar district, Nana Nesda village in Banaskantha district, Trasad village in Ahmedabad district, and Menpura in Kheda district. The CEPT study sought to undermine untouchability, saying caste discrimination as they found it prevailing in these villages was more a “matter of perception”, and if Dalits do not mix up with members of other communities during social functions, it was more a matter of choice.

Finding the argument atrocious, Navsarjan decided to send its team to each of the five villages, whose results have now been compiled in a fresh report. The “resurvey” report shows that in each of these villages, while Rohits, a Dalit sub-caste, alone are made to lift and dispose of when a cow or a buffalo dies, another sub-caste, Valimikis, are made to “remove” rest of the dead animals, including dogs and cats. A village-wise resurvey reveals there were variations, but untouchability prevailed in one form or the other in each of them, and the CEPT conclusions were biased.

In Nava Nesda, the Dalits are asked to sit as a separate group in village panchayat meetings and are served tea in a separate cup; Dalits are not allowed to enter the biggest temple of the village, Dudheshwar Mahadev; untouchability is practiced in several of the village shops, where if a Dalit touches some goods by mistake, the “touched” item is “purified” by sprinkling water; hair cutting saloons and a beauty parlour do not provide any service to Dalits; the local dairy does not provide milk to the Dalits; and there is discrimination against Valmikis in providing water in the village panchayat.

In Khavda, during social functions, the Dalits are made to sit separately for meal; in the village’s Swaminarayan Nagar, Dalits are not offered house on rent; the Dalits here too are not allowed to enter into any of the temples; and during such festivals like Navratri, Dalit youth are not allowed to play Garba with non-Dalits; they can at best see Garba being played, sitting in a distance. In Menpura, which was declared by the Gujarat government as “Gokul gam” because of its excellent record in developmental activities, the Dalits are not allowed to fetch water from the common village well; they are not allowed to enter into the main Ramji temple; they must sit separately and see Garba during Navratri, but not participate; during marriages the Dalits are not allowed to take out the ceremonial procession through the village streets; and the Dalit children in the primary school are not allowed to sit in the front rows, nor are they allowed to take part in cultural festivals.

In Trasad, a village not very away from Ahmedabad, the Dalits told the Navsarjan team that they were not aware of any CEPT scholars having visited their village to carry out a survey. The Navsarjan team was told that in 2009, the Dalits lodged a police complaint under the atrocities Act against the upper castes, who discriminated against them in the sitting arrangement during the Yagna ceremony in the Shiv temple. Despite the complaint, even today, things have not changed. Other forms of discrimination include provision of a separate cremation for the Dalits and not allowing participation in Garba during Navratri. In the fifth village, Kherva, again, a similar type of discrimination was noticed.

Comments

Sattvik Food Festival: Shouldn't one question notion of purity, cultural exclusion in food choices?

Recently, I visited the Sattvik Food Festival, an annual event in Ahmedabad organized by Anil Gupta, professor emeritus at the Indian Institute of Management-Ahmedabad (IIM-A). I have known Prof. Gupta since 1993, when I sought an appointment to meet him a few months after joining The Times of India in Ahmedabad—one reason why I have always been interested in the activities he is involved in.

In lieu of tribute to Pritish Nandy, said to be instrumental in collapse of Reliance-controlled daily

It is widely reported that Pritish Nandy , journalist, author, animal activist, and politician, has passed away. While it is customary to pay tributes to a departing soul—and I, too, have joined those who have posted heartfelt condolences on social media—I cannot forget the way he treated me when he was editor of the Reliance-controlled Business and Political Observer (BPO), for which I had been working informally in Moscow.

Challenging patriarchy? Adopting maternal and marital surnames: Resistance continues

Anandiben Patel The other day, I was talking with a group of family friends. The discussion revolved around someone very close to me who had not changed her official name in documents, including her Aadhaar and passport, after her marriage. However, on social media and within her husband's family, she had adopted her husband's surname as a suffix to her own. I mentioned that there is a growing trend—though not yet widespread—where women prefer to retain their maiden names or add their maiden surnames alongside their husband's surname. Another emerging trend is where men choose to add their mother's name, or even their wife's name, to their own. This revelation surprised my family friends.

To be or not to be Sattvik: Different communities' differing notions of purity and fasting

This is a continuation of my last blog on Sattvik food. When talking about Sattvik, there is a tendency to overlook what it may mean to different sections of people around the world. First, let me redefine Sattvik: it means having a "serene, balanced, and harmonious mind or attitude." Derived from the Sanskrit word sattva, it variously means "pure, essence, nature, vital, energy, clean, conscious, strong, courage, true, honest, and wise." How do people achieve this so-called purity? Among Gujarati Hindus, especially those from the so-called upper castes who are vegetarians, one common way is fasting. On fasting days, such as agiyarash —the 11th day of the lunar cycle in the Vedic calendar—my close relatives fast but consume milk, fruit juices, mangoes, grapes, bananas, almonds, pistachios, and potato-based foods, including fried items. Another significant fasting period is adhik maas. During this time, many of my relatives "fast" by eating only a single me...

Shyam Benegal's Mathan a propaganda film that supported 'system'? No way

A few days ago, I watched Manthan, a Shyam Benegal movie released in 1976. If I remember correctly, the first time I saw this movie was with Safdar Hashmi, one of the rare young theater icons who was brutally murdered in January 1989. Back then, having completed an M.A. in English Literature from Delhi University in 1975, we would often move around together.

Barred premise allowed? 'Modi govt fails to seek release of fishermen languishing in Pak jails'

Are the Indian authorities or their Gujarat counterparts softening their stance toward NGOs that flag human rights concerns? I can't say for sure, as only recently the foreign funding license of one of the most prominent NGOs, Janvikas, headed by the well-known civil society leader Gagan Sethi, was canceled. This NGO has been working on livelihood issues for underprivileged sections of society for several decades.

Would Gujarat Governor, govt 'open up' their premises for NGOs? Activists apprehensive

Soon after I uploaded my blog about the Gujarat Governor possibly softening his stance on NGOs—evidenced by allowing a fisherfolk association to address the media at a venue controlled by the Raj Bhawan about India’s alleged failure to repatriate fishermen from Pakistani prisons—one of the media conference organizers called me. He expressed concern that my blog might harm their efforts to secure permission to hold meetings on state premises.

No to free thought? How Gujarat's private universities are cowing down their students

"Don't protest"—that's the message private universities across Gujarat seem to be conveying to their students. A senior professor told me that students at the university where he teaches are required to sign an undertaking promising not to engage in protests. "They simply sign the undertaking and hand it over to the university authorities," he said.

Beyond the Sattvik plate: Prof Anil Gupta's take on food, ethics, and sustainability

I was pleasantly surprised to receive a rather lengthy comment (I don't want to call it a rejoinder) on my blog post about the Sattvik Food Festival, held near the Sola Temple in Ahmedabad late last year. It came from no less a person than Anil Gupta, Professor Emeritus at the Indian Institute of Management-Ahmedabad (IIM-A), under whose guidance this annual event was held.

Search This Blog