Skip to main content

Covid vaccine coercion 'counter-productive', immunity from natural exposure lasts longer

By Bhaskaran Raman* 

Most parts of India have faced two significant waves of Covid-19. Some places, such as Mumbai have been praised for its management of hospital resources, and rightly so. The current focus is on Covid-19 vaccination. While data from different parts of the world shows that the vaccines reduce risk of disease severity, an unsavoury aspect of the vaccine administration policy concerns coercion of citizens for vaccination.
For instance, Mumbai local train, the “lifeline of Mumbai”, has been made conditional on vaccination, and so has entry to various places such as malls. Aurangabad has made fuel purchase conditional on vaccination. 
Various work places have also issued coercive notices. Such extreme coercion may “work” in the short term, but will erode public trust in the long run. We argue here that such coercion is not only wrong, but lacks any scientific basis.
The obvious question we can begin with is: if there is an effective vaccine for a deadly disease, then why coerce? After all, Covid-19 has been at the centre of people’s attention not only in India but around the world. And most people have been eagerly awaiting a vaccine.
The ostensible argument for vaccine coercion is: “no one is safe until everyone is safe”, and universal vaccination will “eradicate” the virus. But this stance is unscientific for three main reasons.
First, all the current Covid-19 vaccines are non-sterilizing. While there is individual benefit, especially among old and susceptible, in terms disease severity reduction, even those vaccinated can get infected and can transmit the virus.
Data from around the world shows this. For example, Singapore’s Covid surge started after about 75% of its population was fully vaccinated. As another stark example, Waterford city in Ireland had over 99.7% of its adults fully vaccinated as of the last week September 2021, yet had the highest incidence of Covid in Ireland by the second week of October.
The UK’s weekly reports show that vaccine efficacy against infection has been declining steadily; currently the rate of infection among fully vaccinated is much more than that among unvaccinated in all age groups above 30. The vaccine efficacy against infection touched as low as minus 109% for the 40-49 age group! Israel is currently facing its highest Covid peaks yet, despite approving as many as four jabs for each citizen!
If the vaccinated can also get infected and transmit the virus, then individual benefit of vaccination does not translate to societal benefit; so what is the rationale for coercion?
Second, the vast majority of people have already been exposed to the virus in India’s first two waves. Sero-surveys have shown that as high as 80% of Mumbai’s citizens, and over 90% of Delhi’s citizens have been naturally exposed.
Furthermore, pre-pandemic science as well as recent research show consistently that immunity from natural exposure is strong and long lasting. For instance, a large cohort study involving over 17,000 health-care workers in the UK showed not a single instance of symptomatic reinfection.
Even within Mumbai, it is well known that the 2nd wave was largely absent from the slums, which had widespread natural exposure in 2020. Therefore, those who have had natural exposure are extremely safe people to be around!
If the vast majority of people are already at much less chance to get infected or transmit compared to the vaccinated, then what the rationale for vaccine coercion?
Third, the goal of “zero-Covid” is a pipe-dream. Even if we can magically vaccinate every adult and child within a day, the virus will continue to thrive since the vaccines are non-sterilizing.
The SARS-Cov-2 virus also has other species as host, and thus eradicating the virus is a scientific impossibility. The disease will enter endemic phase and the virus will keep circulating, although with negligible severity compared to the pandemic phase.
If even universal vaccination cannot achieve zero-Covid, then what is the rationale for vaccine coercion?
Vaccination should focus on hitherto unexposed susceptible people; coercive methods should stop
To summarize, each of the assumptions behind vaccine coercion: (1) vaccines prevent or stop spread of Covid-19, (2) natural immunity is weak, and (3) zero-Covid is possible, are scientifically flawed.
The current Covid-19 vaccines have a positive role for old, susceptible, and hitherto unexposed individuals, to reduce disease severity. At the same time, while vaccine adverse effects may be rare, they are not nil.
The UK’s yellow card system has reported adverse events at the rate of about 1 in 106 doses for the AstraZeneca vaccine (Covishield). Changes to women’s menstrual cycle have been reported too. Blood clotting from the AstraZeneca (Covishield) vaccine is rare but can be devastating, causing even death in rare cases.
Therefore, there must be a risk-reward analysis: each individual must be free to decide his/her health risks and medical decisions, without any pressure or coercion.
Much trust has been lost due to lack of scientific rationale for vaccine coercion. Recently, in the Mumbai high court, the state of Maharashtra had to cut a sorry figure, forced to state that they do not even have the minutes of the meeting, where the vaccine requirement for travel by Mumbai local train was decided. Honest admissions are overdue to rebuild lost trust.
The assumptions of societal benefit behind vaccine coercion do not hold any water on close examination. Coercion erodes trust which will take years to rebuild. Discrimination based on vaccine status also divides society.
Do we really want a society where we view each other as unclean, especially when there is no scientific basis for this? Certain not. Therefore coercion and mandates must stop with immediate effect; they have no role in public health.
---
*Faculty in the Department of Computer Science and Engineering at IIT Bombay. Views expressed are personal

Comments

TRENDING

'Halt Covid-19 vaccination drive': Indian doctors join campaign across 36 nations

By Rosamma Thomas*  A group of Spanish doctors first got together to call for a halt to the Covid-19 vaccinations, and doctors from other countries too later joined them – there are now over 12,000 doctors from India, Portugal, Canada, Hungary, South Africa, Israel and a host of other nations who have issued a call to halt vaccinations. On September 10, a group of Indian doctors came together to address the press over a webinar to explain why they thought the vaccination drive should end forthwith. Dr Amitav Banerjee, who after a career as an epidemiologist in the Indian Army now teaches at a private medical college in Pune, said there was no longer a medical emergency. Children are at low risk of infection, and there is good reason to halt vaccination and conduct proper research, given the high number of adverse events. There is a sudden and poorly explained spike in the number of young and healthy people dying. While it may be impossible to attribute deaths entirely to the vaccinatio

Did Mother Teresa trivialise poverty? 'You are suffering, that means Jesus is kissing you'

By Harsh Thakor*  The world commemorated the 25th death anniversary of Mother Teresa on September 5. Whatever her flaws, she rendered service to humanity in regions almost untranscended, resembling the relentless spirit of the waves of an ocean. Irrespective of community or religion, she offered her service. Even those not drawn by sainthood revere the role of Mother Teresa. For 68 years, she had worked selflessly and tirelessly in India and elsewhere in the world, taught the destitute, healed the sick, fed and clothed the poor, cared for abandoned children, housed lepers and those afflicted with HIV/AIDS and offered dignity in death to desolate persons abandoned by family and society. Mother Teresa was born in Skopje in 1910 to an Albanian family as AnjezĂ« Gonxhe Bojaxhiu. She became wedded to religious vows at an early age and moved to India to join the missionary work of the Catholic Church. Heartshaken by the misery faced by the Indian masses, in 1950 she set up her own

Tracing roots of Hindutva Zionism: cannon fodder for 'warped' nationalist pretensions

By Shamsul Islam*  Those who believe in a world free of hegemonic ethno-nationalism, racism, religious bigotry and hatred have rightly taken note of Zionism and its ally Christian Zionism, major perpetrators of ethnic cleansing of ‘Others’. However, the civilized world with its core belief in multi-culturalism and peaceful co-existence is oblivious to a no less dangerous threat to the present human civilization: the Hindutva Zionism. As the term reads it is part of the Hindutva world-view which stands for an exclusive Hindu India minus Muslims and Christians. The other religions like Sikhism, Buddhism, and Jainism will have no independent status but treated as part of Hinduism. The Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS; National Volunteer Organization) is the most prominent flag-bearer of the Hindutva politics whose cadres presently rule India, the largest democracy in the world. RSS was founded by Keshav Baliram Hedgewar (1889-1940) in 1925 who was disillusioned with the Indian freedom st

Regional parties, anti-Congress progressives, civil society groups 'joining' Bharat Jodo

By Harshavardhan Purandare, Sandeep Pandey*  The Congress party declared Bharat Chhodo (Quit India) movement against the British regime in 1942. The Congress party has now launched a movement Bharat Jodo (Connecting and Uniting India) against the Modi regime in 2022. Indian people have had a journey of 80 years since Mahatma Gandhi gave that Quit India call to the British and we have to agree that we stand most divided in our modern history when Rahul Gandhi is giving this Bharat Jodo call to the nation. And back then, Congress was a thriving idealistic political movement against the British rulers and now it is an ever weakening political organization electorally defeated several times. However, it is India at stake, not just the Congress party. That is why so many regional political parties, civil society organizations, traditional anti-Congress progressive forces like socialists and communists, intellectuals and civil servants have declared their support and are proactively partici

Shocking? No Covid vaccine trials conducted on pregnant, lactating women: RTI reply

By Rosamma Thomas*  A Right to Information applicant who sought details of safety trials conducted in India on pregnant and lactating women for three Covid vaccines in use in India – Covishield, Covaxin and ZyCov-D -- was shocked to learn from the Central Drugs Standard Control Organization (CDSCO) that Serum Institute, manufacturer of Covishield, and Cadila Healthcare, manufacturer of the ZyCov-D vaccine, had not sought permission for such trials.  Bharat Biotech, manufacturer of Covaxin, had sought permission for trial on pregnant women and later withdrawn its application. This response , provided after the applicant was initially unsatisfied with the response and went in appeal, is from the joint drugs controller, CDSCO. It was dated September 13, 2022. One researcher closely following the vaccine rollout, however, is of the opinion that the lack of a trial on pregnant and lactating women is a blessing; potential trial participants and their unborn babies thus escaped harm. Aruna Ro

Grave error? Scholar blames ex-Gujarat babu for anti-Christian riots 'citing fake report'

By Rajiv Shah  A few days back, I received a message from one of the finest former Gujarat government bureaucrats, PG Ramrakhiani, a 1964 batch IAS official, who retired in November 2000. I would often interact with him in 1997-99, even later, after I was sent to Gandhinagar as a Times of India man to cover Sachivalaya. Those were turbulent times. Shankarsinh Vaghela was the Gujarat chief minister, under attack from two sides – from the BJP, which he had left to form a separate breakaway party, Rashtriya Janata Party (RJP), one one hand, and the Congress, which was supporting him from outside, on the other. Ramrakhiani, in his message, referred to the book authored by Ghanshyam Shah and Jan Breman, both top-notch scholars who have known Gujarat in and out. Called “Gujarat, Cradle and Harbinger of Identity Politics: India’s Injurious Frame of Communalism”, I reviewed the book in January 2022.  It claims that Muslims in Gujarat have been turned into “new untouchables”, thanks to the Hin

Excess to cheetah in Kuno to increase 'woes' of local people, 'disturb' wildlife balance

Bharat Dogra*  The release of eight cheetahs into the Kuno National Park ( Madhya Pradesh) by Prime Minister Narendra Modi on September 17, although accompanied by a media blitz, has raised several questions. The animals were flown from Namibia to Gwalior and from there they were taken to the release site in a helicopter. Official sources have stated that this is the first time a large carnivorous species has been moved across continents for establishing a new population. This first release will be followed by others under this project. However, precisely for this reason, it is important to be cautious because if such translocations have been generally avoided in the past, there may have been reasons for this and at the same time we do not have much learning experiences from the past. The Cheetah became extinct in India in 1952, although this very fast moving animal is still remembered in the folklore of many areas. Hence the first impulse is to say that trying to introduce and revive

Introducing non-native cheetahs is 'not equivalent' to restoring pride in the nation

By Bappaditya Mukhopadhyay*  The Cheetahs from the African continent has finally been introduced to India by the Indian Prime Minister on his 72nd birthday. The process had started with the previous Government in 2009. However, the Supreme Court clearance was pending owing to the objection by the National Tiger Conservation Authority (NTCA) plea to reintroduce cheetahs. Finally the clearance was obtained in January 2020 and thereafter Kuno National Park (KNP) was chosen for the reintroduction of first set of Southeast African Cheetahs. In the near future, depending upon the success story of the current reintroduction, more cheetahs from South Africa may also be introduced. This exercise has generated a lot of interest among various stakeholders with opinions on both sides galore. It is important to pose some questions that surround the whole exercise. Let us evaluate some of these arguments. The first set of arguments are quite detached from the issues of conservation as they most

'Military diplomacy': US praises Bangladesh Army for leadership role in UN operations

By Kamal Uddin Mazumder* As the Indo-Pacific region represents the world’s economic and strategic center of gravity, the Indian Ocean today is becoming the centerpiece of all geo-strategic play. Cooperation in the region is crucial to implementing the international community’s global agenda, including achieving the UN’s Sustainable Development Goals. Major powers like the US have enhanced and deepened their strategic engagement and leadership roles with countries in the region. The Indo-Pacific Army Management Seminar, or IPAMS, is a U.S. Army Pacific (USARPAC) initiated conference that is aimed at facilitating and enhancing interactions among the armies of the Indo-Pacific region. This year's 46th Indo-Pacific Armies Management Seminar (IPAMS)-2022, co-hosted by the Bangladesh Army and US Army Pacific (USARPAC), concluded in Dhaka. The objective of IPAMS is to promote peace and stability in the region through mutual understanding, dialogue, and friendship. It is the largest confer

Buddhist shrines were 'massively destroyed' by Brahmanical rulers: Historian DN Jha

Nalanda mahavihara By Our Representative Prominent historian DN Jha, an expert in India's ancient and medieval past, in his new book , "Against the Grain: Notes on Identity, Intolerance and History", in a sharp critique of "Hindutva ideologues", who look at the ancient period of Indian history as "a golden age marked by social harmony, devoid of any religious violence", has said, "Demolition and desecration of rival religious establishments, and the appropriation of their idols, was not uncommon in India before the advent of Islam".