Skip to main content

Why similar development projects take off in Kerala, but are 'failure' in Tamil Nadu

By NS Venkataraman*

Prime Minister Narendra Modi would inaugurate the much-discussed natural gas pipeline between Kerala and Karnataka on January 5,2021. The story of this gas pipeline is a case study that can enable one to learn and unlearn about the government machinery deals with cause and effect of environmental activism.
The Kochi gas terminal in Kerala was set up with a capacity of five million tonne per annum and was inaugurated a few years back, for importing liquefied natural gas and distributing it across Kerala , Tamil Nadu and Karnataka.
The potential benefits of this gas pipeline can be immense by way of promoting rapid industrialization by using the imported natural gas as feedstock for fertilizer, petrochemical industries and as eco friendly fuel for power projects, as domestic fuel and as fuel for transportation etc.
The potential investment, financial and environmental benefits that could happen due to the use of imported natural gas could be well over Rs 20,000 crore in value in terms in the states of Tamil Nadu, Karnataka and Kerala.
The Government of India-owned Gas Authority of India (GAIL) was entrusted with the responsibility of implementing the gas pipeline project in the above three states. However, the fate of this gas pipeline project is different in Tamil Nadu from that of Kerala and Karnataka.
When GAIL started implementing the pipeline project from Kochi terminal to Tamil Nadu with the pipeline length of around 330 kilometres, there were resistance from farmers in Coimbatore and surrounding region in Tamil Nadu, claiming that the laying of the pipeline would affect the interest of the farmers, as the pipeline would pass through the agricultural field.
GAIL explained to the farmers that the pipeline would be laid around more than five feet under the soil and after laying of the pipeline, farming operations can continue and only the deep rooted plants can not be planted. Further, GAIL said that compensation would be paid to the farmers and the matter can be discussed and finalised.
However, the farmers refused to accept this explanation and said that the pipeline can be set up on the National Highways, without disturbing agricultural operations. Anyone with knowledge of gas pipeline laying technology and engineering practices would readily know that laying a gas pipeline on highways would be impossible, given the width of the highways and safety issues involved due to the vibration caused by the heavy traffic on the highways.
When this issue was raised in Tamil Nadu, almost all political parties and sections of activists supported the stand of the farmers and agitations were launched and hate campaign against GAIL was carried out vehemently.
In the process, proper cost benefit analysis was not carried out and the overall economic and industrial progress that can happen in Tamil Nadu were not given weightage by the farmers and the politicians and activists supporting them.
It appears that the Tamil Nadu government did not play a proactive role to the extent needed to resolve the issue. Apparently, without examining the issue in proper perspective and ignoring the fact that not implementing the project would result in loss of large investment opportunities in the state and loss of job potentials, it banned the implementation of the gas pipeline project. Thus , Tamil Nadu became the loser.

Kerala-Karnataka gas pipeline project

The Kochi-Mangalore pipeline project with a distance of 444 kilometre at the cost of Rs 2,915 crore was initiated in 2009 with the aim of completing it in 2014. There was some objection to the pipeline project in Kerala by the environmentalists.
However, the project has now been completed at the cost of Rs 5,750 crore, that would provide enormous benefits to Kerala and Karnataka, by way of industry promotion, job prospects and consequent economic growth. 
The Kerala government deserves to be complimented for enhancing the debate relating to land acquisition for national projects and in dealing with the environmental issues
What the Tamil Nadu government could not achieve was achieved by the Kerala government. The Kerala government played a proactive role by encouraging the protestors in Kerala to discuss with GAIL authorities and the government itself took an active role in facilitating the discussions and arriving at an amicable solution.
The Kerala government deserves to be complimented for enhancing the debate relating to land acquisition for national projects and in dealing with the environmental issues in a lofty and responsible manner. The Kerala government has shown that the environmental and land acquisition issues relating to projects can be sorted out by scientifically and honestly carrying out cost benefit analysis and satisfying the needs of every stake holder in the project scheme.

Environmental activism in Tamil Nadu

In the last several years, Tamil Nadu has lost several valuable project opportunities that would have done enormous good to the economic and industrial progress of the state. Titanium dioxide project of Tata group in Tuticorin had to be abandoned due to protest by activists and some political parties.
The Koodankulam nuclear power project was delayed by several years due to protests by activists. But the project is now successfully operating, proving that all the accusations against the project were baseless and now have been proved to be wrong.
The Nutrino project in the Theni region in Tamil Nadu now remains stranded due to protests by the activists. Enormous significance of the project from the point of view of science and technology development was repeatedly pointed out by no less a person than the former President Dr Abdul Kalam, who was also an eminent scientist. But activists would not permit the project.
The Sterlite Copper project in Tuticorin was forced to close down by the Tamil Nadu government following protests despite the Green Tribunal and Supreme court ruled in favour of the project.
Gas exploration project in Neduvasal has also been stopped, due to protest by the activists and section of politicians, though the several knowledgeable arguments were advanced in favour of the project by experienced technologists and professionals.
These examples suggest failure of the Tamil Nadu government to enter into reasonable dialogue with environmental activists. Indeed, environmental activism is a necessary in a progressive society, where any harm to the environment due to any activity should be pointed out.
However, those in power need to develop trust in environmental activists, who may not in possession of adequate technological knowledge or overall perspective with regard to the cost benefit scenario and long term national interest.
Surely, environmental activism should not be downgraded from its respectable status. In Tamil Nadu things could have been resolved by creating the necessary climate based on understanding of the country’s needs and technology developments, for with the government machinery should do be working.
---
*Chemical engineer; director, Nandini Consultancy Centre, Chennai

Comments

TRENDING

RSS wanted Constitution 'replaced' by Manusmriti which abused Dalits, women

By Shamsul Islam* The Constituent Assembly of India finalized the Constitution of India on November 26, 1949 which is celebrated as the Constitution Day This Constitution promised new born Indian Republic a polity based on democracy, justice, egalitarianism and rule of law. However, RSS was greatly annoyed. Four days after the historic event of approval of it, the RSS English “Organiser” in an editorial on November 30, 1949, complained:

Pending GoI wage payments to rural labour reach Rs 5,100 crore: NREGA Morcha

By Our Representative  MGNREGA (Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act), which is said to have provided a cushion to millions of rural households amidst great economic distress during the Covid-19 pandemic, continues to be bogged with poor implementation, NREGA Sangharsh Morcha has alleged.

Once centres of civilisation, Indian cities turning into 'major cause of concern'

By Soumyadip Chattopadhyay*  Each year, October 31 is celebrated as the World Cities Day. The theme this year was Adapting Cities for Climate Resilience. The Center for Habitat, Urban and Regional Studies, Impact and Policy Research Institute (IMPRI), New Delhi, organized a special lecture on city as environment as part of the discussion under the #WebPolicyTalk series on the State of Cities -- #CityConversations.

Nuclear energy 'can't solve' global warming, will 'strain' financial, natural resource

Counterview Desk  Taking strong exception to Rafael Mariano Grossi, Director General, International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), who has favoured nuclear energy as a solution to global warning, well-known power and policy analyst Shankar Sharma has said that the IAEA chief's “unsubstantiated advocacy” of nuclear power is associated with “diversion of considerable amounts of scarce resources, both financial as well as natural, of many developing countries, such as India.”

Forget 'bheek', by this logic, Gujarat was free of British rule in 1995, 19 yrs before India

The real freedom fighting brigade By Rajiv Shah  Bollywood actor Kangana Ranaut may have her own reasons to say that India acquired real freedom in May 2014, when Narendra Modi came to occupy India’s seat of power.  There was little to be amused by what she said, for, as many commentators have variously pointed out, her viewpoint was surely based on her little or no knowledge of the history of the Indian freedom movement.

Swami Vivekananda's views on caste and sexuality were 'painfully' regressive

By Bhaskar Sur* Swami Vivekananda now belongs more to the modern Hindu mythology than reality. It makes a daunting job to discover the real human being who knew unemployment, humiliation of losing a teaching job for 'incompetence', longed in vain for the bliss of a happy conjugal life only to suffer the consequent frustration.

Learning to bridge 'huge chasm' between highly educated, illiterate, badly literate

By Shrey Ostwal, Sandeep Pandey*  The pivotal point of Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi’s journey to become Mahatma Gandhi began when his “political guru” – Gopal Krishna Gokhale – advised young Mohandas to travel around India. This rigorous journey was essential for Mohandas to understand his country and countrypersons better if he were to fight the inhumane and unempathetic British regime which had been looting India of its glory for about two centuries then.

Buddhist shrines were 'massively destroyed' by Brahmanical rulers: Historian DN Jha

Nalanda mahavihara By Our Representative Prominent historian DN Jha, an expert in India's ancient and medieval past, in his new book , "Against the Grain: Notes on Identity, Intolerance and History", in a sharp critique of "Hindutva ideologues", who look at the ancient period of Indian history as "a golden age marked by social harmony, devoid of any religious violence", has said, "Demolition and desecration of rival religious establishments, and the appropriation of their idols, was not uncommon in India before the advent of Islam".

Farm laws: Modi has been taking decisions without consulting experts, stakeholders

By Ajit Singh* In a surprise move, the Prime Minister of India in a video message that went live on the occasion of Guru Nanak Jayanti announced to scrap three contentious farm laws in the upcoming winter session of Parliament. These laws were notified in September last year but put on hold due to widespread opposition, especially by farmers from Uttar Pradesh, Punjab and Haryana.

Modi withdrew farm laws, but has no word on 'pro-corporate, oppressive' policies

Farmers celebrate withdrawal of three laws By Harsh Thakor  Punjab farmers have no doubt won a historic battle in overpowering the farm laws with the support of the working class, students, youth and intellectuals. Noticeably, the non-sectarian approach of the participating organisations, which confronted Hindutva neo-fascism, Sikh separatist politics and Indian and foreign corporate monopoly, helped in enhancing their striking capacity.