Skip to main content

Statistical fraud: Sample size 5 households, Gujarat OBC Muslims’ poverty rate 1.9%!

 
By Rajiv Shah 
Is the National Sample Survey (NSS) Organization, the statistical arm of the Government of India, seeking to play a “statistical fraud” by saying that overall Muslim poverty levels in rural Gujarat have gone down from 31 per cent in 2004-05 to 7.7 per cent in 2011-12? It would seem so if one looks at the NSS’ 2011-12 extremely small sample size for Gujarat’s OBC Muslims – just five households! Based on this sample size, the NSS’ unreleased report on monthly per capita expenditure (MPCE) for socio-religious groups suggests that the OBC Muslims’ poverty rate went down from 40.5 to 1.9 per cent during the seven years.
In the second week of March 2014, a few newspapers carried a report that Gujarat had emerged as one of the top states in India where poverty among Muslims in both rural and urban areas has declined drastically in the last seven years. This was reportedly brought to light by a high-level committee formed under the Jawaharlal Nehru University professor, Amitabh Kundu. The committee was appointed by the Government of India in August 2013 to evaluate the socio-economic condition of the Muslim community during the period following the implementation of the Sachar Committee report on the condition of minorities in India, released in 2006.
Basing its findings on an unreleased National Sample Survey (NSS) Organization report on monthly per capita expenditure of socio-religious groups in 2011-12, the media reports said, the committee has highlighted that that, in rural Gujarat, the number of Muslims below poverty line (BPL) fell from 31 per cent in 2004-05 to a “measly” 7.7 per cent in 2011-12. Comparison of the same period reveals that those in the BPL population in urban areas also declined, from 42 per cent to 14.6 per cent. This happened at a time when the maximum MPCE (an indicator of economic well-being) of Muslims in rural Gujarat went up from Rs 209 to Rs 291. In urban areas, it shot up from Rs 259 to Rs 328 in the last seven years.
“I am neither a BJP supporter nor a Narendra Modi fan, but as far as the welfare of the Muslim community is concerned, the facts say that Gujarat did much better in the past seven years compared to other states,” Prof Kundu was quoted as saying. A right-wing website went gaga over the findings, and it reported how National Sample Survey (NSS) statistics have now confirmed that poverty level among Muslims in Gujarat has declined significantly in comparison to other states, “presently ruled by the parties which fight polls with agenda to lift the condition of people of the community.” The website also highlighted that in rural Gujarat, Muslim poverty has come down to 7.7 per cent – less the number of poor Muslims in rural Kerala, eight per cent!
There was nothing new in what the reports were been saying. A working paper by well-known Columbia University professor Arvind Panagariya and Vishal More, “Poverty by Social, Religious & Economic Groups in India and Its Largest States: 1993-94 to 2011-12” (October 2013), referring the unreleased MPCE data (quoted by the committee headed by Prof Kundu), had said, “In as many as seven out of the sixteen states for which we can credibly estimate poverty rates for both communities, the poverty rates for the Muslims have dropped below those for the Hindus. The seven states are: Andhra Pradesh, Gujarat, Jammu and Kashmir, Kerala, Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan, and Tamil Nadu.”
Muslims’ poverty levels (%) calculated by Kundu committee
The working paper adds, “In four of these seven states, Andhra Pradesh, Jammu and Kashmir, Kerala and Tamil Nadu, the poverty ratio for the Muslims is below ten per cent. In the fifth, Gujarat, at 11.4 percent, it is only marginally above the ten percent mark.” The paper doesn’t stop here. It says, the “perhaps the single most striking feature” found, on the basis of the 2011-12 NSS data, is, “In the rural areas, Gujarat leads with the lowest poverty ratio of 7.7 per cent for the Muslims. Other states with lower poverty ratio for the Muslims than Hindus are Andhra Pradesh, Bihar, Jammu and Kashmir, Kerala, Madhya Pradesh and Rajasthan.”
Well-known economic commentator Swaminathan S. Anklesaria Aiyar, while analyzing the Pahagariya-More paper, was the first to see that there was something wrong with the NSS data, based on which the Kundu committee appeared to have reached its conclusions about a steep decline in the poverty levels in Gujarat. Writing in his blog swaminomics.org, he agrees that there may be good news for Muslims, as their poverty ratio declined in this seven-year period by 18.2 per cent, faster than the 15.6 per cent for Hindus, even though “the absolute level of Muslim poverty remains higher than of Hindus”.
Now coming to the “whopping surprise” of Panagariya and More – that “in as many as seven states, Muslims are less poor than Hindus” – Aiyar says, “Astonishingly, the rural Muslim poverty ratio is lowest of all in Gujarat, at 7.7 per cent. This is much lower than the urban ratio, and so raises the question whether it is a statistical quirk.” He adds, “Muslims in Gujarat were victims of terrible violence in 2002, and many still feel unsafe.” He sounds a note of caution with the data used by Panagariya-More to reach their conclusions: “The year-wise variations in some states look very steep, and seem to need a pinch of salt”. In Aiyar’s view, Panagariya and More conclusions were guided by the “rapid GDP growth in the seven years between 2004-05 and 2011-12”.
A deeper look into the data, which are part of the still unreleased Kundu committee report, suggests a much deeper malaise than what Aiyar has noted — “a statistical quirk”, which “need a pinch of salt.” A breakup of the Muslim poverty ratio suggests that in rural Gujarat (where the poverty ratios in are down to 7.7 per cent), other backward classes (OBC) Muslims’ poverty levels were 40.5 per cent in 2004-05. And these went to just 1.9 per cent in 2011-12! As against to this, the Other Muslims’ poverty levels in rural Gujarat have gone down at a much lower pace – during the same period, these have gone down from 23.2 per cent in 2004-05 to 18.7 per cent in 2011-12.
These data form part of an unpublished paper, prepared by Prof Kundu, who has clarified, through an e-mail, that there is no “typographical error” here, but are a result of “standard error”. To quote him: “The standard error in the estimates for different socio-economic groups in rural and urban areas would be high due to small sample size in the NSS.” He has said, “I looked at the disaggregated data for different socio-religious categories at the state level. The sample size for OBC Muslims in Gujarat, for example, is very small, even smaller than the size in 2004-05. I would therefore not be very confident in drawing conclusion for these sub-categories at the state level.”
And what is the sample size of OBC Muslims in Gujarat, based on which their poverty has allegedly gone down from 40.5 per cent to 1.9 per cent in the seven years in question? Prof Kundu says, “The sample size for OBC Muslims is five in 2011-12 and 25 in 2004-5. For total Muslims also the size is much below the acceptable level and with high standard error.” Hence, he points out, “The committee did not want to comment on the state-level estimates for socio-religious groups.” He adds, “Also, the growth rate in consumption expenditure and poverty reduction figures can be misleading due to their problem of uneven base.”
Prof Kundu further says, this is not just true of Gujarat but several states. To quote him, “The data for estimation of Muslim OBC poverty is below ten for a few states.” Overall, too, the Muslim sample size of OBC Muslims and Other Muslims taken together for several states is extremely small, hence it is impossible to reach a conclusion. This is one reason, he explains, that the committee under him has “not used the state-level NSS data for drawing inferences regarding the conditions of the Muslims.” Muslims’ small sample size is very small many states – it is “less than 100.” He underlines, “It is important that people discussing the results know about this.” Gujarat-based activists, working among poor Muslims, who suffered during the 2002 riots, believe, the data suggest nothing but a “statistical fraud.”

Comments

TRENDING

A comrade in culture and controversy: Yao Wenyuan’s revolutionary legacy

By Harsh Thakor*  This year marks two important anniversaries in Chinese revolutionary history—the 20th death anniversary of Yao Wenyuan, and the 50th anniversary of his seminal essay "On the Social Basis of the Lin Biao Anti-Party Clique". These milestones invite reflection on the man whose pen ignited the first sparks of the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution and whose sharp ideological interventions left an indelible imprint on the political and cultural landscape of socialist China.

N-power plant at Mithi Virdi: CRZ nod is arbitrary, without jurisdiction

By Krishnakant* A case-appeal has been filed against the order of the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEF&CC) and others granting CRZ clearance for establishment of intake and outfall facility for proposed 6000 MWe Nuclear Power Plant at Mithi Virdi, District Bhavnagar, Gujarat by Nuclear Power Corporation of India Limited (NPCIL) vide order in F 11-23 /2014-IA- III dated March 3, 2015. The case-appeal in the National Green Tribunal at Western Bench at Pune is filed by Shaktisinh Gohil, Sarpanch of Jasapara; Hajabhai Dihora of Mithi Virdi; Jagrutiben Gohil of Jasapara; Krishnakant and Rohit Prajapati activist of the Paryavaran Suraksha Samiti. The National Green Tribunal (NGT) has issued a notice to the MoEF&CC, Gujarat Pollution Control Board, Gujarat Coastal Zone Management Authority, Atomic Energy Regulatory Board and Nuclear Power Corporation of India Limited (NPCIL) and case is kept for hearing on August 20, 2015. Appeal No. 23 of 2015 (WZ) is filed, a...

1857 War of Independence... when Hindu-Muslim separatism, hatred wasn't an issue

"The Sepoy Revolt at Meerut", Illustrated London News, 1857  By Shamsul Islam* Large sections of Hindus, Muslims and Sikhs unitedly challenged the greatest imperialist power, Britain, during India’s First War of Independence which began on May 10, 1857; the day being Sunday. This extraordinary unity, naturally, unnerved the firangees and made them realize that if their rule was to continue in India, it could happen only when Hindus and Muslims, the largest two religious communities were divided on communal lines.

Spirit of leadership vs bondage: Of empowered chairman of 100-acre social forestry coop

By Gagan Sethi*  This is about Khoda Sava, a young Dalit belonging to the Vankar sub-caste, who worked as a bonded labourer in a village near Vadgam in Banskantha district of North Gujarat. The year was 1982. Khoda had taken a loan of Rs 7,000 from the village sarpanch, a powerful landlord doing money-lending as his side business. Khoda, who had taken the loan for marriage, was landless. Normally, villagers would mortgage their land if they took loan from the sarpanch. But Khoda had no land. He had no option but to enter into a bondage agreement with the sarpanch in order to repay the loan. Working in bondage on the sarpanch’s field meant that he would be paid Rs 1,200 per annum, from which his loan amount with interest would be deducted. He was also obliged not to leave the sarpanch’s field and work as daily wager somewhere else. At the same time, Khoda was offered meal once a day, and his wife job as agricultural worker on a “priority basis”. That year, I was working as secretary...

Epic war against caste system is constitutional responsibility of elected government

Edited by well-known Gujarat Dalit rights leader Martin Macwan, the book, “Bhed-Bharat: An Account of Injustice and Atrocities on Dalits and Adivasis (2014-18)” (available in English and Gujarati*) is a selection of news articles on Dalits and Adivasis (2014-2018) published by Dalit Shakti Prakashan, Ahmedabad. Preface to the book, in which Macwan seeks to answer key questions on why the book is needed today: *** The thought of compiling a book on atrocities on Dalits and thus present an overall Indian picture had occurred to me a long time ago. Absence of such a comprehensive picture is a major reason for a weak social and political consciousness among Dalits as well as non-Dalits. But gradually the idea took a different form. I found that lay readers don’t understand numbers and don’t like to read well-researched articles. The best way to reach out to them was storytelling. As I started writing in Gujarati and sharing the idea of the book with my friends, it occurred to me that while...

Two more "aadhaar-linked" Jharkhand deaths: 17 die of starvation since Sept 2017

Kaleshwar's sons Santosh and Mantosh Counterview Desk A fact-finding team of the Right to Feed Campaign, pointing towards the death of two more persons due to starvation in Jharkhand, has said that this has happened because of the absence of aadhaar, leading to “persistent lack of food at home and unavailability of any means of earning.” It has disputed the state government claims that these deaths are due to reasons other than starvation, adding, the authorities have “done nothing” to reduce the alarming state of food insecurity in the state.

Fate of Yamuna floodplain still hangs in "balance" despite National Green Tribunal rap on Sri Sri event

By Ashok Shrimali* While the National Green Tribunal (NGT) on Thursday reportedly pulled up the Delhi Development Authority (DDA) for granting permission to hold spiritual guru Sri Sri Ravi Shankar's World Culture Festival on the banks of Yamuna, the chief petitioners against the high-profile event Yamuna Jiye Abhiyan has declared, the “fate of the floodplain still hangs in balance.”

From triple centurion to master coach: Bob Simpson’s enduring legacy

By Harsh Thakor*  Former Australia cricket captain and coach Bob Simpson has died in Sydney aged 89. He leaves behind an indelible legacy, having shaped Australian cricket for more than four decades as a player, captain and coach. Beyond the field, he also served the game as a law-maker, referee and commentator, carving a permanent niche among the all-time greats of Australian cricket.

Proposed Modi yatra from Jharkhand an 'insult' of Adivasi hero Birsa Munda: JMM

Counterview Desk  The civil rights network, Jharkhand Janadhikar Mahasabha (JMM), which claims to have 30 grassroots groups under its wings, has decided to launch Save Democracy campaign to oppose Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Vikasit Bharat Sankalp Yatra to be launched on November 15 from the village of legendary 19th century tribal independence leader Birsa Munda from Ulihatu (Khunti district).