Skip to main content

Remember, Ambedkar consigned Manusmriti to flames: PUCL reminds CJI, Gujarat HC CJ

Counterview Desk 

Commenting on “uncalled for” remarks by Gujarat High Court judge Justice Sameer Dave on pregnancy and child birth even as approvingly referring to Manusmriti in this context, the People’s Union for Civil Liberties (PUCL), Gujarat, has stated that such practice of citing scriptures and religious texts “could negate the very basis of our constitutional jurisprudence.”
In an open letter addressed to the Chief Justice of India (CJI) and the Gujarat High Court Chief Justice, Adv Govind Parmar, president, and Pankti Jog, general secretary, PUCL, say, Manusmriti has “several objectionable texts that violates the dignity of women” which seek to “exercise control over her body and freedom, thus perpetuating patriarchy explicitly.”
“Let us also remember that Dr BR Ambedkar organized a mass event where the Manusmriti was consigned to flames on December 25, 1927, and the day is celebrated as both, Manusmriti Dahan Din and Stree Mukti Din”, they add.

Text:

PUCL Gujarat notes with great distress and concern, the practice of constitutional courts making references to scriptures and religious texts, a practice that could negate the very basis of our constitutional jurisprudence.
As per certain media reports there have been almost 38 such references to Manusmriti between 1950 and 2019 by the High Courts and the Supreme Court, with 26 (almost 70%) of them being made during the period 2009-19. There have been also references to other religious texts like the Koran and the Bible too in the course of hearings by constitutional courts.
The most recent reference to Manusmriti was reportedly made on the 8th of June, 2023, by a bench of the Gujarat High Court during the hearing of a plea for termination of pregnancy of a minor rape survivor. The said hearing in the Gujarat HC was in the context of the case of rape and subsequent pregnancy of a minor girl (R/Special Criminal Application No. 6643 of 2023).
While the order passed by the judge for a panel of doctors to ascertain the medical and psychological condition of the child and the foetus is beyond reproach, the manner in which certain observations were made do not appear to be consistent with our constitutional jurisprudence.
The judge reportedly made the following remarks orally: 
“Because we are living in the 21st century, ask your mother or great-grandmother, 14-15 was the maximum age (for getting married). The child used to take birth before the age of 17. Girls get matured before boys. 4-5 months here and there doesn’t make a difference. You will not read it, but do read Manusmruti once for this.”
These reported remarks are uncalled for, and can convey a very wrong message, especially when the law on Medical Termination of Pregnancy (MTP) and several judgments of the SC are among the best in the world, which respects the autonomy of the woman in deciding on abortion; on what is best for her.
Justice Samir Dave 
The lawyer representing the father of the rape survivor was also heard responding to the judge’s remark that under Islamic law, too, the marriageable age is 13. These unwarranted remarks undermine the belief in the commitment of the constitutional court to uphold constitutional jurisprudence and morality; it trivializes and normalizes the pregnancy of a minor and seemingly do not see anything traumatic with underage marriage or pregnancy.
The effort of the judge seems to ‘legitimize’ those unwarranted remarks by making the abovementioned reference to the Manusmriti in this context. This appears to negate the progressive reforms that we have made as a nation thanks to the women’s movement in India. Will the court therefore agree that old, anti-woman practices like Sati, denying education to women, prohibition of widow remarriage etc. should be revived?
It should be noted that Manusmriti and many other religious scriptures have several objectionable texts that violates the dignity of women and seeks to exercise control over her body and freedom, thus perpetuating patriarchy explicitly.
Let us also remember that Dr BR Ambedkar organized a mass event where the Manusmriti was consigned to flames on December 25, 1927, and the day is celebrated as both, Manusmriti Dahan Din and Stree Mukti Din.
In India, a secular democratic country with a diverse population, the legal system is based on a combination of common law principles and statutory laws. The primary sources of law in India are the Constitution of India, enacted by the Constituent Assembly in 1950, and various statutes passed by the Parliament and state legislatures. The Indian judiciary follows a system of precedent, where judgments of higher courts are binding on lower courts.
The judges in the court of justice take oaths to abide by the constitution of India. Normalizing the use of religious text and scriptures like Manusmriti in the court by judges clearly points to the larger majoritarian agenda in the country today. This also negates the struggle of the women’s movement that has been pushing to uphold the constitutional rights of women.
This also clearly indicates a disturbing trend in the judiciary where in the judges seem to feel comfortable passing value judgements on women and their choices. To refer to the Manusmriti as a source of rights of women is an insult to the Constitution.
We, as PUCL Gujarat, urge your excellency to take cognizance of this trend and take corrective action to strengthen the commitment of our constitutional courts to the Constitution of India and constitutional values and morality.

Comments

TRENDING

'Flawed' argument: Gandhi had minimal role, naval mutinies alone led to Independence

Counterview Desk Reacting to a Counterview  story , "Rewiring history? Bose, not Gandhi, was real Father of Nation: British PM Attlee 'cited'" (January 26, 2016), an avid reader has forwarded  reaction  in the form of a  link , which carries the article "Did Atlee say Gandhi had minimal role in Independence? #FactCheck", published in the site satyagrahis.in. The satyagraha.in article seeks to debunk the view, reported in the Counterview story, taken by retired army officer GD Bakshi in his book, “Bose: An Indian Samurai”, which claims that Gandhiji had a minimal role to play in India's freedom struggle, and that it was Netaji who played the crucial role. We reproduce the satyagraha.in article here. Text: Nowadays it is said by many MK Gandhi critics that Clement Atlee made a statement in which he said Gandhi has ‘minimal’ role in India's independence and gave credit to naval mutinies and with this statement, they concluded the whole freedom struggle.

A Hindu alternative to Valentine's Day? 'Shiv-Parvati was first love marriage in Universe'

By Rajiv Shah*   The other day, I was searching on Google a quote on Maha Shivratri which I wanted to send to someone, a confirmed Shiv Bhakt, quite close to me -- with an underlying message to act positively instead of being negative. On top of the search, I chanced upon an article in, imagine!, a Nashik Corporation site which offered me something very unusual. 

Don't agree on domestic subsidies, ensure food security at WTO meet: Farmer leaders

Counterview Desk  The Indian Coordination Committee of Farmers Movements (ICCFM), a top network of farmers’ organizations in India, in a letter to Piyush Goyal, Minister of Commerce and Industry, has asked him to “safeguard food security and sovereignty, even as ensuring peasants' rights" at the 13th Ministerial Conference of the World Trade Organization (WTO MC 13), to take place from 26 to 29 February 2024 in Abu Dhabi.

Sharp 61-85% fall in Tech startup funding in India's top 'business-friendly' States

By Rajiv Shah Funding in Tech startups in top business-friendly Indian states has witnessed a major fall, a data intelligence platform for private market research has said in a series of reports it has released this month. Analysing Tech startup data of Telangana, Maharashtra, Delhi NCR, Gujarat, Tamil Nadu, Karnataka and Kerala, Tracxn Technologies Ltd , the Bengaluru-based research firm, finds that except for Kerala, funding witnessed a fall of anywhere between 61% and 85%.

Students, lawyers, professors detained in Delhi for demonstrating in support of farmers

By Our Representative  About 25 protestors, belonging to the civil rights network, Campaign Against State Repression (CASR), a coalition of over 40 organisations, were detained at Jantar Mantar for holding a demonstration in support of the farmers' stir on Friday. Those detained included students, lawyers and professors, including Prof Nandita Narain and Prof N Sachin. 

Maize, bajra, jute, banana cultivation banned off West Bengal border: Plea to NHRC

Counterview Desk  West Bengal-based human rights defender Kirity Roy, who is secretary, Banglar Manabadhikar Suraksha Manch, and is national convenor of the Programme Against Custodial Torture & Impunity, in a representation to the chairman, National Human Rights Commission, second within few days, has bought to light one more case of trespassing and destruction of a fertile banana plantation by BSF personnel along the Indo-Bangladesh border, stating, despite a written complaint to the police has taken "no initiative".

Solar energy funding dips 9% in 2023; 2024 'kicks off' with US$1 billion investment

By Lakshmitha Raj*  Solar energy tech companies have already secured slightly over US$1 billion in funding in 2024 (till Feb 7, 2024) after total funding into Solar Energy companies in India fell 9% to US$1.55B in 2023 from US$1.7B in 2022. A total of 39 $100M+ rounds have been closed till date, with Delhi leading the city-wise funding, followed by Gurugram and Mumbai.

India second best place to invest, next to UAE, yet there is 'lacks support' for IT services

By Sreevas Sahasranamam, Aileen Ionescu-Somers*  The United Arab Emirates (UAE) is the best place in the world to start a new business, according to the latest annual Global Entrepreneurship Monitor (GEM) survey. The Arab nation is number one for the third year in a row thanks to a big push by the government into cutting-edge technology in its efforts to diversify away from oil.

Buddhist shrines were 'massively destroyed' by Brahmanical rulers: Historian DN Jha

Nalanda mahavihara By Our Representative Prominent historian DN Jha, an expert in India's ancient and medieval past, in his new book , "Against the Grain: Notes on Identity, Intolerance and History", in a sharp critique of "Hindutva ideologues", who look at the ancient period of Indian history as "a golden age marked by social harmony, devoid of any religious violence", has said, "Demolition and desecration of rival religious establishments, and the appropriation of their idols, was not uncommon in India before the advent of Islam".

Mahanadi delta: Aggressive construction in flood plains, reduced fish stock, pollution

By Sudhansu R Das  Frequent natural calamities, unemployment, low farmers’ income, increase in crime rate and lack of quality human resources to strike a balance between growth and environment etc. continue to haunt the state. The state should delve into the root causes of poverty, unemployment and natural calamities.