Skip to main content

Modi's ‘mother of democracy’ talk develops clay feet: RTI plea on PM Cares funds

By Rosamma Thomas* 

Prime Minister Modi often refers to India as the “mother of democracy”, arguing that the democratic spirit is ingrained in the very DNA of the nation. For democracy to thrive, though, citizens should be aware of the ways in which government funds are utilized, and the procedures through which decisions are arrived at by the government. 
There is a reluctance to share such information on the part of the Modi government, even though Section 4 of the Right to Information Act, 2005, provides for proactive disclosure of information.
The last available audited statement of accounts for the PM CARES (Prime Minister’s Citizen Assistance and Relief in Emergency Situations) Fund, available on its website, shows receipts and payments for the year ended March 2022 – of the Rs 10,990 crore received, only a third, or Rs 3,976 crore was spent; over Rs 7,000 crore remained as unspent balance. 
Ideally, under provisions of proactive disclosure of information under the Right to Information, citizens of India ought to be kept informed about the whereabouts of this sum of money, since PM Cares Fund was set up in March 2020 to raise funds to meet demands made by the pandemic. 
The government, however, has insisted that since the fund is financed by donations from individuals and organizations – domestic and foreign – and not funded by the government, and is run by private individuals operating as trustees, it is not a “public authority” and does not fall under the purview of the Right to Information Act, 2005.
Now that the pandemic is past, it is unclear what will be done with the unspent funds. PM Cares is not audited by the Comptroller and Accountant General of India, but by a firm of chartered accountants, M/S SARC Associates. The audit is supposed to be conducted at the end of the financial year, but the audited statement for 2022-23 has not yet been uploaded on the website of the trust.
Commodore Lokesh Batra, who has been pursuing transparency in this fund, pointed out that the fund has a website allotted to it on the server of the Government of India; officials from the Prime Minister’s Office man the activities of the trust; the trustees are the prime minister, the Union ministers of home and finance and a few others. When the prime minister, Union home and finance ministers serve as trustees, how can the fund be private, and beyond scrutiny by citizens of India?
Commodore Lokesh Batra filed Right to Information requests with the Commissioner of Income Tax to ascertain whether the fund has exemptions from Income Tax. He was denied access to information on the ground that what he sought was exempted from disclosure under Section 8 of the Right to Information Act. 
In his appeal before the Central Information Commission, Commodore Batra explained that Section 8 pertains only to personal information, and does not cover a public charitable trust, as the PM Cares Fund was described, under its purview.
Commodore Batra
Since the administration of the trust is carried out by government officials and since the trustees are also mainly Union ministers with key portfolios, there is great public interest in the functioning of the trust; activities of the trust occur with expenses drawn from tax revenues, so it is only right that citizens be informed.
In 2019, Commodore Batra filed an application seeking to examine files of the Department of Personnel and Training of the Government of India, pertaining to the appointment of information commissioners in the Central Information Commission. He found that the documents were not being released fully under the RTI Act, and several pages of the communication that he sought were being withheld, with no proper reason assigned for the redaction.
The Central Information Commission, on hearing his appeal for complete information, noted: “The conduct of the then link CPIO amounts to a gross violation of the RTI Act and is a clear case of sheer non-application of mind.”
“Non-application of mind” was evident also in Prime Minister Modi’s recent trip to the United States, where video footage showed him reading a prepared speech to US President Biden, using notes from a diary in his lap. President Biden patiently served as PM Modi’s one-man audience. 
Given that PM Modi never interacts with the press in India, it was perhaps only to be expected that he would gulp water and beat about the bush when asked pointed questions about the rights of minority communities and freedom of speech. It is rather late in the day already, but even now, the Prime Minister can decide to end his monthly Man Ki Baat series and meet the press in India at least once in a fortnight. 
If nothing else, those interactions will help make claims of India being the “mother of democracy” sound less hollow.
---
*Freelance journalist 

Comments

TRENDING

Vaccine nationalism? Covaxin isn't safe either, perhaps it's worse: Experts

By Rajiv Shah  I was a little awestruck: The news had already spread that Astrazeneca – whose Indian variant Covishield was delivered to nearly 80% of Indian vaccine recipients during the Covid-19 era – has been withdrawn by the manufacturers following the admission by its UK pharma giant that its Covid-19 vector-based vaccine in “rare” instances cause TTS, or “thrombocytopenia thrombosis syndrome”, which lead to the blood to clump and form clots. The vaccine reportedly led to at least 81 deaths in the UK.

'Scientifically flawed': 22 examples of the failure of vaccine passports

By Vratesh Srivastava*   Vaccine passports were introduced in late 2021 in a number of places across the world, with the primary objective of curtailing community spread and inducing "vaccine hesitant" people to get vaccinated, ostensibly to ensure herd immunity. The case for vaccine passports was scientifically flawed and ethically questionable.

'Misleading' ads: Are our celebrities and public figures acting responsibly?

By Deepika* It is imperative for celebrities and public figures to act responsibly while endorsing a consumer product, the Supreme Court said as it recently clamped down on misleading advertisements.

A Hindu alternative to Valentine's Day? 'Shiv-Parvati was first love marriage in Universe'

By Rajiv Shah*   The other day, I was searching on Google a quote on Maha Shivratri which I wanted to send to someone, a confirmed Shiv Bhakt, quite close to me -- with an underlying message to act positively instead of being negative. On top of the search, I chanced upon an article in, imagine!, a Nashik Corporation site which offered me something very unusual. 

Magnetic, stunning, Protima Bedi 'exposed' malice of sexual repression in society

By Harsh Thakor*  Protima Bedi was born to a baniya businessman and a Bengali mother as Protima Gupta in Delhi in 1949. Her father was a small-time trader, who was thrown out of his family for marrying a dark Bengali women. The theme of her early life was to rebel against traditional bondage. It was extraordinary how Protima underwent a metamorphosis from a conventional convent-educated girl into a freak. On October 12th was her 75th birthday; earlier this year, on August 18th it was her 25th death anniversary.

Palm oil industry deceptively using geenwashing to market products

By Athena*  Corporate hypocrisy is a masterclass in manipulation that mostly remains undetected by consumers and citizens. Companies often boast about their environmental and social responsibilities. Yet their actions betray these promises, creating a chasm between their public image and the grim on-the-ground reality. This duplicity and severely erodes public trust and undermines the strong foundations of our society.

'Fake encounter': 12 Adivasis killed being dubbed Maoists, says FACAM

Counterview Desk   The civil rights network* Forum Against Corporatization and Militarization (FACAM), even as condemn what it has called "fake encounter" of 12 Adivasi villagers in Gangaloor, has taken strong exception to they being presented by the authorities as Maoists.

No compensation to family, reluctance to file FIR: Manual scavengers' death

By Arun Khote, Sanjeev Kumar*  Recently, there have been four instances of horrifying deaths of sewer/septic tank workers in Uttar Pradesh. On 2 May, 2024, Shobran Yadav, 56, and his son Sushil Yadav, 28, died from suffocation while cleaning a sewer line in Lucknow’s Wazirganj area. In another incident on 3 May 2024, two workers Nooni Mandal, 36 and Kokan Mandal aka Tapan Mandal, 40 were killed while cleaning the septic tank in a house in Noida, Sector 26. The two workers were residents of Malda district of West Bengal and lived in the slum area of Noida Sector 9. 

India 'not keen' on legally binding global treaty to reduce plastic production

By Rajiv Shah  Even as offering lip-service to the United Nations Environment Agency (UNEA) for the need to curb plastic production, the Government of India appears reluctant in reducing the production of plastic. A senior participant at the UNEP’s fourth session of the Intergovernmental Negotiating Committee (INC-4), which took place in Ottawa in April last week, told a plastics pollution seminar that India, along with China and Russia, did not want any legally binding agreement for curbing plastic pollution.

Mired in controversy, India's polio jab programme 'led to suffering, misery'

By Vratesh Srivastava*  Following the 1988 World Health Assembly declaration to eradicate polio by the year 2000, to which India was a signatory, India ran intensive pulse polio immunization campaigns since 1995. After 19 years, in 2014, polio was declared officially eradicated in India. India was formally acknowledged by WHO as being free of polio.