Skip to main content

Aadhaar sold as panacea for all ills – black money, terrorism, leakage etc. like herbal medicine: Advocate Datar

By A Representative
Senior advocate Arvind Datar, in his strong rebuttal to the plan to link aadhaar with Permanent Account Number (PAN) by the Government of India, has argued in the Supreme Court that the earlier orders of the apex court that aadhaar cannot be made mandatory “continue to hold weight.”
“The Union and all states were before the court when these orders were passed. The Attorney General (AG) had even given an undertaking to the Court stating that aadhaar would be voluntary”, Datar said.
Datar appeared before the court to represent CPI leader Binoy Viswam.
When Justice AK Sikri said that the Aadhaar Act would shave to be tested for its basis, Datar said, he “agreed” that this was a new kind of case, placed before the court for the first time.
And when Justice Ashok Bhushan said that the “scheme has now become an Act", Datar explained that when the Supreme Court had given its orders, Parliament could only overrule judicial orders in a manner known to law – that is, by taking away their basis.
A Supreme Court directive or judgment is sacrosanct, unless set aside by a process known to law, Datar said, adding, there was a clear collision between the Aadhaar Act and the Income Tax Act, and "if both Acts are allowed to stand the results would be absurd."
Datar added, the government had failed to show how the stated objective of curtailing black money is possible by linking aadhaar and PAN.
On the AG’s argument that aadhaar was needed to fight black money and terrorism, Datar said, "Anybody with any common sense would ask, how will aadhaar check black money? Aadhaar was sold as a panacea for all ills – black money, terrorism, leakage etc. like herbal medicine", but, he noted, "Aadhaar is like having built a bridge and looking for a river. It is hunting for problems to make itself relevant."
On the AG’s argument on Foreign Account Tax Compliant Act (FATCA), Datar said that nothing in FATCA created a requirement for aadhaar.
When interrupted by government counsel Arghya Sengupta, who said "the problem is that if we give the US duplicate PANs, it becomes an embarrassment", Datar responded, this had nothing to do with the stated objective of 139AA.
The Finance Bill’s Section 139AA says, “Every person who is eligible to obtain aadhaar number shall, on or after the 1st day of July 2017, quote aadhaar number in the application form for allotment of permanent account number” and in “in the return of income”.
Datar said, only 0.04% of PAN cards were duplicates. He asked whether the government had done any study before introducing 139AA. He said "for 0.4% duplicates, 99.6% must seed their Aadhaar with PAN. Is that reasonable restriction under Article 19(6)?"
He argued, without a PAN card, people's economic lives would come to a standstill, and that interests (the ability to do business versus duplicate PAN cards) had to be balanced.
Datar said, the government was slowly attempting to make aadhaar mandatory, though it claimed it was voluntary. This was a case of extreme and far-reaching consequences. He added, "The AG says, 99% have got it. What's your problem? That argument is the death knell of individual rights and democracy."
Supported by Salman Khurshid, Datar submitted that the Court must strike down 139AA or read it down and in case the court decides to refer the case it should stay 139AA. The judgment has been reserved and no date has been given yet for the orders of the court.

Comments

TRENDING

Wave of disappearances sparks human rights fears for activists in Delhi

By Harsh Thakor*  A philosophy student from Zakir Hussain College, Delhi University, and an activist associated with Nazariya magazine, Rudra, has been reported missing since the morning of July 19, 2025. This disappearance adds to a growing concern among human rights advocates regarding the escalating number of detentions and disappearances of activists in Delhi.

How community leaders overcome obstacles to protect forests and pastures in remote villages

By Bharat Dogra  Dheera Ram Kapaya grew up in such poverty that, unable to attend school himself, he would carry another boy’s heavy school bag for five kilometers just to get a scoop of daliya (porridge). When he was finally able to attend school, he had to leave after class five to join other adolescent workers. However, as soon as opportunities arose, he involved himself in community efforts—promoting forest protection, adult literacy, and other constructive initiatives. His hidden talent for writing emerged during this time, and he became known for the songs and street play scripts he created to promote forest conservation, discourage child marriages, and support other social reforms.

‘Act of war on agriculture’: Aruna Rodrigues slams GM crop expansion and regulatory apathy

By Rosamma Thomas*  Expressing appreciation to the Union Agriculture Minister for inviting suggestions from farmers and concerned citizens on the sharp decline in cotton crop productivity, Aruna Rodrigues—lead petitioner in the Supreme Court case ongoing since 2005 that seeks a moratorium on genetically modified (GM) crops—wrote to Union Minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan on July 14, 2025, stating that conflicts of interest have infiltrated India’s regulatory system like a spreading cancer, including within the Indian Council for Agricultural Research (ICAR).

The GMO illusion: Three decades of hype, harm, and false hope

By Sridhar Radhakrishnan  Three decades of hype, billions of dollars spent, and still no miracle crop. It's time to abandon the GMO biotech fairy tale and return to the soil, the seed, and the farmer. “Trust us,” they said. “GMOs will feed the world.” Picture a world where there is plenty of food, no hunger, fields grow without chemical pesticides, children are saved from malnutrition, and people live healthily.

Sandra Gonzalez Sanabria: An inspiring life from Colombia’s Amazonian valley

By Vidya Bhushan Rawat*  In the village of Héctor Ramírez, known as Agua Bonita, in La Montañita, Caquetá, Colombia, a vision of peace and renewal is unfolding. In the pre-2016 period, this would have been nearly impossible for outsiders to visit, as it was the epicenter of violent resistance against state oppression. However, after the Peace Accord was signed between the Colombian government and former revolutionaries—marking the end of a 70-year insurgency that claimed over 400,000 lives until 2025, including civilians, rebel fighters, and security personnel—things began to change. Visiting Agua Bonita during the Global Land Forum in Bogotá revealed a village of hope and resilience. Former FARC revolutionaries have settled here and transformed the village into a center of peace and aspiration.

Overriding India's constitutional sovereignty? Citizens urge PM to reject WHO IHR amendments

By A Representative   A group of concerned Indian citizens, including medical professionals and activists, has sent an urgent appeal to Prime Minister Narendra Modi, urging him to reject proposed amendments to the International Health Regulations (IHR) before the ratification deadline of July 19, 2025. 

Indigenous Karen activist calls for global solidarity amid continued struggles in Burma

By A Representative   At the International Festival for People’s Rights and Struggles (IFPRS), Naw Paw Pree, an Indigenous Karen activist from the Karen Human Rights Group (KHRG), shared her experiences of oppression, resilience, and hope. Organized with the support of the International Indigenous Peoples Movement for Self-Determination and Liberation (IPMSDL), the event brought together Indigenous and marginalized communities from across the globe, offering a rare safe space for shared learning, solidarity, and expression.

Activists allege abduction and torture by Delhi Police Special Cell in missing person probe

By A Representative   A press statement released today by the Campaign Against State Repression (CASR) alleges that several student and social activists have been abducted, illegally detained, and subjected to torture by the Delhi Police Special Cell. The CASR claims these actions are linked to an investigation into the disappearance of Vallika Varshri, an editorial team member of 'Nazariya' magazine.

India’s zero-emission, eco-friendly energy strategies have a long way to go, despite impressive progress

By N.S. Venkataraman*   The recent report released by OPEC’s World Oil Outlook 2025 has predicted that by the year 2050, crude oil would replace coal as India’s key energy source. Clearly, OPEC expects that India’s dependence on fossil fuels for energy will continue to remain high in one form or another.