Skip to main content

Aadhaar sold as panacea for all ills – black money, terrorism, leakage etc. like herbal medicine: Advocate Datar

By Our Representative
Senior advocate Arvind Datar, in his strong rebuttal to the plan to link aadhaar with Permanent Account Number (PAN) by the Government of India, has argued in the Supreme Court that the earlier orders of the apex court that aadhaar cannot be made mandatory “continue to hold weight.”
“The Union and all states were before the court when these orders were passed. The Attorney General (AG) had even given an undertaking to the Court stating that aadhaar would be voluntary”, Datar said.
Datar appeared before the court to represent CPI leader Binoy Viswam.
When Justice AK Sikri said that the Aadhaar Act would shave to be tested for its basis, Datar said, he “agreed” that this was a new kind of case, placed before the court for the first time.
And when Justice Ashok Bhushan said that the “scheme has now become an Act", Datar explained that when the Supreme Court had given its orders, Parliament could only overrule judicial orders in a manner known to law – that is, by taking away their basis.
A Supreme Court directive or judgment is sacrosanct, unless set aside by a process known to law, Datar said, adding, there was a clear collision between the Aadhaar Act and the Income Tax Act, and "if both Acts are allowed to stand the results would be absurd."
Datar added, the government had failed to show how the stated objective of curtailing black money is possible by linking aadhaar and PAN.
On the AG’s argument that aadhaar was needed to fight black money and terrorism, Datar said, "Anybody with any common sense would ask, how will aadhaar check black money? Aadhaar was sold as a panacea for all ills – black money, terrorism, leakage etc. like herbal medicine", but, he noted, "Aadhaar is like having built a bridge and looking for a river. It is hunting for problems to make itself relevant."
On the AG’s argument on Foreign Account Tax Compliant Act (FATCA), Datar said that nothing in FATCA created a requirement for aadhaar.
When interrupted by government counsel Arghya Sengupta, who said "the problem is that if we give the US duplicate PANs, it becomes an embarrassment", Datar responded, this had nothing to do with the stated objective of 139AA.
The Finance Bill’s Section 139AA says, “Every person who is eligible to obtain aadhaar number shall, on or after the 1st day of July 2017, quote aadhaar number in the application form for allotment of permanent account number” and in “in the return of income”.
Datar said, only 0.04% of PAN cards were duplicates. He asked whether the government had done any study before introducing 139AA. He said "for 0.4% duplicates, 99.6% must seed their Aadhaar with PAN. Is that reasonable restriction under Article 19(6)?"
He argued, without a PAN card, people's economic lives would come to a standstill, and that interests (the ability to do business versus duplicate PAN cards) had to be balanced.
Datar said, the government was slowly attempting to make aadhaar mandatory, though it claimed it was voluntary. This was a case of extreme and far-reaching consequences. He added, "The AG says, 99% have got it. What's your problem? That argument is the death knell of individual rights and democracy."
Supported by Salman Khurshid, Datar submitted that the Court must strike down 139AA or read it down and in case the court decides to refer the case it should stay 139AA. The judgment has been reserved and no date has been given yet for the orders of the court.

Comments

TRENDING

IMA vs Ramdev: Why what's good or bad for goose should be good or bad for gander

By Dr Amitav Banerjee, MD* Baba Ramdev and his associate Balkrishna faced the wrath of the Supreme Court for their propaganda about their Ayurvedic products and belittling mainstream medicine. Baba Ramdev had to apologize in court. His apology was not accepted and he may face the contempt of court with harsher punishment. The Supreme Court acted on a public interest litigation (PIL) moved by the Indian Medical Association (IMA).

Women innovators on simple, revolutionary alternate solutions for water problems

By Proshakha Maitra, Mansee Bal Bhargava* The detrimental effects of uncontrolled population rise and accelerated change in the global climate have posed tremendous pressure on the water and sanitation. This calls all stakeholders, from both developed and developing nations, to improve their resilience and to instigate sustainability. It is more crucial than ever to optimise the use of the resources we have on hand since the world population is projected to reach 9.7 billion by 2050.

Magnetic, stunning, Protima Bedi 'exposed' malice of sexual repression in society

By Harsh Thakor*  Protima Bedi was born to a baniya businessman and a Bengali mother as Protima Gupta in Delhi in 1949. Her father was a small-time trader, who was thrown out of his family for marrying a dark Bengali women. The theme of her early life was to rebel against traditional bondage. It was extraordinary how Protima underwent a metamorphosis from a conventional convent-educated girl into a freak. On October 12th was her 75th birthday; earlier this year, on August 18th it was her 25th death anniversary.

Alleged killing of another Bangladesh youth inside Indian territory: NHRC inquiry sought

By Kirity Roy* There was yet another incident of the killing of a Bangladeshi youth by the Border Security Force personnel attached with ‘Barthar’ BOP of ‘G’ Company of 75 BSF Battalion. In last five years several incidents of killings happened under this police station’s jurisdiction and the cases will get the award as “Not Guilty” as usual.

Modi model, Hindutva icon 'justified' alliance with Muslim League before Independence

By Shamsul Islam*  Our PM describes himself as ‘Hindu’ nationalist and member of RSS. He proudly shares the fact that he was groomed to be a political leader by one of the two fathers of the Hindutva politics, MS Golwalkar (the other being VD Savarkar) and given the task of establishing Hindutva polity in India after eradicating secularism.

A Hindu alternative to Valentine's Day? 'Shiv-Parvati was first love marriage in Universe'

By Rajiv Shah*   The other day, I was searching on Google a quote on Maha Shivratri which I wanted to send to someone, a confirmed Shiv Bhakt, quite close to me -- with an underlying message to act positively instead of being negative. On top of the search, I chanced upon an article in, imagine!, a Nashik Corporation site which offered me something very unusual. 

Crusader for people’s causes, this Hollywood actor entered 'unexplored zones' in US

By Harsh Thakor*  Marlon Brando on April 3rd completes his birth centenary. He perished in 2004, on July 1, aged 80 years. Arguably in Hollywood Brando penetrated sensitivity and versatility at an unparalleled scale and discovered new horizons or explored path breaking zones in acting.

Nuclear power expansion: Is AEC's new, 'unrealistic' target fully backed by PMO?

By Shankar Sharma*  Another unrealistic and tall claim by Atomic Energy Commission (AEC) has been announced: India is eyeing 100 GW nuclear power by 2047, the AEC chairman  AK Mohanty   has said. A few years ago, the dream target for the Indian nuclear establishment was 275,000 MWe of nuclear power by 2050 (as per DAE document of 2008 "A Strategy for the Growth of Electricity in India”). Now this target of 100 GW nuclear power by 2047. And as at the end of February 2024, the actual nuclear power capacity was only 7,480 MWe, which formed only 1.7% of the total power capacity in the country. 

'Flawed' argument: Gandhi had minimal role, naval mutinies alone led to Independence

Counterview Desk Reacting to a Counterview  story , "Rewiring history? Bose, not Gandhi, was real Father of Nation: British PM Attlee 'cited'" (January 26, 2016), an avid reader has forwarded  reaction  in the form of a  link , which carries the article "Did Atlee say Gandhi had minimal role in Independence? #FactCheck", published in the site satyagrahis.in. The satyagraha.in article seeks to debunk the view, reported in the Counterview story, taken by retired army officer GD Bakshi in his book, “Bose: An Indian Samurai”, which claims that Gandhiji had a minimal role to play in India's freedom struggle, and that it was Netaji who played the crucial role. We reproduce the satyagraha.in article here. Text: Nowadays it is said by many MK Gandhi critics that Clement Atlee made a statement in which he said Gandhi has ‘minimal’ role in India's independence and gave credit to naval mutinies and with this statement, they concluded the whole freedom struggle.

How huge crowd at Mukhtar Ansari funeral is comparable to BJP's 'people's court' talk

By Vidya Bhushan Rawat*  The massive crowd at the funeral of Mukhtar Ansari in Mohammadabad reflects the power and influence that his family wields in the area. One can't deny that he had enormous power in Ghazipur and Mau districts. But the crowd that came and chanted slogans in his favour does not exonerate him of his conviction by the court.  It is important that we understand this.