Skip to main content

J&K ‘extra-judicial’ killings: Will army disclose court martial records?

By Venkatesh Nayak*
Readers will remember the incident of extra-judicial killing of 3 persons in Machil in the State of Jammu and Kashmir on 30 April, 2010 by army personnel. The Indian Army instituted a court of inquiry in June 2010. Based on the findings of this process, the Indian Army constituted a General Court Martial in 2013 to try the accused. Later, the Court Martial handed life imprisonment to the six accused one of whom was of Colonel rank. The Central Information Commission (CIC) has directed that all records relating to these proceedings be disclosed.
In another alleged incident of extra-judicial killing that occurred in 2000 five persons are reported to have been killed in Pathribal, also in Jammu and Kashmir. Media reports indicated that the Court of Inquiry instituted by the Army did not find any evidence against its personnel to proceed further. The Indian Army argued before the CIC that a Court of Inquiry was never held regarding this incident.
In January 2015, I filed a request for information under The Right to Information Act, 2005 (RTI Act) with the Indian Army seeking the following information:
“1) A clear photocopy of the entire text of the findings of the Court Martial in relation to the conviction of five Army Personnel for the killings committed at Macchil, Jammu and Kashmir in the year 2010 as reported in the attached news clipping;
2) A clear photocopy of the chargesheet filed before the said Court Martial in relation to the case mentioned above at para #1 along with Annexures, if any;
3) A clear photocopy of the sentence awarded to the convicted Army Personnel by the said Court Martial;
4) A clear photocopy of the communication along with Annexures, if any, sent to the concerned confirming officer/confirming authority in relation to the said case as per the relevant Rules under the Indian Army Rules, 1954;
5) A clear photocopy of all proceedings of the Court of Inquiry which enquired into the matter pertaining to the killing of five persons in Pathribal, Anantnag district, Jammu and Kashmir in the year 2000.”
The Central Public Information Officer (CPIO) of the Indian Army invoked Section 8(1)(h) of the RTI Act to deny access to the Court Martial and Court of Inquiry records. Under Section 8(1)(h), a public authority may deny access to information if disclosure will impede the process of investigation or the arrest or the prosecution of persons accused of committing crimes. Later on, the First Appellate Authority upheld the decision of the CPIO.
In my second appeal filed before the CIC, I argued that Section 8(1)(h) was simply not applicable to the information that I sought. I cited case law from the Delhi High Court about how the exemptions must not be applied in a mechanical manner. Subsequently, the CIC has ordered the disclosure of all information sought in my RTI application relating to the Court Martial in the Machil case. This may be a rare instance where a direction has been issued to disclose Court Martial related records. I have not seen other CIC decisions on similar matters issued till date. I request readers to share with me any earlier decision of the CIC directing the disclosure of similar information under the RTI Act.
However what is perplexing in this case is that the Indian Army representative admitted at the CIC hearing that a Court of Inquiry was never held in the Pathribal incident. The CIC has recorded this admission in its decision. The national and J&K media have reported more than once about the existence of a Court of Inquiry in the Pathribal case. I request informed readers to educate me about the nature of inquiry that the Indian Army conducted in relation to the Pathribal incident as the matter had reached the Supreme Court of India.
Will the Indian Army disclose the Court Martial records or challenge the CIC’s order in some High Court remains to be seen.

*Programme Coordinator, Access to Information Programme, Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative, New Delhi

Comments

TRENDING

'Modi govt's assault on dissent': Foreign funds of top finance NGO blocked

By Rajiv Shah  In a surprise move, the Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India, has cancelled the foreign funding license of the well-known advocacy group, Centre for Financial Accountability (CFA), known for critically examining India's finance and banking sectors from human rights and environmental angle.

'Wedding of the century': What does Mukesh Ambani want to prove by such extravaganza?

By NS Venkataraman*  Mukesh  Ambani,   a renowned Indian industrialist who is said to be the richest person in India and  one of the richest persons in the world,   has just now conducted the wedding celebration of  his son in Mumbai,   with unheard level of lavishness in India.

A Hindu alternative to Valentine's Day? 'Shiv-Parvati was first love marriage in Universe'

By Rajiv Shah*   The other day, I was searching on Google a quote on Maha Shivratri which I wanted to send to someone, a confirmed Shiv Bhakt, quite close to me -- with an underlying message to act positively instead of being negative. On top of the search, I chanced upon an article in, imagine!, a Nashik Corporation site which offered me something very unusual. 

Swami Vivekananda's views on caste and sexuality were 'painfully' regressive

By Bhaskar Sur* Swami Vivekananda now belongs more to the modern Hindu mythology than reality. It makes a daunting job to discover the real human being who knew unemployment, humiliation of losing a teaching job for 'incompetence', longed in vain for the bliss of a happy conjugal life only to suffer the consequent frustration.

'28% rise in sedition cases': Top global NGO alliance rates India's civil space 'repressed'

By Rajiv Shah Rating India's civic space as repressed , Civicus, a global civil society alliance, in its new report submitted to the UN Human Rights Committee (UNHRC) on the state of civic space in the country has said that the use of sedition law against the Modi government’s critics continues. "Under the government of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, sedition cases have increased by 28 per cent with over 500 cases against more than 7,000 people", it says.

How US is using Tibetans to provoke conflict with China 'ignoring' India

By Lobsang Tenzin*  On July 12, US President Joe Biden signed the Resolve Tibet Act, and Tibetans cheered for it, believing that the law promotes a resolution of the dispute between Tibet and China. Is this true? First, let's look at the issue of the ownership of Tibet. 

Over 3.8 billion animals at risk: India on crossroad in animal welfare practices

By Rupali Soni*  In a collaborative effort, the India Animal Fund and Dasra have unveiled their report , "Our Shared Future | Securing Animal Welfare, Human Wellbeing, and Sustainability in India." This landscape report provides a thorough overview of animal welfare and underscores its indispensable role within India's socio-economic and ecological frameworks. It also illustrates how animal welfare is intricately intertwined with public health, labor welfare, and climate resilience.

Tribals from 60 villages observe seed festival to 'protect' diversity of indigenous seeds

By Bharat Dogra*  Nearly sixty villagers are sitting on an open floor covered by a roof for shade but otherwise open on all sides. Women and men are present in equal numbers but the visibility of women is higher because of their colorful dresses.

Misleading ads 'manipulate, seduce, lure' to market unhealthy harmful food

By Our Representative  The Nutrition Advocacy in Public Interest (NAPI) in its new report “50 Shades of Food Advertising” has sought to expose how seductive, luring, manipulative or deceptive these advertisements can be. Consequences of such advertising are increased intake of unhealthy food products that is associated with obesity and diabetes, it says.