Skip to main content

Poor performance in teaching children a major roadblock in Gujarat: DISE data

Latest data released by the Government of India’s District Information System for Education (DISE), which claims to be the basis for assessing the progress under Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan (SSA) and the status of implementation of the Right to Education (RTE) Act, suggest that primary education remains an area of much concern in Gujarat, despite wide-scale efforts made by the Gujarat government through its Kanya Kelavni school enrolment drive. Provisional flash statistics published in the just-released book, “Elementary Education in India: Progress towards Universal Elementary Education (UEE)”, go to show that Gujarat is strong in education-related infrastructure and can claim to doing much better than most states on this score, but when it comes to human resource development, which is the primary aim of education, it is one of the worst performers.
Indeed, whether it is number of classrooms, number of kitchen sheds for midday meal scheme, number of computers in schools, drinking water facilities or girls’ toilets, Gujarat has been able to create a much better infrastructure, thanks to huge funds available with the state coffers. Not without reason, these infrastructure facilities are being used quite often by the state officialdom to propagate how well has Gujarat done in implementing RTE, indeed much better than other states, and how much does it care for primary education. Of course, there is little realization in the process that spending funds on education is one thing, while going the hard way to invest in human resources is something totally different, which is where Gujarat remains lagging in implementing the RTE.
First about how well has Gujarat done in developing infrastructure by spending funds on the state’s primary schools. DISE data suggest that a large number of classrooms have been constructed in Gujarat in order to ensure that children have enough space to study. There are on an average 6.2 classrooms per school in Gujarat, as against the national average of 4.7. Only three out of 20 major states – Kerala (10.4), Haryana (6.5) and Punjab (6.3) – provide more classrooms that Gujarat does. All other states do not match up to Gujarat. While constructing class rooms, a large number of schools also got kitchen sheds to serve midday meal to children in Gujarat. Gujarat’s 44.83 per cent of schools having kitchen sheds is higher than the national average of 40.95 per cent, and is worse than only few states.
If DISE data are to be believed, the situation is quite good with regard to drinking water facilities for children and girls’ toilets, too. Thus, the data suggest that 99.55 per cent of the schools have drinking water facilities, which is much better than the national average of 92.71 per cent of schools. Tamil Nadu and Punjab are the only two states which have covered nearly all schools for providing drinking water. The situation is quite good for toilet for girls, a major reason considered necessary for ensuring that girls become equal partners with boys in primary education. Thus, DISE data say, 97.80 per cent of the schools in Gujarat have toilet facilities for girls, which is better than the national average of 84.68 per cent of schools. Only one state performs better than Gujarat here – Karnataka with 98.58 per cent of schools having toilet facilities for girls.
Further, Gujarat’s primary schools have three times more computers than the national average. As many as 60.01 per cent of the schools have computers in the state, as against the national average of 20.53 per cent, and here only one state, Kerala, surpasses Gujarat, with 87.72 per cent schools having computers. Even net-savvy Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka are very poor performers here – the respective number of schools with computers in these states is 27.05 per cent and 33.16 per cent. But as one scans through DISE data, clearly, beyond class rooms, kitchen sheds, drinking water, toilets and computers, however, Gujarat has little to offer vis-à-vis other states.
No doubt, the Gujarat government, by constructing more class rooms and schools has ensured that there are fewer number of single teacher schools in the state. In fact, it recently undertook a massive recruitment drive for primary school teachers, appointing ad-hoc teachers at a very low pay for five years. This has led to a situation where the proportion of schools with single teachers in Gujarat has come down a mere 0.81, lower than any other state. The all-India average is 8.31 per cent of schools being run by one teacher each.
However, data suggest that there is a clear imbalance in Gujarat on this score. There are as many as 19 districts in Gujarat out of a total 218 in India in which the number of students in a single classroom is more than 30, the norm fixed by the RTI for student-classroom ratio. Only two states – Uttar Pradesh with 56 districts and Bihar with 38 districts – are worse performers than Gujarat on this score. Worse, average student-teacher ratio in Gujarat is 31, which is better only than four “backward” states — Bihar (59), Uttar Pradesh (44), Jharkhand (40) and Madhya Pradesh (34). Does it mean that despite recruiting so many teachers, Gujarat would need to do more? DISE data have no answers.
Now towards the gloomier picture. While Gujarat may be having proportionately more midday meal sheds than other states, the number of schools serving midday meal is much lower than the all-India average. It is 89.94 per cent in Gujarat as against the all-India average of 92.06 per cent. The states which are worse performer here are Punjab (87.49 per cent), West Bengal (86.82 per cent) and Rajasthan (75.41 per cent). Midday meal was introduced in Gujarat way back in mid-1980s, when the state became the pioneer of the scheme for the country to ensure that poorer sections of children attend school. The state policy makers may have to do some explaining as to what has gone wrong.
Much against the Gujarat government claim that cent per cent children are enrolled in the state’s primary schools, DISE data suggest there is clear discrepancy. In fact, Gujarat’s net enrolment ratio is one of the worst in India. While at the lower primary level (classes one to five) is a poor 85.73 per cent, it plummets further to 48.77 per cent at the upper primary level, as against the national average of 61.82 per cent. Even states such as Bihar with 52.70 per cent enrolment are a better performers at the upper primary level; other backward states which have performed better than Gujarat are Jharkhand (69.65 per cent), Rajasthan (54.97 per cent), Uttar Pradesh (47.13 per cent), to mention a few.
What should be even more worrisome to the policy makers is the fact that Gujarat has a higher percent of school dropouts than most Indian states. While at the lower primary level the dropout ratio, worked out on the basis of the data given by the Gujarat government, is not much (a mere 2.69 per cent), at the higher primary level it reaches a whopping 29.33 per cent. It is not known how those who run the enrolment drive would explain their failure here. Only one state has a worse upper primary level dropout than Gujarat’s – Karnataka (36.45 per cent). The national average dropout at the upper primary level is just about 9.08!
It seems from the DISE data that the Gujarat government is not “showing” higher dropout rate at the primary level, hiding it under the guise of very high repetition rate. The children who would be potentially dropouts are, apparently, re-enrolled in the same class. One can only see DISE data to prove this. Gujarat’s “repetition rate” at the lower primary level is a whopping 6.67 per cent as against the national average of 3.17 per cent, which is twice lower. Except for West Bengal, which has the highest repetition ratio of 10.90 per cent, all other states show a much lower repetition rate. In fact, Bihar has almost the same repetition rate as that of Gujarat, 6.68 per cent. Even while providing these data, there is very little that DISE has to reveal on girl child education. As against every 100 boys enrolled at the lower primary level, 87 are girls, which is almost equal to the sex ratio of Gujarat, but this becomes worse at the higher primary level, where girls’ enrolment drops to 84 as against 100 boys. This is against the national average of 95 per cent girls.

Comments

TRENDING

Why predictions of an imminent collapse of the Russian economy may be wrong

A veteran Canadian journalist, settled in Russia, stated in a Facebook post that President Donald Trump "is apparently listening to experts who tell him that Russia's economy is on the verge of 'imploding,' and if he just squeezes a bit harder," his Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin "will fall into line."

Talking of increased corporate control over news, Rajdeep Sardesai 'evades' alternative media

When I received an intimation that well-known journalist Rajdeep Sardesai was to speak at the Ahmedabad Management Association (AMA) on February 2, my instant reaction was: I know what he is going to say—his views are quite well known; he wouldn’t be saying anything new. Yet, I decided to go and listen to him to catch his mood at a time when the media, as he (and I) knew it, is changing fast due to the availability of new technological tools that were not accessible even a decade ago.

DeepSeek censors uncomfortable queries on China, but why's Gemini so touchy on India?

The powerful Chinese AI app DeepSeek, which has taken the Silicon Valley by surprise, as it has capacities matching Google’s Gemini and Open AI's ChatGPT, is being criticised for restricting free speech, and rightly so. It is being said that those signing up for the chatbot and its open-source technology "are being confronted with the Chinese Communist Party’s brand of censorship and information control."

Gujarat a police state? How top High Court advocate stunned a senior-most journalist

Rajdeep Sardesai, Anand Yagnik This is a continuation of my earlier blog on well-known journalist Rajdeep Sardesai's lecture in memory of the late Achyut Yagnik at the Ahmedabad Management Association (AMA). I was a little surprised when I received the intimation about the venue for the lecture.

5% poor in India? Union govt claim debunked, '26.4% of population below poverty line'

A recent paper, referring to the Household Consumption Expenditure Survey (HCES) 2022-23 of the Government of India (GoI), has debunked the official claim that poverty has substantially declined. Titled "Poverty in India: The Rangarajan Method and the 2022–23 Household Consumption Expenditure Survey", the paper —authored by scholars CA Sethu, LT Abhinav Surya, and CA Ruthu—states that "more than a quarter of India’s population falls below the poverty line."

Gujarat's water anarchy? 16.7% of Narmada water going to industry, 33% of targeted area irrigated: Govt insider

The Narmada project is something that has always excited me, including how much water will be distributed and to which sector. A few days ago, when I was talking to a top Gujarat government insider, I was a little surprised when I was told that it is up to the “respective states to decide how much Narmada water they would distribute among various sectors” out of the total quota allocated to the four states—Madhya Pradesh, Gujarat, Maharashtra, and Rajasthan—as per the Narmada Water Disputes Tribunal award of 1979.

Russians at a Bali yoga camp to avoid drafting for war? Things aren't any different in Ukraine

Are people in Russia becoming frustrated with the prolonged war in Ukraine? And is the war having a similar impact on the people of Ukraine? I have no firsthand information about this, but it is well known how nationalist hysteria often seeks to conceal such frustration, particularly among the youth.

I'm flattered: A New York media house claims I was a KGB agent! Wow, I didn't know that

I was astonished, let me say pleasantly surprised, on receiving a comment by Rich TVX News  on my blog   "Why predictions of an imminent collapse of the Russian economy may be wrong" (January 28).  I don't know who wrote the strange comment from this "media house", which is based in New York, and claims to "hold sway not only among the masses but also within global corridors of power, influencing esteemed politicians and shaping international diplomacy, especially evident during pivotal events like the ongoing crisis in Ukraine."

A shocker for parents? Rush for 'prestigious' varsity degrees to reduce; instead, industry may prefer skills

Recently, I had a conversation with a senior researcher working on a project for a consumer goods multinational corporation (MNC) at one of the top institutes abroad. Insightful and articulate, he holds a PhD from a prestigious university and has a remarkable ability to analyze social dynamics. I am withholding his name because our discussion took place informally during a friend’s lunchtime gathering.