Accused of contributing to turmoil, excesses, Zhang Chunqiao was a key figure in Chinese Cultural Revolution

By Harsh Thakor* 

Zhang Chunqiao, a prominent Chinese communist theoretician and political leader, died of throat cancer on April 21, 2005, at the age of 88. Next month marks the 20th anniversary of his death, coinciding with the 50th anniversary of his notable 1975 document, On Exercising the All-Around Dictatorship of the Proletariat.

Zhang was a key figure during the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution (1966–1976), contributing both theoretically and practically to Mao Zedong’s campaign to prevent what was termed the restoration of capitalism in socialist China. Despite his influence, he was arrested following Mao’s death in 1976 as part of the so-called “Gang of Four” and spent over two decades in prison before his release in 1998. He lived the remainder of his life in relative obscurity.

Early Career and Role in Shanghai

Zhang began his career as a journalist in Shanghai and joined the Communist Party of China (CPC) in the late 1930s. During the war against Japanese occupation, he served as a guerrilla fighter behind enemy lines. By the 1960s, Zhang emerged as a prominent political leader in Shanghai, China’s industrial and working-class center.

In 1967, Zhang played a pivotal role in the "January Storm," an uprising in Shanghai where rebel workers and students overthrew the municipal government. Initially, they attempted to establish the "Shanghai Commune," modeled after the 1871 Paris Commune, where governance would be carried out directly by the masses through elected representatives. However, Mao Zedong concluded that China’s conditions required a different structure. The commune was replaced by a Revolutionary Committee, a tripartite governing body combining the military, revolutionary cadres, and mass representatives. This model was replicated throughout China by late 1968.

The Cultural Revolution and Theoretical Contributions

Zhang was an influential member of the Central Cultural Revolution Group (CCRG), the body overseeing the Cultural Revolution. He advocated for broadening the movement from students (Red Guards) to include the industrial working class. Zhang’s leadership was instrumental in transitioning the Cultural Revolution into a mass political movement that engaged workers, students, and peasants.

In 1975, Zhang authored "On Exercising the All-Around Dictatorship of the Proletariat", a significant theoretical work that analyzed the contradictions within socialist society. He argued that socialist societies remained transitional and vulnerable to capitalist restoration if class struggle was not continued under the dictatorship of the proletariat. His essay stressed the need for continuous revolution to prevent the rise of a new bourgeois class within the Communist Party itself.

Zhang identified several contradictions that persisted under socialism, including incomplete socialist ownership in the countryside and ongoing inequalities in labor relations and distribution. He emphasized that without active efforts to revolutionize social relations, cultural norms, and political institutions, capitalist elements could reassert themselves.

Challenges and Weaknesses

Despite his contributions, Zhang and the leadership of the Cultural Revolution faced significant challenges. Sectarianism, inadequate mass line practice, factional struggles, and the failure to build enduring institutions weakened the movement. Revolutionary Committees became ineffective in many regions, and the influence of conservative forces within the military was not fully addressed. These issues contributed to the eventual defeat of the Cultural Revolution’s political project.

Following Mao’s death, Zhang was arrested along with other members of the "Gang of Four." The CPC leadership that succeeded them repudiated the Cultural Revolution and reversed many of its policies.

Legacy

Zhang Chunqiao remains a controversial figure in Chinese history. Supporters view him as a committed Marxist theorist who sought to extend and defend the socialist revolution. Critics accuse him of contributing to the turmoil and excesses of the Cultural Revolution. His theoretical work, particularly his 1975 essay, continues to be studied by those examining the complexities of socialism and class struggle in post-revolutionary societies.

---

*Freelance journalist