Parliament has "no powers" to abrogate Article 370, which provides special status to Jammu & Kashmir

Rajindar Sachar

By A Representative
Justice (retired) Rajindar Sachar, who headed high-powered committee, which came up with a much-debated report on the social, economic and educational status of Muslims in India in 2006, has declared that the BJP is living in great delusion that Article 370 of the Constitution of India, which provides autonomous status to Jammu & Kashmir (J&K) , can be abrogated. In a commentary circulated on the social media by well-known social activist Teesta Setelvad, fighting a legal battle against Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s involvement in the 2002 Gujarat riots, Sachar said, J&K became part of India on October 27, 1947 only because of the Instrument of Accession, dated October 27, 1947, signed by the Maharaja, allowing the J&K to acceded to the Dominion of India.
Sachar, who was Delhi High Court judge earlier, said, clause 3 of the the Instrument of Accession specifically provides that the terms of instrument shall not be varied by amending any law by Indian Parliament, unless such “amendment is accepted by the Maharaja”. Sachar added, “The instrument also clearly laid down that nothing in the instrument shall be deemed to commit the state in any way to the acceptance of any future Constitution of India.”
According to Sachar, the instrument accepted “only a limited number of matters, defence, external affairs, communications”, etc. on which the Indian legislature could make laws for J&K. Pointing out that “this special relationship of J&K found its reflection in Article 370 of the Indian Constitution”, Sachar said, Article 370 lays down that, “notwithstanding anything in the Constitution, the powers of Parliament to make laws for the state shall be limited to those matters in the Union list and the concurrent list.”
Even these laws would apply to J&K “in consultation with the government of the state”, and these should be in consonance with the Instrument of Accession, Sachar suggested, adding, “Thus by virtue of Article 370 Parliament can legislate for J&K on matters other than those mentioned in the Instrument of Accession, but only after obtaining the concurrence of the state of J&K.”
Sachar admitted that there is a provision in Article370, in section (3), which provides that the President may by notification declare that this article shall cease to be operative. However, he adds, “But the proviso clearly lays down a limitation that the recommendation of the constituent assembly of the state shall be necessary before the President issues such a notification.” He adds, this shows that “Article 370 cannot be withdrawn by Parliament purporting to exercise the power of amendment given by Article 368.”
Giving the example of Mizoram, which like J&K was given an autonomous status through Article 371G, introduced through Constitution’s 55th amendment Act, 1986, Sachar said, the constitutional amendment “provides that no Act of parliament in respect of ownership and transfer of land shall apply to the State of Mizoram unless the legislative assembly of Mizoram by a resolution so decides.”
Pointing out that this provision is “identical to Article 370 of the constitution regarding J&K, and the BJP was a party to the amendment”, Sachar wondered, “Why does BJP apply double standards in the case of Muslim majority State of J&K?”
“It needs to be appreciated that retention of Article 370 is a matter of self respect and honour and assertion of its distinct identity for people of J&K”, says Sachar, asking why can’t the BJP, even when most of parties in J&K are desirous of finding a lasting solution, have the courage to “give up its opposition to Article 370 – which no Kashmiri can possibly agree to abrogate because it is a matter of preserving his special identity.”
Sachar’s commentary comes in the wake of open debate triggered by Modi ahead of the recent Lok Sabha polls where he called for debate on article 370. Among others, BJP chief Rajnath Sigh called for debate on why Article 370 of the constitution cannot be abrogated. “One wishes he had sought this enlightenment before including the provocative item of abrogation of Article 370 in BJP election manifesto”, Sachar said.

Comments

Gujarat Information Commission issues warning against misinterpretation of RTI orders

By A Representative The Gujarat Information Commission (GIC) has issued a press note clarifying that its orders limiting the number of Right to Information (RTI) applications for certain individuals apply only to those specific applicants. The GIC has warned that it will take disciplinary action against any public officials who misinterpret these orders to deny information to other citizens. The press note, signed by GIC Secretary Jaideep Dwivedi, states that the Right to Information Act, 2005, is a powerful tool for promoting transparency and accountability in public administration. However, the commission has observed that some applicants are misusing the act by filing an excessive number of applications, which disproportionately consumes the time and resources of Public Information Officers (PIOs), First Appellate Authorities (FAAs), and the commission itself. This misuse can cause delays for genuine applicants seeking justice. In response to this issue, and in acc...

A comrade in culture and controversy: Yao Wenyuan’s revolutionary legacy

By Harsh Thakor* This year marks two important anniversaries in Chinese revolutionary history—the 20th death anniversary of Yao Wenyuan, and the 50th anniversary of his seminal essay "On the Social Basis of the Lin Biao Anti-Party Clique". These milestones invite reflection on the man whose pen ignited the first sparks of the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution and whose sharp ideological interventions left an indelible imprint on the political and cultural landscape of socialist China.

'MGNREGA crisis deepening': NSM demands fair wages and end to digital exclusions

By A Representative The NREGA Sangharsh Morcha (NSM), a coalition of independent unions of MGNREGA workers, has warned that the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA) is facing a “severe crisis” due to persistent neglect and restrictive measures imposed by the Union Government.

Gandhiji quoted as saying his anti-untouchability view has little space for inter-dining with "lower" castes

By A Representative A senior activist close to Narmada Bachao Andolan (NBA) leader Medha Patkar has defended top Booker prize winning novelist Arundhati Roy’s controversial utterance on Gandhiji that “his doctrine of nonviolence was based on an acceptance of the most brutal social hierarchy the world has ever known, the caste system.” Surprised at the police seeking video footage and transcript of Roy’s Mahatma Ayyankali memorial lecture at the Kerala University on July 17, Nandini K Oza in a recent blog quotes from available sources to “prove” that Gandhiji indeed believed in “removal of untouchability within the caste system.”

Targeted eviction of Bengali-speaking Muslims across Assam districts alleged

By A Representative A delegation led by prominent academic and civil rights leader Sandeep Pandey visited three districts in Assam—Goalpara, Dhubri, and Lakhimpur—between 2 and 4 September 2025 to meet families affected by recent demolitions and evictions. The delegation reported widespread displacement of Bengali-speaking Muslim communities, many of whom possess valid citizenship documents including Aadhaar, voter ID, ration cards, PAN cards, and NRC certification.

'Centre criminally negligent': SKM demands national disaster declaration in flood-hit states

By A Representative The Samyukt Kisan Morcha (SKM) has urged the Centre to immediately declare the recent floods and landslides in Punjab, Himachal Pradesh, Jammu & Kashmir, Uttarakhand, and Haryana as a national disaster, warning that the delay in doing so has deepened the suffering of the affected population.

Saffron Kingdom – a cinematic counter-narrative to The Kashmir Files

By Syed Ali Mujtaba* “Saffron Kingdom” is a film produced in the United States by members of the Kashmiri diaspora, positioned as a response to the 2022 release “The Kashmir Files.” While the latter focused on the exodus of Kashmiri Pandits and framed Kashmiri Muslims as perpetrators of violence, “Saffron Kingdom” seeks to present an alternate perspective—highlighting the experiences of Kashmiri Muslims facing alleged abuses by Indian security forces.

'Govts must walk the talk on gender equality, right to health, human rights to deliver SDGs by 2030'

By A Representative With just 64 months left to deliver on the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), global health and rights advocates have called upon governments to honour their commitments on gender equality and the human right to health. Speaking ahead of the 80th United Nations General Assembly (UNGA), experts warned that rising anti-rights and anti-gender pushes are threatening hard-won progress on SDG-3 (health and wellbeing) and SDG-5 (gender equality).

From lazy to lost? The myths and realities behind generational panic about youth

By Bhabani Shankar Nayak Older generations in many societies often describe the young with labels such as “lazy, unproductive, lost, anxious, depoliticised, unpatriotic or wayward.” Others see them as “social media, mobile phone and porn addicts.” Such judgments arise from a generational anxiety rooted in fears of losing control and from distorted perceptions about youth, especially in the context of economic crises, conflicts, and wars in which many young lives are lost.

Counterview

Search This Blog