Parliament has "no powers" to abrogate Article 370, which provides special status to Jammu & Kashmir

Rajindar Sachar

Justice (retired) Rajindar Sachar, who headed high-powered committee, which came up with a much-debated report on the social, economic and educational status of Muslims in India in 2006, has declared that the BJP is living in great delusion that Article 370 of the Constitution of India, which provides autonomous status to Jammu & Kashmir (J&K) , can be abrogated.

In a commentary circulated on the social media by well-known social activist Teesta Setelvad, fighting a legal battle against Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s involvement in the 2002 Gujarat riots, Sachar said, J&K became part of India on October 27, 1947 only because of the Instrument of Accession, dated October 27, 1947, signed by the Maharaja, allowing the J&K to acceded to the Dominion of India.
Sachar, who was Delhi High Court judge earlier, said, clause 3 of the the Instrument of Accession specifically provides that the terms of instrument shall not be varied by amending any law by Indian Parliament, unless such “amendment is accepted by the Maharaja”. Sachar added, “The instrument also clearly laid down that nothing in the instrument shall be deemed to commit the state in any way to the acceptance of any future Constitution of India.”
According to Sachar, the instrument accepted “only a limited number of matters, defence, external affairs, communications”, etc. on which the Indian legislature could make laws for J&K. Pointing out that “this special relationship of J&K found its reflection in Article 370 of the Indian Constitution”, Sachar said, Article 370 lays down that, “notwithstanding anything in the Constitution, the powers of Parliament to make laws for the state shall be limited to those matters in the Union list and the concurrent list.”
Even these laws would apply to J&K “in consultation with the government of the state”, and these should be in consonance with the Instrument of Accession, Sachar suggested, adding, “Thus by virtue of Article 370 Parliament can legislate for J&K on matters other than those mentioned in the Instrument of Accession, but only after obtaining the concurrence of the state of J&K.”
Sachar admitted that there is a provision in Article370, in section (3), which provides that the President may by notification declare that this article shall cease to be operative. However, he adds, “But the proviso clearly lays down a limitation that the recommendation of the constituent assembly of the state shall be necessary before the President issues such a notification.” He adds, this shows that “Article 370 cannot be withdrawn by Parliament purporting to exercise the power of amendment given by Article 368.”
Giving the example of Mizoram, which like J&K was given an autonomous status through Article 371G, introduced through Constitution’s 55th amendment Act, 1986, Sachar said, the constitutional amendment “provides that no Act of parliament in respect of ownership and transfer of land shall apply to the State of Mizoram unless the legislative assembly of Mizoram by a resolution so decides.”
Pointing out that this provision is “identical to Article 370 of the constitution regarding J&K, and the BJP was a party to the amendment”, Sachar wondered, “Why does BJP apply double standards in the case of Muslim majority State of J&K?”
“It needs to be appreciated that retention of Article 370 is a matter of self respect and honour and assertion of its distinct identity for people of J&K”, says Sachar, asking why can’t the BJP, even when most of parties in J&K are desirous of finding a lasting solution, have the courage to “give up its opposition to Article 370 – which no Kashmiri can possibly agree to abrogate because it is a matter of preserving his special identity.”
Sachar’s commentary comes in the wake of open debate triggered by Modi ahead of the recent Lok Sabha polls where he called for debate on article 370. Among others, BJP chief Rajnath Sigh called for debate on why Article 370 of the constitution cannot be abrogated. “One wishes he had sought this enlightenment before including the provocative item of abrogation of Article 370 in BJP election manifesto”, Sachar said.

Comments

No to free thought? How Gujarat's private universities are cowing down their students

"Don't protest"—that's the message private universities across Gujarat seem to be conveying to their students. A senior professor told me that students at the university where he teaches are required to sign an undertaking promising not to engage in protests. "They simply sign the undertaking and hand it over to the university authorities," he said.

Beyond the Sattvik plate: Prof Anil Gupta's take on food, ethics, and sustainability

I was pleasantly surprised to receive a rather lengthy comment (I don't want to call it a rejoinder) on my blog post about the Sattvik Food Festival, held near the Sola Temple in Ahmedabad late last year. It came from no less a person than Anil Gupta, Professor Emeritus at the Indian Institute of Management-Ahmedabad (IIM-A), under whose guidance this annual event was held.

'Potentially lethal, carcinogenic': Global NGO questions India refusing to ban white asbestos

Associated with the Fight Inequality Alliance, a global movement that began in 2016 to "counter the concentration of power and wealth among a small elite", claiming to have members in the United Kingdom, South Africa, Kenya, Zambia, the Philippines, and Denmark, the advocacy group Confront Power appears all set to intensify its campaign against India as "the world’s largest asbestos importer".

In lieu of tribute to Pritish Nandy, said to be instrumental in collapse of Reliance-controlled daily

It is widely reported that Pritish Nandy , journalist, author, animal activist, and politician, has passed away. While it is customary to pay tributes to a departing soul—and I, too, have joined those who have posted heartfelt condolences on social media—I cannot forget the way he treated me when he was editor of the Reliance-controlled Business and Political Observer (BPO), for which I had been working informally in Moscow.

Shyam Benegal's Mathan a propaganda film that supported 'system'? No way

A few days ago, I watched Manthan, a Shyam Benegal movie released in 1976. If I remember correctly, the first time I saw this movie was with Safdar Hashmi, one of the rare young theater icons who was brutally murdered in January 1989. Back then, having completed an M.A. in English Literature from Delhi University in 1975, we would often move around together.

A conman, a demolition man: How 'prominent' scribes are defending Pritish Nandy

How to defend Pritish Nandy? That’s the big question some of his so-called fans seem to ponder, especially amidst sharp criticism of his alleged insensitivity during his journalistic career. One such incident involved the theft and publication of the birth certificate of Masaba Gupta, daughter of actor Neena Gupta, in the Illustrated Weekly of India, which Nandy was editing at the time. He reportedly did this to uncover the identity of Masaba’s father.

Sattvik Food Festival: Shouldn't one question notion of purity, cultural exclusion in food choices?

Recently, I visited the Sattvik Food Festival, an annual event in Ahmedabad organized by Anil Gupta, professor emeritus at the Indian Institute of Management-Ahmedabad (IIM-A). I have known Prof. Gupta since 1993, when I sought an appointment to meet him a few months after joining The Times of India in Ahmedabad—one reason why I have always been interested in the activities he is involved in.

To be or not to be Sattvik: Different communities' differing notions of purity and fasting

This is a continuation of my last blog on Sattvik food. When talking about Sattvik, there is a tendency to overlook what it may mean to different sections of people around the world. First, let me redefine Sattvik: it means having a "serene, balanced, and harmonious mind or attitude." Derived from the Sanskrit word sattva, it variously means "pure, essence, nature, vital, energy, clean, conscious, strong, courage, true, honest, and wise." How do people achieve this so-called purity? Among Gujarati Hindus, especially those from the so-called upper castes who are vegetarians, one common way is fasting. On fasting days, such as agiyarash —the 11th day of the lunar cycle in the Vedic calendar—my close relatives fast but consume milk, fruit juices, mangoes, grapes, bananas, almonds, pistachios, and potato-based foods, including fried items. Another significant fasting period is adhik maas. During this time, many of my relatives "fast" by eating only a single me...

Challenging patriarchy? Adopting maternal and marital surnames: Resistance continues

Anandiben Patel The other day, I was talking with a group of family friends. The discussion revolved around someone very close to me who had not changed her official name in documents, including her Aadhaar and passport, after her marriage. However, on social media and within her husband's family, she had adopted her husband's surname as a suffix to her own. I mentioned that there is a growing trend—though not yet widespread—where women prefer to retain their maiden names or add their maiden surnames alongside their husband's surname. Another emerging trend is where men choose to add their mother's name, or even their wife's name, to their own. This revelation surprised my family friends.

Search This Blog