Skip to main content

UNICEF-sponsored study says untouchability a major factor in health delivery in rural Gujarat, Rajasthan

Sanghamitra Acharya
By Rajiv Shah 
Even as a recent survey report, prepared jointly by the US-based East-West Management Institute, and Navsarjan Trust, a human rights NGO, has found that nearly 20 per cent of Dalit children aged 2-5 in rural Gujarat “miss” the anti-polio dose, thus failing to be immunized, a top study sponsored by the United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF), based on on-the-spot inquiry, has found that untouchability is the most important factor in failure in health delivery to Gujarat’s (and Rajasthan’s) Dalit children. Based on primary data and personal interviews, the study, done a couple of years ago, has surprisingly gone largely unnoticed.
The study is titled “Access to Health Care and Patterns of Discrimination: A Study of Dalit Children in Selected Villages of Gujarat and Rajasthan”, by Sanghmitra S. Acharya, associate professor at the Centre of Social Medicine and Community Health, Jawaharlal Nehru, New Delhi. One is tempted to argue that its weakest spot may be the selection of the districts for getting primary data – Ahmedabad in Gujarat and Barmer in Rajasthan. While Ahmedabad is perhaps the most urbanized district of Gujarat, hence here discrimination against Dalits cannot be as sharp as Barmer, which is a remote Rajasthan district bordering Pakistan.
Be that as it may, the study, carried out with the help of the Indian Institute of Dalit Studies, suggests that even in a “forward district” like Ahmedabad, untouchability remains a major factor to be reckoned with, adversely affecting the delivery of health to the Dalits. In all, 12 villages were selected, six each in the two districts. The villages were selected from Dholka taluka of Ahmedabad district and Barmer tehsil of Barmer district. Two primary health centres (PHCs), two villages with sub-centres and two without a sub-centre were selected from each state.
Also, the information collected was comprehensive. In all, 200 and 65 non-Dalit children were interviewed. In case of those aged below 12, their mothers were interviewed. About 6-10 In-depth interviews were held in each village. The respondents were mothers, children, panchayati raj institution members, NGO/ government organization/ self-help groups workers, anganwadi workers (AWWs), auxiliary nurse midwife (ANM), and health worker. At least two group discussions and a couple of consultative meetings were also held in each of the village.
The study finds that “most children experienced caste-based discrimination in dispensing of medicine (91 per cent) followed by the conduct of the pathological test (87 per cent).” It adds, ”Of 1,298 times that the 200 Dalit children were given any medicine, they experienced discrimination on 1,181 occasions. Nearly nine out of 10 times Dalit children experienced discrimination while receiving or getting the medicine or a pathological test conducted. While seeking referral about 63 per cent times Dalit children were discriminated. Also, nearly six in every 10 times Dalit children were discriminated during diagnosis and while seeking referral.”
The author says, “It was observed that most of the discrimination was experienced by Dalit children in the form of ‘touch’ (94 per cent), when they accessed health care. Duration of time spent between the provider and Dalit children was the next most discriminating form. About 81 per cent Dalit children were not given as much time by the providers as other children. The use of derogatory words and waiting at the place of care provisioning were the forms where less discrimination was experienced as compared to duration of interaction and touch. About seven out of 10 times children were discriminated by doctors, lab technicians and registered medical practitioners (RMPs) vis-à-vis touch. This form was more vigorously practiced by pharmacists, ANMs and AWWs. They did not touch the Dalit children for almost every time they interacted with them.”
“As regards the place of discrimination”, the study underlines, “discrimination occurs while providing and receiving care at home. Providers do not enter, or only up to a certain limit. Comparatively lesser discrimination is evident at care centres. There are no separate places for waiting, but Dalit users feel inhibited to share the same space as the dominant caste. There is no evident difference in time spent. There are, although, some evidences of use of less respectful words – ‘they are dirty so falling ill is natural’. Dispensing of medicine is done directly on hand through a piece of paper, and not in small packets conventionally used for putting the medicines (‘they can digest even stone’).”
The study says, “In more than 93 per cent times Dalit children experienced discrimination at (pharmacists’) hands while about 59 per cent times they experienced any form of discrimination by doctors. Pharmacists discriminated the most while giving the medicine and least in making them wait for their turn. However, lab technicians seem to be most discriminating in terms of making them wait (91 per cent times) and least in the conduct of the pathological test (71 per cent times). While most other providers discriminate mostly when it comes to touching the Dalit child, probably, due to the nature of the work which lab technicians do, ‘touching’ becomes inevitable.”
The author finds that Amaliyara village in Gujarat has the least number of children who experienced any form of discrimination. But even here things are far from rosy. According to her, “In Ambaliyara, children from the Dalit community are seated separately from those belonging to upper castes in the Anganwadi Centre. In the anganwadi, where children from both communities come, separate vessels are provided for drinking water. One Vinubhai and his wife, a nurse, worked to help the malaria affected persons during one of the outbreaks. They owned a vehicle which was used to take patients to care centres/ hospitals in other places at time of emergency, free of cost.”
However, “the upper caste people initially tried to dissuade them from rendering their services to the Dalits. When they did not pay any heed to their intimidation, they were implicated in false charges of corruption. He is now suspended and the villagers do not have any mode of transportation in case of emergency.” In another village, Bhurkhi, also of Gujarat, “most of the Dalits have to wait longer for their turn because the upper caste people are given priority. The Dalits drink water from separate vessels kept for them. The ANMs and other health workers rarely visit the Dalit quarters of the village.”
The author concludes, “Evidences from the field suggest that non-Dalits are governed by age old beliefs and stereotypes to continue practicing discrimination. Consultative meetings and discussions have reflected that the providers do not visit the Dalit quarters by giving reasons such as preference for central location to enable everyone’s access; and that Dalit quarters are further inwards into the village, thus inaccessible to locate them for rendering the services. Dalit providers, on the other hand, cannot enter the house of the non-Dalit users; if they can, then up to the outer courtyard. They have separate cup/glass etc for consuming offered eatables; and have to wash the vessels after consuming which are ‘cleaned’ once again by the owners. Their ‘efficiency’ is almost always doubted.”
She adds, “Dalit children experience social hindrances toward health care access and often have to travel longer than others for accessing service. Discrimination in the delivery of the services is often visible. Children are not given the chance to express explicitly to the care provider in the health care centre. Burden of health care utilization is often not possible for Dalit children to bear. Benefits of the various development programmes which accrue to Dalit children are few. Different forms of discrimination are manifested at the interface of various factors and hence experienced differently by Dalit children.”

Comments

TRENDING

'Draconian' Kerala health law follows WHO diktat: Govt readies to take harsh measures

By Dr Maya Valecha*  The Governor of Kerala has signed the Kerala Public Health Bill, which essentially reverses the people’s campaign in healthcare services in Kerala for decentralisation. The campaign had led to relinquishing of state powers in 1996, resulting in improvement of health parameters in Kerala. Instead, now, enforcement of law through the exercise of power, fines, etc., and the implementation of protocol during the pandemic, are considered of prime importance.

Reject WHO's 'draconian' amendments on pandemic: Citizens to Union Health Minister

By Our Representative  Several concerned Indian citizens have written to the Union Health Minister to reject amendments to the International Health Regulations (IHR) of the World Health Organization (WHO) adopted during the 75th World Health Assembly (WHA75) in May 2022, apprehending this will make the signatories surrender their autonomy to the “unelected, unaccountable and the whimsical WHO in case of any future ‘pandemics’.”

A Hindu alternative to Valentine's Day? 'Shiv-Parvati was first love marriage in Universe'

By Rajiv Shah*   The other day, I was searching on Google a quote on Maha Shivratri which I wanted to send to someone, a confirmed Shiv Bhakt, quite close to me -- with an underlying message to act positively instead of being negative. On top of the search, I chanced upon an article in, imagine!, a Nashik Corporation site which offered me something very unusual. 

Bihar rural women entrepreneurs witness 50% surge in awareness about renewal energy

By Mignonne Dsouza*  An endline survey conducted under the Bolega Bihar initiative revealed a significant increase in awareness of renewable energy among women, rising from 25% to 76% in Nalanda and Gaya. Renu Kumari, a 34-year-old entrepreneur from Nalanda, Bihar, operates a village eatery that serves as the primary source of income for her family, including her husband and five children. However, a significant portion of her profits was being directed toward covering monthly electricity expenses that usually reach Rs 2,000. 

Swami Vivekananda's views on caste and sexuality were 'painfully' regressive

By Bhaskar Sur* Swami Vivekananda now belongs more to the modern Hindu mythology than reality. It makes a daunting job to discover the real human being who knew unemployment, humiliation of losing a teaching job for 'incompetence', longed in vain for the bliss of a happy conjugal life only to suffer the consequent frustration.

Work with Rajasthan's camel herders: German scientist wins World Cookbook Award 2023

By Rosamma Thomas*  Gourmand World Cookbook Awards are the only awards for international food culture. This year, German scientist  Ilse Kohler Rollefson , founder of Camel Charisma, the first of India’s camel dairies, in Pali district of Rajasthan, won the award for her work with camel herders in Rajasthan, and for preparing for the UN International Year of Camelids, 2024. 

Why is electricity tariff going up in India? Who is the beneficiary? A random reflection

By Thomas Franco*  Union Ministry of Power has used its power under Section 11 of the Electricity Act, 2003 to force States to import coal which has led to an increase in the cost of electricity production and every consumer is paying a higher tariff. In India, almost everybody from farmers to MSMEs are consumers of electricity.

'Very low rung in quality ladder': Critique of ICMR study on 'sudden deaths' post-2021

By Bhaskaran Raman*  Since about mid-2021, a new phenomenon of extreme concern has been observed throughout the world, including India : unexplained sudden deaths of seemingly healthy and active people, especially youngsters. In the recently concluded Navratri garba celebrations, an unprecedented number of young persons succumbed to heart attack deaths. After a long delay, ICMR (Indian Council for Medical Research) has finally has published a case-control study on sudden deaths among Indians of age 18-45.

'Pro-corporate agenda': Odisha crackdown on tribal slum dwellers fighting for land rights

By Our Representative  The civil rights network Campaign Against State Repression (CASR), even as condemning what it calls “brutal repression” on the Adivasi slum dwellers of Salia Sahi in Bhubaneshwar by the Odisha police, has said that the crackdown was against the tribals struggling for land rights in order to “stop the attempts at land-grab by the government.”

Deplorable, influential sections 'still believe' burning coal is essential indefinitely

By Shankar Sharma*  Some of the recent developments in the power sector, as some  recent news items show, should be of massive relevance/ interest to our policy makers in India. Assuming that our authorities are officially mandated/ committed to maintain a holistic approach to the overall welfare of all sections of our society, including the flora, fauna and general environment, these developments/ experiences from different parts of the globe should be clear pointers to the sustainable energy pathways for our people.