Skip to main content

Tata Mundra's possible closure? Power ministry's 'pressure tactic' on consumer states

By Bharat Patel*
Tata power has announced to the Union Ministry of Power that Tata Power may be forced to stop operating  its imported coal-based Mundra Ultra-Mega Power Project (UMPP) after February, 2020. It is not only unfortunate but also criminal that irreversible damage has been caused to the fragile ecosystem of Mundra coast for a project that will have a running life of only seven years.
The project has destroyed the environment the economic displacement of the communities affected. Farmers, fish workers, salt pan workers, cattle grazers have suffered irreversible damage to their lives and livelihoods. The outdated open cycle technology used in the plant has destroyed the marine ecology.
Today, thousands of fish workers are struggling to make ends meet due to decline in the fish catch in the area, agricultural land has become saline to ingress of sea water from the intake channel and the grazing land has been acquired for the project. After all this damage, the project didn’t even make any financial sense also.
This project has displaced people, snatched their livelihoods and failed to carry out any genuine consultations. Making matters worse, the plant from the very beginning has been operating at a financial loss following rises in the prices of imported coal. Now, the company may be looking at selling the plant to the government.
This situation points out to many failures on part of the government, financing agencies and company who have clearly failed to conduct due diligence, assess the financial viability of the project and the damage that the project would cause to the people and environment.
The Union Power Ministry’s orders to consumer states Haryana, Rajasthan, Punjab and Maharashtra, which buy power from the Mundra plant, to decide on the matter, or deal with power shortage without Centre’s support are pressure tactics to force consumers states to bear with the losses of the company.
These costs would eventually come to the consumer. In case, the five consumer states allow pass-through of additional fuel cost to consumers, this would mean allowing relief beyond the PPA terms and conditions which would imply passing on to the consumers, commercial risks that were voluntarily assumed by the project developer to win the contract.
The reports that the government may take over the project is of serious concern. The project is a stressed asset. By the end of FY2018-19, the Mundra UMPP, also known as Coastal Gujarat Power, had incurred total retained losses in excess of US$-1.5bn. This is when to combat continual, significant losses the plant, the company imported a higher proportion of lower energy coal in an attempt to reduce fuel costs. The proportion of lower energy coal used at Mundra increased from 20% in 2018 to 42% in 2019.
Governments’ record of running companies profitably has taken a beating in the last many years. Deliberately they have been made to underperform, to pave way for privatization. Examples of BSNL, Air India, MTNL, SAIL and many such flagship companies are well known to all.
The story of Gujarat is not any different. In Gujarat, state run entities (PSUs) incurred losses of Rs 3,813.93 crore in 2017-18 according to a CAG report. The major loss-making state PSUs were GSPC (Rs 1,564 64 crore), Sardar Sarovar Narmada Nigam Ltd (Rs 1,075.8 crore), Bhavnagar Energy Company Ltd (Rs 617.31 crore) Gujarat State Road Transport Corporation (Rs 264.81 crore) and Gujarat Water Infrastructure Ltd (Rs 137.53 crore.
At a time when the government is unable to run the PSUs properly, it doesn’t make any sense to acquire a loss making private company with taxpayers’ money, especially when the prospects of turning it into a profit making one is nearly impossible.
In the worst case scenario, even if the government decides to take up and run the project, it is essential that the technology is changed from open cycle to a closed cycle cooling system for the outlet channel. This step is critical to save the marine life, which in the years of operation of the plant has been destroyed due to discharge hot water into the sea. Over the years, there has been a significant decline in the fish catch and has destroyed the livelihood of thousands of fish workers.
The initiative launched by government of India for facilitating the development of coal-based Ultra Mega Power Plants (UMPPs), each of minimum 4000 MW capacity has been a complete failure. The first UMPP of India, Mundra UMPP was awarded to Tata Power through a competitive tariff-based bidding process.
Mundra UMPP takeover? Govt record of running companies profitably has taken a beating in the last many years
Of the 16 proposed UMPP projects 8 have been cancelled, 4 have been shelved, one is at a pre-permit development sage. Only two projects have been operational, one being Tata Mundra UMPP and other Sasan UMPP. Both projects are under financial distress and have been marred with serious environment and social concerns.
With the scale and design of the Ultra Mega Power Projects they are designed for failures. It is important that the energy security are met in a sustainable manner. It also raises questions about the aggressive development paradigm and inequality in energy access and consumption.
This project also highlights the failure of Multilateral Development Banks, which claim commitment to reducing poverty and promoting sustainable development. Both International Finance Corporation (IFC) and Asian Development Bank (ADB), who have financed this project failed to conduct due diligence.
The financial viability of a project needs to be factored in before a project is sanctioned. This should have included not only the building and operational costs of the project, but also displacement and loss of livelihood and environmental damage. Government subsidies also needed to be factored in.
Negative environmental and social impacts of this project were recognized by audit reports of the Compliance Advisor Ombudsman (CAO) – the independent recourse mechanism for the World Bank’s IFC – and the ADB’s Compliance Review Panel (CRP), following complaints from the communities.
Despite scathing reports from their accountability mechanisms recognizing the non-compliance of environmental and social policies of these institutions, the response of the management was of denial and there was little or no relief for the affected community. The affected community rejected remedial Action Plans that were prepared as a part of the compliance processes as they were mere bandage work.
This is also a reminder of the little or no power these accountability mechanisms of MDBs have, reducing them to merely toothless observers. It is a shame that after nine years of the complaint being filed by the affected community to CAO, and the IFC loan being paid off; in the last monitoring report of the remedial action plan of IFC for the Project remains incomplete.
The complete apathy of the funding institutions led to the fish workers adversely affected by the project file suit against the IFC in federal court in Washington, DC in April 2015. After a long battle a historic decision in February 2019 the US Supreme Court decided that international organizations like the World Bank Group can be sued in US courts, they “don’t enjoy absolute immunity”.
The case will again go back to the lower court for the arguments to establish that in this particular case IFC can be held responsible in the US Courts for the destruction of livelihood of the fishing community of Mundra by lending finance to Tata Mundra Power Project as, now they are stripped of their absolute immunity.
The Tata Mundra UMPP is a complete failure. From the violation of national laws to the failure of to apply the environmental and social safeguards, from environmental and social destruction to financial disaster, to failed policies of energy security, this project is a case study of what should not be done.
But, it is the people of Mundra who have suffered the worst for the wrong decisions of the Government. Whether the government decides to buy the plant or company abandons the project the people continue to suffer and this needs to be addressed immediately.
---
*Machimar Adhikar Sangharsh Sangathan, Kutch, Gujarat

Comments

TRENDING

August 22 to be observed as Apostasy Day: International coalition of ex-Muslim groups

By Our Representative
In a unique move, an international coalition of ex-Muslim organisations has decided to observe August 22, 2020 as the Apostasy Day. To be observed for “the abandonment or renunciation of religion”, the coalition, calling upon people to join the call, said, the decision to observe the Apostasy Day has been taken because of apostasy is “punishable by death in Afghanistan, Iran, Malaysia, Maldives, Mauritania, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Somalia, UAE, and Yemen.”

Buddhist shrines massively destroyed by Brahmanical rulers in "pre-Islamic" era: Historian DN Jha's survey

By Our Representative
Prominent historian DN Jha, an expert in India's ancient and medieval past, in his new book, "Against the Grain: Notes on Identity, Intolerance and History", in a sharp critique of "Hindutva ideologues", who look at the ancient period of Indian history as "a golden age marked by social harmony, devoid of any religious violence", has said, "Demolition and desecration of rival religious establishments, and the appropriation of their idols, was not uncommon in India before the advent of Islam".

RSS' 25,000 Shishu Mandirs 'follow' factory school model of Christian missionaries

By Bhabani Shankar Nayak*
The executive committee of the International Union of Anthropological and Ethnological Sciences (IUAES) recently decided to drop the KISS University in Odisha as the co-host of the World Anthropology Congress-2023. The decision is driven by the argument that KISS University is a factory school.

India must recognise: 4,085 km Himalayan borders are with Tibet, not China

By Tenzin Tsundue, Sandeep Pandey*
There has as been a cancerous wound around India’s Himalayan neck ever since India's humiliating defeat during the Chinese invasion of India in 1962. The recent Galwan Valley massacre has only added salt to the wound. It has come to this because, when China invaded the neighbouring country Tibet in 1950, India was in high romance with the newly-established communist regime under Mao Zedong after a bloody revolution.

Time to give Covid burial, not suspend, World Bank's 'flawed' Doing Business ranking

By Maju Varghese*
On August 27, the World Bank came out with a statement suspending the Doing Business Report. The statement said that a number of irregularities have been reported regarding changes to the data in the Doing Business 2018 and Doing Business 2020 reports, published in October 2017 and 2019. The changes in the data were inconsistent with the Doing Business methodology.

Swami Vivekananda's views on caste and sexuality were 'painfully' regressive

By Bhaskar Sur*
Swami Vivekananda now belongs more to the modern Hindu mythology than reality. It makes a daunting job to discover the real human being who knew unemployment, humiliation of losing a teaching job for 'incompetence', longed in vain for the bliss of a happy conjugal life only to suffer the consequent frustration.

Delhi riots: Cops summoning, grilling, intimidating young to give 'false' evidence

Counterview Desk
More than 440 concerned citizens have supported the statement issued by well-known bureaucrat-turned-human rights activist Harsh Mander ‘We will not be silenced’ which said that the communal riots in Delhi in February 2020 have not been caused by any conspiracy, as alleged by the Delhi Police, but by “hate speech and provocative statements made by a number of political leaders of the ruling party.”

WHO chief ignores India, cites Pak as one of 7 top examples in fight against Covid-19

By Our Representative
In a move that would cause consternation in India’s top policy makers in the Modi government, Dr Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, World Health Organization (WHO) director-general, has singled out Pakistan among seven countries that have set “examples” in investing in a healthier and safer future in order to fight the Covid-19 pandemic.

Tata Mundra: NGOs worry as US court rules World Bank can't be sued for 'damages'

By Kate Fried, Mir Jalal*
On August 24 evening, a federal court ruled that the World Bank Group cannot be sued for any damage caused by its lending, despite last year’s Supreme Court ruling in the same case that these institutions can be sued for their “commercial activity” in the United States.