Skip to main content

Shyam Benegal's Mathan a propaganda film that supported 'system'? No way

A few days ago, I watched Manthan, a Shyam Benegal movie released in 1976. If I remember correctly, the first time I saw this movie was with Safdar Hashmi, one of the rare young theater icons who was brutally murdered in January 1989. Back then, having completed an M.A. in English Literature from Delhi University in 1975, we would often move around together.
Those were the days when Indira Gandhi had imposed the National Emergency (1975–77), perhaps one reason why Safdar couldn’t fully pursue his passion for street theater, which he had started in 1973 as one of the founders of the CPI-M’s theater wing, Jan Natya Manch. He was in search of a permanent job (though he had started teaching part-time English at a Delhi college), and I, too, was looking for employment.
During the Emergency, however, Safdar’s passion for theater did not wane. A big fan of German playwright Bertolt Brecht, he did everything possible to acquire theater-related knowledge. Unable to pursue street theater, Safdar took me along to a massive sports complex in Haryana at a place strangely called Bisva Meel (20th Mile), where Habib Tanvir, one of India’s finest theater personalities, was conducting a workshop.
We stayed there for two days, watching tribals from Madhya Pradesh rehearse for a play directed by Habib Tanvir. While I simply observed the rehearsals, Safdar actively interacted with Habib Tanvir and the tribal actors who were undergoing training.
I usually didn’t watch movies back then, partly because I couldn’t afford it, except when they were recommended as socially relevant and aligned with what we in the Left considered a class struggle approach. It was with this perspective that Safdar introduced me to my first Shyam Benegal movie — Ankur — which was made in 1974, while we were still pursuing our post-graduation.
Since then, I must have watched Manthan several times, mostly on VCR or CD, as circumstances permitted. On January 1, 1979, I formally entered journalism as a sub-editor for Link, a semi-Left newsweekly published alongside the daily Patriot, after resigning as assistant editor of People’s Publishing House, owned by the CPI. Two years after the movie’s release, John Dayal, then chief reporter of Patriot and now a prominent human rights leader, reviewed Manthan.
I don’t remember what others wrote about the movie in Link or Patriot during those days. However, John Dayal’s review struck me and remains somewhat fresh in my memory. I don’t recall whether it was published in Patriot or Link, but it was sharply critical, describing Manthan as a propaganda movie for Gujarat’s most well-known milk cooperative federation, which still markets several dairy products under the Amul brand.
Watching the movie again the other day on a TV channel commemorating Shyam Benegal’s passing, I was reminded of John Dayal’s 1979 critique. Since I still exchange messages with him, I asked him on WhatsApp whether he stood by his scathing assessment of Manthan as a propaganda piece for Amul.
Safdar Hashmi
John Dayal’s cryptic reply stated that while the movie wasn’t soft propaganda for everyone, and its technical aspects were flawless, "I side with those who say Shyam Benegal was very soft in his critique of the system."
Soft on the system? That too in Manthan, just because it was made during the Emergency and supported by Amul? Neither Safdar, who was far more critical of the Emergency than I was, nor I felt that way. We saw it as a sharp commentary on the powerful exploiter class attempting to undermine the fledgling experiment of an Amul-type milk cooperative in rural Gujarat.
The movie shows how a socially conscious government official's insistence that poor Dalits must be included for the cooperative to have any meaning ends with two simultaneous developments. On one hand, the powerful rural exploiters, who initially attack and later try to cajole the Dalits into submission, successfully lobby for the transfer of the government official. On the other hand, the movie offers hope: a group of Dalits decides to proceed with the cooperative experiment on their own, defying the powerful interests and claiming it as theirs.
While it is true that the movie was supported by Amul, with the acknowledgment clearly displayed at the beginning and end, at no point does it give the impression of supporting the system. On the contrary, it portrays the challenges faced by Dalits as they confront the entrenched interests of the rural elite. It also highlights the transformative potential of the awareness sparked by the government official, even after he is forced out.

Comments

  1. Thanks for recalling my review. I too am trying to remember if it was in Patriot or Link. Patriot possibly. I did pan Manthan, and very little in the late Shyam Bengal's filmography speaks as much of his impeccable technical excellence and brevity in narration -- harking back to the hundreds of commercial ads he did - has since made me change my opinion. I have written very little n cinema in the last 25 years, and regretfully for various reasons, have seen very few commercial or other films. But i have seen almost all of his. Each was a piece of ar.t. But not necessarily a scathing commentary on our times. His death remains a loss to the nation.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

NOTE: While there is no bar on viewpoint, comments containing hateful or abusive language will not be published and will be marked spam

TRENDING

World Hijab Day? Ex-Muslim women observe Feb 1 as No Hijab Day, insist: 'Put it on a Man'

I didn't know that there could ever be a thing as World Hijab Day until I received an email alert from Maryam Namazie of the Council of Ex-Muslims of Britain (CEMB), stating that several ex-Muslim women's groups had observed the same day—February 1—as No Hijab Day! According to Namazie, the day "was created on February 1 as a direct response to World Hijab Day" to "illuminate the coercive and oppressive realities of the hijab as a pillar of sex apartheid and a war on women."

Google powered AI refuses to correct grammar of a 'balanced' piece on Trump sending chained immigrants to India!

This is a continuation of my blog on how, while the start-up-developed AI app DeepSeek is being criticized for consistently rejecting content related to China or Maoism, there appears to be no mention in Western media about why another app, developed by the powerful Google, Gemini, remains silent on Indian political issues.  

How the middle classes are returning to the BJP fold, be it Delhi or Gujarat: Mahakumbh, Sitharaman's budget

Whatever reasons may be offered for the Aam Aadmi Party's defeat in Delhi—whether it was the BJP's promises of more freebies than AAP, the shedding of ultra-nationalist slogans, or the successful demolition of Arvind Kejriwal's "Mr. Clean" image—my recent interaction with a group of middle-class individuals highlighted a notable trend. Those who had just begun to sit on the fence were now once again returning to the BJP fold.

Trump’s research cuts 'may mean' advantage China: But will India leverage global brain drain to its advantage?

When I heard from a couple of NRI professionals—currently on work visas and engaged in research projects at American universities—that one of President Donald Trump's major policy thrusts was to cut federal funding to the country's top educational institutions, I was instantly reminded of what Prof. Kaushik Basu had said while delivering a lecture in Ahmedabad.

Gujarat a police state? How top High Court advocate stunned a senior-most journalist

Rajdeep Sardesai, Anand Yagnik This is a continuation of my earlier blog on well-known journalist Rajdeep Sardesai's lecture in memory of the late Achyut Yagnik at the Ahmedabad Management Association (AMA). I was a little surprised when I received the intimation about the venue for the lecture.

Why burn Manusmriti? Why not preserve it to demonstrate, display historicity of casteism?

In a significant Facebook post, Rana Singh, former associate professor of English at Patna University, has revealed something that few seem to know. Titled "The Shudras in Manusmriti", Singh says,  because Manusmriti is discussed so often, he thought of reading it himself. “This book likely dates back to the 2nd or 3rd century BCE, and the presence of contradictory statements suggests that it is not the work of a single author,” he says in his Facebook post in Hindi, written in 2022 and recently reshared.

5% poor in India? Union govt claim debunked, '26.4% of population below poverty line'

A recent paper, referring to the Household Consumption Expenditure Survey (HCES) 2022-23 of the Government of India (GoI), has debunked the official claim that poverty has substantially declined. Titled "Poverty in India: The Rangarajan Method and the 2022–23 Household Consumption Expenditure Survey", the paper —authored by scholars CA Sethu, LT Abhinav Surya, and CA Ruthu—states that "more than a quarter of India’s population falls below the poverty line."

Talking of increased corporate control over news, Rajdeep Sardesai 'evades' alternative media

When I received an intimation that well-known journalist Rajdeep Sardesai was to speak at the Ahmedabad Management Association (AMA) on February 2, my instant reaction was: I know what he is going to say—his views are quite well known; he wouldn’t be saying anything new. Yet, I decided to go and listen to him to catch his mood at a time when the media, as he (and I) knew it, is changing fast due to the availability of new technological tools that were not accessible even a decade ago.

A Hindu alternative to Valentine's Day? 'Shiv-Parvati was first love marriage in Universe'

  The other day, I was searching on Google a quote on Maha Shivratri which I wanted to send to someone, a confirmed Shiv Bhakt, quite close to me -- with an underlying message to act positively instead of being negative. On top of the search, I chanced upon an article in, imagine!, a Nashik Corporation site which offered me something very unusual.  I don't know who owns this site, for there is nothing on it in the About Us link. It merely says, the Nashik Corporation  site   "is an educational and news website of the municipal corporation. Today, education and payment of tax are completely online." It goes on to add, "So we provide some of the latest information about Property Tax, Water Tax, Marriage Certificate, Caste Certificate, etc. So all taxpayer can get all information of their municipal in a single place.some facts about legal and financial issues that different city corporations face, but I was least interested in them."  Surely, this didn't intere...