Skip to main content

Crushing dissent? Why 'plot' to remove Mewani from Gujarat ahead of polls failed

By Bharat Dogra* 

All those committed to protecting democracy, and more specifically to stopping the recent trend of highly undemocratic assaults on political opponents, will feel greatly relieved by the happy ending of the 10 day ordeal of Jignesh Mewani on April 29 by the acceptance of his bail by the Barpeta district and sessions court.
As a bonus gain for the democracy movement, the courageous judge Justice Aparesh Chakraborty, the real hero of this significant chapter of the march for democratic rights, has initiated an additional effort for stopping similar efforts of police harassment and high-handedness.
Jignesh Mewani is one of the most promising of our young political leaders who would do credit to any democracy. At the age of 41, he has already served the nation well as a lawyer, journalist, social justice activist and elected MLA. He has been particularly active in articulating the problems and causes of the dalits, the minorities and other weaker sections. He has shown high capabilities of mobilizing people for justice based causes. Our democracy has high hopes from him.
However, there are certain very powerful forces who consider him to be a big obstacle in their efforts of ruling people by dividing them and giving false hopes to the poor. This year their fear of Mewani has increased as elections are due in Gujarat, the state where Mewani is most active.
These forces have never been known for any reluctance in using undemocratic methods of harassing and intimidating political opponents. Thus it was that the drama of the arrest and intimidation of Mewani started, probably as a tactic of removing him from Gujarat till election time.
While he lives in western India, on April 19 a complaint was lodged against him in a distant eastern part of the country, for quite a harmless looking tweet. He was arrested the next day and taken all the way from Gujarat to Assam. Then on April 25 when his bail was accepted, he was immediately implicated in another case which has since then been exposed for all its absurdity in the April 29 court judgment granting him bail. 
From beginning to end, the 10 day ordeal appears to be a case of victimization and harassment of a political opponent which in turn is clearly part of a larger scheme to remove him from Gujarat for a considerable time. However he has returned, stronger than before. In his absence there were several mobilizations in his support, which have strengthened him further.
Real hero of the episode, who converted what was planned as a high-power conspiracy, is sessions court judge Aparesh Chakraborty
However, the real hero of this episode, who converted what was planned as a high-power conspiracy of injustice and victimization, into a victory of justice and democracy, is the sessions court judge Aparesh Chakraborty. If we have many more more courageous and upright judges like him we can be much more sure that our precious democracy will be protected against the worst conspiracies to harm it.
He has not only exposed the victimization tactics for what they are, but he has also used the excessive and more obvious presence of these tactics in the present case to ask for a police reforms as well as wider efforts to prevent such cases of victimization and worse.
This judgment on April 29 stated that the instant case is manufactured for the purpose of keeping the accused Jignesh Mewani in detention for a longer period, abusing the process of the court and the law. Then the judgment gives a much wider warning that such intimidation and victimization should not lead to turning our democracy into a police state.
Finally the judgment mentioned cases of the police personnel firing for killing or injuring such accused, which it stated has become a routine phenomenon in the state. Keeping in view such wider factors, this judgment has been referred to the honorable High Court at Gauhati for consideration of initiating any efforts to check such tactics of victimization and worse.
On his release when journalists asked him about his harassment, Jignesh replied quite coolly that while attempts to harass him were certainly made but he is feeling not harassed at all! Perhaps this is the best way to face such harassment and demoralize the tormentors instead!
---
*Honorary convener, Save the Earth Now Campaign. His recent books include ‘Planet in Peril' aand'Man over Machine—A Path to Peace'

Comments

TRENDING

Beyond the 'silent relocation' narrative in Bangladesh's Chittagong Hill Tracts

By Dr. Mohammad Asaduzzaman*  In recent years, a narrative has emerged from the rugged and forested terrain of the Chittagong Hill Tracts (CHT), portraying the region as the site of a “silent relocation” — a mass forced migration of Bangladesh’s non-Muslim ethnic communities into neighboring India and Myanmar.

The farmer's burden: How oil, war, and climate are rewriting the price of food

By Vikas Meshram   The scorching flames of the Middle East conflict are now slowly reaching the kitchens of ordinary people. The true price of this war is paid in daily markets, vegetable shops, and in the shattered minds of farmers. Expensive crude oil, skyrocketing fertilizer prices, and rising agricultural costs are together creating the conditions for global food inflation — and this crisis is directly tied to what people eat and drink every day.

Ram, Bam and Bengal: Memories of a Left turn toward the Right

By Rajiv Shah   The BJP ’s massive electoral win in West Bengal is being interpreted across political persuasions — except, of course, by the BJP itself — as the result of the alleged deletion of around 90 lakh voters from the electoral rolls during the controversial intensive revision process. This may well be true, given my own experience in Gujarat regarding the shoddy manner in which electoral revisions have often been conducted. In West Bengal, there also appeared to be a political angle to the exercise. But I am not interested in discussing that here, as enough has already appeared in the media on the subject.