Skip to main content

Gujarat health department red tape: Checked by private hospital, silicosis victims refused compensation

By A Representative
Gujarat’s powerful health officialdom has created yet another hurdle in the payment of compensation to the victims of the deadly disease, silicosis. It has questioned the diagnosis of the disease by a privately-run reputed hospital operating in Anand district. This came to light in a strongly-worded representation made by the People’s Training and Research Centre’s (PTRC’s) Jagdish Patel to state health minister Nitin Patel.
The representation wonders whether the hospital in question, which tested these patients, is recognized by the state officialdom at all, and if yes, then why is its expert doctors’ diagnosis being questioned.
According to the representation, an outpatient department (OPD) of the Karamsad-based Pramukh Swami Medical College-cum-Shri Krishna Hospital has been in existence at the PTRC’s office of Shakarpur area in Khambhat taluka ever since 2007. Khambhat, and especially Shakrpur, is notorious for large number of silicosis cases, caused by polishing stones in tens of agate units.
Between 2007 and 2014, the expert doctors at the hospital’s OPD Shakrpur tested as many as 1,050 agate polishing workers, out of which 251 were found to be suffering from silicosis.
“Of these, 127 died of the deadly disease”, says Patel. The issue of “recognition” came up after the PTRC sent the names of 50 of those who had died to the district health office for compensation payable against the death due to silicosis.
Compensation was sought under the Gujarat government resolution dated September 5, 2014, which requires payment of Rs 1 lakh to the relatives of a worker who dies of silicosis. Following a nod by the district health office, the district labour office is forwarded the plea for payment.
“We have learnt that several of pleas for compensation have been rejected by the health officials on the ground that the patients were not tested by officials of government hospital and that their certificate is from Karamsad’s Shri Krishna Hospital”, Patel says.
Suggesting this is strange, Patel says, in 2012-13, the health officials had themselves checked the diagnosis of silicosis patients by the Karamsad hospital. He adds, “This time, however, the health officials have not checked out things either with those suffering from silicosis or with the Karmasad hospital.”
Patel wonders, “Does it mean that the Gujarat government believes the Karamsad’s doctors are incapable of diagnosing silicosis? Also, there is reason to ask, why has the state government not set up any facility for silicosis diagnosis in Khambhat taluka.”
Asking the Gujarat government to immediate act to work out a solution so that those who died because of silicosis are able to get the compensation payable to them, Patel says, “In Rajasthan, there is a clearcut guidelines for diagnosing silicosis by a medical board under each of the medical college. A permanent mechanism, why can’t it be operationalized in Gujarat, too?”

Comments

TRENDING

Telangana CM urged to call off investment summit amid El Niño drought crisis

By A Representative   A group of 400 concerned citizens, environmentalists, scientists, academics, and people's organizations from Telangana and across India has written an open letter to Chief Minister A. Revanth Reddy, demanding the cancellation or postponement of the 'Invest Telangana Global Summit 2026', scheduled to be held from December 7 to 9 at Bharat Future City near Hyderabad, citing the severe El Niño-induced drought and water crisis in the state.

'Give It a Shot’: Documentary chronicles an Indian breakthrough in male contraception

By Ankur Shah*  One of the perks of living in Los Angeles seems to be the opportunity to attend early screenings of films. Recently, I watched a documentary feature about a breakthrough at the intersection of gender equity , healthcare and bioelectric engineering . The film traces the story of a remarkable Indian innovation, supported by significant clinical data, based on a technology first published in 1979 by its inventor, Dr. Sujoy Guha , and his colleagues.

The uncounted work of women academics: Whither gender equity in Indian universities?

By Dr Niti Upadhyay*  Consider a lecturer who stays back after class to help a student going through a difficult time. The conversation is important, and the student leaves feeling supported. But the lecturer has now lost the time she had set aside to finish a research article. When her performance is reviewed, the delayed publication might count against her, while the time spent helping the student goes unnoticed. The university benefits from her care and commitment, but she bears the professional cost.