In India’s high Himalayas and northeastern borderlands, two prominent voices, Sonam Wangchuk in Ladakh and Ebo Mili in Arunachal Pradesh, have emerged as symbols of broader tensions surrounding autonomy, environmental protection, indigenous rights and the freedom to express dissent. Their experiences, along with those of other activists and local communities, reflect growing concerns over restrictions, preventive detentions and administrative measures that critics view as undermining fundamental rights, including freedom of speech, peaceful assembly, movement and access to due process. Both regions are strategically sensitive, have significant tribal populations and face competing ecological and developmental pressures.
Sonam Wangchuk, an engineer, education reformer and climate innovator known for his work on artificial glaciers, popularly called ice stupas, and the Students’ Educational and Cultural Movement of Ladakh (SECMOL), has long advocated sustainable development. In recent years, he has also emerged as a prominent voice demanding constitutional safeguards for Ladakh following its reorganisation as a Union Territory. Through hunger strikes and public campaigns, he has called for statehood or protection under the Sixth Schedule, greater local autonomy and accountability in governance.
In September 2025, Wangchuk was detained under the National Security Act following protests in Leh that turned violent in some areas. He was released several months later in 2026.
In November 2026, Ladakhi groups protested against the timing of the hill council elections, arguing that holding them during the harsh winter months could disenfranchise a significant section of the electorate because of seasonal migration. Against this backdrop, the authorities issued orders under Section 163 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), restricting Wangchuk’s movement for 60 days.
Wangchuk said he was removed from a protest site and escorted to his residence at the Himalayan Institute of Alternatives, Ladakh (HIAL), where police and paramilitary personnel were deployed. He described the restrictions as "arbitrary, vague and disproportionate", arguing that they curtailed his fundamental rights ahead of the elections. The authorities, however, justified the measures as preventive steps intended to maintain public order and ensure the smooth conduct of the electoral process. Supporters and civil society organisations in Ladakh viewed the action as part of a broader pattern of restrictions on peaceful assembly and freedom of expression.
Ebo Mili, a young lawyer and human rights activist from the Idu Mishmi community in Arunachal Pradesh, has focused on indigenous land rights and opposition to large hydropower projects, particularly the proposed Siang Upper Multipurpose Project (SUMP), a massive dam project on the Siang River.
Local communities, including sections of the Adi population, have expressed concerns about the possible displacement of thousands of people, the loss of ancestral lands and cultural sites, the disruption of livelihoods and the ecological consequences of the project. They have also questioned whether adequate consultation and free, prior and informed consent have been obtained from the affected communities.
Mili has provided legal assistance to affected communities and raised concerns about land acquisition and indigenous rights at United Nations forums dealing with business and human rights. His activism has reportedly been accompanied by repeated preventive detentions, demands for peace bonds restricting his activities, surveillance and travel restrictions, including lookout notices.
In late October 2026, tensions escalated amid protests led by young people and local communities against the proposed project and related survey activities. Violence subsequently erupted in Pasighat in East Siang district, with reports of arson targeting an NHPC office, police property and other locations.
Mili and youth leader Otul Jerang surrendered to the authorities, condemned the violence and maintained that they had no involvement in the incidents. They said they had instead sought to maintain peace. Both were arrested. Mili, who is diabetic, reportedly began a hunger strike while in custody, asserting his innocence.
The developments were accompanied by a wider crackdown, including dozens of arrests and the deployment of security personnel. There were also allegations of excessive use of force, internet disruptions and pressure on activists and journalists. Indigenous organisations and community forums demanded the release of those detained, the withdrawal of security forces from villages described as having been militarised, and meaningful consultation with the affected population.
The experiences of Wangchuk and Mili have also intersected through their shared concerns over the rights of communities in India's frontier regions. In July 2026, Mili visited Wangchuk in Delhi while the latter was on a hunger strike over demands relating to Ladakh. Expressing solidarity, Mili discussed concerns surrounding the proposed hydropower project in Arunachal Pradesh and presented Wangchuk with a traditional Idu Mishmi garment as a symbol of shared courage and solidarity.
Several other organisations in Arunachal Pradesh, including farmers' forums, youth associations, student groups and community leaders, have raised similar concerns. They question the absence of meaningful consent for projects justified partly on the grounds of national security and energy requirements, particularly in the context of developments involving Chinese infrastructure projects upstream. They have also criticised the heavy security presence during survey activities and reported cases involving FIRs and detentions under local laws relating to unlawful activities.
For many indigenous residents, the central concern is the possible loss of control over their ancestral lands and resources. Their fear of displacement is not limited to the physical relocation of villages but extends to the loss of cultural identity, traditional livelihoods and community institutions. The expression "refugees in our own land" captures the anxiety of communities that fear being marginalised in decisions concerning their future.
In Ladakh, parallel concerns centre on demands for political representation, constitutional safeguards and greater local control following the region's reorganisation as a Union Territory. Environmental protection and democratic participation are also important elements of the movement. In both regions, activists argue that questioning development policies, administrative decisions or electoral arrangements can invite movement restrictions, preventive orders and detention, even when their stated position is opposition through peaceful means.
These developments raise important questions about the balance between public order, strategic interests and constitutional freedoms in India's border regions. Governments have a responsibility to prevent violence, maintain security, ensure the conduct of elections and facilitate development. However, these objectives must be pursued within the framework of constitutional guarantees and democratic accountability.
Critics, including the activists concerned, argue that vague or disproportionate restrictions, prolonged reliance on preventive measures and actions that appear to target vocal defenders of local rights can undermine freedom of speech, peaceful assembly and movement. They also raise questions about the recognition of indigenous rights and the extent to which affected communities are allowed to participate in decisions concerning their land, resources and future.
The hunger strikes undertaken by Wangchuk on several occasions and Mili while in custody reflect the seriousness of the concerns being raised and the frustration of those who believe that conventional channels of representation have not adequately addressed their grievances.
The experiences of Wangchuk, Mili and the communities they represent point to a larger challenge facing India: how to reconcile large-scale development projects and administrative control with democratic participation, environmental sustainability and human rights protections in strategically important frontier regions.
Development cannot be meaningful if the people directly affected by it are excluded from decision-making. Similarly, national security concerns cannot become a justification for disregarding the rights and aspirations of indigenous communities. Transparent consultations, meaningful participation, accountability for any excesses and restraint in the use of restrictive powers are essential.
Ultimately, the credibility of democratic governance in these regions will depend not merely on the implementation of development projects or the maintenance of administrative order, but also on whether local communities are treated as equal stakeholders whose voices, rights and concerns deserve recognition.
---
Neha Desai is a graduate of Jawaharlal Nehru University and an independent writer based in Arunachal Pradesh. Her research focuses on society, religion, ethnicity and women's issues, and she has published numerous articles
Comments