A collective of 72 retired civil servants has written an open letter to Tamil Nadu Chief Minister Thiru C. Joseph Vijay, urging his government to reconsider its decision to disband the High-Level Committee (HLC) on Union-State Relations chaired by former Supreme Court judge Justice Kurian Joseph.
The Constitutional Conduct Group (CCG), describing itself as "a collective of former civil servants belonging to the All-India Services and the Central Services" that is "committed to the promotion of the foundational values of our Republic and the observance of norms of Constitutional conduct," stated in the letter that it found it "incomprehensible that your government has decided on 6 November 2026 to discontinue the High-Level Committee (HLC) on Union-State Relations chaired by a former Supreme Court judge, Justice Kurian Joseph." The letter noted that the HLC had submitted Part I of its report in February 2026 and "was working towards bringing out Part II of the report by the scheduled date of 31 May 2027."
The CCG emphasised the broad appreciation Part I had received, stating that it "had been widely appreciated by all segments of society — Union government Ministers, politicians from different political parties, including the BJP, academics, leading public intellectuals, the legal fraternity and former civil servants." It further noted that "important areas of federal functioning, including emergency provisions, disaster management, inter-state river water disputes, local government, climate change, environment and forests, Union-State legislative and financial relations, Inter-State Council, All India Judicial Service, Mines & Minerals and Union agencies, were to be covered in Part II of the Report and considerable work on this was already under way."
Challenging the government's justification, the letter pointed out that while "the Government Order (GO) of 6 November mentions that the now disbanded HLC is non-statutory in nature," the State Law Commission is likewise "an executive body, established by a GO of 1994 and reconstituted subsequently through executive orders." It argued that "there is no bar on a non-statutory body undertaking an inquiry into centre-state relations and suggesting measures for a healthier and more responsive federal structure," citing precedent that "the Tamil Nadu (TN) government had set up the Rajamannar Committee (1969-71) and the Union government had constituted the Sarkaria (1983-88) and Punchhi (2007-10) Commissions for this very purpose through executive orders only. Even the Law Commission of India is not a statutory body but only an executive body."
The group dismissed the overlap argument as "a specious and unconvincing justification," noting that "this has not inhibited successive TN governments from constituting high-level committees to examine issues relating to the legislative relations between the State and Union governments." It added that "there is no evidence on record that the State Law Commission has, in the over three decades of its existence, examined issues relating to Union-State relations nor are any of its past reports available on your government's website or elsewhere for study and evaluation."
The letter warned that "transferring the task of preparation of Part II of the Report from the HLC to the State Law Commission six months before the deadline for its submission is a retrograde step," with "every likelihood of loss of institutional knowledge acquired in the HLC research efforts and inconsistencies in constitutional interpretation and analytical approach," and that "an integrated, coherent analysis of the complex issues involved requires a single body applying its mind." It added that "the transfer to the State Law Commission will also delay its publication."
Expressing concern over the removal of the report from the government website, the CCG stated it understood "that PDF copies of the English and Tamil versions of Part I of the Report have been removed with unseemly haste from the Tamil Nadu government website." It noted that "considering that the reputed international publishing house, Bloomsbury, undertook the publication of Part I, which is perhaps the first of its kind for a Report commissioned by a state government and a testimony to the high quality of the Report, the removal of the Report from the website seems to indicate that the current government seeks to disown the Report commissioned by its predecessor government and shrug off any association with the Report."
The letter then offered two possible explanations for the government's decision, stating that as "former civil servants who have worked closely with the political executive throughout our years of public service, we find it difficult to discern any compelling justification for your Government's decision." The first explanation suggested was that "your government may not fully subscribe to the ideal of a genuinely federal democracy, in which power is decentralised to the lowest levels of governance – Gram Panchayats and Municipalities – and higher levels exercise only those functions that cannot be effectively discharged below."
The second explanation was that "your government may be reluctant to displease the Union government and the ruling party at the Centre, a government and party that are obsessed with the ideology of an overarching centralisation of Constitutional functions and whose actions over the past few years, including effecting Constitutional changes altering the distribution of powers between the Union and the States, conditional fiscal transfers and rigidly structured centrally sponsored schemes have progressively constrained the financial and administrative autonomy of the States and tilted the federal balance towards the Union."
The letter concluded with an appeal: "We trust that your government will affirm its commitment to a strong federal democracy, with devolution of powers to local government institutions. Restoring the remit of the High-Level Committee on Union-State Relations to complete its task of bringing out Part II of the Report will be a welcome step in this direction."
The letter, signed under the motto "Satyameva Jayate," carried the names of 72 signatories, including Anand Arni, former Special Secretary, Cabinet Secretariat, GoI; Julio Ribeiro, former Director General of Police, Govt. of Punjab; N.C. Saxena, former Secretary, Planning Commission, GoI; Harsh Mander, IAS (Retd.), Govt. of Madhya Pradesh; Ardhendu Sen, former Chief Secretary, Govt. of West Bengal; Meena Gupta, former Secretary, Ministry of Environment & Forests, GoI; and Ramesh Narayanaswami, former Chief Secretary, Govt. of NCT of Delhi, among others.
Comments