'Life and Struggle-Dr BR Ambedkar' by Sukriti Ranjan Biswas treats Dr. Ambedkar's life not just as historical chronology, but as a vehicle for social emancipation. Written by a long-time leader and activist in the Dalit movement, the book makes a progressive rupture from abstract academic biographies. It is one of the most comprehensive and readable of Ambedkar, meeting the challenge of complex sophisticated academic research. The author aspires to enable readers to understand Ambedkar more clearly and encourage them to engage more seriously with Ambedkar. He substantiates how Ambedkar's ideas are deeply enshrined in the Constitution. The publication of an accessible English version of his writings added fuel to the flood of fresh excitement, curiosity and enthusiasm among educated members of Dalit Society.
Spanning hundreds of pages, such as the 415-page comprehensive accounts in his Bengali writings, 'Life and Struggle' intrinsically explores Ambedkar's journey from his birth on April 14, 1891, to his relentless socio-political struggles and the Dalit liberation movement. The narrative unfolds his birth to Ramji Sakpal and Bhimabhai Murbadkar of the Mahar caste, his early struggles with untouchability, and how his school records came to bear the surname Ambedkar through a benevolent Brahmin teacher, Krishnamurthy Keshav Ambedkar. It serves a vital counter-narrative role against mainstream Savarna-dominated historiography.
The author engages in an intensive and illustrative exploration of the social and political movements that orchestrated or propelled the ideas and work of Ambedkar, navigating the Temple Entry movement, Second Mahad Satyagraha, Opening of Hostels, Wearing of Paita, the second Textile Factory strike, First Round Table meeting, Communal awards and Pune Pact, Making the Constitution, the 1933-36 period, 1939 farmers meeting in Mahad, Partition period and so on. It summarizes the backdrop within which social and political upheavals triggered, testifying how Dr. Ambedkar's understanding of social problems, his evaluation of reform and his goals for the movement were at loggerheads with all others.
The author has chosen to focus on the writings and speeches of Dr. Ambedkar with great concentration and detail. He has been discriminating in his search for Truth while adhering unwaveringly to an individual and unique point of view. The author has devoted meticulous space to the chronological order of events and contextual understanding of the political stance and social philosophy of Congress leaders.
The author has explored selected dimensions of Dr. Ambedkar's vast knowledge and work, particularly those most relevant to the social and political realities of our time. The central theme navigates the condition of minorities, the struggles of backward classes, and the emancipation of Dalits. The author analytically refutes the Orthodox Leftists, Communists and Naxalites for inheriting the prejudices of Hindu Society for subjecting Ambedkar to such bitter criticism. He is critical of their ignorance of Ambedkar in spite of seriously studying Marx, Engels, Lenin and Mao.
The chapter on election in the constituent assembly makes a testament of Ambedkar's capacity to win over critics in the constituent assembly. It reflects how the constitution in certain ways contradicted Ambedkar's social philosophy. A most positive feature of this book is the detailed analysis of Ambedkar's written statement which offers an explanation for his resignation from the cabinet.
The biography symbolizes how Hindutva forces have targeted Dalits as the Constitution safeguards their rights and thus Dalits are evoking renewed interests. It is a most compelling refutation of Brahmanical forces, who obstruct the reconciliation of Muslims with Dalits and launch a scathing attack on opposition to the Pune pact and Communalism. The author explains how Dr Ambedkar boldly challenged the Hindu influence in chartering the Constitution and critically explored the complex challenges Ambedkar faced.
The book makes a testament about Ambedkar writing extensively on minority rights, communalism, reservations, and anticipating the grave doom of establishing a Hindu Raj in India. The biography has a chapter highlighting Dr Ambedkar's criticism of Hinduism, showcasing the fascistic elements retained by Hinduism, even if only a philosophy.
It analytically and coherently explores the evolution of the dynamics of the Vedic literature including the Vedas and Brahmans, and Brahmanical literature, including the Manu Smriti, Bhagavad Gita, the Vedanta, the Mahabharata, Ramayana and Puranas. It recounts how these scriptures were composed stretching centuries. The chapter unfolds the evolution of the Vedic era into the Brahmanical era, stretching across a period of 450 years. The author foresees the Brahmanical scriptures as a continuation of Vedic scriptures, unlike many others who analyze them as basically different. The chapter unfolds how there was a 450-year gap between the conclusion of the Vedic age to the rise of Brahmanical era, with the distinction between the Vedic and Brahmanical scriptures lying only in the period of their composition.
The author narrated how Ambedkar analysed how the Vedas were not sacred treasures of Wisdom but instead a collection of writings discarding or stifling real value for human progress. Ambedkar also analyzed Sanatana dharma as what Hinduism analyzed as 'that which existed before creation and is eternal.' He critically explored the unscientific character of the Vedas, placing Brahmanical tradition beyond questioning. Charvaka is quoted who exposed the falsehood, contradiction and boring reputation of the same ideas. Views of Brihaspati, Hari Chand Thakur and Hari Prasad Shastri are quoted, who argued that Vedas had little spiritual values. A detailed analysis is made of the original character of the Manu Smriti, navigating its essence—everything in the world was property of the Brahmans, who could punish anyone even without royal sanction, granted the right to execute anyone who refused to bow down to them.
Being critical of the social reforms executed by earlier philosophers, in the name of Hindu family reform, Ambedkar advocated the restructuring of Hindu Society, on the principles of equality, friendship and freedom, claiming it achievable only through abolition of caste and rejected piecemeal reforms. Ambedkar was convinced that caste Hindus would never voluntarily surrender their privilege. He recognized what was concealed within the caste system was supposed superiority of Brahmins, preserved for thousands of years.
The biography makes an analytical and illustrative juxtaposition or dichotomy of Gandhi's ideology to that of Dr Ambedkar, exploring how Gandhi defended the caste system as integral to Hinduism and reposed faith in the Hindus to propel the rise of untouchables—caste system should be purified, not abolished. The biography powerfully underscores Ambedkar's thesis from "Annihilation of Caste", making a testament of how casteism not only triggers division of oppressors from the oppressed but also breaks up oppressed communities internally.
It reflects how Ambedkar fought relentlessly for improving the condition of farmers and factory workers, through integration with farm labour movement. It unfolds Ambedkar's revolutionary vision and struggle recollecting Ambedkar's legal work for the farmers and workers.
The book recollects a most groundbreaking analysis of Dr Ambedkar of the Indian National Congress in September 1937, when he described the party as a proponent of social economic inequality, and not a revolutionary organisation. On September 17th, 1937 he introduced a bill in the Bombay legislative assembly abolishing the Khoti system in the Konkan region—sought to abolish the system and ownership rights to farmers who actually tilled the land. Regretfully, the bill failed to pass. Similarly, the Mahar Batan system, was abolished through a bill and reversed.
The book critically examines Dr Ambedkar's thoughts and prospects and problems of the partition of the country and its consequences. He projects an illustrative picture of Ambedkar's contribution to democratic ideology—navigates Ambedkar's writings on the future of minorities and vision of the Muslim League, the politics of Jinnah, question of communal harmony and impact of two nation theory.
In chapter on 'Partition of India and Transfer of Population' it recounts how Dr Ambedkar stressed that the will and aspirations of the people must play the decisive role. It reflected how for Ambedkar, the recognition of the majority's will was the very basis of democracy. Ambedkar was deeply concerned about the fate of minorities and argued in favour of reducing the number of minorities in each state and providing proper rehabilitation for those who migrated. Ambedkar pointed out the grave marginalisation in Bengal and Punjab, where the minority Hindu population was concentrated in contiguous areas. He opposed the Muslim League's demand for boundaries of Punjab and Bengal becoming boundaries of Western and Eastern Pakistan, with scattered Hindus being surrounded by a big Muslim population.
While the text encapsulates the broad expanse of Ambedkar's life and struggles with deep empathy, it analyses monumental intellectual milestones—such as his 1916 Columbia University seminar paper "Castes in India: Their Mechanism, Genesis and Development"—reflecting the same generalized tone of standard articles, lacking a comprehensive theoretical dissection of that specific text.
Arguably a biased framing of the 1929 Bombay textile workers' strike and omission of parallel anti-caste constitutional protests, such as those led by Periyar's Dravidar Kazhagam, are flaws. Critics note that the final chapters are vague, giving inadequate coverage to Ambedkar's final years, the impact of his 1952 election defeats, and the political circumstances triggering his historic conversion to Buddhism in October 1956.
---
*Freelance journalist
Comments