No environmental release of GM mustard, 'at least till SC considers the case further'

By Rosamma Thomas*
On November 3, 2022, a Supreme Court bench comprising Justices Dinesh Maheshwari and Sudhanshu Dhulia ordered status quo on the Genetic Engineering Appraisal Committee’s (GEAC) decision of October 18, 2022 and subsequent decision of the Ministry of Environment and Forests of 25 October 2022 to allow environmental release of herbicide-tolerant (HT) genetically modified mustard DMH11 (Dhara Mustard Hybrid 11) in five states, based on an interim application filed by Ms Aruna Rodrigues in her pending writ petition.
No environmental release will be permitted, at least until the case is considered further on 10 November. Advocate Prashant Bhushan, representing Rodrigues, contended that the apex court in 2012 had constituted a technical expert committee with broad terms of reference to examine in detail the matter of genetically modified crops in India.
A press release from the petition said, “That committee called HT crops “unsustainable” and “unsuitable” for India; it noted that the herbicide sprayed on HT crops caused cancer; and said that non-GMO alternatives were available in the country; and recommended a “total ban” on all HT crops on the basis of the precautionary principle, as no long-term safety studies were done on the impact of edible GM crops in India on human health, animal health, and biodiversity.”
The government counsel had informed the court that GM mustard seeds were going to be planted in facilities of Indian Council of Agricultural Research (ICAR).
The court ordered the counsel to ensure that “no precipitative action is taken” until the application is heard and scheduled the matter for consideration on November 10.
Advocate Prashant Bhushan, representing Ms Rodrigues, reminded the court of the committee it had constituted in 2012, the Technical Expert Committee, whose terms of reference were to examine in detail the matter of genetically modified crops in India.
Here are excerpts from the TEC report:

Conclusion on HT crops: “The major concern with HT approaches is the excessive reliance on increased amounts of one or two herbicides which results in strong selective pressure for the emergence of herbicide resistant weeds and a negative impact on sustainability... they are likely to be accompanied by negative socio economic consequences as well as on the environment. There are alternatives to HT ….more appropriate in the Indian context”. p.67 of TEC Report
“The conclusion of the TEC is that HT crops would most likely exert a highly adverse impact over time on sustainable agriculture, rural livelihoods, and the environment. The TEC finds them completely unsuitable in the Indian context”. p.71 of TEC Report
“The release of GM crop into its area of origin or diversity has far greater ramifications and potential for negative impact…. The TEC therefore recommends that release of GM crops for which India is a center of origin or diversity should not be allowed”. p.72 of TEC Report
In the case of HT Crops, “The evidence of harm is significant. ‘Roundup’ is also a potent carcinogen; it causes mammary cancers in rats which are equivalent to breast cancers in humans”. p.72 of TEC Report
“The bottom line for any biotechnology regulatory policy should be the safety of the environment, the wellbeing of farming families, the ecological and economic sustainability of farming systems, the health and nutrition security of consumers, safeguarding home and external trade and biosecurity of nation... Since there is public, political, and professional concern about transgenics with reference to their short and long term impacts on human health and the environment, their testing, evaluation, and approval have to be stringent, elaborate, and science based. The general approach therefore should be that: Biotech applications, which do not involve transgenics as biopesticides, biofertilizers and bio-remediation agents, should be accorded high priority.” p.93 of TEC Report
“Having examined the issue of HT crops in the detail required to arrive at a decision, the TEC recommends a complete ban on HT crops". p.93 of TEC Report

Bhushan reminded the court of its earlier orders and the submission by the Union government that as of that time no decision had been taken to release GM mustard in the environment. At that time, the government had also said that if such a decision were to be taken, it would be placed before the court.
The court asked Additional Solicitor General Ms Aishwarya Bhati of the current status of environmental release of GM mustard. She informed the court that GM mustard seeds were going to be planted in facilities of ICAR. The court directed her to ensure “no precipitative action is taken” until the application is heard. The matter is posted for hearing on November 10, 2022.
---
*Freelance journalist

Comments

MG-NREGA: A global model still waiting to be fully implemented

By Bharat Dogra When the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MG-NREGA) was introduced in India nearly two decades ago, it drew worldwide attention. The reason was evident. At a time when states across much of the world were retreating from responsibility for livelihoods and welfare, the world’s second most populous country—with nearly two-thirds of its people living in rural or semi-rural areas—committed itself to guaranteeing 100 days of employment a year to its rural population.

Gram sabha as reformer: Mandla’s quiet challenge to the liquor economy

By Raj Kumar Sinha* This year, the Union Ministry of Panchayati Raj is organising a two-day PESA Mahotsav in Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh, on 23–24 December 2025. The event marks the passage of the Panchayats (Extension to Scheduled Areas) Act, 1996 (PESA), enacted by Parliament on 24 December 1996 to establish self-governance in Fifth Schedule areas. Scheduled Areas are those notified by the President of India under Article 244(1) read with the Fifth Schedule of the Constitution, which provides for a distinct framework of governance recognising the autonomy of tribal regions. At present, Fifth Schedule areas exist in ten states: Andhra Pradesh, Chhattisgarh, Gujarat, Himachal Pradesh, Jharkhand, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, Odisha, Rajasthan and Telangana. The PESA Act, 1996 empowers Gram Sabhas—the village assemblies—as the foundation of self-rule in these areas. Among the many powers devolved to them is the authority to take decisions on local matters, including the regulation...

Concerns raised over move to rename MGNREGA, critics call it politically motivated

By A Representative Concerns have been raised over the Union government’s reported move to rename the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA), with critics describing it as a politically motivated step rather than an administrative reform. They argue that the proposed change undermines the legacy of Mahatma Gandhi and seeks to appropriate credit for a programme whose relevance has been repeatedly demonstrated, particularly during times of crisis.

A comrade in culture and controversy: Yao Wenyuan’s revolutionary legacy

By Harsh Thakor* This year marks two important anniversaries in Chinese revolutionary history—the 20th death anniversary of Yao Wenyuan, and the 50th anniversary of his seminal essay "On the Social Basis of the Lin Biao Anti-Party Clique". These milestones invite reflection on the man whose pen ignited the first sparks of the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution and whose sharp ideological interventions left an indelible imprint on the political and cultural landscape of socialist China.

Rollback of right to work? VB–GRAM G Bill 'dilutes' statutory employment guarantee

By A Representative The Right to Food Campaign has strongly condemned the passage of the Viksit Bharat – Guarantee for Rozgar and Ajeevika Mission (Gramin) (VB–GRAM G) Bill, 2025, describing it as a major rollback of workers’ rights and a fundamental dilution of the statutory Right to Work guaranteed under the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA). In a statement, the Campaign termed the repeal of MGNREGA a “dark day for workers’ rights” and accused the government of converting a legally enforceable, demand-based employment guarantee into a centralised, discretionary welfare scheme.

Swami Vivekananda's views on caste and sexuality were 'painfully' regressive

By Bhaskar Sur* Swami Vivekananda now belongs more to the modern Hindu mythology than reality. It makes a daunting job to discover the real human being who knew unemployment, humiliation of losing a teaching job for 'incompetence', longed in vain for the bliss of a happy conjugal life only to suffer the consequent frustration.

Making rigid distinctions between Indian and foreign 'historically untenable'

By A Representative Oral historian, filmmaker and cultural conservationist Sohail Hashmi has said that everyday practices related to attire, food and architecture in India reflect long histories of interaction and adaptation rather than rigid or exclusionary ideas of identity. He was speaking at a webinar organised by the Indian History Forum (IHF).

India’s Halal economy 'faces an uncertain future' under the new food Bill

By Syed Ali Mujtaba* The proposed Food Safety and Standards (Amendment) Bill, 2025 marks a decisive shift in India’s food regulation landscape by seeking to place Halal certification exclusively under government control while criminalising all private Halal certification bodies. Although the Bill claims to promote “transparency” and “standardisation,” its structure and implications raise serious concerns about religious freedom, economic marginalisation, and the systematic dismantling of a long-established, Muslim-led Halal ecosystem in India.

From jobless to ‘job-loss’ growth: Experts critique gig economy and fintech risks

By A Representative Leading economists and social activists gathered in the capital on Friday to launch the third edition of the State of Finance in India Report 2024-25 , issuing a stark warning that the rapid digitalization of the Indian economy is eroding welfare systems and entrenching "digital dystopia."

Search This Blog