Skip to main content

Making rigid distinctions between Indian and foreign 'historically untenable'

By A Representative
 
Oral historian, filmmaker and cultural conservationist Sohail Hashmi has said that everyday practices related to attire, food and architecture in India reflect long histories of interaction and adaptation rather than rigid or exclusionary ideas of identity. He was speaking at a webinar organised by the Indian History Forum (IHF).
According to a statement issued after the event, the webinar, titled “The Story of Our Attire, Food and Architecture”, examined social and cultural developments in India between the 12th and 18th centuries. Hashmi said historical evidence shows that Indian society evolved through sustained contact with diverse regions and cultures, shaped by geography, climate, technology and the movement of people. He noted that contemporary debates often seek fixed definitions of what is “Indian”, whereas historical processes reveal layered and shared influences.
Discussing clothing traditions, Hashmi said India was among the earliest regions to cultivate cotton and that unstitched garments such as the dhoti, sari and lungi formed the basis of early attire. He said stitched garments became more common only after the introduction of scissors through European contact. Several garments now widely regarded as Indian, including the kurta, pyjama, kameez, blouse and petticoat, were described as having origins outside the subcontinent. He added that unstitched cloth continues to play a central role in rituals associated with birth, learning, marriage and death.
On food, Hashmi said Indian cuisine developed through centuries of exchange with other parts of the world. While many staples are indigenous, he pointed out that several fruits, vegetables and culinary techniques arrived through trade and empire, including items such as potatoes and chillies. He referred to grafting methods introduced by the Portuguese and later promoted during the Mughal period, and traced the spread of sugarcane from India to other regions, linking food history with global labour and trade networks.
Addressing architecture, Hashmi questioned colonial-era classifications such as Hindu or Islamic architecture. He said these labels overlook factors such as climate, available materials and technological practices. He cited examples from Asia and Europe to argue that architectural features like domes and arches predate organised religions and evolved in different forms across regions.
Hashmi said migration, travel and cultural exchange have been constant features of human history, making strict distinctions between what is Indian and what is foreign historically misleading.
The webinar was moderated by Humaira Afreen, Research Assistant and Coordinator at the Indian History Forum, who welcomed participants and thanked the speaker. She reiterated the organisation’s commitment to informed and inclusive engagement with India’s past.

Comments

TRENDING

Civil society at a crossroads: Service delivery vs. rights in the fight for social change

Counterview News   In the latest episode of the podcast Unmute , hosts Gagan Sethi and Minar Pimple convened a profound conversation with two veteran development practitioners to dissect a persistent tension within civil society: the perceived divide between service delivery and the struggle for rights. The episode, titled "Beyond Service Delivery: Civil Society, Rights, and the Politics of Social Change," featured Apoorva Oza , a development practitioner with decades of experience in rural development and institution-building, and Professor Dipa Sinha , a development economist known for her work on food, nutrition, gender, and social policy.

Bangkok IMF-World Bank meetings: New reports put India's debt, climate, accountability crisis in focus

Counterview News   As the World Bank and International Monetary Fund (IMF) concluded their Annual Meetings in Bangkok this week, civil society groups and policy experts outside the official proceedings released two critical documents challenging the institutions' legacy and prescriptions for Asia, calling for a fundamental overhaul of the global financial architecture.

European banks accused of coal double standard after shunning Adani’s Galilee mine in Australia

By Rajiv Shah    European banks that helped shut down Adani ’s Galilee Basin coal frontier in Australia a decade ago are now bankrolling a far larger coal expansion just 150 kilometres away, according to a new report from Reclaim Finance and partner NGOs. The study , "Coal Hypocrisy: European Banks’ Double Standard on Thermal and Metallurgical Coal in Australia", finds that 19 European banks provided US$30.3 billion to companies planning metallurgical coal expansion in Queensland’s Bowen Basin between 2021 and 2025, out of a total of US$105.9 billion from international banks.