Consider a lecturer who stays back after class to help a student going through a difficult time. The conversation is important, and the student leaves feeling supported. But the lecturer has now lost the time she had set aside to finish a research article. When her performance is reviewed, the delayed publication might count against her, while the time spent helping the student goes unnoticed. The university benefits from her care and commitment, but she bears the professional cost.
This raises an important question for Indian universities: who performs the everyday work of supporting students and colleagues, and how much of this responsibility falls on women? Universities often appreciate faculty members who are approachable, patient and willing to help. Yet appreciation means little if the same work is missing from workload calculations and career assessments. Encouraging women to become more resilient will not solve a problem rooted in how institutions distribute and recognise work.
Women's participation in higher education has increased considerably. According to AISHE 2023–24, India had 2.24 crore women students, while women made up 44.9 per cent of teachers. Yet their representation was much lower at senior academic levels. Women accounted for only about 31.3 per cent of those in the professor and equivalent category, based on the report's designation-wise data. These numbers do not tell us why fewer women occupy senior positions or how individual careers progress. They do, though, give universities good reason to examine whether academic responsibilities, opportunities and rewards are distributed fairly.
One part of academic work that deserves greater attention is emotional labour. This involves managing one's feelings and expressions to meet the expectations of a professional role. A lecturer might need to remain calm during a difficult interaction, reassure an anxious student or respond patiently to someone experiencing distress. Such efforts often form part of mentoring and student support. Emotional labour is different from administrative responsibilities and unpaid care at home, although these demands sometimes overlap. Recognising these differences matters because each places distinct pressures on a person's time and wellbeing.
Research on academic workloads suggests why these patterns deserve closer examination. In a 2017 study, Cassandra Guarino and Victor Borden analysed two datasets from the United States and found that women performed more academic service than men, even after differences in rank, discipline and other characteristics were considered. Much of this difference came from service responsibilities within institutions. The study does not measure emotional labour among Indian academics, but it shows how unequal workloads might exist even among faculty members holding similar positions.
The demands women face outside the university also matter. A 2023 qualitative study by Merlin Mythili Nelson and Bhawna Agarwal, based on interviews with 30 women academics, explored the difficulties of balancing professional and family responsibilities during pandemic-related working from home. The study described how these competing demands intensified work–family conflict. Although the findings relate to a particular period and group of participants, they remind us that working from home or having flexible arrangements does not automatically reduce the burden of care.
The larger concern is how these responsibilities affect academic careers over time. A faculty member might be appreciated for always being available to students, supporting colleagues or taking on additional departmental responsibilities. Yet every extra hour spent on such work leaves less time for research, writing and other activities recognised during promotion. If refusing another responsibility leads to criticism or disappointment, setting boundaries becomes difficult. Universities need to ask whether faculty members genuinely have the same freedom to decline additional work without facing professional consequences.
It is also important to recognise that women academics do not all experience these pressures in the same way. A lecturer working on a renewable contract might find it harder to refuse extra responsibilities than someone with a secure senior position. Caste, disability, caregiving responsibilities and employment conditions might further shape these experiences. Any serious effort to improve gender equity must account for these differences. A policy based on the assumption that all women face identical challenges risks overlooking those with the least control over their working conditions.
A useful starting point would be to examine how academic work is distributed within departments. Universities should review who takes on mentoring, student welfare responsibilities and committee work, and compare these demands with the time available for research, promotion opportunities and access to leadership positions. Student support needs to be recognised in terms of the time and responsibility involved, without compromising the privacy of students who seek help. Faculty members should also have a safe way to raise concerns about excessive workloads without fearing consequences for contract renewal or career progression.
Recognition, though, is only the first step. Simply adding mentoring or emotional support responsibilities to an appraisal form will achieve little if teaching, research and administrative expectations remain unchanged. When faculty members take on substantial student support or welfare duties, universities should provide workload credit, dedicated time or a reduction in other responsibilities. Such work should also be shared across genders rather than falling repeatedly on the same individuals. Clear guidelines and appropriate training would help define what faculty members are expected to handle. Situations requiring specialist mental health support should be referred to qualified counsellors and professional services.
Universities also need to make everyday working conditions more manageable. Predictable teaching schedules, accessible childcare facilities and clear policies for caregiving leave would help faculty members balance their responsibilities. Opportunities for leadership should follow transparent selection processes rather than informal recommendations or personal networks. Women also need fair access to research time and administrative experience that prepare them for senior roles. These opportunities should be supported by institutional policies, not depend on the understanding or goodwill of individual supervisors.
Psychological wellbeing deserves attention too, but universities need to approach it carefully. Confidential counselling and mental health support are important. At the same time, faculty distress should not automatically be treated as a personal inability to cope. Sometimes the problem lies in unreasonable expectations, excessive responsibilities or a workplace culture where saying no feels risky. Wellbeing programmes will have limited value if institutions do not also examine the conditions contributing to stress. Teaching faculty members to set boundaries makes little sense if they face negative consequences for maintaining them.
The lecturer who stayed back to support a distressed student was doing something important for the university. Her contribution helped create the kind of learning environment institutions say they value. Yet if such work continues to go unrecognised while research output alone shapes career advancement, universities will keep overlooking a significant part of academic life.
Gender equity in higher education must therefore involve more than increasing the number of women in academic positions. Universities need to examine who carries the everyday responsibilities that keep departments functioning, whose time is taken for granted and whose contributions receive recognition. Supporting students and colleagues is part of academic life, and the responsibility should be shared fairly. Women should not have to choose between being supportive members of their institutions and protecting their own professional growth.
---
*Assistant Professor of Psychology, CHRIST (Deemed to be University), Delhi NCR Campus
Comments