Skip to main content

CCG raises concerns over Indian State of Forest Report 2023 in open letter to environment minister

By A Representative 
The Constitutional Conduct Group (CCG), a collective of former civil servants, has expressed serious concerns over the Indian State of Forest Report (ISFR) 2023 in an open letter to the Union Minister for Environment, Forests & Climate Change. The group has criticized the report's delayed release, flawed methodology, and misleading claims regarding the state of India's forests.
The ISFR, which is released biennially, was expected in January 2023 but was only published in December 2024—almost a year late. CCG claims the report paints an overly optimistic picture, suggesting a net increase in forest cover while disregarding actual deforestation trends.
The group highlighted serious methodological issues, stating that the ISFR wrongly includes orchards, plantations, and gardens as forests. Coconut, oil palm, and rubber plantations have been counted as forest cover. The reported increase of 1,445.81 sq km in total forest and tree cover appears inaccurate. Ground-truthing (verification on the ground) has been inadequate, and independent satellite data suggests significant forest loss.
The ISFR 2023 fails to comply with key Supreme Court rulings, including the 1996 Godavarman case, which mandates identifying all forests (irrespective of ownership), was not followed. The 2011 Lafarge case required digital mapping of all forests under the Forest Conservation Act, which the ISFR has not done.
Despite ISFR 2023’s claims, CCG points to data showing India lost 1.49 million hectares of trees between 2013 and 2023, making it the second-highest in global deforestation rankings. The report reveals that Northeastern states lost 3,132.27 sq km of forest cover over a decade, likely due to oil palm plantations. High-altitude forests (above 1,000 meters) saw a decline of over 1,500 sq km, increasing risks of landslides and floods. Additionally, 92,989 sq km of forests degraded between 2011 and 2021, despite large government investments in afforestation.
CCG warns that the Green Credit Program (GCP), promoted in ISFR 2023, is a flawed scheme that allows businesses to offset deforestation by funding questionable plantations. The scheme has been legally challenged, and CCG has previously written to the government highlighting its dangers.
CCG urges the government to ensure ISFR reports are based on scientific accuracy and transparent data. It calls for prioritizing forest and biodiversity conservation over development projects that primarily benefit corporate interests and stopping misleading claims that foster complacency while deforestation and ecological degradation accelerate.
Signed by 60 eminent former civil servants, including ex-Chief Secretaries, Ambassadors, and high-ranking officials, the letter calls for an immediate course correction in India’s forest conservation policies to prevent irreversible ecological damage.

Comments

Post a Comment

NOTE: Hateful, abusive comments won't be published. -- Editor

TRENDING

The making of a self-made woman: How eighty sheep changed everything for Kalawati Ninama

By Vikas Meshram*  About forty-two kilometres from Rajasthan's Banswara district, in the tribal heartland of Ghatol block, lies the small village of Ubapana. This is where Kalawati Ninama, her husband Dhulji, and their four children make their home. Their days unfold much like those of their neighbours—bustling mornings, long hours of farm labour through the afternoon, and evenings spent tending livestock. For this family, farming and livestock were once simply a means of putting food on the table. Today, they have become the sturdy foundation of something far greater: genuine self-sufficiency.
Post a Comment
»

India has spent billions on skilling. Where are the jobs?

By Vikas Gupta   India loves the photograph of a certificate ceremony. A minister on a stage. A banner bearing the word “skill.” Young people holding folders that promise a future. It is a reassuring image because it tells us the problem has a manageable answer: train the young, make them job-ready, and work will follow.
Post a Comment
»

BAPS, the Eiffel Tower and the curious silence on secularism

By Rajiv Shah   I was a little surprised to see how some of those whom I respect for taking a firm stand on patriarchal issues reacted to the manner in which they responded to the recent incident in Paris, in which women employees of the Eiffel Tower were asked to remain "invisible" on September 5 when 100 BAPS sadhus visited one of the world's top tourist destinations.
3 comments
»