Samay Raina’s cousin-marriage joke on India’s Got Latent has reignited an old debate about religion, cultural practices, and the selective targeting of Muslims. But beyond the controversy lies a more important question: why is a practice permitted across different religious traditions and legal systems so often reduced to a stereotype when Muslims are involved?
The incident took place during an interaction with contestant Bhagyashree Tarke, who appeared in the comic persona of Salma Deewani. When she mentioned that her cousin had accompanied her, guest judge Huma Qureshi asked who the cousin was. Raina promptly interjected, suggesting that the cousin must be her husband. The remark drew laughter in the studio but also triggered criticism on social media, with many viewers interpreting it as a dig at Muslims and the stereotype surrounding cousin marriages in the community. The exchange has since become a talking point far beyond the usual boundaries of roast comedy.
There is, of course, a distinction between comedy and prejudice. Comedians enjoy considerable creative freedom, and humour often derives its strength from challenging social conventions. But when a punchline repeatedly draws upon the identity of a particular religious community, it is worth asking whether the joke is genuinely challenging a social practice or merely reinforcing an existing stereotype. The larger concern is not that a comedian made a joke; it is that an entire community can become the subject of ridicule through a practice that is neither exclusive to it nor unknown elsewhere.
One of the most striking aspects of this debate is how readily cousin marriage is presented as something peculiar to Muslims, a portrayal that is both historically and culturally inaccurate. Marriage between cousins has existed across different societies, religions, and communities for centuries. In parts of South India, particularly among certain communities, cross-cousin marriages have traditionally been recognised, and some communities have also practised maternal uncle-niece marriages. These customs have their own distinct social and historical contexts.
The law itself reflects this diversity. The Hindu Marriage Act of 1955 generally prohibits marriages within specified degrees of relationship, including first cousins. However, it provides exceptions where an established custom or usage governing the parties permits such marriages, recognising that marriage customs are not uniform across all Hindu communities. Similarly, the Parsi Marriage and Divorce Act of 1936 does not include first cousins in its list of prohibited relationships. The position under Christian traditions varies according to applicable laws and denominational rules, making it inaccurate to suggest that every Christian community follows one uniform rule. Internationally, first-cousin marriages are legally permitted in the United Kingdom, and Canada’s Marriage (Prohibited Degrees) Act of 1990 does not prohibit them either. In other words, cousin marriage is a social and cultural practice with a much wider geographical and religious footprint. It cannot honestly be reduced to a mere Muslim identity marker.
This is where the debate becomes uncomfortable. When a practice exists within one community, it is often explained through the lens of tradition, culture, regional customs, or individual choice. But when the same practice is associated with Muslims, it can quickly become a source of ridicule, generalisation, and insinuation. Why this double standard? Why should a marriage between cousins become a punchline about an entire religious community? Why should an individual practice, permitted under a particular religious tradition, be used to define millions of people?
Muslims are not a monolithic community. They come from different regions, cultures, linguistic backgrounds, and social traditions. Not every Muslim marries a cousin, just as not every Hindu, Christian, or Parsi follows the marriage customs recognised within their respective traditions. Reducing a diverse community to one matrimonial practice is not social commentary; it is stereotyping. And the problem with stereotypes is that they rarely remain confined to comedy. Repeated often enough, they become entrenched in popular perception.
Let me make one thing absolutely clear: I neither wish to play the victim nor offer a justification for something that does not require one. In Islam, marriage between cousins is permissible. The Quran, in Surah An-Nisa (4:23), identifies the categories of relatives with whom marriage is prohibited, and cousins are not included among them. For a Muslim who follows this religious understanding, the matter is straightforward. Something that Allah has declared *halal* does not require validation from society, approval from comedians, or acceptance from those who may find it unfamiliar.
I am not the least bit ashamed of this permissible practice, nor do I believe that Muslims should feel compelled to defend every aspect of their faith simply because someone has chosen to make it a subject of public ridicule. There is a difference between explaining one's beliefs and seeking permission to practise them. We can engage in a conversation about marriage customs, social practices, and changing societal preferences without treating religious permissibility as something embarrassing.
There is another dimension that deserves an honest discussion. Marriage between close biological relatives, particularly first cousins, can increase the risk of certain inherited genetic conditions in their children. This is a legitimate medical consideration and should be addressed with scientific evidence, awareness, and appropriate genetic counselling. But this consideration applies irrespective of religion. It should not become a tool for mocking one community while overlooking similar practices elsewhere. Furthermore, a scientific discussion about health should never be confused with a moral judgement about the worth or dignity of people who follow a particular tradition. If the concern is public health, let us discuss public health. If the concern is marriage customs, let us discuss cultural diversity. But selectively turning a religious practice into an instrument of ridicule serves neither purpose.
India is a country of extraordinary cultural, religious, and social diversity. Our traditions are not identical, our customs are not uniform, and our understanding of marriage, family, and relationships has evolved differently across communities. A genuinely plural society does not demand that everyone follow the same customs; it demands that people respect the freedom of others to follow their own lawful traditions. That respect must work both ways. Nobody is obliged to agree with another person's religious beliefs, and nobody is required to adopt another community's customs. But disagreement does not provide a licence to humiliate, stereotype, or reduce an entire community to a cheap punchline.
Comedy can question authority, challenge hypocrisy, and expose social contradictions. Indeed, some of the finest comedy does precisely that. But when humour relies on inherited prejudices rather than intelligent observation, it deserves scrutiny. The real question is not whether cousin marriage is acceptable to everyone. The question is why a practice that exists across cultures and societies suddenly becomes a matter of public mockery when Muslims are brought into the picture. I do not need anyone's approval for what my faith permits, and I certainly do not need to apologise for it. Respect our differences, question our ideas, debate our practices—but do not turn an entire community into a stereotype.
---
Mohd. Ziyaullah Khan is a freelance content writer and editor based in Nagpur. He is also an activist and social entrepreneur, and the co-founder of TruthScape, a team of digital activists fighting disinformation on social media
Comments