Skip to main content

Policy analyst urges Govt of India to prioritize battery storage over pumped hydro, citing ecological concerns

By A Representative 
A prominent power and climate policy analyst, Shankar Sharma, has raised significant concerns regarding India's current reliance on pumped storage plants (PSPs) for energy transition, advocating strongly for the adoption of battery energy storage systems (BESS) instead. In a detailed communication addressed to top government officials and ministers, including the Chairman CUM Managing Director of Grid-India, the Chairman of the Central Electricity Authority, and the Secretaries of Power, MNRE, and MoEF&CC, Sharma highlighted the "unacceptable ecological costs" associated with PSPs and called for a strategic re-evaluation of India's energy storage policy.
Sharma’s letter underscores the widespread opposition to PSPs due to their massive ecological footprint, citing specific proposals in the ecologically sensitive Sharavathi and Varahi river valleys in Karnataka. He argues that while state governments and the Ministry of Power project PSPs as crucial for integrating large-scale solar and wind capacities, they remain "callously silent" on the environmental damages and societal costs. Conversely, civil society groups have consistently advocated for BESS, citing their advantages of minimal ecological damage, lower carbon footprint, shorter gestation periods, and technical superiority.
The communication points to international experiences, particularly a recent article detailing how batteries are enhancing grid reliability in the US, to illustrate the clear advantages of BESS over PSPs. The article highlights the rapid growth of grid-scale battery storage, projecting it to surpass pumped hydro as the largest source of grid-scale electrical storage in the US around 2029. Sharma contends that this global trend is highly relevant to the Indian power sector, given the comparable complexities of the grids.
Sharma criticizes the lack of a comprehensive strategic policy paper from Indian authorities objectively comparing PSP and BESS technologies. He emphasizes the urgent need for diligent studies to assess their relative costs and benefits under Indian conditions, leading to concrete policy recommendations that prioritize the overall welfare of society in the medium and long term. While acknowledging that both technologies can meet grid demand variations, he points out the superior cycle efficiencies of BESS (around 85% compared to PSP's 76%) and their significantly lower carbon footprint and project construction periods. For India, he asserts, the substantial forest loss and ecological concerns associated with PSPs in river valleys should be the decisive factor favoring BESS technology.
Until a societal consensus is achieved through an objective analysis of environmental, social, and economic considerations, Sharma urges a pause on the approval and construction of multiple PSPs, particularly those facing public opposition. He expresses hope for a rational policy on critical energy storage issues and reiterates the urgent need for a comprehensive National Energy Policy to guide India's energy future.

Comments

Post a Comment

TRENDING

Can free‑living Indian street dogs teach us about how to care for pet dogs?

By Daniel Ramp, Kapil Vishwas Patwardhan, Rosalie Chapple  We give our pet dogs shelter, veterinary care, affection, training and play. We decide when they eat, where they sleep, when they go outside, who they meet, and how they move through the world.
Post a Comment
»

Grid bottlenecks threatening India’s renewable energy growth, Centre warned

By A Representative   Senior p ower and climate policy analyst Shankar Sharma has urged the Ministry of Power and other senior policymakers to undertake an urgent review of India’s power-sector priorities, citing rising renewable-energy curtailment, transmission bottlenecks, delays in battery storage projects and the growing financial and ecological costs of conventional power infrastructure.
Post a Comment
»

Rights groups condemn arrests and security buildup amid Siang mega-dam protests in Arunachal

By A Representative    A  coalition of  several civil rights, labour, student and social justice groups,  Campaign Against State Repression (CASR), has condemned the arrest of three anti-dam activists in Arunachal Pradesh following recent violence in Pasighat, demanding their immediate release and the withdrawal of security forces from protest areas opposing the proposed 11,200-MW Siang Upper Multipurpose Project (SUMP).
Post a Comment
»