Is the Narendra Modi government, in its third but what would appear to be a weaker avatar, seeking to show that it would keep a distance, albeit temporarily, from its most favorite business house, the Adanis? It would seem so if the latest move of the Ministry of Environment, Forests and Climate Change (MoEFCC) latest to "defer" the Adani Energy’s application for 1500 MW Warasgaon-Warangi Pump Storage Project is any indication.
Quoting the September 27 MoEFCC's Expert Appraisal Committee (EAC) meeting, released on October 2, a senior scholar-activist of the top environmental advocacy group South Asia Network on Dams, Rivers and People (SANDRP) has reported that in a "respite" to forest dwelling communities, fragile biodiversity and community conservation areas, the EAC has "rejected" the Adani application for project.
However, the window for continuing with the controversial project hasn't been entirely closed. To quote Parineeta Dandekar, the proponents have been asked "to apply afresh" for Stage I Clearance, adding several conditions to assessment. To quote her, "The EAC did not approve the Adani application for amendments in the Terms of Reference (TORs) earlier granted for 1200 MW Warasgaon-Warangi Pumped Storage Project (PSP) by Adani Green Energy."
Appreciating the move, Dandekar said, the EAC not just "rejected" the application but "decided to visit sites all the PSPs that have applied for environment clearance before giving any further clearances", hoping, "The site visits will expose the perilous siting of over 15 pumped storage projects in the Western Ghats."
In a detailed analysis on September 24 on the advocacy group's website, Dandekar had pointed to how the upper dam of 1500 MW Warasgaon Warangi Project "was set to destroy a sacred fish pool and sacred grove of Goddess Varadayini in the village Tekpowale." This followed an SANDRP submission to the EAC outlining the impacts of this project on the "ecologically sensitive area" and the "wider cumulative impact" of the multiple PSP schemes in the Western Ghats.
The submission was signed by more than 200 individuals and organizations, including Parineeta Dandekar and Himanshu Thakkar of SANDRP; Suniti SR and colleagues of the National Alliance for People’s Movements; Shailaja Deshpande and colleagues of the Jeevit Nadi; Priyadarshini Karve of the Indian Network on Ethics and Climate Change; Jaideep Baphana of Pune River Revival (a group with over 1000 members in Pune); and Shripad Dharmadhikary of the Manthan Adhyayan Kendra, Pune.
Quoting the minutes of the EAC meeting, Dandekar said, it asked the project proponents to prepare "a new project layout which will not obstruct rivulets in Western Ghats" and "change the project layout to reduce impact on forest land". Refusing to grant TORs (Stage I Clearance) to the project and deciding on a site visit to all the proposed PSP sites in the Western Ghats for which TORs have been issued prior to granting Environmental Clearance, EAC said, "These projects are located in the ecologically fragile Western Ghats and huge forest area is also involved".
She quoted EAC as rejecting the Adanis' TOR given on February 13, 2023 which had specifically said the project proposes to use water of the catchment of the lower reservoir for initial filling and annual recuperation of losses, pointing out, this will "impact several small rivulets draining into these reservoirs as the water will not be released downstream."
Said Dandekar, the EAC was of the view that project proponents had "changed configuration of the project drastically which could attract more impact on the environment", raising concerns about "change in the total forest land required for the project with an increase of more than three times, i.e. from 24.50 ha to 88.98 ha."
Hence, the EAC suggested submission of a fresh proposal for grant of TOR with modified pre-feasibility report (PFR) with "fresh alternative site analysis modifying the project layout with no obstruction of small rivulets in the area as the small rivulets are the key source of water for the perennial rivers in the western ghats", and "change in project profile i.e. change in project layout, change in forest land and private land requirement.”
At the same time, the EAC noted that the MoEFCC had granted TOR to approximately 15 projects in the Western Ghats, but "given the region’s high environmental sensitivity", there should be site visits by sub-committee members to several PSPs as these are located in "the ecologically fragile Western Ghats and huge forest area is involved". Hence, the need for a site visit "in toto wherever possible.”
In her September 25 analysis of the project prior to the EAC move, Dandekar (photo), who had visited the project site earlier, had said, Adani Energy's had planned the project "in a remote, densely forested area of the Western Ghats and enveloped by dam backwaters" around Tekpowale village, which "feels like a place lost in time".
"This village", she said, "narrowly escaped submersion from the Panshet Dam and now precariously perches on its encroaching backwaters. The Warasgaon Dam backwaters lie about seven kilometers away, with Mulshi and Temghar Dams approximately 19 kilometers distant and Pawana Dam around 48 kilometers", adding, "The region is densely packed with dams; a mere straight-line distance of 66 kilometers from the northern-most Thokarwadi Dam to Panshet encompasses ten large dams in the Mula-Mutha Basin."According to Dandekar, "Unsurprisingly, Maharashtra holds the distinction of being the most dammed state in India, and this area might be the most heavily dammed within the state. Despite the proliferation of dams, upscale resorts, and urban developments like Lonavala and Lavasa encroaching upon the Western Ghats' forests." Yet, the region "still boasts vital community conservation areas, including sacred groves, temple forests, and remarkable community fish sanctuaries."
Recalling her visits to Tekpowale, she said, they have "often revolved around its cherished fish sanctuary, which preserves a sacred pool devoted to Vardayini, a fierce forest goddess known as the Bestower of Boons. Surrounded by an ancient dark grove, the pool is home to sacred Mahseer fish, which villagers protect with utmost reverence. The grove, adorned with traditional garments and offerings, forms an eerie yet majestic setting."
Pointing out that the community in the village "strictly forbids fishing in this sanctuary, believing the Mahseer bears a distinctive mark given by their goddess—similar to tales from other regions in India about fish marked by divine figures", Dandekar noted, "Even in times of drought, the villagers refrain from drawing water from the pool, opting instead to carry it by hand as a show of respect."
She underlined, "The 1500 MW Warasgaon-Warangi Pumped Storage Project will involve the construction of two massive dams—one in Tekpowale and another in Warangi—connected by a two-kilometer underground tunnel... Despite its proclaimed benefits, the environmental implications of such a project in a biodiversity-rich and sacred region are concerning."
Calling the project's pre-feasibility study "superficial" focusing "solely on economic factors while neglecting ecological realities, such as the presence of the Varadayini Fish Sanctuary", Dandekar said, "The project would disturb not only the sacred pool in Tekpowale but also the nearby Walen Kondh Fish Sanctuary, without acknowledging its significance in project considerations."
Asserting that the "communities like those in Tekpowale, deeply connected to their land and water, oppose any developments that threaten their heritage", she said, "The claim that the Warasgaon-Warangi Project supports green energy initiatives is misleading". She added, "The destruction of these sacred places is anything but eco-friendly and sustainable. As the guardians of Vardayini and her sanctuary, the villagers of Tekpowale stand resolutely against the encroachment of industry into their revered spaces."
Comments